Kristen A Andersen1, Matthew R Aronoff, Nicholas A McGrath, Ronald T Raines. 1. Molecular & Cellular Pharmacology Graduate Training Program, ‡Department of Chemistry, and §Department of Biochemistry, University of Wisconsin-Madison , Madison, Wisconsin 53706, United States.
Abstract
We introduce a stabilized diazo group as a reporter for chemical biology. ManDiaz, which is a diazo derivative of N-acetylmannosamine, is found to endure cellular metabolism and label the surface of a mammalian cell. There its diazo group can undergo a 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition with a strained alkyne, providing a signal comparable to that from the azido congener, ManNAz. The chemoselectivity of diazo and alkynyl groups enables dual labeling of cells that is not possible with azido and alkynyl groups. Thus, the diazo group, which is approximately half the size of an azido group, provides unique opportunities for orthogonal labeling of cellular components.
We introduce a stabilized diazo group as a reporter for chemical biology. ManDiaz, which is a diazo derivative of N-acetylmannosamine, is found to endure cellular metabolism and label the surface of a mammalian cell. There its diazo group can undergo a 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition with a strained alkyne, providing a signal comparable to that from the azido congener, ManNAz. The chemoselectivity of diazo and alkynyl groups enables dual labeling of cells that is not possible with azido and alkynyl groups. Thus, the diazo group, which is approximately half the size of an azido group, provides unique opportunities for orthogonal labeling of cellular components.
Appreciation[1] of the broad utility of the Huisgen azide–alkyne
1,3-dipolar cycloaddition[2] has had a profound
impact on chemical biology.[3] The diazo
group shares this reactivity with the azido group while conferring
additional versatility. For example, cycloaddition with a diazo compound
can be tuned to be much faster or much slower than that with its azide
analogue.[4] Diazo compounds offer other
useful modes of reactivity, including the O-alkylation
of carboxylic acids in water to form esters.[5] Indeed, the utility of diazo compounds in chemical synthesis was
established long ago[6] and likely exceeds
that of azides.[7] Nevertheless, rightful
concern about their toxicity and high, even explosive, reactivity[8] has deterred the application of diazo compounds
in chemical biology. While recent work has demonstrated their utility
in biomolecular transformations in vitro,[4] we are unaware of any application of diazo compounds in cellulo
or in vivo.A diazo group has attributes of an ideal reporter
for chemical
biologists. Smaller than an azido group (Figure 1A), a diazo group has the same number of atoms as a methyl group
(RCH3 versus RCHN2) or a methylene group (R1R2CH2 versus R1R2CN2). Moreover, a diazo compound can be prepared readily
from its parent azide by simple deimidogenation, that is, loss of
“NH” (Figure 1B).[9] This deimidogenation reaction allows access to diazo compounds
in aqueous solution via abstraction of an α-proton from an incipient
acyl triazene with a mild base such as bicarbonate. The requisite
acidity of that α-proton requires conjugation of the anion with,
for example, an amidic carbonyl group.[10] We hypothesized that such mitigation of reactivity could allow diazo
compounds to endure physiological conditions.
Figure 1
(A) Space-filling models
of diazo and azido derivatives of acetamide.
Diazo and azido groups add 15.4 and 31.6 Å2 of solvent-accessible
surface area, respectively (see the Supporting
Information). (B) Scheme for the deimidogenation of an azide
to form a diazo
compound.[9] (C) Bar graph of the rate constants
for the reactions of an azide (1, R = Bn) and a diazo
compound (2, R = Bn) with strained cyclooctynes in CD3CN or *1:1 CD3CN/H2O as determined with 1H NMR spectroscopy.
(A) Space-filling models
of diazo and azido derivatives of acetamide.
Diazo and azido groups add 15.4 and 31.6 Å2 of solvent-accessible
surface area, respectively (see the Supporting
Information). (B) Scheme for the deimidogenation of an azide
to form a diazo
compound.[9] (C) Bar graph of the rate constants
for the reactions of an azide (1, R = Bn) and a diazo
compound (2, R = Bn) with strained cyclooctynes in CD3CN or *1:1 CD3CN/H2O as determined with 1H NMR spectroscopy.We sought to assess the resilience of a diazo group in a
meaningful
context. To do so, we chose metabolic trafficking, which is more demanding
than the mere demonstration of chemoselective reactivity in a biomolecular
milieu. The labeling of cell-surface glycans is an ideal theater for
this test because of the high tolerance demanded by cellular biosynthetic
machinery,[11] the rigid constraint on size,[12] and the precedent for this labeling established
by Reutter, Bertozzi, and others with derivatives of N-acetylmannosamine (ManNAc) (Scheme 1).[13]
Scheme 1
We began by examining the in
vitro reactivity of a relevant diazo
compound with strained functionalizable alkynes. Three cyclooctynes
were reacted with a representative azide (1, R = Bn)
and diazo compound (2, R = Bn). In acetonitrile, the
reactions with the diazo compound were as fast or faster than those
with the azide (Figure 1C). Notably, the addition
of water augmented both the rates and their differential, likely as
a result of stabilization of the especially polar transition state
for cycloaddition with the diazo compound.[4b,14] On the basis of these data, we chose DIBAC as an optimal functionalizable
alkyne for our experiments.Next, we sought to confirm the chemoselectivity
of the diazo group
in a biological context. First, we stirred a solution of N-benzyl-2-diazoacetamide (2, R = Bn) and glutathione
for 24 h and did not observe a reaction (Figure S1 in the Supporting Information). Then we linked a diazoacetamide
to biotin to probe for nonspecific labeling in cellulo. CHO K1 cells
treated with the diazo–biotin conjugate or its parent azide
showed no labeling on an immunoblot, in contrast to an analogous acrylate
(Figure 2A). Likewise, nonspecific labeling
with the diazo group was not detectable with flow cytometry or confocal
microscopy at 24 h (Figure 2B,C).
Figure 2
Chemoselectivity
of diazo and azido groups. (A) Immunoblot of the
biotin signals of cell lysates grown in either DMSO (D), acrylic ester–biotin
(AEB) (1 mM), azido–biotin (AB) (25 μM), or diazo–biotin
(DB) (25 μM) for 24 or 48 h. (B) Flow cytometry analysis of
cells grown as in (A) for 24 h (p < 0.0001). (C)
Microscopy of fixed and permeabilized cells grown as in (A) for 24
h. Cells were stained with avidin–Alexa Fluor 488 and Hoechst
33342. Scale bars: 25 μm.
Chemoselectivity
of diazo and azido groups. (A) Immunoblot of the
biotin signals of cell lysates grown in either DMSO (D), acrylic ester–biotin
(AEB) (1 mM), azido–biotin (AB) (25 μM), or diazo–biotin
(DB) (25 μM) for 24 or 48 h. (B) Flow cytometry analysis of
cells grown as in (A) for 24 h (p < 0.0001). (C)
Microscopy of fixed and permeabilized cells grown as in (A) for 24
h. Cells were stained with avidin–Alexa Fluor 488 and Hoechst
33342. Scale bars: 25 μm.Next, we asked whether a diazo compound would be accepted
by an
endogenous biosynthetic pathway alongside extant biomolecules. To
answer this question, we synthesized the stabilized diazo compoundAc4ManDiaz (Scheme 1) by deimidogenation
of Ac4ManNAz. The four acetyl groups enhance cell permeability
and are hydrolyzed by intracellular esterases.[15] We added Ac4ManDiaz or Ac4ManNAz
to medium containing live CHO K1 cells. After 2 days, any extracellular
diazo or azido groups were reacted with a DIBAC–biotin conjugate
and labeled with avidin–Alexa Fluor 488, which is green. Super-resolution
images of cells exposed to Ac4ManDiaz and Ac4ManNAz were indistinguishable (Figure 3A).
Quantification with flow cytometry revealed that labeling with Ac4ManDiaz was slightly less efficient (Figure 3B), despite its higher reaction rate (Figure 1C). The differential labeling is likely related to the instability
of a diazo group at low pH. Most peracylated sugars are taken up by
passive diffusion across the outer membrane, but some are taken up
by endocytosis.[15] The low pH of endosomes[16] likely leads to C-protonation and hydrolysis
of the ensuing diazonium salt.[5] Finally,
we showed that Ac4ManDiaz is metabolized and displayed
on the surface of three other cell types, though at different rates
(Figure 3C).
Figure 3
Trafficking of diazo and azido sugars
in mammalian cells. (A) Super-resolution
images of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing Ac4ManDiaz
or Ac4ManNAz (25 μM) for 2 days, washed, treated
with DIBAC–biotin (10 μM) for 60 min and then avidin–Alexa
Fluor 488 and Hoechst 33342, and fixed. Scale bars: 10 μm. (B)
Histogram of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing Ac4ManNAc, Ac4ManDiaz, or Ac4ManNAz (25 μM)
as in (A). (C) Graph of the concentration-dependent fluorescence of
Jurkat, CHO K1, HEK293T, and HeLa cells grown in medium containing
Ac4ManDiaz (0–50 μM) as in (A). The data in
(B) and (C) were acquired by flow cytometry.
Trafficking of diazo and azido sugars
in mammalian cells. (A) Super-resolution
images of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing Ac4ManDiaz
or Ac4ManNAz (25 μM) for 2 days, washed, treated
with DIBAC–biotin (10 μM) for 60 min and then avidin–Alexa
Fluor 488 and Hoechst 33342, and fixed. Scale bars: 10 μm. (B)
Histogram of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing Ac4ManNAc, Ac4ManDiaz, or Ac4ManNAz (25 μM)
as in (A). (C) Graph of the concentration-dependent fluorescence of
Jurkat, CHO K1, HEK293T, and HeLa cells grown in medium containing
Ac4ManDiaz (0–50 μM) as in (A). The data in
(B) and (C) were acquired by flow cytometry.To confirm that Ac4ManDiaz was trafficked into
sialic
acid in the same manner as Ac4ManNAz, we grew CHO K1 cells
in each peracylated sugar at 250 μM for 3 days and labeled them
with DIBAC–biotin as described above. We then treated the cells
with either neuraminidase (sialidase) or peptide-N-glycosidase F (PNGase F). Both the azido and diazo sugars showed
high levels of labeling with DIBAC–biotin in the absence of
enzyme, with diazo labeling being (86 ± 3)% of the azido labeling.
Exogenous addition of either enzyme decreased the labeling levels
sharply (Figure S2), indicating that labeling
was due to incorporation of the sugars.[17] In addition, using the pendant biotin of the DIBAC conjugate, we
isolated the cellular metabolites generated from the azido and diazo
precursors and observed the expected sialic acid conjugates by mass
spectrometry (Figure S3).To ascertain
the optimal conditions for labeling of CHO K1 cells
that had metabolized Ac4ManDiaz, we exposed these cells
to 0–20 μM DIBAC–biotin for 60 min or 10 μM
DIBAC–biotin for 0–120 min. Although labeling continued
to increase with increasing levels of DIBAC–biotin, concentrations
in excess of 10 μM or times beyond 60 min began to elicit cytotoxicity
(Figures S4 and S5). Accordingly, we chose
labeling at 10 μM for 60 min as a compromise between high labeling
efficiency and cell viability. Notably, the cytotoxic activities of
Ac4ManDiaz and Ac4ManNAz were similar (LD50 ∼ 1 mM; Figure S6).Next, we sought to perform chemoselective dual labeling on the
cell surface.[18] Unlike azide 1 (R = Bn), diazo compound 2 (R = Bn) is a poor substrate
for Cu(I)-catalyzed cycloaddition with a terminal alkyne in aqueous
solution (data not shown). Hence, we reasoned that a cell surface
displaying both diazo and terminal alkynyl groups could provide opportunities
for orthogonal reactivity.To test this hypothesis, we allowed
cells to metabolize Ac4ManDiaz, Ac4ManKyne,
or both. We then probed for
diazo groups by using strain-promoted cycloaddition with DIBAC–biotin
and labeling with avidin–Alexa Fluor 594 (microscopy) or avidin–Alexa
Fluor 647 (flow cytometry), which are red; we probed for alkynyl groups
by using Cu(I)-catalyzed cycloaddition with picolyl azide–Alexa
Fluor 488,[19] which is green. Both microscopy
and flow cytometry indicated that the two cycloaddition reactions
could be performed in either order without interfering cross-reactivity
(Figure 4). In marked contrast, performing
the same experiment with Ac4ManNAz and Ac4ManKyne
resulted in diminished cell-surface labeling, especially when Cu(I)-catalyzed
cycloaddition was performed first. We suspect that the labeling was
diminished by the cross-linking of cell-surface azido and alkynyl
groups, as these two functional groups are not orthogonal in the presence
of Cu(I). The evident clumping of cells displaying both azido and
alkynyl groups also suggests that the glycocalyx of two cells can
be in such close proximity that their sialic acid residues react to
form covalent cross-links. The data in Figure 4 indicate that diazo compounds, unlike azides, are orthogonal to
terminal alkynes in a cellular context, and this orthogonality enables
novel dual-labeling experiments.
Figure 4
Dual labeling of mammalian cells with
diazo and alkynyl sugars.
(A) Images of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing derivatives
of N-acetylmannosamine for 2 days, labeled by cycloaddition
with an alkyne (red) and azide (green), and visualized with confocal
microscopy. Scale bars: 10 μm. (B) Plots demonstrating the dual
labeling of cells that had metabolized Ac4ManDiaz and Ac4ManKyne. Data were acquired by flow cytometry.
Dual labeling of mammalian cells with
diazo and alkynyl sugars.
(A) Images of CHO K1 cells grown in medium containing derivatives
of N-acetylmannosamine for 2 days, labeled by cycloaddition
with an alkyne (red) and azide (green), and visualized with confocal
microscopy. Scale bars: 10 μm. (B) Plots demonstrating the dual
labeling of cells that had metabolized Ac4ManDiaz and Ac4ManKyne. Data were acquired by flow cytometry.To provide another example of the chemoselectivity
of the diazo
group, we performed dual labeling with Ac4ManDiaz and Ac4GalKyne, which is a peracetylated galactosamine functionalized
with an alkyne. Metabolism positions the galactosamine moiety in the
core of mucin-type O-linked glycoproteins.[20] Again, we probed for diazo groups by using strain-promoted cycloaddition
with DIBAC–biotin and subsequent labeling with avidin–Alexa
Fluor 594 (microscopy) or avidin–Alexa Fluor 647 (flow cytometry),
and we probed for alkynyl groups by using Cu(I)-catalyzed cycloaddition
with picolyl azide–Alexa Fluor 488.[19] Both microscopy and flow cytometry data showed an orthogonal labeling
pattern that colocalized at the cell surface (Figure S7A,C). Because of the lower abundance of the alkynylsugar (Figure S7B), the deleterious cross-reactivity
with the Ac4ManNAz metabolite was even more apparent in
this experiment. Labeling of the alkyne was diminished substantially
in the presence of the azido sugar (Figure S7D). In contrast, labeling of the alkyne was not affected by the presence
of the diazo group. These data highlight the importance of orthogonal
labeling methods for the simultaneous analysis of more than one metabolite
and how diazo and alkynyl groups can provide the requisite chemoselectivity.We conclude that stabilized diazo groups can rival azido groups
as probes in chemical biology. The diazo group is smaller than an
azido group and has overlapping but distinct reactivity. Remarkably,
an α-diazo amide is able to survive complex metabolic transformations
in a mammalian cell. Although other systems exist for dual labeling,[18] we conclude that none provide the small size,
metabolic stability, and chemoselective reactivity of the diazo group.
Our findings encourage the development of new biocompatible reactions
for stabilized diazo compounds that could further manifest their potential.
Authors: Mohammad Rashidian; Sidath C Kumarapperuma; Kari Gabrielse; Adrian Fegan; Carston R Wagner; Mark D Distefano Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2013-10-17 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Eileen G Burke; Brian Gold; Trish T Hoang; Ronald T Raines; Jennifer M Schomaker Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2017-05-31 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Yun Hu; Jessica M Roberts; Henry R Kilgore; Amirah S Mat Lani; Ronald T Raines; Jennifer M Schomaker Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2020-10-21 Impact factor: 15.419