| Literature DB >> 24572993 |
H Terrones1, E Del Corro2, S Feng3, J M Poumirol4, D Rhodes4, D Smirnov4, N R Pradhan4, Z Lin3, M A T Nguyen5, A L Elías3, T E Mallouk6, L Balicas4, M A Pimenta2, M Terrones7.
Abstract
Although the main Raman features of semiconducting transition metal dichalcogenides are well known for the monolayer and bulk, there are important differences exhibited by few layered systems which have not been fully addressed. WSe2 samples were synthesized and ab-initio calculations carried out. We calculated phonon dispersions and Raman-active modes in layered systems: WSe2, MoSe2, WS2 and MoS2 ranging from monolayers to five-layers and the bulk. First, we confirmed that as the number of layers increase, the E', E″ and E2g modes shift to lower frequencies, and the A'1 and A1g modes shift to higher frequencies. Second, new high frequency first order A'1 and A1g modes appear, explaining recently reported experimental data for WSe2, MoSe2 and MoS2. Third, splitting of modes around A'1 and A1g is found which explains those observed in MoSe2. Finally, exterior and interior layers possess different vibrational frequencies. Therefore, it is now possible to precisely identify few-layered STMD.Entities:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24572993 PMCID: PMC5379439 DOI: 10.1038/srep04215
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Sci Rep ISSN: 2045-2322 Impact factor: 4.379
First order Raman-active modes in cm−1 of few layered WSe2, MoSe2, MoS2 and WS2 (from L = 1 to L = 5 layers) and the bulk, calculated using DFPT, and experimental results published in the literature (in yellow). The point symmetry of the unit cell is indicated in the first row by its Shöenflies symbol. An asterisk * indicates the more intense calculated signals, “ir” indicates that the mode is also infrared-active, “in” indicates that just the interior layers vibrate and “ex” represents that just the exterior layers vibrate. The lower frequency modes have not been included since some of them do not appear in the most common Raman configurations
| Structure | L = 1(cm−1)D3h | L = 2 (cm−1)D3d | L = 3(cm−1)D3h | L = 4(cm−1)D3d | L = 5(cm−1)D3h | Bulk(cm−1)D6h |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WSe2 | 175.75(E″) | 176.20(Eg2) | 175.01(E″2) | 175.22(Eg2) | 174.69(E″2) | 175.01(E1g) |
| 249.36(E′)*ir | 176.26(Eg2)19 | 175.58(E′2)ir | 175.52(Eg2) | 175.07(E′2)ir | 177.5(E1g) | |
| 250.23(A′1*) | 248.52(Eg1)* | 175.84(E″2) | 176.38(Eg2) | 175.60(E″2) | 247.78(E2g)* | |
| 249.5(E′) | 250.83(A1g)* | 176.33(E″2) | 247.66(Eg1)*In | 176.01(E′2)ir | 251.61(A1g)* | |
| 249.5(A′1) | 306.97(A1g2)* | 247.83(E′)*ir,In | 248.35(Eg1)*Ex | 176.23(E″2) | 248.0(E2g) | |
| 309.00(A1g2) | 248.32(E′)*ir,Ex | 249.57(A1g) | 247.55(E′1)*ir,In | 250.8(A1g)22 | ||
| 310.00(A1g2) | 248.31(E″1)*Ex | 251.30(A1g)* | 247.65(E′1)ir,In | 247.00(E2g) | ||
| 249.16(A′1) | 305.57(A1g2) | 248.55(E′1)*ir,Ex | 251.00(A1g)30 | |||
| 251.23(A′1)* | 306.62(A1g2)* | 247.59(E″1)In | 250(E2g) | |||
| 306.57(A′12)* | 309.00(A1g2) | 248.54(E″1) Ex | 253(A1g) | |||
| 309.00(A′12) | 310.00(A1g2) | 248.83(A′1) | ||||
| 310.00(A′12) | 250.15(A′1) | |||||
| 251.21(A′1)* | ||||||
| 305.29(A′12) | ||||||
| 306.84(A′12)* | ||||||
| 309.00(A′12) | ||||||
| 310.00(A′12) | ||||||
| MoSe2 | 167.60(E″) | 167.72(Eg2) | 166.55(E″2) | 166.96(Eg2) | 166.37(E″2) | 166.81(E1g) |
| 240.27(A′1)* | 284.03(Eg1)* | 167.51(E′2)ir | 167.94(Eg2) | 166.80(E′2)ir | 168.00(E1g) | |
| 240.5(A′1) | 285.90(Eg1) | 168.00(E″2) | 239.49(A1g) | 167.35(E″2) | 241.84(A1g)* | |
| 241.2(A′1) | 240.68(A1g)* | 238.74(A′1)* | 241.23(A1g)* | 167.84(E′2)ir | 242.5(A1g) | |
| 285.32(E′)*ir | 348.04(A1g2)* | 241.14(A′1)* | 282.64(Eg1)*In | 168.10(E″2) | 243.00(A1g) | |
| 287.2(E′) | 353.00(A1g2) | 282.69(E′1)*ir,In | 284.06(Eg1)*Ex | 238.42(A′1) | 283.11(E2g)* | |
| 287.3(E′) | 284.18(E′1)*ir,Ex | 345.72(A1g2) | 238.03(A′1) | 283.7(E2g) | ||
| 284.17(E″1)Ex | 347.92(A1g2)* | 240.02(A′1) | ||||
| 348.07(A′12)* | 353.00(A1g2) | 240.12(A′1) | ||||
| 353.00(A′12) | 241.40(A′1)* | |||||
| 242.04(A′1) | ||||||
| 282.63(E′1)*ir,In | ||||||
| 282.81(E′1)ir,In | ||||||
| 284.07(E′1)*ir,Ex | ||||||
| 282.73(E″2)In | ||||||
| 284.10(E″2)Ex | ||||||
| 345.54(A′12) | ||||||
| 347.90(A′12)* | ||||||
| 353.00(A′12) | ||||||
| WS2 | 298.54(E″) | 299.08(Eg2) | 297.22(E″2) | 297.73(Eg2) | 297.10(E″2) | 299.20(E1g) |
| 359.24(E′)ir | 358.26(Eg1)* | 298.22(E′2)ir | 298.94(Eg2) | 297.83(E′2)ir | 357.21(E2g)* | |
| 356.00(E′) | 419.39(A1g)* | 298.92(E″2) | 357.13(Eg1)*In | 298.55(E″2) | 356.5(E2g) | |
| 357.50(E′) | 437.61(A1g2) | 357.17(E′1)*ir,In | 358.06(Eg1)*Ex | 299.36(E′2)ir | 420.27(A1g)* | |
| 418.7(A′1)* | 358.13(E′1)*ir,Ex | 417.69(A1g) | 299.47(E″2) | 421.00(A1g) | ||
| 417.50(A′1) | 358.13(E″2)Ex | 419.81(A1g)* | 357.09(E′1)ir,In | |||
| 418.0(A′1) | 416.87(A′1) | 436.14(A1g2) | 357.21(E′1)*ir,In | |||
| 419.63(A′1)* | 437.28(A1g2) | 358.64(E′1)*ir,Ex | ||||
| 437.09(A′12) | 357.23(E″1)In | |||||
| 358.66(E″1)Ex | ||||||
| 416.73(A′1) | ||||||
| 418.49(A′1) | ||||||
| 420.14(A′1)* | ||||||
| 435.75(A′12) | ||||||
| 437.57(A′12) | ||||||
| MoS2 | 284.00(E″) | 283.78(Eg2) | 281.91(E″2) | 281.79(Eg2) | 281.84(E″2) | 282.05(E1g) |
| 383.61(E′)*ir | 381.65(Eg1)* | 283.24(E′2)ir | 283.28(Eg2) | 282.29(E′2)ir | 286.00(E1g) | |
| 384.7(E′) | 402.86(A1g)* | 283.83(E″2) | 379.57(Eg1)*In | 282.95(E″2) | 287.00(E1g) | |
| 384.0(E′) | 463.84(A1g2)* | 379.89(E′1)*ir,In | 381.54(Eg1)*Ex | 283.57(E′2)ir | 380.35(E2g)* | |
| 402.65(A′1)* | 381.75(E′1)*ir,Ex | 400.67(A1g) | 284.01((E′2)ir | 383.00(E2g) | ||
| 406.1(A′1) | 381.74(E″1)Ex | 402.80(A1g)* | 380.14(E′1)*ir,In | 383.50(E2g) | ||
| 403.00(A′1) | 400.00(A′1) | 461.12(A1g2) | 380.50(E′1)ir,In | 383.7(E2g) | ||
| 403.05(A′1)* | 463.39(A1g2)* | 381.46(E′1)ir,Ex | 405.02(A1g)* | |||
| 463.62(A′12)* | 380.33(E″1)In | 408.6(A1g) | ||||
| 381.47(E″1)*Ex | 408.7(A1g) | |||||
| 399.73(A′1) | ||||||
| 401.43(A′1) | ||||||
| 403.44(A′1)* | ||||||
| 461.28(A′12) | ||||||
| 463.18(A′12)* | ||||||
| 463.00(A′12) |
Figure 1Optical and atomic force microscope images of exfoliated WSe2 crystals a) Monolayer; b) Bilayer; c)Tetra-layer; d) Penta-layer.
Figure 2Raman spectra of few layered WSe2 with different excitation wavelengths; (a) 488 nm; (b) 514.5 nm; (c) 633 nm; (d) 647 nm; (e) Photoluminescence (PL) spectra obtained with the 488 nm.
Figure 3Experimental Raman spectra of WSe2 taken with a 514 nm laser under conventional geometry (VV) and cross polarization (VH).
(a) Monolayer (L = 1). (b) Bilayer (L = 2). (c) Trilayer (L = 3). Insets show models of the out of plane vibrational modes present in each case. (d) Calculated DFPT phonon dispersion of the WSe2 monolayer.
Figure 4Models showing the vibrations of A′1, E′ and E″ Raman-active modes for L = 5 WSe2.
A′1(1) at 248.83 cm−1; A′1(2) at 250.15 cm−1; A′1(3) at 251.21 cm−1; A′12(1) at 305.29 cm−1; A′12(2) at 306.84 cm−1;E′1(1) at 247.55 cm−1; E′1(2) at 247.65 cm−1; E′1(3) at 248.55 cm−1; E″1(1) at 247.59 cm−1 and E″1(2) at 248.54 cm−1.