Nicole Balasco1, Antonella Paladino2, Giuseppe Graziano3, Marco D'Abramo4, Luigi Vitagliano2. 1. Institute of Molecular Biology and Pathology, CNR c/o Dep. Chemistry, University of Rome, Sapienza, P.le A. Moro 5, 00185 Rome, Italy. 2. Institute of Biostructures and Bioimaging, CNR, Via Pietro Castellino 111, 80131 Naples, Italy. 3. Department of Science and Technology, University of Sannio, via Francesco de Sanctis snc, Benevento 82100, Italy. 4. Department of Chemistry, University of Rome Sapienza, P.le A.Moro 5, 00185 Rome, Italy.
Abstract
Tetrameric hemoglobins (Hbs) are prototypal systems for studies aimed at unveiling basic structure-function relationships as well as investigating the molecular/structural basis of adaptation of living organisms to extreme conditions. However, a chronological analysis of decade-long studies conducted on Hbs is illuminating on the difficulties associated with the attempts of gaining functional insights from static structures. Here, we applied molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to explore the functional transition from the T to the R state of the hemoglobin of the Antarctic fish Trematomus bernacchii (HbTb). Our study clearly demonstrates the ability of the MD technique to accurately describe the transition of HbTb from the T to R-like states, as shown by a number of global and local structural indicators. A comparative analysis of the structural states that HbTb assumes in the simulations with those detected in previous MD analyses conducted on HbA (human Hb) highlights interesting analogies (similarity of the transition pathway) and differences (distinct population of intermediate states). In particular, the ability of HbTb to significantly populate intermediate states along the functional pathway explains the observed propensity of this protein to assume these structures in the crystalline state. It also explains some functional data reported on the protein that indicate the occurrence of other functional states in addition to the canonical R and T ones. These findings are in line with the emerging idea that the classical two-state view underlying tetrameric Hb functionality is probably an oversimplification and that other structural states play important roles in these proteins. The ability of MD simulations to accurately describe the functional pathway in tetrameric Hbs suggests that this approach may be effectively applied to unravel the molecular and structural basis of Hbs exhibiting peculiar functional properties as a consequence of the environmental adaptation of the host organism.
Tetrameric hemoglobins (Hbs) are prototypal systems for studies aimed at unveiling basic structure-function relationships as well as investigating the molecular/structural basis of adaptation of living organisms to extreme conditions. However, a chronological analysis of decade-long studies conducted on Hbs is illuminating on the difficulties associated with the attempts of gaining functional insights from static structures. Here, we applied molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to explore the functional transition from the T to the R state of the hemoglobin of the Antarctic fish Trematomus bernacchii (HbTb). Our study clearly demonstrates the ability of the MD technique to accurately describe the transition of HbTb from the T to R-like states, as shown by a number of global and local structural indicators. A comparative analysis of the structural states that HbTb assumes in the simulations with those detected in previous MD analyses conducted on HbA (human Hb) highlights interesting analogies (similarity of the transition pathway) and differences (distinct population of intermediate states). In particular, the ability of HbTb to significantly populate intermediate states along the functional pathway explains the observed propensity of this protein to assume these structures in the crystalline state. It also explains some functional data reported on the protein that indicate the occurrence of other functional states in addition to the canonical R and T ones. These findings are in line with the emerging idea that the classical two-state view underlying tetrameric Hb functionality is probably an oversimplification and that other structural states play important roles in these proteins. The ability of MD simulations to accurately describe the functional pathway in tetrameric Hbs suggests that this approach may be effectively applied to unravel the molecular and structural basis of Hbs exhibiting peculiar functional properties as a consequence of the environmental adaptation of the host organism.
In recent years, the field of protein
structure prediction has
been revolutionized by the development of machine-learning approaches.[1,2] The application of these algorithms to the proteome of many species
that are widely studied has largely expanded our knowledge of protein
structures (see the EBI-AlphaFold Database at https://alphafold.ebi.ac.uk/). It is likely that in the near future, the amount of structural
data will further increase with the application of these approaches
to virtually all known protein sequences. Although the release of
these structures will have a tremendous impact on our understanding
of protein function, it is important to note that, in many cases,
the definition of the precise functional implications of these static
structural data will not be straightforward. In this context, a chronological
analysis of studies conducted on vertebrate tetrameric hemoglobins
(Hbs), which are prototype systems for elucidating structure–function
relationships, is illuminating.[3−5] Although the determination of
the three-dimensional structure of these proteins, even in different
binding states, dates back to the sixties,[6] the elucidation of the structural mechanism underlying their functional
transition is a long-standing issue that is still a topic of intense
research activities. In this scenario, the discovery that all-atoms
molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are able not only to emulate the
transition from the T (tense) to the R (relaxed) crystallographic
states but also to properly sample the intermediates that have been
experimentally detected[7] may represent
a significant advance in the field.[8−13]In addition to the classical questions related to the atomic-level
forces that drive the transition from the oxygen low (T state) to
the high (R state) affinity structures in response to physiological
stimuli and to the origin of the Hb cooperativity, functional studies
have highlighted a wide range of tetrameric Hb modifications as an
effective tool for the adaptation needed to survive in specific environmental
conditions. Among these, particularly intriguing are the studies devoted
to unravel sequence/function and structure/function relationships
in unusual environments such as birds flying at high altitudes[14,15] or fishes living in extreme conditions as those adapted to survive
in the Antarctic Ocean.[16,17] Extensive functional
studies on Antarctic fish Hbs (AntHbs) have highlighted a remarkable
diversification in Hb functionality ranging from iceless fish, which
lacks Hb,[18] to fish containing multiple
forms of this protein.[19−21] AntHbs also display a variety of different properties
as a consequence of external effectors. Although some AntHbs present
pH-independent oxygen affinities, most of them are endowed with a
strong Root effect.[22] In vitro functional
and structural investigations have unraveled some peculiar properties
of these Hbs. In particular, AntHbs present a remarkable propensity
to undergo oxidation with the ability of the iron to adopt a multitude
of Fe(III) forms such as aquomet, hemichrome, and penta-coordinated
states.[23] Structural studies have shown
that not only these states occur in the fully folded protein but they
also frequently possess three-dimensional structures that perfectly
fall in the T to R functional transition, thus providing a strong
evidence of similarities between their unfolding and functional pathways.[7,24−29] To provide structural explanations for the peculiar properties of
these proteins and to check whether fully atomistic MD simulations
can reproduce the functional transition in nonhuman tetrameric Hbs,
we here report an extensive analysis of the Hb isolated from the Antarctic
fish Trematomus bernacchii (HbTb).
These MD simulations were validated by comparing the trajectory structures
with crystallographic intermediate states identified for the closely
related Trematomus newnesi hemoglobin
(HbTn). Moreover, MD results were also compared to those recently
obtained in similar MD studies conducted on human Hb (HbA).[12] Our findings indicate that this approach can
effectively describe the transition and also provide interesting analogies
and differences between HbTb and human HbA.
Results
Overall Analysis of the T to R Transition of HbTb
Recent
literature investigations have demonstrated that the functional transition
of human Hb could be monitored by MD simulations starting from the
tense T state. In these studies, the transition was facilitated by
weakening a key interaction that stabilizes the tetramer in the T
state, the electrostatic interaction between the side chains of Asp94β
and the terminal His146β. By analogy, we here set up the simulations
using as starting model the high-resolution structure of HbTb T state[26] in which the carboxyl–carboxylate interaction
(Asp95α1–Asp101β2) of the aspartic triad, which
is believed to stabilize this state,[26,30] was removed
being Asp side chains deprotonated at physiological pH (see Methods for details). To perform an adequate sampling
of the T state evolution, we performed 10 independent simulations
(r1-r10). These were preliminarily analyzed by monitoring the root-mean-square
deviation (RMSD) values of the trajectory structures versus the starting model (Figure ). The inspection of the time evolution of these simulations
indicates that in five of them (runs r1, r2, r5, r7, and r9), a transition
was observed, and, importantly, the post-transition trajectory structures
were much closer to the relaxed R state than to the starting T state.
In other simulations (runs r4, r6, r8, and r10), no transition was
observed. In the case of r3, an intermediate situation was detected,
with structures of the second part of the trajectory displaying similar
RMSD values when compared with either the R or the T state. To gain
further insights into the time evolution of the HbTb T state, we compared
the structures of the five trajectories that exhibit a clear transition
with some crystallographic structures of vertebrate Hbs endowed with
intermediate quaternary structures. In particular, we considered the
well-characterized intermediate states (A, B,[7] and H[28]) of the closely related HbTn,
whose sequence presents only 13 amino acid mutations, out of 288 residues,
compared to HbTb.[20] The A and the B states,
although structurally located in the T–R transition, present
some similarities with the T state. On the other hand, the H state
is a genuine intermediate state being clearly distinct from both the
T and the R state. In addition to these states, we also considered
the only intermediate state, although quite close to the R state,
hitherto reported for HbA and denoted as HL-(C).[31] As shown in Figure S1, trajectory
structures when compared to the HL-(C) states essentially present
RMSD values that are similar to those detected against the R state.
Analogously, the RMSD values against the A and B states follow the
trend observed for the T state. On the other hand, the RMSD trend
against the H state presents an intermediate behavior between the
R and the T state since it does not present major variations along
the trajectories.
Figure 1
Root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) analysis. RMSD values
(computed
on Cα atoms) of the trajectory structures versus the starting T model (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and the R state
(red, PDB ID: 1PBX) in the HbTb simulations (runs r1 to r10). Green boxes indicate
simulation runs with observed T → R transition.
Root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) analysis. RMSD values
(computed
on Cα atoms) of the trajectory structures versus the starting T model (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and the R state
(red, PDB ID: 1PBX) in the HbTb simulations (runs r1 to r10). Green boxes indicate
simulation runs with observed T → R transition.The observation reported in the previous paragraphs
indicates that
the structural transition observed in five distinct simulations may
globally represent the functional transition associated with the oxygen
binding of this protein. To substantiate this idea, we subsequently
monitored the iron–iron distances in the trajectory structures
as it is well established that in HbA, the T–R transition leads
to an increase of the α1β2 and a concomitant decrease
of the β1β2 iron–iron distance.[32−37] Similar trends are detected in the crystal structures of HbTb.[21,26] Indeed, comparing the T to the R state, a clear increase of the
α1β2 (from 24.4 to 25.8 Å) and a decrease of the
β1β2 (from 39.9 to 34.6 Å) distances are observed.
As shown in Figure , the structures sampled in the final part of the simulations present
larger iron–iron α1β2 and lower iron–iron
β1β2 compared to those located at the beginning of the
simulations. It is important to note that the largest variations of
these distances (Figure ) are concomitant with the structural transition detected in the
RMSD diagrams (Figure ). Collectively, these findings indicate that, at global level, the
structural transition detected in five MD runs corresponds to the
functional transition of these proteins.
Figure 2
Iron–iron distances.
Distances between the heme iron (Fe)
atoms computed for the α1-β2 (black) and β1-β2
(red) dimers in the HbTb simulation runs with observed T→R
transition. Correspondent Fe–Fe distance values detected in
the crystallographic structures of the T and R state of HbTb are indicated
by solid and dashed lines, respectively.
Iron–iron distances.
Distances between the heme iron (Fe)
atoms computed for the α1-β2 (black) and β1-β2
(red) dimers in the HbTb simulation runs with observed T→R
transition. Correspondent Fe–Fe distance values detected in
the crystallographic structures of the T and R state of HbTb are indicated
by solid and dashed lines, respectively.
HbTb MD Simulation: Essential Dynamics Analysis
To
better characterize the T–R transition detected in the HbTb
simulations described in the previous paragraphs, the trajectories
r1, r2, r5, r7, and r9 were also analyzed by the essential dynamics
(ED) method, where the principal motion directions of the molecular
systems (i.e., the proteins) are represented by a set of eigenvectors
(see Methods for further details). From the
ensemble of the structures obtained from these trajectories, the eigenvectors
were calculated and ranked according to their eigenvalues. Interestingly,
for all of these simulations, the first principal component (eigenvector)
accounts for most of the whole protein fluctuations (74–84%).
On the basis of this finding, we projected the structures sampled
by MD on the first eigenvector as well as the crystallographic structures
of Antarctic fish Hbs corresponding to the end points of the transition
(T and R states of HbTb) and to some intermediate states for both
the individual runs (Figure ) and for the concatenated trajectory in which the MD structures
of the five simulations were collectively considered (Figure S2). In addition, we also projected some
significant states of human HbA, including potential functional states
(R2, RR2, and R3) that have been reported to fall beyond the classical
T–R pathway.[5,33,35,36,38]
Figure 3
Essential dynamics
analysis. Projection on the first eigenvector
of the MD trajectories with observed T→R transition. The vertical
solid lines correspond to the projections of the crystallographic
structures of HbTb states: T (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and R (red, PDB
ID: 1PBX); HbTn
intermediates: TnA (dark green, PDB ID: 5LFG), TnB (magenta, PDB ID: 5LFG), and TnH (cyan,
PDB ID: 3D1K); HbA states: intermediate HL-(C) (violet, PDB ID: 4N7P), R2 (blue, PDB
ID: 1BBB), RR2
(yellow, PDB ID: 1MKO), and R3 (orange, PDB ID: 4NI0).
Essential dynamics
analysis. Projection on the first eigenvector
of the MD trajectories with observed T→R transition. The vertical
solid lines correspond to the projections of the crystallographic
structures of HbTb states: T (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and R (red, PDB
ID: 1PBX); HbTn
intermediates: TnA (dark green, PDB ID: 5LFG), TnB (magenta, PDB ID: 5LFG), and TnH (cyan,
PDB ID: 3D1K); HbA states: intermediate HL-(C) (violet, PDB ID: 4N7P), R2 (blue, PDB
ID: 1BBB), RR2
(yellow, PDB ID: 1MKO), and R3 (orange, PDB ID: 4NI0).In line with the expectations, the crystallographic
intermediate
states fall within the pathway defined by the T and R states. In particular,
the A state of HbTn and the HL-(C) state of HbA are quite close to
the T and R states, respectively. On the other hand, the H state of
HbTn (TnH) appears to be an intermediate state that is quite distinct
from both the T and R structures. The position of the states R2, RR2,
and R3 that fall beyond the transition further indicates the ability
of this principal component to represent the functional motions of
the protein.In line with similar data collected for HbA,[12] the projection of the trajectory structures
of the HbTb
simulations on this diagram highlights that they are frequently located
beyond the R state and present similarities with the human R2, RR2,
and R3 structures. This finding corroborates the hypotheses that these
states play functional roles.[5,33,35,36,38]A deep inspection of the distribution of the trajectory structures
within the T and R states indicates that structural states presenting
similarities with the H intermediate of HbTn are frequently populated
(Figures and S2). This is particularly evident in r1, r7,
and r9 simulation runs (Figure ).This result is somehow surprising as MD simulations
carried out
on HbA using similar protocol and conditions resulted in sudden T
to R transitions with a marginal population of the intermediate states.[12]
HbTb MD Simulations: Monitoring of Specific Structural Probes
of the Transition
Decade-long structural investigations carried
out on vertebrate Hbs have highlighted a number of specific structural
features that can be considered as fingerprints of either the R or
the T state. With the aim of classifying the trajectory structures
as a function of these specific structural parameters, we considered
a number of indicators that were mutuated from studies conducted on
HbA. In particular, we monitored the distance between the Cα atoms of the terminal His residues (His146) of the two β chains
(Cα His146β1–Cα His146β2)
that is very sensitive to the T to R transition and the key interactions
that specifically stabilize the T state (i.e., Lys40α1 side
chain–H146β2 COOH terminal group and Tyr42α1–Asp99β2
side chains).[12,32,39] We also checked the distance between the residues located in the
switch region α1CD-β2FG at the interface between the dimers
α1β1 and α2β2 (Cα Ser44α1–
Cα His97β2). In addition, we also considered
some structural features that emerged from the analysis of crystallographic
studies of AntHbs. In particular, the Cα–Cα distance between proximal and distal His residues,
which was found to significantly decrease in some intermediate states,
and the distances among the side chains of the aspartic triad (Asp95α,
Asp99β, and Asp101β).As shown in Figures and S3–S6 that report the evolution of the probes mutuated from HbA, the analysis
of these specific parameters corroborates the indications arising
from the global analysis. Indeed, the T–R transition is associated
with the disappearance of the strong electrostatic interaction formed
by the Lys40α1 side chain and the His146β2 COOH terminal
group. Moreover, the analysis of the other probes clearly indicates
that in a significant number of structures, these parameters assume
the values observed in the HbTn states (see, for example, the distances
Cα His146β1–Cα His146β2
and Tyr42α1–Asp99β2 side chains).
Figure 4
Time evolution of the
structural probes that are characteristic
of the different HbTb states in the r1 simulation run. Specifically,
the distances (a) Nζ Lys40α1–OT His146β2,
(b) Oη Tyr42α1–Oδ Asp99β2,
(c) Cα Ser44α1–Cα His97β2,
and (d) Cα His146β1–Cα His146β2 are monitored.
Time evolution of the
structural probes that are characteristic
of the different HbTb states in the r1 simulation run. Specifically,
the distances (a) Nζ Lys40α1–OT His146β2,
(b) Oη Tyr42α1–Oδ Asp99β2,
(c) Cα Ser44α1–Cα His97β2,
and (d) Cα His146β1–Cα His146β2 are monitored.The Cα–Cα distances between
the distal and proximal His, whose shortening has been associated
with intermediate states of the quaternary structure of AntHbs,[7,28] do not highlight significant variations throughout the simulations
(Figure S7). This implies that the transition
does not require the major compression of the EF corner usually observed
in crystallographic structures. Therefore, the closing of this region
observed in these structures is due to the peculiar oxidation states
of the iron (hemichrome, aquomet, oxidized penta-coordination).As the carboxyl–carboxylate interaction formed by Asp95α1
and Asp101β2 (and Asp95α2-Asp101β1) of the catalytic
triad is believed to be a key interaction that stabilizes the T state
of HbTb at low pH values, thus producing the physiological strong
dependence of the oxygen affinity of the protein as a function of
the pH (Root effect[26,30]), we also monitored the evolution
of these inter-aspartic distances along the MD trajectories (Figure ). As shown in Figures and 6, the distance between Asp95α1 and Asp101β2 (and
Asp95α2 and Asp101β1) side chains is larger (with values
spanning from ∼4 to ∼15 Å) than that found in the
T state crystalline structure (2.5 Å) where the two residues
form the carboxyl–carboxylate interaction. The distance between
these residues often increases upon the T to R transition.
Figure 5
Inter-aspartic
distances at α1β2 (left) and α2β1
(right) interfaces as observed along the MD trajctories. Minimum distances
between Asp Oδ atoms of the pairs Asp95α1–Asp101β2
and Asp95α2–Asp101β1 are reported. Red line at
3.0 Å is given as an indicative H-bond length threshold.
Figure 6
Cartoon representation of the three-dimensional structure
of HbTb
tetramer in the T state (PDB ID: 2H8F). (a) Asp95α1, Asp99β2, and
Asp101β2 of the catalytic triad are shown as sticks. Close-up
view of the α1β2 interfacing Asp residues (b) in the X-ray
starting structure (PDB ID: 2H8F) and (c) in a representative trajectory frame (r2
simulation run, t = 75.5 ns) upon T → R transition.
See also Figure .
Inter-aspartic
distances at α1β2 (left) and α2β1
(right) interfaces as observed along the MD trajctories. Minimum distances
between Asp Oδ atoms of the pairs Asp95α1–Asp101β2
and Asp95α2–Asp101β1 are reported. Red line at
3.0 Å is given as an indicative H-bond length threshold.Cartoon representation of the three-dimensional structure
of HbTb
tetramer in the T state (PDB ID: 2H8F). (a) Asp95α1, Asp99β2, and
Asp101β2 of the catalytic triad are shown as sticks. Close-up
view of the α1β2 interfacing Asp residues (b) in the X-ray
starting structure (PDB ID: 2H8F) and (c) in a representative trajectory frame (r2
simulation run, t = 75.5 ns) upon T → R transition.
See also Figure .
Low-Temperature Hbtb MD Simulations
The results illustrated
in the previous paragraphs clearly indicate that HbTb undergoes a
major structural transition during the simulations that recapitulates
the variations associated with the conversion between its different
functional states. One intriguing observation that emerged from these
analyses is the significant population of intermediate states. It
is important to note that the simulations as well as the crystallization
experiments have been conducted at room temperature, which is quite
different from the temperature of the Antarctic Ocean (∼ −1.8
°C) where this species lives.[40] To
verify whether the results obtained at room temperature were biased
by the nonphysiological temperature (300 K) used in the simulations,
these were repeated at 273 K (low-temperature simulations). In particular,
ten 100 ns long independent runs were carried out. As shown in Figures a and S8, we observed the transition in a single run
(r1L) only. Due to the low temperature used in this set
of MD simulations, which might reflect a decrease in the transition
rate, we also performed a longer (250 ns, r1L*) simulation,
which indeed exhibited a clear T to R transition (Figure c).
Figure 7
HbTb T–R transition
at T = 273 K. RMSD
values (computed on Cα atoms) of the trajectory structures versus
the starting T model (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and the R state (red, PDB ID: 1PBX) for (a) r1L and
(b) r1L* simulations performed at 273 K. Projection of the MD trajectory
on the first eigenvector for (c) r1L and (d) r1L*. The vertical solid
lines correspond to the projections of the crystallographic structures
of HbTb states: T (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and R (red, PDB ID: 1PBX); HbTn intermediates:
TnA (dark green, PDB ID: 5LFG), TnB (magenta, PDB ID: 5LFG), and TnH (cyan, PDB ID: 3D1K); HbA states: intermediate
HL-(C) (violet, PDB ID: 4N7P), R2 (blue, PDB ID: 1BBB), RR2 (yellow, PDB ID: 1MKO), and R3 (orange,
PDB ID: 4NI0).
HbTb T–R transition
at T = 273 K. RMSD
values (computed on Cα atoms) of the trajectory structures versus
the starting T model (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and the R state (red, PDB ID: 1PBX) for (a) r1L and
(b) r1L* simulations performed at 273 K. Projection of the MD trajectory
on the first eigenvector for (c) r1L and (d) r1L*. The vertical solid
lines correspond to the projections of the crystallographic structures
of HbTb states: T (black, PDB ID: 2H8F) and R (red, PDB ID: 1PBX); HbTn intermediates:
TnA (dark green, PDB ID: 5LFG), TnB (magenta, PDB ID: 5LFG), and TnH (cyan, PDB ID: 3D1K); HbA states: intermediate
HL-(C) (violet, PDB ID: 4N7P), R2 (blue, PDB ID: 1BBB), RR2 (yellow, PDB ID: 1MKO), and R3 (orange,
PDB ID: 4NI0).The eigenvector analysis of the two low-temperature
simulations
in which the transition was observed clearly indicates that states
resembling TnH were significantly populated (Figure b,d). This indication was also corroborated
by the analysis of the specific probes (Figures S9–S10).
Discussion
Tetrameric hemoglobins are prototypal systems
for studies aimed
at unveiling basic structure–function relationships.[6,41,42] As these proteins are present
in organisms living in extremely different environmental conditions,
they are particularly suited also for studies focused on the identification
of the basis of molecular adaptation. However, the rapid transition
of these proteins from oxygen-bound to ligand-free states has hampered
for decades a detailed structural characterization of their functional
pathway, thus limiting the understanding of the underlying structure–function
relationships. Indeed, the vast majority of crystallographic data
available on tetrameric Hbs essentially represents variations of the
R or the T state, with the valuable addition of the off-pathway structures
R2, RR2, and R3.[5] In this scenario, structural
studies conducted on AntHbs constitute an intriguing exception as
a significant portion of their crystallographic structures are structural
intermediates of the canonical states. By exploiting the ability of
all-atoms MD simulations to characterize at the atomic level the functional
T–R transition of human HbA,[8,9,11,12] we here applied this
technique to the hemoglobin of the Antarctic fish T.
bernacchii as MD simulations on AntHbs have been limited
to the analysis of the behavior of isolated single chains.[43] Our study, which, to the best of our knowledge,
represents the first attempt to investigate the functional pathway
of a nonhuman Hb by means of MD, clearly demonstrates the ability
of this technique to accurately describe the transition of HbTb from
T-like to R-like states, as demonstrated by a number of global and
local structural indicators. The ED analysis also indicates that the
starting T state not only does evolve toward R-like structures but
also samples different conformational states, such as R2, RR2, and
R3, which lie outside the T–R pathway.[5,33,35,36,38] This finding suggests, in line with previous hypotheses,
that the actual functional pathway of tetrameric Hbs also includes
these states. It is worth underlining that a similar result has been
obtained in MD simulations carried out on HbA.[12] A comparative analysis of the structural states that HbTb
sampled in the simulations with those detected in MD analyses conducted
on HbA using a similar approach highlights interesting analogies and
differences. In particular, the overall and the local structural features
of the trajectory structures indicate that these proteins essentially
follow a very similar pathway. In both cases, the ED analysis indicates
that the first eigenvector is able to represent the vast majority
of the protein motions. Moreover, the position of the crystallographic
structures on the essential subspace provided by this eigenvector
indicates that it essentially describes the motion direction underlying
the T–R transition. These similarities clearly indicate that
atomic-level features of the functional switch of these Hbs are well
conserved, despite the hundredths of millions of years that evolutionarily
separate these proteins.However, although the two proteins
follow the same structural pathway
in the simulations, a comparative analysis indicates that some intermediate
states detected in the crystallographic studies on tetrameric Hbs,
notably tetramer H of HbTn, that are barely detected in the HbA MD
simulations[12] are frequently well populated
in HbTb simulations (Figure ). Our data suggest that the interconversion between the T
and the R state, which is very rapid in HbA, is somehow smoothed in
HbTb. This finding provides a clear explanation to the puzzling observation
that intermediate states are frequently detected for AntHb, while
they are extremely elusive for HbA, despite the several hundredths
of independent structures reported for this protein in the PDB.[39] In this scenario, the larger population of these
states in AntHb compared to HbA has allowed their trapping in the
crystalline state and the visualization of a variety of peculiar and
partially oxidized states that are not compatible with the canonical
R and T states. Moreover, the present results perfectly fit with the
observation that in HbTb, a significant degree of oxygen-binding cooperativity
can be ascribed to tertiary conformational changes toward R-like positions
that anticipate the real T–R quaternary transition.[44] In general terms, these findings are in line
with the emerging idea that the classical two-state view underlying
tetrameric Hb functionality is probably an oversimplification and
that other structural states play important roles in these proteins.[45]The ability of MD simulations to accurately
describe the functional
pathway in both HbA and Hb isolated from an organism living in extreme
conditions strongly suggests that this approach may be effectively
applied to unravel the molecular and structural basis of Hbs exhibiting
peculiar functional properties, as a consequence of the environmental
adaptation of the host organism.In conclusion, the historical
analysis of the controversial and
several decade-long investigations aimed at describing Hb functionality
at atomic level perfectly illustrates the difficulties associated
with gaining functional insights from static structures. The present
study demonstrates that the application of current standard protocols
may provide important information in this field. This finding is particularly
important in the AlphaFold era, in which a huge amount of structural
data should be appropriately exploited to gain biologically relevant
insights.
Methods
Structural Models
Fully atomistic MD simulations were
performed on the T state of HbTb. In detail, the transition from this
form to the R state was studied at neutral pH using the high-resolution
crystallographic structure of the tetrameric TbHb in the deoxygenated
form determined at pH 6.2 (PDB ID: 2H8F)[26] as starting
model. The protonation states of the histidine residues were chosen
following the protocol adopted for HbA in Balasco et al.[12] In detail, for conserved His between HbA and
HbTb, the same protonation state of HbA was adopted also for HbTb,
whereas the state of the additional His residues of HbTb was assigned
by GROMACS software. As done for HbA,[8−11] to favor the T–R transition,
the terminal His of the β chains were kept in the deprotonated
state. Moreover, to emulate pH conditions close to neutrality, the
three Asp residues (Asp95α, Asp99β, and Asp101β)
of the aspartic triad were kept deprotonated (Asp side-chain pKa ∼ 3.9).To analyze the overall
and local structural features of the trajectory models, we considered
a number of both canonical and putative states identified for HbA,[31] for HbTb, and for the hemoglobins from the Antarctic T. newnesi (HbTn) fish (96% sequence identity) whose
intermediate states along the functional transition have been well-characterized.[7,28] Coordinates of these structural models were retrieved from the Protein
Data Bank (https://www.rcsb.org/). In detail, for HbTb, the canonical T (PDB ID: 2H8F)[26] and R (PDB ID: 1PBX)[21] states were considered.
For HbA the following PDB structures were used: 1BBB (R2 state),[33]1MKO (RR2 state),[35]4NI0 (R3 state),[46] and 4N7P(31) (intermediate half-liganded
HL-(C) state). The structures of HbTn tetramers A, B[7] (TnA and TnB, PDB ID: 5LFG), and H[28] (TnH,
PDB ID: 3D1K) were also considered. Structural details of these crystallographic
models are reported in Table S1.
Protocol
The GROMACS[47] software
(version 2020.3) has been used to carry out fully atomistic MD simulations
of the HbTb T state using the CHARMM-36[48] all-atom force field. The protein model was solvated with water
molecules of the TIP3P model[49] in a cubic
box of 150 Å edge size. The system was neutralized with sodium
and chloride counterions to achieve a salt concentration of 0.15 mol/L.
Electrostatic interactions were treated with the particle-mesh Ewald
(PME) method[50] (1 Å grid spacing and
10–6 relative tolerance), whereas a 10 Å switching
was considered for the Lennard–Jones (LJ) interactions. The
LINCS algorithm[51] was used to constrain
bond lengths. The system was energy minimized in 50000 steps using
the steepest descent algorithm. Then, it was equilibrated in two phases.
First, the system temperature was raised to 300 K in 300 ps using
increments of 10 K (NVT). The system pressure was then equilibrated
at 1 atm in 500 ps (NpT). The Velocity Rescaling and Parrinello–Rahman
algorithms[52,53] were applied for temperature
and pressure control, respectively.MD production runs were
performed at the constant pressure of 1 atm and at two different temperatures
with a time step of 2 fs. In detail, 10 independent replicas of 100
ns were performed at 300 K (r1–r10) and 273 K (r1L–r10L) with random initial velocities (gen_seed
option in mdp input file). In addition, we run a longer simulation
(250 ns) to improve the conformational sampling at T = 273 K (r1L*).We apply the essential dynamics[54] technique
to carry out the principal component analysis of the MD runs. In detail,
we built the covariance matrix of the protein Cα atomic
positions. The diagonalization of this matrix provides a set of eigenvectors
with their associated eigenvalues that represent the principal protein
motions. Using this approach, it is possible to represent the protein
overall dynamics in a reduced essential subspace described by the
first eigenvectors, which are therefore defined as principal components.
The gmx covar and gmx anaeig tools of GROMACS software were used to
build the covariance matrix and to calculate the projection with respect
to the first eigenvector.
Data and Software Availability
Coordinates of the three-dimensional
structures used in this project were retrieved from the Protein Data
Bank (https://www.rcsb.org/). MD simulations were performed using GROMACS[47] software (version 2020.3). GROMACS tools and the Visual
Molecular Dynamics (VMD) program[55] were
used to conduct the structural analyses of trajectory models. Figures
were generated using the VMD and Xmgrace software version 50125 (https://plasma-gate.weizmann.ac.il/Grace/). Authors will release MD trajectories upon article publication
using Zenodo repository (https://zenodo.org/).
Authors: Jonathan A Lukin; Georg Kontaxis; Virgil Simplaceanu; Yue Yuan; Ad Bax; Chien Ho Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2003-01-13 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: David Van Der Spoel; Erik Lindahl; Berk Hess; Gerrit Groenhof; Alan E Mark; Herman J C Berendsen Journal: J Comput Chem Date: 2005-12 Impact factor: 3.376
Authors: Andrew W Senior; Richard Evans; John Jumper; James Kirkpatrick; Laurent Sifre; Tim Green; Chongli Qin; Augustin Žídek; Alexander W R Nelson; Alex Bridgland; Hugo Penedones; Stig Petersen; Karen Simonyan; Steve Crossan; Pushmeet Kohli; David T Jones; David Silver; Koray Kavukcuoglu; Demis Hassabis Journal: Nature Date: 2020-01-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: L Camardella; C Caruso; R D'Avino; G di Prisco; B Rutigliano; M Tamburrini; G Fermi; M F Perutz Journal: J Mol Biol Date: 1992-03-20 Impact factor: 5.469
Authors: Jumin Lee; Xi Cheng; Jason M Swails; Min Sun Yeom; Peter K Eastman; Justin A Lemkul; Shuai Wei; Joshua Buckner; Jong Cheol Jeong; Yifei Qi; Sunhwan Jo; Vijay S Pande; David A Case; Charles L Brooks; Alexander D MacKerell; Jeffery B Klauda; Wonpil Im Journal: J Chem Theory Comput Date: 2015-12-03 Impact factor: 6.006