Metal complexes bearing nitrido ligands (M≡N) are at the forefront of current scientific research due to their resemblances with the metal complexes involved in the nitrogen fixation reactions. An oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex was used as a precursor complex for the facile synthesis of a new nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex was characterized by various spectroscopic techniques. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex to assign the vibrational and electronic transitions of this complex. The chromium-nitrogen (nitrido) bond distance obtained in the DFT-optimized structure is 1.530 Å and matches well with the earlier reported authentic Cr≡N bond distances obtained from the single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. This nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) compound exhibited a sharp Soret band at 438 nm and a Q band at 608 nm. DFT calculations deliver that the origin of the bands at 438 and 608 nm is due to the intraligand charge transfer transitions. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex showed one reversible oxidation and one reversible reduction couple at +0.53 and -0.06 V, respectively, vs the Ag/AgCl reference electrode. The simulation of the electron paramagnetic resonance data of the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) compound provided the following parameters: g iso = 1.987, A 53Cr = 26 G, and A 14N = 2.71 G. From all these analyses, we can conclude that the electronic configuration in the native state of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) can be best described as [(cor3-)CrV(N3-)]-. Reactions of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) with the chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex resulted in a complete intermetal N atom transfer reaction between chromium corrole and chromium porphyrin complexes. A second-order rate constant of 4.29 ± 0.10 M-1 s-1 was obtained for this reaction. It was also proposed that this reaction proceeds via a bimetallic μ-nitrido intermediate.
Metal complexes bearing nitrido ligands (M≡N) are at the forefront of current scientific research due to their resemblances with the metal complexes involved in the nitrogen fixation reactions. An oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex was used as a precursor complex for the facile synthesis of a new nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex was characterized by various spectroscopic techniques. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex to assign the vibrational and electronic transitions of this complex. The chromium-nitrogen (nitrido) bond distance obtained in the DFT-optimized structure is 1.530 Å and matches well with the earlier reported authentic Cr≡N bond distances obtained from the single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. This nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) compound exhibited a sharp Soret band at 438 nm and a Q band at 608 nm. DFT calculations deliver that the origin of the bands at 438 and 608 nm is due to the intraligand charge transfer transitions. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex showed one reversible oxidation and one reversible reduction couple at +0.53 and -0.06 V, respectively, vs the Ag/AgCl reference electrode. The simulation of the electron paramagnetic resonance data of the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) compound provided the following parameters: g iso = 1.987, A 53Cr = 26 G, and A 14N = 2.71 G. From all these analyses, we can conclude that the electronic configuration in the native state of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) can be best described as [(cor3-)CrV(N3-)]-. Reactions of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) with the chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex resulted in a complete intermetal N atom transfer reaction between chromium corrole and chromium porphyrin complexes. A second-order rate constant of 4.29 ± 0.10 M-1 s-1 was obtained for this reaction. It was also proposed that this reaction proceeds via a bimetallic μ-nitrido intermediate.
Synthetic metalloporphyrins are frequently
described as model systems
for various enzymatic active sites.[1] However,
it was observed that often, these intermediates bearing metalloporphyrins
are highly reactive, and thus, it essentially precludes their spectroscopic
characterization. In this context, a corrole ligand system has some
definitive advantage over the porphyrin-based systems.[2] Corrole is an 18 π-electron tetrapyrrolic aromatic
system similar to porphyrin. It has a smaller cavity size than porphyrin
and is also less symmetric than porphyrin.[2] Corroles are trianionic when fully deprotonated as opposed to porphyrin,
which is dianionic.[2] The inner π
system of corrole is more electron-rich, and thus, it stabilizes the
higher oxidation states of metals.[3−26] Transition metal complexes bearing multiple bonds between metals
and ligands, e.g., nitrido, imido, oxo, alkylidyne, and alkylidene,
have gained considerable research interest in recent times.[27−31] Multiple bonded metal–ligand complexes are frequently invoked
in the atom and group transfer reactions. In this context, metal complexes
bearing nitride ligands (M≡N) are at the forefront of current
scientific research due to their resemblance with the metal complexes
involved in the nitrogen fixation reactions.[32,33] Nitride complexes are also efficiently used in the nitrogenation
reactions of various organic compounds.[34,35] The nitride
ligand is also known for the stabilization of higher oxidation states
of metals. Thus, a combination of nitride and corrole ligand functionalities
would be a perfect choice for stabilizing higher oxidation states
of metals. Metal complexes bearing highly oxidized metal centers are
frequently encountered in various catalytic oxidation reactions.[1,2] It was also observed that the metal complexes bearing a nitride
ligand (N3–) are more abundant with second- and
third-row transition metals.[36] However,
similar complexes with first-row transition metals are scarcely reported
in the literature. Only a limited number of examples are available
for well-characterized nitridochromium complexes {both (+V) and (+VI)
oxidation states}.[37] It was also observed
that similar reports in porphyrinoid-based ligand scaffolds, i.e.,
nitrido(porphyrinoid)chromium(V/VI)-type complexes, are indeed very
few.[38] The first structurally characterized
nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V) complex was reported by Groves et al.[38a] In the corrole framework,
spectroscopically characterized nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complexes
were reported by Gross and Golubkov[38b] and
Christensen et al.[38c] We
have reported here the synthesis of a new nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex, namely, [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3 (Scheme ). An oxo[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V) complex, 1,[39] has been used as a precursor complex, and the
synthesis of a new nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex was achieved via using nitrido(salophen)manganese(V) [salophen =N,N′-phenylenebis(salicylidene-iminato) dianion] as
a nitrogen atom transfer reagent (Scheme ). The nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V) complex, 3, has been
fully characterized via various spectroscopic techniques.
Theoretical calculations were also performed in order to understand
the spectroscopic nature of this nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex, 3.
Scheme 1
Structures of Oxo[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V),[39]1, {Bis(triphenylphosphineoxide)}[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(III), 2, and
[Nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3
Scheme 2
Schematic Representation of the Formation of Nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, from the Precursor Complex Oxido(corrolato)chromium(V), 1, via the Intermediate Complex {Bis(triphenylphosphineoxide)}(corrolato)chromium(III), 2
Results and Discussion
Synthesis and Characterization
The oxo[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V) complex (1) was synthesized by refluxing a mixture of 5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrole and Cr(CO)6 in toluene
by following an earlier reported protocol.[39] The elemental analyses and UV–Vis, FT-IR, and ESI-MS data
(Figures S1–S3 and Tables S1 and S2) of complex 1 match well with
the authentic compound reported in the literature.[39] Meanwhile, most often, the (corrolato)chromium(III) complexes
were used as a starting material and are converted into nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complexes via nitrogen atom transfer reactions using
(salen)MnV(N) {salen = N,N′-ethylenebis(salicylideneiminato) dianion} or (saloph)MnV(N) complexes as a nitrogen atom source.[38b] However, in the present case, we have used an oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex as the precursor complex. We believe that the use of the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex as a starting material will be more advantageous as the chromium
metalation in the corrole core often yields the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex directly via aerial oxidation. Thus, one
does not need to reduce it further in a separate reaction to get the
precursor complex, (pyridine)2(corrolato)chromium(III),
as described by Gross and Golubkov.[38b] We
have observed that the addition of (saloph)MnV(N) and PPh3 in a solution of the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex in
a dichloromethane–acetonitrile mixture in a stepwise manner
resulted in the generation of the nitridochromium(V) complex in good
yields (Scheme ).
Meanwhile, Gross et al. reported earlier the generation
of (corrolato)CrIII(OPPh3)2 derivatives via the treatment of PPh3 into a solution of
the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative in an argon atmosphere.[40] Based on their observations, we have also proposed
the generation of (corrolato)CrIII(OPPh3)2 derivatives in the first step. Thus, the first step likely
involves the reduction of the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex into
the chromium(III)–corrolato complex with two axially bound
O=PPh3 ligands. This chemical transformation is
highly feasible as it was observed earlier that oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
complexes can effectively transfer oxygen atoms to PPh3 ligands and can generate (corrolato)chromium(III) and O=PPh3.[40] The conversion of PPh3 to O=PPh3 was described by earlier researchers.
We have also confirmed it via ESI-MS data. The intermediate
compound, {5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}CrIII(OPPh3)2, 2 is highly
unstable and is immediately converted back into the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
derivative via aerial oxidation.Albeit a different
reaction condition was used, the similar reactivities of (corrolato)CrIII(OPPh3)2 derivatives {corrolato =
tris(pentafluorophenyl)corrolato} were earlier reported by Gross et al.[40] As these derivatives
are highly air-sensitive, thus, they have not isolated them in a pure
form. We have also observed similar kinds of reactivities of this
intermediate compound, 2. Compound 2 was
characterized via the ESI-MS technique (Figure S5, see the Supporting Information). This intermediate compound, 2, was
also analyzed via various spectroscopic techniques
like UV–Vis, IR, and EPR (Figures S6–S8, see the Supporting Information). All
these techniques prove the composition of compound 2.
In the subsequent step, the nitrogen atom transfer took place (Scheme ). The resultant
nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative, 3, is paramagnetic
in nature; thus, it is characterized via X-band EPR
spectroscopy. Compound 3 is sufficiently stable in the
solid state (for days).However, in solution (except CH3CN and benzene), the
compound decomposes within minutes.
DFT-Optimized Structure
In order to support the experimental
findings, we have performed the DFT calculations on [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3. As no crystal structure was reported earlier with other
analogous nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complexes, thus, the bond
parameters of the DFT-calculated structures can be compared with the
literature-reported crystal structure of the nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V)
derivative by Groves et al.[38a] The bond lengths and angles of the DFT-optimized structure of 3 (Figure ) match well with the earlier reported nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V)
derivative.[38a] The chromium–nitrogen
(nitrido) bond distance obtained in the DFT-optimized structure of 3 is 1.530 Å. In the single-crystal data of nitrido(5,10,15,20-tetra-p-tolylporphyrinato)chromium(V), CrN(TTP), the similar distance
was reported to be 1.565 Å.[38a] This
short chromium–nitrogen (nitrido) bond distance supports triple
bond formation between chromium and nitrogen. The out-of-plane displacement
(from the N4 corrole plane) of the chromium atom is 0.577 Å.
This displacement is comparable to the other literature-reported oxo(corrolato)chromium(V)
derivatives.[23] In the oxo[10-(p-hydroxyphenyl)-5,15-bis(m-bromophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V)
derivative, the chromium atom is axially displaced from the N4 corrole
plane by 0.57 Å.[23]
Figure 1
DFT-optimized structure
of 3.
DFT-optimized structure
of 3.The chromium–nitrogen (pyrrolic) bond lengths
are in the
range of 1.988–1.997 Å. These bond distances matched nicely
with the previously reported bond distances of CrN(TTP). The analogous
distances in CrN(TTP) are in the ranges of 2.032–2.052 Å.[38a]
Electronic Absorption Spectroscopy
Compound 1 exhibited a Soret band and a Q band at 404 and 557 nm, respectively.
Compound 3 also exhibited a Soret band and a Q band at
438 and 608 nm, respectively. Two weak shoulders were also observed
at 506 and 540 nm. Thus, both the Soret and Q bands are redshifted
in the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) complex in comparison to the
oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex. To support the experimentally obtained
UV–Vis spectra, TD-DFT calculations were carried out on 3. The theoretically calculated UV–Vis spectra of 3 match reasonably well with the DFT-calculated spectra (Figures and 3). From TD-DFT, the origin of the band at 466 nm, which matches
with the experimentally observed absorption maximum at 438 nm, can
be ascribed to SOMO-1 to LUMO+1 transitions (2.66 eV). The experimentally
observed Q band at 608 nm is due to SOMO to LUMO transitions (2.13
eV). Further, the origins of the bands at 438 and 608 nm are attributed
to the ILCT transitions (Figure ). Selected molecular orbitals involved in the electronic
transitions and their orbital contributions are given in Table S3 and Figure S9. It was also observed
that the experimentally obtained FT-IR and FT-Raman spectra of 3 match well with the DFT-calculated FT-IR and FT-Raman spectra
of 3 (Figures and 5). The assignment of important
vibrational frequencies of 3 is summarized in Table S4. The experimentally obtained ν(Cr≡N)
band at 1076 cm–1 matches well with the DFT-obtained
ν(Cr≡N) band at 1137 cm–1 with a scaling
factor of 0.955. The obtained ν(Cr≡N) vibrational frequency
of 3 is observed at a slightly higher energy side in
comparison with the earlier reported value of 1017 cm–1 for a nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V) complex by Groves et al.[38a] The ν(Cr≡O)
vibrational frequency of 1 is observed at 1064 cm–1. Meanwhile, in both the complexes (1 and 3), most of the stretching vibrations are very
much similar; however, the close comparison reveals that the vibration
at 1076 cm–1 {ν(Cr≡N)} is absent in
the FT-IR spectra of the oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) complex. In analogy
with that, the band at 1064 cm–1 {ν(Cr≡O)}
is also clearly missing in the FT-IR spectra of the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex. Meanwhile, comparing the FT-IR data of all the three complexes
(1, 2, and 3), both the vibrations
{ν(Cr≡O) and ν(Cr≡N)} are missing in the
FT-IR spectra of 2.
Figure 2
Calculated single occupied molecular orbitals
(SOMO) and the lowest
unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of 3 involved in
particular electronic transitions with maximum contributions and their
corresponding transition energies.
Figure 3
Experimentally obtained UV–Vis absorption spectrum
(red
line) of 3 and TD-DFT-based absorption spectrum (black
line) of 3 in acetonitrile using an IEF-PCM solvent model
(Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM of ∼25 nm).
Figure 4
Experimentally obtained FT-IR spectrum of 3 (red line)
and DFT computation-based IR spectrum of 3 (black line)
(scaling factor of 0.955; Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM of ∼15
cm–1).
Figure 5
Experimentally obtained FT-Raman spectrum of 3 (red
line) and DFT computation-based Raman spectrum of 3 (black
line) (scaling factor of 0.955; Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM
of ∼7 cm–1).
Calculated single occupied molecular orbitals
(SOMO) and the lowest
unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of 3 involved in
particular electronic transitions with maximum contributions and their
corresponding transition energies.Experimentally obtained UV–Vis absorption spectrum
(red
line) of 3 and TD-DFT-based absorption spectrum (black
line) of 3 in acetonitrile using an IEF-PCM solvent model
(Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM of ∼25 nm).Experimentally obtained FT-IR spectrum of 3 (red line)
and DFT computation-based IR spectrum of 3 (black line)
(scaling factor of 0.955; Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM of ∼15
cm–1).Experimentally obtained FT-Raman spectrum of 3 (red
line) and DFT computation-based Raman spectrum of 3 (black
line) (scaling factor of 0.955; Lorentzian broadening with an FWHM
of ∼7 cm–1).
Electrochemistry
Cyclic voltammetric (CV) and differential
pulse voltammetric (DPV) measurements were performed to understand
the redox properties of complex 3. The measurements are
performed by using acetonitrile as a solvent and tetra-n-butyl ammonium perchlorate (0.1 M) as a supporting electrolyte (Table S1 and Figure ). The Ag/AgCl reference electrode was also
used to express potentials. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative, 3, exhibited one reversible oxidation couple at +0.53 V (ΔEp = 80 mV) vs Ag/AgCl. It also
showed one reversible reduction couple at −0.06 V (ΔEp = 80 mV). These values are in good agreement
with the values reported by Gross and Golubkov for a similar nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
derivative.[38b] This value is drastically
different from that of an earlier reported nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V)
derivative.[38] However, it is essentially
very difficult to conclude the metal/ligand-centered redox processes
from the electrochemistry data alone. Spectroelectrochemical data
are necessary to pinpoint the redox processes.
Figure 6
Cyclic (CV) (solid line)
and differential pulse voltammogram (DPV)
(dashed line) of [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3, in CH3CN. The potentials
are vs Ag/AgCl.
Cyclic (CV) (solid line)
and differential pulse voltammogram (DPV)
(dashed line) of [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3, in CH3CN. The potentials
are vs Ag/AgCl.
EPR Spectroscopy
The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
derivative, 3, demonstrated EPR signals in solution at
room temperature (Figure ).
Figure 7
Experimental and simulated EPR spectrum of [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3, in CH3CN at 298 K.
Experimental and simulated EPR spectrum of [nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]−, 3, in CH3CN at 298 K.An isotropic EPR signal was obtained in fluid solution
at RT. The
spectrum of the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative, 3, shows 11 hyperfine lines. The origin of the 11 lines is due to
the hyperfine coupling of the unpaired electron residing at the Cr
center with the four pyrrolic nitrogen atoms and one nitrido nitrogen
atom (99.6% 14N, I = 1). In addition to
the 11 hyperfine lines, very weak satellite peaks are also present
in the spectrum. These peaks are due to the presence of a 53Cr nucleus. This spectrum can be simulated by considering hyperfine
coupling to five 14N (99.6% 14N, I = 1) nuclei and also to 53Cr (I = 3/2,
natural abundance of 9.5%; other isotopes, I = 0).
The simulated EPR spectrum reproduced the experimental results with
reasonable accuracy. Thus, in the native state, the oxidation state
of chromium in compound 3 is also +5. The simulation
of the EPR data of compound 3 provided the following
parameters: giso = 1.987, A53Cr = 26 G, and A14N = 2.71
G (Figure and Table S2). These values are in line with the
other earlier reported authentic nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) and
nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V) complexes.[38a,38b] The electronic configuration in the native state of compound 3 thus can be best described as [(cor3–)CrV(N3–)]−.
Nitrogen Atom Transfer Reactivity
The intermetal nitrogen
atom transfer reaction was also studied between nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and a chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex, 4. Although similar studies were described in a porphyrin
framework,[38d] it was never described earlier
in a corrole metal complex. The progress of the nitrogen atom transfer
reaction was studied by using a spectrophotometer. The kinetics of
this reaction was studied by monitoring the change of absorption spectra
of reactants and products as a function of time. The reaction between
nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and a chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III)
complex, 4, resulted in the formation of nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V), 5, and a probable (corrolato)chromium(III) species (Scheme ).
Scheme 3
Schematic Representation
of the Formation of Nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V), 5, and a Probable (Corrolato)chromium(III) Species from the
Precursor Complex Nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and
a Chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) Complex, 4
The reaction between nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and a chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex, 4, in benzene solution is completed in 3–4 h, and the
reaction
is irreversible in nature. From the UV–Vis spectra of the end
product, it is evident that this reaction resulted in the complete
transfer of nitrogen atoms (Figure S10,
see the Supporting Information). The end
product of this reaction, i.e., the nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V)
species, 5, is fully characterized via UV–vis, IR, and EPR data (Figures S10–S12, see the Supporting Information). The
end product (after complete transfer of nitrogen atoms) exhibited
characteristic spectral data relevant to the presence of nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V)
species,[38g]5. A sharp Soret
band at 421 nm and a Q band at 542 nm in benzene confirm the presence
of compound 5 in the reaction mixture (Figure S10). The compound 5 (in the reaction
mixture) also exhibited the ν(Cr≡N) band at 1017 cm–1, and it matches well with the literature-reported
values (Figure S11).[38g] An isotropic EPR signal was obtained in fluid solution
at RT. The spectrum shows 11 hyperfine lines. The simulation of the
EPR data of the end product provided the following parameters: giso = 1.986, A53Cr = 27.9 G, and A14N = 2.96 G (Figure S12 and Table S2, see the Supporting Information).[38g] The EPR data also suggest the presence of compound 5 in the reaction mixture. The kinetics of this reaction is
measured for the change of absorbance as a function of time. A typical
analysis is presented in the inset of Figure . A second-order rate constant of 4.29 ±
0.10 M–1 s–1 is obtained. The
rate constant for the reaction of nitridochromium(V) octaethylporphyrin
and chlorochromium(III) tetraphenylporphyrins in benzene was reported
to be 6.8 to 1420 M–1 s–1.[38d] A mechanism has been proposed by Bottomley
and Neely for these kinds of intermetal N atom transfer reactions.
We also believe that a similar type of mechanism is also involved
here. A μ-nitrido intermediate is generated via the nucleophilic attack of nitrogen atoms of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
to the backside of chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III).[38e] Although there is no direct proof available
for the existence of μ-nitrido intermediate species in solution,
keeping the reaction mixture at a higher temperature for several hours
also does not lead to any back reaction. It thus supports that the
driving force of this nitrogen atom transfer reaction is purely thermodynamic
in nature.[38e]
Figure 8
Time evolution of UV–Vis
absorption spectra of an equal
volume mixture of 0.4 × 10–5 M nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and 0.4 × 10–5 M (porphyrinato)chromium(III), 4, in benzene in a cuvette (normalized). The inset shows the
typical A0/A time plot.
Time evolution of UV–Vis
absorption spectra of an equal
volume mixture of 0.4 × 10–5 M nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and 0.4 × 10–5 M (porphyrinato)chromium(III), 4, in benzene in a cuvette (normalized). The inset shows the
typical A0/A time plot.Additionally, the energetics of the intermetal
nitrogen atom transfer
reaction was also studied by employing DFT calculations. All the reactants
{nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, and the chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III)
complex, 4} and products {nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V), 5, and (corrolato)chromium(III) species} were optimized at
the B97D level of theory. The free energy values were calculated by
using the SMD solvation model by performing a single-point energy
calculation in a benzene solvent. Zero-point energy correction was
done while calculating the free energies of the product formation.
The schematic presentation of the nitrogen atom transfer reaction
and the energetics of reactants and products are depicted in Figure S13. The higher product energy (ΔG = 36.7 kcal/mol) with respect to the reactants indicates
the endothermic nature of the reaction. The involvement of multiple
transition states and intermediates in the reaction mechanism has
been ignored in the energy profile diagram. However, we could optimize
one possible reaction intermediate, i.e., (corrolato)chromium(V)-nitrido-chromium(III)
(porphyrinato) (Figure ). This species is probably involved in the N atom transfer reaction
from the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) moiety to the (porphyrinato)chromium(III)
moiety with concomitant electron transfer. It is worthwhile mentioning
here that we have optimized the energy profile of the reactants and
products, and based on that, we have calculated the corresponding
free energy change. Thus, a direct correlation between the asymmetric
nitride-bridged intermediate complex (Figure ) with the computed thermodynamics is not
possible.
Figure 9
Spin density representations for the μ-nitrido intermediate
complex: (corrolato)chromium(V)-nitrido-chromium(III) (porphyrinato)
(iso-value of 0.02). The quintet ground state was used for computation.
Spin density representations for the μ-nitrido intermediate
complex: (corrolato)chromium(V)-nitrido-chromium(III) (porphyrinato)
(iso-value of 0.02). The quintet ground state was used for computation.It has been shown experimentally that the intermolecular
interaction
in the ···Cr–N≡Cr–N···
chain structure (in a polymeric nitridochromium(V) complex) is ferromagnetic
in nature.[37g] In the proposed reaction
intermediate, i.e., (corrolato)chromium(V)-nitrido-chromium(III) (porphyrinato),
the Cr(V) is inside the corrole ring and has a coordination number
of 5 and has one unpaired electron, and the Cr(III) inside the porphyrin
cavity has also a coordination number of 5 and has three unpaired
electrons. In analogy with the earlier observations,[37g] we have assumed that the reaction intermediate has an S = 2 ground spin state. From the DFT-optimized structure,
it is clearly evident that the Cr–N bond distance (1.64 Å)
of the (corrolato)chromium section of the μ-nitrido dimer is
relatively longer than that of the Cr–N bond distance (1.53
Å) of the (corrolato)chromium(V) nitrido complex. This clearly
explains the strong affinity of nitrogen atoms toward the (porphyrinato)chromium(III)
moiety. Thus, the structural analysis of this most probable intermediate
species clearly explains the observed N atom transfer reactivity.
The spin density representation of the μ-nitrido intermediate
complex is shown in Figure . The calculated spin density on chromium in the (corrolato)chromium(V)
section of the dimer is 2.76 and in the (porphyrinato)chromium(III)
section is 2.55. Thus, a significant intermetal spin density transfer
occurs in the μ-nitrido intermediate complex.
Conclusions
In conclusion, a new nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex has
been synthesized. The precursor complex, oxo(corrolato)chromium(V),
has been successfully transformed into the corresponding nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex by using a nitrido group transfer reagent. The most widely
used synthetic strategy for nitridochromium(V) complexes involves
the N atom transfer from MnV(N)(salen/salophen) to a Cr(III)
derivative. However, we have transferred the nitrogen atom directly
from MnV(N)(salophen) to an oxo(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative via in situ reduction by using a PPh3 ligand.
DFT calculations were also performed on the nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V)
complex in addition to the spectroscopic characterizations. Our studies
confirm that complex 3 has a paramagnetic d1 electronic configuration. The experimentally obtained EPR spectrum
can be simulated with reasonable accuracy by considering hyperfine
coupling to five 14N nuclei and also to 53Cr.
The simulation of the EPR data of compound 3 provided
the following parameters: giso = 1.987, A53Cr = 26 G, and A14N = 2.71 G. The nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) derivative, 3, exhibited one reversible oxidation couple at +0.53 V. It also showed
one reversible reduction couple at −0.06 V vs Ag/AgCl. These redox potential values are drastically different
compared to the related nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V) derivatives.[38b] Compound 3 exhibited a sharp Soret
band at 438 nm and a Q band at 608 nm. The absorbance maxima at 438
and 608 nm are thus assigned as ILCT transitions. The chromium–nitrogen
(nitrido) bond distance obtained in the DFT-optimized structure of 3 is 1.530 Å. This short chromium–nitrogen (nitrido)
bond distance indicates triple bond formation between chromium and
nitrogen. Thus, a combination of nitride and corrole ligand functionalities
would be perfect for stabilizing higher oxidation states of chromium.
Reactions of nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V), 3, with the
chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex, 4, resulted
in the formation of nitrido(porphyrinato)chromium(V), 5, and a probable (corrolato)chromium(III) species. A second-order
rate constant of 4.29 ± 0.10 M–1 s–1 was obtained for this complete intermetal N atom transfer reaction
between chromium(V) corrole and chromium(III) porphyrin complexes.
A bimetallic μ-nitride intermediate is the probable intermediate
for this reaction, and a net two-electron transfer occurs. Work is
in progress to find suitable nitrido(corrolato)chromium(V) derivatives
that will transfer nitrogen atoms to different organic substrates.
Experimental Section
Materials
Pyrrole, chloranil, Cr(CO)6, and
TBAP (tetrabutylammonium perchlorate) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich
(USA). p-Cyanobenzaldehyde was purchased from Merck
(India). Hexane and dichloromethane were obtained via distillation from KOH and CaH2, respectively. The rest
of the starting chemicals were of reagent grade. Oxo-[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V), 1, was
synthesized by following a literature-reported method.[39] (Saloph)MnV(N) was prepared by following
a literature-reported method.[41] 5,10,15-Tris(4-cyanophenyl)corrole
was prepared according to a literature-reported protocol.[24] The chloro(porphyrinato)chromium(III) complex, 4, was also prepared by following a literature-reported method.[38f]
Physical Measurements
The C/H/N analysis was performed
with a Euro EA elemental analyzer. A PerkinElmer spectrophotometer
(LAMBDA-750) was used to record the UV–Vis spectra. A PerkinElmer
spectrophotometer was used to record FT-IR spectra. The samples were
prepared as KBr pellets. A LabRAM HR Evolution (Horiba Scientific)
was used to record the Raman spectra. A Bruker AVANCE 400 MHz NMR
spectrometer was used to record the NMR data. Tetramethylsilane (TMS)
was the internal standard. A Bruker Micro TOF-QII mass spectrometer
was used to record the electrospray mass spectra (ESI-MS). An electrochemical
instrument (CS 350, China) was used to record the cyclic voltammetric
measurements. A platinum wire (as an auxiliary electrode), glassy
carbon (as a working electrode), and Ag/AgCl (as a reference electrode)
were used in a traditional three-electrode cell. TBAP (tetrabutylammonium
perchlorate, 10–1 M) was used as the supporting
electrolyte. The concentration of the complex solution was mentioned
to be 10–3 M. The E0298 (half-wave potential) was set equal to 0.5 (Epa + Epc) {Epa = anodic peak potentials and Epc = cathodic peak potentials}. The scan rate was 100
mV s–1. EPR spectra were recorded with a Bruker
EMX System (ER 073) (X-band frequency of ca. 9.5 GHz). Synthetic quartz
glass tubes were used for the measurements.
Computational Methods
Ground-state geometry optimization
of the studied complexes was performed by density functional theory
(DFT). The B97 functional was used with dispersion correction (B97D)
as implemented in the Gaussian 16 program.[42,43] The B97D functional provides reliable spectroscopic parameters that
reasonably match the experimental data.[44] For hydrogen, carbon, and nitrogen, the 6-31G(d) basis set was used.
The TZVP basis set was used for chromium. An IEF-PCM solvent model
was implemented in the calculation considering acetonitrile as the
solvent. The vibrational frequency calculations were also performed
at the same level of theory to ensure that the optimized structure
was at the true minima. The same functional and basis sets were used
for the time-dependent DFT calculations (TD-DFT). The free energy
values were calculated by using the SMD solvation model by performing
a single-point energy calculation on the gas-phase optimized geometries
in a benzene solvent. Zero-point energy correction was done while
calculating the free energies of the product formation.
Synthesis of Oxo[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(V),[39]1
5,10,15-Tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrole[24] (48 mg,
0.081 mmol) was dissolved in 24 mL of toluene. Excess Cr(CO)6 was added to the reaction vessel. Reflux with stirring was continued
for 2–3 h. The color of the solution gradually changed to deep
red. The solution was cooled to room temperature, and the unreacted
Cr(CO)6 crystals were removed. The solvent was evaporated
to dryness by using a rotary evaporator, and the product was purified
by silica gel column chromatography (100–200 mesh, CH2Cl2/hexane). Recrystallization yielded a deep red crystalline
solid. Yield: 48% (25 mg, 0.0375 mmol). Anal. calcd for C40H20CrN7O (1): C, 72.07; H, 3.02;
N, 14.71. Found: C, 72.15; H, 2.97; N, 14.61. λmax/nm (ε/M–1 cm–1) in acetonitrile:
404 (86000), 557 (15500) (Figure S1). HRMS
(ESI-TOF) m/z: [M]− calcd for C40H20CrN7O, 666.1130;
found, 666.1124 (Figure S3). All the values
matched nicely with the earlier reported values.[39]
Synthesis of {Bis(triphenylphosphineoxide)}[5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato]chromium(III), 2
1 (26 mg, 0.039 mmol) was dissolved in 10 mL of a
CH2Cl2 + CH3CN mixture (9:1) under
a N2 atmosphere. Then, excess PPh3 was added
to it under stirring conditions. The reaction mixture was stirred
continuously for 5 min during which the color of the reaction mixture
changed from red to greenish-red. As this compound is highly air-sensitive,
thus, it is not possible to purify it via column chromatography. This
crude reaction mixture was used for further characterization of this
compound. λmax/nm in the CH2Cl2:CH3CN (9:1) mixture (with PPh3 and OPPh3): 445, 602, 643, 708 (Figure S6). MS (ESI-TOF) m/z: [M + OH]+ calcd for C76H51CrN7O3P2, 1223.2934; found, 1223.4494 (Figure S5). EPR X-band, 100 K, CH2Cl2:CH3CN (9:1) mixture: gav ≈
1.982 (Figure S8).
Synthesis of [Nitrido{5,10,15-tris(p-cyanophenyl)corrolato}chromium(V)]− [(Saloph)MnIII]+; 3, [(Saloph)MnIII]+
1 (26
mg, 0.039 mmol) was dissolved in 10 mL of a CH2Cl2 + CH3CN mixture (9:1) under a N2 atmosphere.
Then, 18 mg (0.047 mmol) of solid (saloph)MnV(N) and excess
PPh3 were added to it under stirring conditions. The reaction
mixture was stirred continuously for 5 min during which the color
of the reaction mixture changed from red to green. Then, the reaction
was stopped, and the solvent was evaporated by a rotary evaporator.
The crude mixture was washed 6–7 times with a DCM:hexane (1:1)
mixture to remove excess PPh3 and OPPh3. After
that, the compound was purified through a silica column (CH3CN), and the desired compound was collected (purple solid). Yield:
62% (16 mg, 0.024 mmol). λmax/nm (ε/M–1 cm–1) in acetonitrile: 438 (134,500), 506 (9600),
540 (12,500), 608 (35,900). HRMS (ESI-TOF) m/z: [M]− calcd for C40H20CrN8, 664.1211; found, 664.1216 (Figure S4).
Authors: Roberto Paolesse; Sara Nardis; Manuela Stefanelli; Frank R Fronczek; Maria Graça H Vicente Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2005-05-13 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: A E Meier-Callahan; A J Di Bilio; L Simkhovich; A Mahammed; I Goldberg; H B Gray; Z Gross Journal: Inorg Chem Date: 2001-12-17 Impact factor: 5.165