PURPOSE: To test the effect of an Appreciative Inquiry (AI) quality improvement strategy on clinical quality management and practice development outcomes. Appreciative inquiry enables the discovery of shared motivations, envisioning a transformed future, and learning around the implementation of a change process. METHODS:Thirty diverse primary care practices were randomly assigned to receive an AI-based intervention focused on a practice-chosen topic and on improving preventive service delivery (PSD) rates. Medical-record review assessed change in PSD rates. Ethnographic field notes and observational checklist analysis used editing and immersion/crystallization methods to identify factors affecting intervention implementation and practice development outcomes. RESULTS: The PSD rates did not change. Field note analysis suggested that the intervention elicited core motivations, facilitated development of a shared vision, defined change objectives, and fostered respectful interactions. Practices most likely to implement the intervention or develop new practice capacities exhibited 1 or more of the following: support from key leader(s), a sense of urgency for change, a mission focused on serving patients, health care system and practice flexibility, and a history of constructive practice change. CONCLUSIONS: An AI approach and enabling practice conditions can lead to intervention implementation and practice development by connecting individual and practice strengths and motivations to the change objective.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To test the effect of an Appreciative Inquiry (AI) quality improvement strategy on clinical quality management and practice development outcomes. Appreciative inquiry enables the discovery of shared motivations, envisioning a transformed future, and learning around the implementation of a change process. METHODS: Thirty diverse primary care practices were randomly assigned to receive an AI-based intervention focused on a practice-chosen topic and on improving preventive service delivery (PSD) rates. Medical-record review assessed change in PSD rates. Ethnographic field notes and observational checklist analysis used editing and immersion/crystallization methods to identify factors affecting intervention implementation and practice development outcomes. RESULTS: The PSD rates did not change. Field note analysis suggested that the intervention elicited core motivations, facilitated development of a shared vision, defined change objectives, and fostered respectful interactions. Practices most likely to implement the intervention or develop new practice capacities exhibited 1 or more of the following: support from key leader(s), a sense of urgency for change, a mission focused on serving patients, health care system and practice flexibility, and a history of constructive practice change. CONCLUSIONS: An AI approach and enabling practice conditions can lead to intervention implementation and practice development by connecting individual and practice strengths and motivations to the change objective.
Authors: Deborah Cohen; Reuben R McDaniel; Benjamin F Crabtree; Mary C Ruhe; Sharon M Weyer; Alfred Tallia; William L Miller; Meredith A Goodwin; Paul Nutting; Leif I Solberg; Stephen J Zyzanski; Carlos R Jaén; Valerie Gilchrist; Kurt C Stange Journal: J Healthc Manag Date: 2004 May-Jun
Authors: M A Goodwin; S J Zyzanski; S Zronek; M Ruhe; S M Weyer; N Konrad; D Esola; K C Stange Journal: Am J Prev Med Date: 2001-07 Impact factor: 5.043
Authors: L I Solberg; T E Kottke; M L Brekke; S Magnan; G Davidson; C A Calomeni; S A Conn; G M Amundson; A F Nelson Journal: Eff Clin Pract Date: 2000 May-Jun
Authors: Benjamin F Crabtree; Jenna Howard; William L Miller; DeANN Cromp; Clarissa Hsu; Katie Coleman; Brian Austin; Margaret Flinter; Leah Tuzzio; Edward H Wagner Journal: Milbank Q Date: 2020-05-13 Impact factor: 4.911
Authors: Luci K Leykum; Holly J Lanham; Jacqueline A Pugh; Michael Parchman; Ruth A Anderson; Benjamin F Crabtree; Paul A Nutting; William L Miller; Kurt C Stange; Reuben R McDaniel Journal: Implement Sci Date: 2014-11-19 Impact factor: 7.327
Authors: Donald E Nease; Matthew J Simpson; Linda Zittleman; Jodi Summers Holtrop; Tristen L Hall; Mary Fisher; Maret Felzien; John M Westfall Journal: J Prim Care Community Health Date: 2020 Jan-Dec