| Literature DB >> 19204035 |
Tara J T Kennedy1, Glenn Regehr, G Ross Baker, Lorelei Lingard.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To develop a conceptual framework of the influences on medical trainees' decisions regarding requests for clinical support from a supervisor.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2009 PMID: 19204035 PMCID: PMC2640114 DOI: 10.1136/bmj.b128
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ ISSN: 0959-8138
Clinical factors affecting requests from medical trainees for clinical support
| Themes and definitions | Representative transcript excerpts |
|---|---|
| Refers to influence of nature of clinical situation (such as urgency, importance) on decisions about requests for clinical support | “The other day when this guy came in short of breath . . . he just didn’t look good, he was working so hard to breathe and I started to talk to him, and at that point I was like ‘this guy could get really sick really fast,’ so I just ran out and called the fifth year emerg resident” (junior resident 13, emergency medicine) |
| Refers to way trainees’ judgments about whether or not required clinical action is outside expected knowledge or responsibility for their programme and level of training influences decisions about asking for clinical support related to that action | “You are expected to make certain decisions by yourself at a certain stage of training and that you are really inconveniencing someone else by asking them, that would be used to judge your level of competence I guess” (medical student 4, emergency medicine) |
Supervisor factors affecting requests from medical trainees for clinical support
| Themes and definitions | Representative transcript excerpts |
|---|---|
| Refers to examples of how physical proximity of supervisor and timing of clinical situation affect likelihood that trainees will ask for clinical support | “Especially if they’re busy, if they’re running around, answering pages, reassessing people, trying to deal with EMS calling on the patch phone for example . . . it can make it tough to sort of stick your head in and say ‘can we review a case’ or ‘I have a question’” (junior resident 9, emergency medicine) |
| Refers to influence of trainees’ perceptions of their relationship with supervisor on decisions about whether or not to ask for clinical support | “There are certain staff that are known for . . . they don’t like to be bothered, you feel that if you call them they’ll feel it’s just a petty problem, why didn’t you look after it yourself. They’ll think less of you as a resident” (junior resident 14, general internal medicine) |
EMS=emergency medical services (dispatching service for ambulances, etc).
Trainee factors affecting requests from medical trainees for clinical support
| Themes and definitions | Representative transcript excerpts |
|---|---|
| Refers to situations where trainees’ level of expertise has an impact on their ability to know when it would be appropriate to ask for clinical support | “I guess one of my pet-peeves . . . there were sort of a bunch of things last year where it wasn’t so much a problem of people didn’t know how to manage patients, but they just didn’t know how or when to call for help. And that’s sort of when bad things can happen” (senior resident 8, general internal medicine) |
| Refers to instances where trainees’ desire to take on responsibility and perform clinical activities independently might influence decisions about requesting clinical support | “I think there is some personal . . . satisfaction of getting a procedure done by yourself especially when you are a junior, you know it is really satisfying, so you might try not to ask for help” (senior resident 3, emergency medicine) |
| Refers to instances where trainees make decisions about requesting clinical support for evaluative or educational purposes | “I want to look like I’m independent and I can handle questions on my own and I don’t need to go to the attending for every little thing unless it’s big . . . [because] you want to impress and you want to have good things said about you at the end of your rotations” (junior resident 5, emergency medicine) |