| Literature DB >> 36042465 |
Priya Vakil1, Amanda Henry1,2,3, Maria E Craig1,2,4, Megan L Gow5,6,7.
Abstract
Preeclampsia is a hypertensive disorder of pregnancy with serious health implications for mother and their offspring. The uteroplacental vascular insufficiency caused by preeclampsia is associated with epigenetic and pathological changes in the mother and fetus. However, the impact of preeclampsia in infancy (birth to 2 years), a time of rapid development influenced by pre- and postnatal factors that can predict future health outcomes, remains inconclusive. This narrative review of 23 epidemiological and basic science studies assessed the measurement and impact of preeclampsia exposure on infant growth and psychomotor developmental outcomes from birth to 2 years. Studies assessing infant growth report that preeclampsia-exposed infants have lower weight, length and BMI at 2 years than their normotensive controls, or that they instead experience accelerated weight gain to catch up in growth by 2 years, which may have long-term implications for their cardiometabolic health. In contrast, clear discrepancies remain as to whether preeclampsia exposure impairs infant motor and cognitive development, or instead has no impact. It is additionally unknown whether any impacts of preeclampsia are independent of confounders including shared genetic factors that predispose to both preeclampsia and childhood morbidity, perinatal factors including small for gestational age or preterm birth and their sequelae, and postnatal environmental factors such childhood nutrition. Further research is required to account for these variables in larger cohorts born at term, to help elucidate the independent pathophysiological impact of this clinically heterogenous and dangerous disease.Entities:
Keywords: Development; Growth; Hypertensive pregnancy; Infant; Preeclampsia
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 36042465 PMCID: PMC9426217 DOI: 10.1186/s12887-022-03542-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Pediatr ISSN: 1471-2431 Impact factor: 2.567
Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy: definitions and associated features
| Hypertensive Disorder | Definition of hypertension | Associated Features |
|---|---|---|
| Chronic hypertension | Onset before pregnancy or before 20 weeks’ gestation: − ≥ 140 mmHg SBP or − ≥ 90 mmHg DBP | − Mainly due to essential hypertension − 24-h ambulatory BP monitoring assists the exclusion of white-coat hypertension − Risk factor for preeclampsia, maternal CVD and FGR |
| Gestational hypertension | New onset at or after 20 weeks’ gestation: − ≥ 140 mmHg SBP or − ≥ 90 mmHg DBP | − May be transient in nature, arising and settling in the 2nd-3rd trimester − 25% will progress to preeclampsia − Return to normal BP postpartum with no antenatal proteinuria or maternal end-organ dysfunction − Increased future risk of maternal CVD |
| Preeclampsia | New onset at or after 20 weeks’ gestation with end-organ dysfunction: − ≥ 140 mm Hg SBP or − ≥ 90 mm Hg DBP | New onset of ≥ 1: − Proteinuria − Acute Kidney Injury − Elevated liver transaminases − Neurological complications − Thrombocytopenia − Uteroplacental dysfunction − FGR − HELLP syndrome (haemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, thrombocytopaenia) |
| Eclampsia | New onset of antenatal, intrapartum or postpartum tonic–clonic, focal, or multifocal seizures without other causative conditions | Often preceded by: − Severe and persistent occipital or frontal headaches − Blurred vision − Photophobia − Altered mental status |
Abbreviations: BP Blood pressure, CVD Cardiovascular disease, DBP Diastolic blood pressure, FGR Fetal growth restriction, mmHg millimetres of mercury, SBP Systolic blood pressure
Studies assessing the impact of preeclampsia exposure on growth in infancy (birth – 2 years)
| Szymonowicz (1987) [ | Prospective case–control | PE (35) NTP (35) | Weight | PE lower | Nil | Cohort: preterm, VLBW infantsb ROB: Low |
| Length | ND | |||||
| Head circumference | ||||||
Martikainen (1989) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (31 preterm, 40 term) NTP (128 preterm, 175 term) | Weight Length | Preterm: PE lower Term: ND | Infant sex, GA | Also assessed other HDPs Cohort stratified by hypertension exposure, prematurity and SGA status. Assessed 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
Weight gain Length gain | Term PE: greater catch up than preterm PE infants | |||||
| Head circumference | Preterm: ND Term: PE higher | |||||
| Cheng (2004) [ | Retrospective cohort | PE (28) NTP (61) | Weight | ND | Nil | Cohort: very preterm (< 32 weeks), VLBW infantsb. Small sample size ROB: Low |
| Length | ||||||
| Head circumference | ||||||
| Silveira (2007) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (40) NTP (46) | Weight, Weight-for-age | PE lower, slower catch-up weight in VLBW PE than VLBW NTP | GA | Cohort: preterm, VLBW infantsb. Assessed 12, 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Length-for-age | ND | |||||
| Head circumference | PE lower | |||||
| Weight-for-length | ||||||
| Davis (2015) [ | Prospective cohort | C-HTNc (89) NTP (1434) | Weight | ND | Infant sex, GA, birthweight | Grouped PE and GH causing preterm birth into C-HTN Assessed 12-month outcomes. Assessed growth and CVD risk to 20 years ROB: Low |
| Length | ||||||
| BMI | ||||||
| Byberg (2017) [ | Nested case–control | S-PEc (54) M/M-PEc (164) NTP (385) | Weight z-score | PE lower (all) | Infant sex, age Maternal age, BMI, antenatal smoking, education | Considered severity of PE Assessed growth to 13 years No adjustment for GA or birthweight ROB: Low |
| Length z-score gain | M/M-PE boys greater, S-PE boys and all girls lower | |||||
| BMI | MM-PE girls greater, S-PE girls and all boys lower | |||||
| Matić (2017) [ | Retrospective cohort | GH/PE (261) NTP (1212) | Weight | GH/PE lower | Nil | Grouped PE and GH Cohort: 2–3 year old infants born very preterm (< 29 weeks)b. Powered for chronic lung disease and neurodevelopment ROB: Low |
| Length | ||||||
| Head circumference | ||||||
| Gunnarsdottir (2018) [ | Retrospective cohort | S-PEc + M/M-PEc (865) NTP (22,898) | Length z-score | S-PE lower | Infant sex, GA, birthweight, SGA status, breastfeeding status Maternal age, parity, height, BMI, diabetes, smoking, education, country of birth Paternal smoking | Assessed 18-month outcomes. Assessed growth from birth to 5 years. No adjustment for paternal factors influencing length ROB: Low |
| Length gain | All PE greater, especially S-PE than M/M-PE infants, partly associated with GA | |||||
| Huang (2020) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (24) NTP (168) | BMI | PE greater | Infant sex, GA, birthweight Maternal age, parity, gestational diabetes mellitus, education, marital status | Considered association of both gestational diabetes mellitus and PE on growth. Assessed 18, 24-month outcomes. Assessed growth to 6 years. Small sample size ROB: Low |
| Gow (2021) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (84) NTP (298) | Weight Weight z-score | PE lower | Infant sex, GA, NICU/SCN stay length, feeding status, labour onset, mode of delivery Maternal age, weight, BMI, parity, ethnicity, smoking, education | Assessed 6-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Weight gain | PE greater | |||||
Weight z-score gain Rapid weight gain Conditional weight gain | ND, any SGA greater than not SGA | |||||
Length Length z-score | PE lower ND | |||||
Length gain Length z-score gain | PE greater ND | |||||
| BMI | ND | |||||
| Jasper (2021) [ | Retrospective cohort | PE (659) NTP (1909) | Rate of weight z-score gain | ND | Infant birthweight, GA, head circumference, multiple birth, postnatal hospitalisation, year of birth, mode of delivery, perinatal complications Maternal age, BMI, ethnicity, SES | Cohort: preterm infantsb Many perinatal exposures assessed, including PE ROB: Low |
Abbreviations: BMI Body mass index, C-HTNc Complicated hypertension exposed, CVD Cardiovascular disease, FGR Fetal growth restriction, GA Gestational age at birth, GH Gestational hypertension, M/M-PEc Mild/moderate preeclampsia, ND No difference, NICU/SCN Neonatal intensive care unit/special care nursery, NTP Normotensive pregnancy, PE Preeclampsia, ROB Risk of bias, SGA Small for gestational age, S-PEc Severe preeclampsia, VLBW Very low birth weight
aAll results in the ‘Main Findings’ column are of infant growth outcomes at 2 years, unless specified in the ‘Comments’ column. Any study that continued reporting outcomes beyond 2 years is also specified
bPreterm birth was defined as birth < 37 weeks’ gestation. VLBW was defined as birthweight < 1500 g. SGA birth was defined as birthweight corrected for gestational age < 10th centile. Study-specific definitions of ‘very preterm’ are specified in the ‘Comments’ column
cMild/moderate PE and severe PE definitions differed between studies: Davis et al. (2015) [18] combined PE and gestational hypertension severe enough to result in preterm delivery into C-HTN; Byberg et al. (2017) [27] used criteria developed by the CLASP study based on blood pressure and proteinuria levels at GA 20 weeks [33, 34]; Gunnarsdottir et al. (2018) [29] used the WHO ICD-10 classifications [35]
Fig. 1Factors associated with preeclampsia and mechanisms by which they may impact childhood growth and neurodevelopmental outcomes
Studies assessing the impact of preeclampsia exposure on infant neurodevelopment in infancy (birth – 2 years)
| Szymonowicz (1987) [ | Case–control | PE (35) NTP (35) | BSID | MDI: PE lower PDI: ND | Nil | Cohort: preterm, VLBW infantsb ROB: Low |
| Spinillo (1994) [ | Case–control | PE (68) NTP (184) | BSID | MDI: PE lower PDI: PE lower | Maternal age, SES, education | Cohort: preterm infants, PE group had expectant management ROB: Low |
| McCowan (2002) [ | Prospective cohort | PE/GH (88) NTP (131) | BSID-II | MDI: PE/GH higher PDI: ND ND between < 32 weeks and > 32 weeks | Infant sex, GA, hospital stay, breastfeeding status, perinatal complications Maternal age, parity, ethnicity, smoking, education | Cohort: SGA infantsb Grouped PE and GH Assessed 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Cheng (2004) [ | Retrospective cohort | PE (25) NTP (54) | BSID-II | MDI: PE lower (mild delay from -1 to -2 SDs), ND (severe delay), ND between SGA PE and SGA NTP PDI: ND | Infant sex, GA, birthweight, lack of prenatal steroid, PPROM, intraventricular haemorrhage Maternal/paternal education, chronic lung disease | Cohort: VLBW, very preterm (< 32 weeks) infantsb. Small sample ROB: Low |
| Silveria (2007) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (40) NTP (46) | BSID-II | MDI: ND PDI: PE higher | Nil | Cohort: VLBW infantsb Small sample. Assessed 12, 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Spinillo (2009) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (185) NTP (596) | BSID-II | MDI: PE higher (female higher than male), SGA lower than non-SGA | Infant sex, GA, proportion of expected birthweight, SGA status, antenatal steroids, placental abruption, praevia, PPROM, non-reassuring fetal heart rate, chorioamnionitis, caesarean section, year of birth, umbilical artery pH = < 7.2 Maternal age, parity, education, SES, smoking | Cohort: preterm infantsb ROB: Low |
| Schlapbach (2010) [ | Case–control | PE (33) NTP (33) | BSID-II | MDI: ND PDI: ND | Infant GA, birthweight, 2-year body weight, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, mechanical ventilation | Cohort: very preterm (< 32 weeks) infantsb |
| Matić (2017) [ | Retrospective cohort | PE/GH (261) NTP (1212) | Griffiths MDS, BSID-II | ND Long-term functional disability: SGA status, earlier GA and male sex were significant | Infant sex, GA, birthweight, surfactant therapy Maternal parity | Grouped PE and GH Cohort: infants aged 2–3 years, born very preterm (< 29 weeks). Powered to assess chronic lung disease, not just neurodevelopment ROB: Low |
| Degirmenci-oglu (2018) [ | Retrospective cohort | PE (120) NTP (251) | BSID-II | MDI: PE higher PDI: ND Overall neurodevelopmental index: ND | Infant GA, birthweight, asphyxia, sepsis, intraventricular haemorrhage, necrotising enterocolitis Maternal hypothyroidism | Cohort: VLBW, very preterm (< 32 weeks) infants, but FGR infants were excludedb Assessed 18- 24-month outcomes ROB: Low |
Martikainen (1989) [ | Prospective cohort | GH (14 preterm, 60 term) PE (31 preterm, 40 term) NTP (128 preterm, 175 term) | Denver | Term: PE/GH higher motor performance, visuo-auditory perception, and social abilities Preterm: PE lower fine motor and visuo-auditory perception, SGA lower than non-SGA | Infant sex, GA | Also assessed other HDPs. Cohort stratified by hypertension exposure, prematurity and SGA statusb. Assessed 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Gray (1998) [ | Prospective cohort | GH (14) PE (79) NTP (107) | Griffiths-II, NSMDA | ND | Nil | Cohort: very preterm (24–32 weeks) infantsb ROB: Low |
| Johnson (2015) [ | Prospective cohort | Preterm (638) Term (765) | PARCA-R | Preterm: PE was independent risk factor for cognitive impairment, preterm lower than term | Infant sex, SGA status Maternal ethnicity, SES | Cohort: late preterm infants (32–36 weeks)b Assessed other perinatal variables, including PE ROB: Low |
| Wade (2016) [ | Prospective cohort | HDP (23) NTP (478) | Many tools- see study | Social cognition: HDP lower | Infant age, sex, GA, birthweight Maternal age, gestational diabetes mellitus, thyroid problems, SES, smoking status | Grouped PE with other HDPs. Small sample Assessed 18-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Warshafsky (2016) [ | Prospective cohort | Mild PE (34) Severe PE (46) NTP (103) | ASQ | Severe PE was protective, higher GA reduced risk and FGR increased risk in both groups | Infant sex, GA, SGA status breastfeeding status, MgSO4 usage Maternal age, parity, ethnicity, smoking, SES, education | Cohort: FGR infants below 5th centile Removed the mild PE subgroup due to poor numbers. Assessed 12, 24-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Bharadwaj (2018) [ | Case–control | PE (56) NTP (61) | DASII | Motor and mental development quotients: PE lower, maternal total antioxidant status was an independent motor development quotient predictor (PE group) | Infant GA, early onset sepsis, respiratory distress syndrome, necrotising enterocolitis Maternal total antioxidant status, Maternal and cord/baby protein carbonyl levels | No adjustment for SGA or prematurity status Assessed 12-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Chen (2020) [ | Prospective cohort | GH (233) PE (41) NTP (3669) | GDS | Social Behaviour Development Quotient: GH lower Neurodevelopmental delay: ND | Infant sex, GA, birthweight, mode of delivery, asphyxia neonatorum Maternal age, smoking, drinking, education, folic acid supplementation | Also studied chronic hypertension Assessed 6-month outcomes ROB: Low |
| Maher (2020) [ | Prospective cohort | PE (709) NTP (10,425) | ASQ | ASQ failure: ND, ND between preterm vs term | Infant sex, SGA, prematurity Maternal age, ethnicity, BMI, gestational diabetes mellitus, education, SES | PE status determined by maternal recall. Assessed 9-month outcomes ROB: Low |
Abbreviations: ASQ Ages and Stages Questionnaire [125], BSID-II Bayley Scales of Infant Development (2nd edition) [138], C-HTN† Complicated hypertension, DASII Developmental Assessment Scale for Indian Infants [160], Denver The Denver Developmental Screening Test [161], FGR Fetal growth restriction, GA gestational age at birth, GDS Gesell Developmental Schedules [162, 163], GH Gestational hypertension, HDP Hypertensive disorder of pregnancy, HTN, Hypertension, MDI Mean developmental index (BSID), MDS Griffiths Mental Development Scale [141], ND No difference, NSMDA Neurosensory Motor Developmental Assessment [164], NTP Normotensive pregnancy, PARCA-R Parent Report of Children’s Abilities- Revised [132], PDI Psychomotor development index (BSID), PE Preeclampsia, PRROM Preterm premature rupture of the membranes, ROB Risk of bias, SES Socioeconomic status, SGA Small for gestational age, VLBW Very low birth weight
aAll results in the ‘Main Findings’ column are of infant developmental outcomes at 2 years, unless specified in the ‘Comments’ column
bPreterm birth was defined as birth < 37 weeks’ gestation. VLBW was defined as birthweight < 1500 g. SGA birth was defined as birthweight corrected for gestational age < 10th centile. Study-specific definitions of ‘very preterm’ are specified in the ‘Comments’ column