Literature DB >> 25549636

Evaluation of hematocrit interference with MyStar extra and seven competitive devices.

Filiz Demircik1, Sanja Ramljak2, Iris Hermanns3, Anke Pfützner2, Andreas Pfützner4.   

Abstract

In previous studies, meters employing dynamic electrochemistry (DE), have been shown to correct for hematocrit (HCT) interference. This laboratory investigation assessed the HCT stability of MyStar Extra (Sanofi) in comparison to 7 competitive devices (Accu-Chek Aviva Nano & Accu-Chek Performa, Roche Diagnostics; Contour XT and Contour Link, Bayer; FreeStyle Freedom Lite, Abbott; MyLife Pura, Ypsomed; OneTouch Verio Pro, LifeScan). Venous heparinized blood was freshly drawn, immediately aliquoted, and manipulated to contain 3 different blood glucose concentrations (50-80 mg/dL, 150-180 mg/dL, and 350-400 mg/dL) and 5 different HCT levels (20-25%, 30-35%, 40-45%, 50-55%, and 60-65%). After careful oxygenation to normal blood oxygen pressure, each of the 15 different samples was measured 8 times with 2 devices and 2 strip lots of each meter (32 measurements/meter/sample). YSI Stat 2300 served as laboratory reference method. Next to determination of the mean absolute relative deviation (MARD), stability to HCT influence was assumed, when less than 10% difference occurred between the highest and lowest mean glucose deviations in relation to HCT over all tested glucose ranges (HIF: hematocrit interference factor). Four of the devices showed stable performance: Contour XT (MARD: 1.3%/HIF: 6.1%), MyStar Extra (4.7%/7.1%), OneTouch Verio Pro (4.5%/7.3%), and Contour Link (6.3%/9.3%). The 4 other meters were influenced by HCT (Accu-Chek Performa: 4.7%/20.9%, Accu-Chek Aviva Nano: 4.5%/22.4%, FreeStyle Freedom Lite: 4.8%/24.5%; MyLife Pura: 6.4%/28.7%). In this study, all meters showed a good accuracy, but only 50% of them, including MyStar Extra, were shown to reliably correct for potential hematocrit influence on the meter results.
© 2014 Diabetes Technology Society.

Entities:  

Keywords:  accuracy; blood glucose meter; dynamic electrochemistry; hematocrit interference

Mesh:

Substances:

Year:  2014        PMID: 25549636      PMCID: PMC4604595          DOI: 10.1177/1932296814565790

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol        ISSN: 1932-2968


  22 in total

Review 1.  [Reference values for hematologic laboratory tests and hematologic disorders in the aged].

Authors:  T Takubo; N Tatsumi
Journal:  Rinsho Byori       Date:  2000-03

2.  Point-of-care glucose testing: effects of critical care variables, influence of reference instruments, and a modular glucose meter design.

Authors:  R F Louie; Z Tang; D V Sutton; J H Lee; G J Kost
Journal:  Arch Pathol Lab Med       Date:  2000-02       Impact factor: 5.534

Review 3.  Evidence-based systematic literature review of hemoglobin/hematocrit and all-cause mortality in dialysis patients.

Authors:  Nataliya Volkova; Lenore Arab
Journal:  Am J Kidney Dis       Date:  2006-01       Impact factor: 8.860

4.  American Diabetes Association: clinical practice recommendations 1996.

Authors: 
Journal:  Diabetes Care       Date:  1996-01       Impact factor: 19.112

Review 5.  The Normal Haematocrit Trial in dialysis patients with cardiac disease: are we any the less confused about target haemoglobin?

Authors:  I C Macdougall; E Ritz
Journal:  Nephrol Dial Transplant       Date:  1998-12       Impact factor: 5.992

6.  Consensus statement on self-monitoring of blood glucose.

Authors: 
Journal:  Diabetes Care       Date:  1987 Jan-Feb       Impact factor: 19.112

7.  Laboratory and bedside evaluation of portable glucose meters.

Authors:  J H Nichols; C Howard; K Loman; C Miller; D Nyberg; D W Chan
Journal:  Am J Clin Pathol       Date:  1995-02       Impact factor: 2.493

8.  Accuracy of plasma glucose measurements in the hypoglycemic range.

Authors:  P M Genter; E Ipp
Journal:  Diabetes Care       Date:  1994-06       Impact factor: 19.112

9.  Intra-operative blood glucose measurements. The effect of haematocrit on glucose test strips.

Authors:  E A Smith; E S Kilpatrick
Journal:  Anaesthesia       Date:  1994-02       Impact factor: 6.955

10.  Capillary blood glucose measurements in hospital inpatients using portable glucose meters.

Authors:  G Phillipou; C J Seaborn; J Hooper; P J Phillips
Journal:  Aust N Z J Med       Date:  1993-12
View more
  8 in total

1.  Histogram analysis for smartphone-based rapid hematocrit determination.

Authors:  Uddin M Jalal; Sang C Kim; Joon S Shim
Journal:  Biomed Opt Express       Date:  2017-06-16       Impact factor: 3.732

2.  Evaluation of Hematocrit Influence on Measurements With a Novel Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose System Based on ISO 15197:2013.

Authors:  Annette Baumstark; Christina Liebing; Nina Jendrike; Stefan Pleus; Cornelia Haug; Guido Freckmann
Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol       Date:  2018-05-17

3.  Seven-Year Clinical Surveillance Program Demonstrates Consistent MARD Accuracy Performance of a Blood Glucose Test Strip.

Authors:  Steven Setford; Mike Grady; Stephen Mackintosh; Robert Donald; Brian Levy
Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol       Date:  2018-05-30

4.  Advances in Patient Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose.

Authors:  Andreas Pfützner
Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol       Date:  2015-11-29

5.  Comparative Accuracy of 17 Point-of-Care Glucose Meters.

Authors:  Laya Ekhlaspour; Debbie Mondesir; Norman Lautsch; Courtney Balliro; Mallory Hillard; Kendra Magyar; Laura Goergen Radocchia; Aryan Esmaeili; Manasi Sinha; Steven J Russell
Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol       Date:  2016-10-03

6.  Evaluation of Hematocrit Influence on Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose Based on ISO 15197:2013: Comparison of a Novel System With Five Systems With Different Hematocrit Ranges.

Authors:  Andrew Hattemer; Sami Wardat
Journal:  J Diabetes Sci Technol       Date:  2018-01-29

7.  Evaluation of newly developed veterinary portable blood glucose meter with hematocrit correction in dogs and cats.

Authors:  Akihiro Mori; Hitomi Oda; Eri Onozawa; Saori Shono; Toshinori Sako
Journal:  J Vet Med Sci       Date:  2017-08-18       Impact factor: 1.267

8.  Effects of a commercially available branched-chain amino acid-alanine-carbohydrate-based sports supplement on perceived exertion and performance in high intensity endurance cycling tests.

Authors:  Marco Gervasi; Davide Sisti; Stefano Amatori; Sabrina Donati Zeppa; Giosuè Annibalini; Giovanni Piccoli; Luciana Vallorani; Piero Benelli; Marco B L Rocchi; Elena Barbieri; Anna R Calavalle; Deborah Agostini; Carmela Fimognari; Vilberto Stocchi; Piero Sestili
Journal:  J Int Soc Sports Nutr       Date:  2020-01-20       Impact factor: 5.150

  8 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.