Literature DB >> 23054672

The epistemic integrity of scientific research.

Jan De Winter1, Laszlo Kosolosky.   

Abstract

We live in a world in which scientific expertise and its epistemic authority become more important. On the other hand, the financial interests in research, which could potentially corrupt science, are increasing. Due to these two tendencies, a concern for the integrity of scientific research becomes increasingly vital. This concern is, however, hollow if we do not have a clear account of research integrity. Therefore, it is important that we explicate this concept. Following Rudolf Carnap's characterization of the task of explication, this means that we should develop a concept that is (1) similar to our common sense notion of research integrity, (2) exact, (3) fruitful, and (4) as simple as possible. Since existing concepts do not meet these four requirements, we develop a new concept in this article. We describe a concept of epistemic integrity that is based on the property of deceptiveness, and argue that this concept does meet Carnap's four requirements of explication. To illustrate and support our claims we use several examples from scientific practice, mainly from biomedical research.

Mesh:

Year:  2012        PMID: 23054672     DOI: 10.1007/s11948-012-9394-3

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Sci Eng Ethics        ISSN: 1353-3452            Impact factor:   3.525


  11 in total

1.  Problems in the design and reporting of trials of antifungal agents encountered during meta-analysis.

Authors:  H K Johansen; P C Gotzsche
Journal:  JAMA       Date:  1999-11-10       Impact factor: 56.272

2.  Croatian Medical Journal introduces culture, control, and the study of research integrity.

Authors:  M Petrovecki; M D Scheetz
Journal:  Croat Med J       Date:  2001-02       Impact factor: 1.351

Review 3.  Evidence b(i)ased medicine--selective reporting from studies sponsored by pharmaceutical industry: review of studies in new drug applications.

Authors:  Hans Melander; Jane Ahlqvist-Rastad; Gertie Meijer; Björn Beermann
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2003-05-31

Review 4.  Comparative efficacy of antipsychotics in the treatment of schizophrenia: a critical assessment.

Authors:  Rajiv Tandon; W Wolfgang Fleischhacker
Journal:  Schizophr Res       Date:  2005-09-02       Impact factor: 4.939

5.  Fostering integrity in research: definitions, current knowledge, and future directions.

Authors:  Nicholas H Steneck
Journal:  Sci Eng Ethics       Date:  2006-01       Impact factor: 3.525

6.  From "publish or perish" to "patent and prosper".

Authors:  Howard K Schachman
Journal:  J Biol Chem       Date:  2006-03-17       Impact factor: 5.157

Review 7.  The financing of drug trials by pharmaceutical companies and its consequences: part 2: a qualitative, systematic review of the literature on possible influences on authorship, access to trial data, and trial registration and publication.

Authors:  Gisela Schott; Henry Pachl; Ulrich Limbach; Ursula Gundert-Remy; Klaus Lieb; Wolf-Dieter Ludwig
Journal:  Dtsch Arztebl Int       Date:  2010-04-30       Impact factor: 5.594

8.  A study of manufacturer-supported trials of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in the treatment of arthritis.

Authors:  P A Rochon; J H Gurwitz; R W Simms; P R Fortin; D T Felson; K L Minaker; T C Chalmers
Journal:  Arch Intern Med       Date:  1994-01-24

9.  Scientific research and the public trust.

Authors:  David B Resnik
Journal:  Sci Eng Ethics       Date:  2010-08-29       Impact factor: 3.525

10.  Ghost authorship in industry-initiated randomised trials.

Authors:  Peter C Gøtzsche; Asbjørn Hróbjartsson; Helle Krogh Johansen; Mette T Haahr; Douglas G Altman; An-Wen Chan
Journal:  PLoS Med       Date:  2007-01       Impact factor: 11.069

View more
  2 in total

1.  Data-Intensive Science and Research Integrity.

Authors:  David B Resnik; Kevin C Elliott; Patricia A Soranno; Elise M Smith
Journal:  Account Res       Date:  2017-05-08       Impact factor: 2.622

2.  "For Its Size, the Most Complex Natural Product Known." Who Deserves Credit for Determining the Structure of Strychnine?

Authors:  Jeffrey I Seeman; Mark C House
Journal:  ACS Cent Sci       Date:  2022-06-08       Impact factor: 18.728

  2 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.