| Literature DB >> 36230128 |
Mikaela Young1, Nicholas Paul2, Dawn Birch3, Libby Swanepoel1,4.
Abstract
Seaweed has been traditionally consumed in Asian and Pacific cultures, yet aside from sushi, is still not commonly eaten in Western societies. Edible seaweeds offer distinct nutritional benefits to terrestrial crops, particularly with respect to mineral and fibre content. Understanding the motivations that drive young Australians to eat seaweed is necessary for food product development and consumer marketing strategies, as well as informing future sustainable production through seaweed aquaculture and wild-harvest practices. An observational cross-sectional online survey with n = 1403 young (19-30 years) Australian seaweed consumers was conducted. The 19-item survey included closed-ended, open-ended, and Likert scale responses. Most respondents were female (89.0%), with tertiary level education or above (57.7%). Seaweed was eaten mostly as a snack (87.7%) and in home-prepared meals (30.7%). The key advantages to consumption were flavour (89.1%), nutrient content (49.1%), and health benefits (44.6%), whilst the key barriers were poor accessibility (59.5%), unaffordable pricing (46.5%), and undesirable packaging (19.0%). The consumers reported wanting more promotion to improve their knowledge about seaweed, in addition to environmentally sustainable packaging and sourcing. Pathways to overcome barriers and encourage greater seaweed consumption are discussed. Most critically, improving the promotion and environmental sustainability of seaweed products will improve intake amongst current and future consumers.Entities:
Keywords: alginate; barrier; consumer behaviour; diet; marketing; motivator; packaging; snack; sustainability
Year: 2022 PMID: 36230128 PMCID: PMC9563983 DOI: 10.3390/foods11193052
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Foods ISSN: 2304-8158
Demographic characteristics of the study participants (n = 1403).
| Sample Characteristics | Frequency ( | Percent (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Age | ||
| 19–24 | 653 | 46.5 |
| 25–30 | 750 | 53.5 |
| Gender | ||
| Female | 1248 | 89.0 |
| Male | 73 | 5.2 |
| Non-binary/other/prefer not to say | 82 | 5.8 |
| Highest education level | ||
| Primary school | 5 | 0.4 |
| High school or equivalent | 319 | 22.7 |
| Diploma, certificate or equivalent | 259 | 18.5 |
| Tertiary level, equivalent, or above | 810 | 57.7 |
| Prefer not to say | 10 | 0.7 |
| Annual household income (AUD) | ||
| Under $40,000 | 316 | 22.5 |
| $40,000–$59,999 | 231 | 16.5 |
| $60,000–$99,999 | 349 | 24.9 |
| $100,000 or over | 368 | 26.2 |
| Prefer not to say | 139 | 9.9 |
| State of residence | ||
| New South Wales | 442 | 31.5 |
| Victoria | 360 | 25.7 |
| Queensland | 334 | 23.8 |
| South Australia | 92 | 6.6 |
| Western Australia | 82 | 5.8 |
| Australian Capital Territory | 54 | 3.8 |
| Tasmania | 34 | 2.4 |
| Northern Territory | 5 | 0.4 |
| Geographical classification | ||
| Metropolitan | 1095 | 78.0 |
| Rural | 266 | 19.0 |
| Metropolitan/rural | 42 | 3.0 |
Importance of various influences on decision making around the purchase of seaweed (n = 1403).
| Influence * | Importance of Influence on Decision Making (Frequency, Percentage) ** | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not Applicable | Not at All/Slightly | Moderately | Very Important | |
| Taste | ||||
| Cost | ||||
| Ease of | ||||
| Health | ||||
| Freshness | ||||
| Friend/family | ||||
* The influences are presented in descending order from most to least important. ** The four-point Likert scale is an amended version of the Likert scale used in the survey tool (see Methods 2.3).
Figure 1Current sources of seaweed-related information (n = 1403). The sources are presented in descending order from most to least reported. The data labels are representative of the percentage of respondents.
Figure 2Forms of seaweed known and consumed, as reported by participants. The varieties are presented in descending order from most to least reported, cumulatively, of both known and consumed responses. The data labels are representative of the percentage of respondents.
Figure 3Popularity of seaweed consumption across eating occasions (n = 1402). The eating occasions are presented in the figure in the way that they appear in the survey question. The data labels are representative of the percentage of participants that responded to each eating occasion.
Frequency of seaweed consumption at different settings (n = 1403).
| Setting * | Consumption Frequency (Frequency, Percentage) ** | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Never | Less Than Once Monthly | Monthly | Fortnightly | Weekly | Daily | |
| Home prepared | ||||||
| Sushi bar/train | ||||||
| Restaurant | ||||||
| Fast food/takeout | ||||||
* The settings are presented in descending order from the most to least frequently consumed. ** The six-point Likert scale presented is an amended version of the Likert scale used in the survey tool (see Methods 2.3).
Motivators and barriers of seaweed consumption, as reported by participants.
| Question (No.) | Theme | Frequency ( | Percentage (%) | Representative Quotes * |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advantages (8) | Flavour profile | 1248 | 89.1 |
“As a vegetarian, I find certain types of seaweed really bring out the umami flavour that is traditionally brought to the dish by non-vegetarian ingredients.” “Helps combat my cravings for salty, processed foods. The taste is unique and salty and satisfying.” |
| Desirable nutrient content | 688 | 49.1 |
“Contains many essential vitamins, nutrients and fibre with low calories.” “Good plant-based source of vitamins and minerals.” “It’s high in minerals such as iodine and magnesium, which are common deficiencies.” | |
| Health benefits | 625 | 44.5 |
“Low calorie, savoury snack alternative.” “I feel that it is a great alternative to salt to sprinkle on dinner.” “It’s fantastic for your health.” | |
| Other sensory characteristics | 274 | 19.6 |
“Aesthetically pleasing.” “Comes in a variety of textures—crunchy seaweed chips, soft seaweed wrapped sushi, fresh seaweed in soup.” “Feels nice in mouth.” | |
| Versatility | 203 | 14.5 |
“It’s tasty and versatile to use in many dishes.” “Incorporating seaweed into my diet has pushed me to expand my diet and cooking skills.” “There are so many different ways you can eat it!” | |
| Convenience | 162 | 11.6 |
“It is a delicious and convenient snack.” “They’re light, convenient and easy to carry.” “Easy to store, no fridge required and light in weight so (I) can carry it around all day.” | |
| Affordable price point | 130 | 9.3 |
“Easy to incorporate into meals and inexpensive.” “Super cheap to buy proper seaweed in bulk.” “Cheap alternative, great for a little snack.” | |
| Sushi | 122 | 8.7 |
“(Seaweed) makes eating sushi less messy.” “I LOVE to make sushi, so it is an essential in my kitchen cupboards.” “It holds delicious sushi fillings together.” | |
| Environmentally sustainable | 106 | 7.6 |
“Supports biodiversity and sustainability.” “(I am) pretty sure seaweed farming can be used to combat climate change.” “Sustainable source of food.” | |
| Disadvantages (9) | Undesirable side-effects | 508 | 38.0 |
“Seaweed breath.” “Gets visibly stuck in your teeth.” “Very messy, (I) get flakes everywhere.” |
| Unaffordable price point | 428 | 32.0 |
“These nice seaweed snacks I like are super expensive gram for gram.” “It is expensive, like all health halo foods.” “More expensive than it should be.” | |
| Lack of accessibility | 399 | 29.9 |
“(I) can’t grow it myself.” “Not readily available at Western supermarkets.” “Hard to find a range of varieties.” | |
| Other sensory characteristics | 340 | 25.4 |
“Some brands have an overpowering smell and are oily.” “Fingers get oily.” “Smells like the ocean.” | |
| Undesirable flavour profile | 262 | 19.6 |
“Can sometimes be overwhelmingly fishy in taste.” “Some varieties have a very strong flavour which can overtake a meal.” “It’s often seasoned with too much salt.” | |
| Undesirable packaging | 241 | 18.0 |
“Packaging is often in languages other than English (language barrier).” “Most seaweed snack packs contain too few sheets of seaweed and it’s not satisfying enough, so I have to open multiple packs.” “Brands promote how good seaweed is for the environment, yet it mostly is still packaged in plastic.” | |
| Undesirable processing | 239 | 17.9 |
“If you buy big packs it tends to go stale before you finish it.” “Often has a lot of oil in it, in commercial products.” “Hard to get good quality consistently.” | |
| Socially unacceptable | 157 | 11.8 |
“Stigma—outside of Asian cuisines, not a lot of people have popularised seaweed as food.” “Lack of understanding/discrimination from others.” “I can’t convince my friends to try it.” | |
| Undesirable nutrient content | 150 | 11.2 |
“If eaten in excess amounts and for long periods of time, can result in high levels of iodine.” “Most seaweed food items contain a lot of salt.” “Often comes with high sodium foods.” | |
| Inadequate knowledge, skills, and awareness | 148 | 11.1 |
“I don’t know many ways to cook it other than sushi.” “Hard to incorporate into lots of meals.” “It isn’t used in a lot of Western cooking, so it’s difficult to find new recipes.” | |
| Unsatiating | 115 | 8.6 |
“Low energy source – misconception that it’s a good snack on its own.” “Never feel completely satisfied after eating a pack.” “Not very filling, more of an addition than a full meal or snack.” | |
| Concern regarding environmental sustainability | 114 | 8.5 |
“You can’t know if the seaweed was farmed sustainably.” “Very hard to find organic or locally farmed seaweed.” “Potentially contaminated with heavy metals.” | |
| Enablers (10) | Greater accessibility | 972 | 71.8 |
“If seaweed was more commonly used in cafes/restaurants.” “More products at convenience stores/petrol stations/general grocery chains.” “Better resources about foraging seaweed.” |
| Affordable price point | 621 | 45.9 |
“Available in major grocery stores at Asian supermarket prices.” “Cheaper prices so it would be less of a ‘treat’ and something that could be had more often.” “Cheaper options (e.g., sushi, onigiri) in convenience stores.” | |
| Desirable packaging | 391 | 28.9 |
“Less plastic packaging, I want to satisfy my cravings without worrying about singlehandedly killing the planet.” “Clearer labelling in English (since many seaweed items are imported).” “If it came in vacuum sealed packs to buy in bulk.” | |
| Greater diversity of options | 384 | 28.4 |
“Maybe if there were more supermarket products containing seaweed i.e., muesli bars or something. I would probably eat seaweed ice-cream not going to lie.” “More flavours of seaweed snacks.” “Sold in different forms (not just dried).” | |
| Opportunity for more targeted promotion | 280 | 20.7 |
“More seaweed posts on social media regarding the benefits of seaweed, what brand to buy, etc.” “Better advertising so I remember it’s an option.” “Advertised more in media (including recipes).” | |
| Greater knowledge and skills | 111 | 8.2 |
“More time and knowledge to prepare seaweed-containing foods.” “Knowing what to do with seaweed at home (other than sushi).” “Better cooking skills/knowledge.” | |
| Desirable processing | 105 | 7.8 |
“If it didn’t spoil quickly.” “If seaweed crisps had olive oil and not oils like sunflower and canola.” “More consistent quality between brands.” | |
| Improved sensory characteristics | 95 | 7.0 |
“Have it smell less like fish??” “Create more seaweed products that taste nice instead of just focusing on the health.” “Less chewy sometimes (i.e., Japanese seaweed salad).” | |
| Environmentally sustainable sourcing | 79 | 5.8 |
“Clearer labelling/communication of where it is sourced from & how.” “More information available so I can be sure I am eating sustainably farmed seaweed.” “More Australian made and owned products.” | |
| Greater social acceptance | 77 | 5.7 |
“If people know about it more, then I would be more comfortable sharing it at parties and what not.” “If seaweed was normalised as a food (most people see it as a foreign ingredient).” “More normalised in Western cooking.” | |
| Barriers (11) | Lack of accessibility | 741 | 59.5 |
“Living in a rural town it is expensive and rare to find.” “I don’t know how to forage for it and assume I’m not legally meant to.” “Not all forms of seaweed are available, may need to go to a specialty shop or Asian grocer.” |
| Unaffordable price point | 579 | 46.5 |
“The cost prevents me from eating it as often as I’d like.” “Good quality/organic seaweed is quite expensive.” “Sometimes seaweed snacks are not worth the price.” | |
| Undesirable packaging | 237 | 19.0 |
“I don’t like how much plastic packaging it usually has so I try not to buy it too often.” “Packaging typically doesn’t display much nutritional information.” “Stockists almost never sell in bulk quantities.” | |
| Lack of product diversity | 209 | 16.8 |
“I only have access to nori, dulse and wakame so I run out of dishes to use it in.” “Not common in shops except in crackers and sushi.” “If it’s in local stores, it’s expensive and really always the same product with no variety.” | |
| Undesirable processing | 157 | 12.6 |
“Poor or untrustworthy quality.” “Shape (is) hard to use in cooking, e.g., long dried strands.” “Favourite crunchy snack seaweeds often cooked in unhealthy oils.” | |
| Lack of seaweed-related knowledge | 174 | 12.4 |
“Not sure how to make it more versatile.” “Not wanting to spend (money) on stuff I don’t know how to use properly.” “Sushi is time consuming to make and I don’t know what else to do with seaweed.” | |
| Social unacceptance | 153 | 12.3 |
“I rarely eat it in public due to the perception and judgement of others.” “Lack of normalisation in majority of Australian society.” “Family refuses to try it so I don’t bother buying it at times.” | |
| Undesirable flavour profile | 132 | 10.6 |
“Occasionally the taste can be strong and off-putting.” “When (processors are) adding salt to already salty seaweed.” “Sometimes they are overly seasoned to mask the taste of the sea.” | |
| Undesirable sensory characteristics | 112 | 9.0 |
“Sometimes I have textural issues with it when it is not crunchy.” “I only eat seaweed at home due to the overpowering smell of it which is not great in my workplace.” “Doesn’t appear appetising.” | |
| Inconvenient to prepare or purchase | 104 | 8.3 |
“(I will) usually only eat it at a restaurant or take away.” “Sushi is time consuming to make and I don’t know what else to do with seaweed.” “Getting to Asian supermarkets to source the best types of seaweed snacks can be inconvenient.” | |
| Undesirable side-effects of consumption | 97 | 7.8 |
“Strong seaweed breath.” “Can be a bit greasy and messy – so not much of an on-the-go snack.” “I have to make sure it’s not stuck on my teeth or face if I’m eating it around other people.” |
* The table presents the themes that correlated to ≥5.0% of respondents. The themes are presented in descending order from most to least frequently reported.