BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: While some authors report that dancers have reduced bone mineral density (BMD) and increased risk of osteoporosis, others have stressed the positive effects of dance training on developing healthy BMD. Given the existing controversy, the aim of this systematic review was to examine the best evidence-based information available in relation to female dancers. METHODS: Four databases (Web of Science, PubMed, EBSCO, Scopus) and two dance science journals (Journal of Dance Medicine and Science and Medical Problems of Performing Artists) were searched for relevant material using the keywords "dance", "ballet", "BMD", "bone density", "osteoporosis" and "female athlete triad syndrome". A total of 257 abstracts were screened using selected inclusion (studies involving bone measurements in dancers) and exclusion (editorials, opinion papers, chapters in books, narrative reviews and non-English language papers) criteria according to PRISMA guidelines. Following the above screening, a total of 108 abstracts were identified as potentially relevant. After the exclusion of conference proceedings, review papers, studies focusing only in male dancers and studies in which dancers' information were combined with other athletes, the eligible papers were subsequently assessed using the GRADE system and grouped according to: (1) prevalence of low BMD and associated factors, (2) incidence of low BMD and risk factors, (3) prevention/treatment of low BMD in dancers, and (4) other studies. RESULTS: Of the 257 abstracts that were initially screened, only 35 studies were finally considered. Only one of these 35 was of high quality, while the remaining 34 were of relatively low quality. Seven studies reported prevalence of low BMD and associated factors, 10 reported associated factors with no prevalence data, while one reported prevalence with no associated factors data. One study cited risk factors, while another one elaborated on the treatment of low BMD in dancers. The remaining 15 studies were classified as "other studies". CONCLUSIONS: It remains unclear whether low BMD is prevalent in female dancers. The present review highlights the need for high-quality BMD research in this area.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: While some authors report that dancers have reduced bone mineral density (BMD) and increased risk of osteoporosis, others have stressed the positive effects of dance training on developing healthy BMD. Given the existing controversy, the aim of this systematic review was to examine the best evidence-based information available in relation to female dancers. METHODS: Four databases (Web of Science, PubMed, EBSCO, Scopus) and two dance science journals (Journal of Dance Medicine and Science and Medical Problems of Performing Artists) were searched for relevant material using the keywords "dance", "ballet", "BMD", "bone density", "osteoporosis" and "female athlete triad syndrome". A total of 257 abstracts were screened using selected inclusion (studies involving bone measurements in dancers) and exclusion (editorials, opinion papers, chapters in books, narrative reviews and non-English language papers) criteria according to PRISMA guidelines. Following the above screening, a total of 108 abstracts were identified as potentially relevant. After the exclusion of conference proceedings, review papers, studies focusing only in male dancers and studies in which dancers' information were combined with other athletes, the eligible papers were subsequently assessed using the GRADE system and grouped according to: (1) prevalence of low BMD and associated factors, (2) incidence of low BMD and risk factors, (3) prevention/treatment of low BMD in dancers, and (4) other studies. RESULTS: Of the 257 abstracts that were initially screened, only 35 studies were finally considered. Only one of these 35 was of high quality, while the remaining 34 were of relatively low quality. Seven studies reported prevalence of low BMD and associated factors, 10 reported associated factors with no prevalence data, while one reported prevalence with no associated factors data. One study cited risk factors, while another one elaborated on the treatment of low BMD in dancers. The remaining 15 studies were classified as "other studies". CONCLUSIONS: It remains unclear whether low BMD is prevalent in female dancers. The present review highlights the need for high-quality BMD research in this area.
Authors: S R Cummings; D M Black; M C Nevitt; W Browner; J Cauley; K Ensrud; H K Genant; L Palermo; J Scott; T M Vogt Journal: Lancet Date: 1993-01-09 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: T Amorim; C Durães; J C Machado; G S Metsios; M Wyon; J Maia; A D Flouris; F Marques; L Nogueira; N Adubeiro; Y Koutedakis Journal: Osteoporos Int Date: 2018-07-05 Impact factor: 4.507
Authors: T Amorim; Y Koutedakis; A Nevill; M Wyon; J Maia; J C Machado; F Marques; G S Metsios; A D Flouris; N Adubeiro; L Nogueira; L Dimitriou Journal: Osteoporos Int Date: 2017-06-27 Impact factor: 4.507
Authors: Tânia Amorim; Laura Freitas; George S Metsios; Thayse Natacha Gomes; Matthew Wyon; Andreas D Flouris; José Maia; Franklim Marques; Luísa Nogueira; Nuno Adubeiro; Yiannis Koutedakis Journal: Arch Osteoporos Date: 2021-09-24 Impact factor: 2.617
Authors: Julia F Christensen; Meghedi Vartanian; Luisa Sancho-Escanero; Shahrzad Khorsandi; S H N Yazdi; Fahimeh Farahi; Khatereh Borhani; Antoni Gomila Journal: Front Psychol Date: 2021-02-25
Authors: Eirini K Kydonaki; Laura Freitas; Henrique Reguengo; Carlos Raposo Simón; Ana R Bastos; Emanuel M Fernandes; Raphaël F Canadas; Joaquim M Oliveira; Vitor M Correlo; Rui L Reis; Maria Vliora; Paraskevi Gkiata; Yiannis Koutedakis; Georgia Ntina; Rui Pinto; Andres E Carrillo; Franklim Marques; Tânia Amorim Journal: Nutrients Date: 2022-07-11 Impact factor: 6.706
Authors: Tânia Amorim; George S Metsios; Matthew Wyon; Alan M Nevill; Andreas D Flouris; José Maia; Eduardo Teixeira; José Carlos Machado; Franklim Marques; Yiannis Koutedakis Journal: PLoS One Date: 2017-07-05 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Rita Civil; Antonia Lamb; Diana Loosmore; Louisa Ross; Kerry Livingstone; Fiona Strachan; James R Dick; Emma J Stevenson; Meghan A Brown; Oliver C Witard Journal: Front Nutr Date: 2019-01-09