S J Katz1, T P Hofer, W G Manning. 1. Departments of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-0376, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: This study compared physician use in Ontario and the midwestern and northeastern United States for persons of different socioeconomic status and health status. The distribution of health problems associated with the most recent physician visit also was compared. METHODS: The design of the study was cross sectional; data derived from the 1990 Ontario Health Survey and the 1990 US National Health Interview Survey were used in analyses. RESULTS: Overall, persons in Ontario averaged 19% more visits than US residents, but differences varied markedly across income and health status. At each level of health status, low- income Canadians had 25% to 33% more visits than their US counterparts. However, among higher income persons, those in excellent or very good health had 22% more visits than Americans, while those in good, fair, or poor health had 10% fewer visits than Americans. Higher visit rates in Ontario were not associated with a greater prevalence of low- priority visits. CONCLUSIONS: Under the Canadian single- payer system, medical care in Ontario has been redistributed to low-income persons and the elderly. Compared with the United States, there has been a lower intensity of medical care for the sick higher income population.
OBJECTIVES: This study compared physician use in Ontario and the midwestern and northeastern United States for persons of different socioeconomic status and health status. The distribution of health problems associated with the most recent physician visit also was compared. METHODS: The design of the study was cross sectional; data derived from the 1990 Ontario Health Survey and the 1990 US National Health Interview Survey were used in analyses. RESULTS: Overall, persons in Ontario averaged 19% more visits than US residents, but differences varied markedly across income and health status. At each level of health status, low- income Canadians had 25% to 33% more visits than their US counterparts. However, among higher income persons, those in excellent or very good health had 22% more visits than Americans, while those in good, fair, or poor health had 10% fewer visits than Americans. Higher visit rates in Ontario were not associated with a greater prevalence of low- priority visits. CONCLUSIONS: Under the Canadian single- payer system, medical care in Ontario has been redistributed to low-income persons and the elderly. Compared with the United States, there has been a lower intensity of medical care for the sick higher income population.
Authors: D B Mark; C D Naylor; M A Hlatky; R M Califf; E J Topol; C B Granger; J D Knight; C L Nelson; K L Lee; N E Clapp-Channing Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1994-10-27 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Deshayne B Fell; George Kephart; Lori J Curtis; Kelly Bower; Nazeem Muhajarine; Robert Reid; Leslie Roos Journal: Health Serv Res Date: 2007-08 Impact factor: 3.402
Authors: Kyndaron Reinier; Elizabeth Thomas; Douglas L Andrusiek; Tom P Aufderheide; Steven C Brooks; Clifton W Callaway; Paul E Pepe; Thomas D Rea; Robert H Schmicker; Christian Vaillancourt; Sumeet S Chugh Journal: CMAJ Date: 2011-09-12 Impact factor: 8.262
Authors: Song Gao; Braden J Manns; Bruce F Culleton; Marcello Tonelli; Hude Quan; Lynden Crowshoe; William A Ghali; Lawrence W Svenson; Sofia Ahmed; Brenda R Hemmelgarn Journal: CMAJ Date: 2008-11-04 Impact factor: 8.262