Literature DB >> 35916469

Earnings during adulthood in patients with childhood-onset inflammatory bowel disease: a nationwide population-based cohort study.

Petter Malmborg1,2,3, Åsa H Everhov2,3, Jonas Söderling3, Jonas F Ludvigsson4,5,6,7, Gustaf Bruze3, Ola Olén1,2,3.   

Abstract

BACKGROUND: IBD with onset during childhood seems to represent a severe disease phenotype with increased morbidity. We have previously demonstrated that children with IBD have significantly lower final grades in compulsory school compared to healthy peers. AIM: To evaluate the association of childhood-onset IBD with a later professional career and subsequent earnings
METHODS: We identified 5404 individuals diagnosed with childhood-onset (<18 years) IBD between 1990 and 2014 (2818 with ulcerative colitis and 2328 with Crohn's disease) in the Swedish National Patient Register. Patients were matched with 10 general population reference individuals by sex, birth year, and place of residence (n = 51,295). Data on earnings during 1992-2017 were obtained through the longitudinal integration database for health insurance and labour market studies. Earnings were converted into Euros (inflation-adjusted to 2019). The differences in earnings between patients and general population reference individuals were calculated through quantile regression.
RESULTS: Patients with childhood-onset IBD had significantly lower annual taxable earnings from ages 20 to 30 (adjusted median annual income difference (AMAID) at age 30: -5.4% [95% CI -9.1% to -1.8%]). In particular, annual taxable earnings through early adult age were lower in patients who, during childhood, had had surgery or long-term inpatient treatment for IBD (AMAID at age 30: -16.3% [95% CI -24.7% to -7.9%]).
CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the negative influence of disease on earnings in early adult age was modest for patients with childhood-onset IBD. The markedly larger negative income gap from ages 20 to 30 in patients with more severe IBD during childhood should be recognised.
© 2022 The Authors. Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2022        PMID: 35916469      PMCID: PMC9544615          DOI: 10.1111/apt.17148

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Aliment Pharmacol Ther        ISSN: 0269-2813            Impact factor:   9.524


INTRODUCTION

IBD with onset in childhood seems to represent a severe disease phenotype and is associated with increased morbidity and mortality. , , , , , Compared to healthy peers and siblings, children with IBD have lower final compulsory school grades. Low grades from 9‐year compulsory school seem to be a strong negative predictor for higher education later in life and are associated with increased risks for psychosocial problems and reduced psychiatric and somatic health in adult age. , , Earnings can be regarded as a measure of professional career. We have recently demonstrated that patients with adult‐onset IBD have significantly lower taxable earnings up to 10 years after diagnosis than IBD‐free siblings. Several studies have also shown that adult‐onset IBD has a negative impact on work ability and professional career as patients are reported to have more sick leave, , , , disability pension , , , , , and unemployment , than the general population. It seems plausible that childhood‐onset IBD can have profound negative consequences for later educational and professional career, but very few studies have addressed this association , , (Table S1). The interpretations of these somewhat contradictive studies are restricted by small numbers, , , low response rate (questionnaire study) and the non‐contemporary study periods. , If childhood‐onset IBD has a significant negative impact on earnings in adult age, this should be recognised by the health care and educational and social security systems and be used as a foundation for discussions on what the society could do to support these chronically diseased young patients to reach their full professional career potential. The aim of this study was to examine if childhood‐onset IBD patients have lower earnings in adult age than general population reference individuals. A secondary aim was to study whether some subsets of children with IBD, characterised by sex, IBD subtype and disease severity, are at higher risk of low earnings as adults.

METHODS

Study design

In a cohort study design, we compared earnings in adult age between individuals with childhood‐onset IBD and matched general population reference individuals.

Setting and data sources

In Sweden, all patients with childhood‐onset IBD are treated by paediatricians until the age of 18 years and they are then referred for follow‐up by adult gastroenterologists. Sweden is a high‐income country with publicly funded healthcare including both inpatient and outpatient care as well as medications for all residents. We used the personal identity number, assigned to all Swedish residents, to link data from national administrative and clinical registers. , , , , (Table S2).

Study population

IBD patients

We identified all individuals diagnosed with IBD before their 18th birthday in the Swedish National Patient Register (NPR) from 1990 until 2014. The study period was chosen to estimate the impact of childhood‐onset IBD during the modern immunomodulatory era (azathioprine was widely introduced in Swedish paediatric IBD care during the first years of the 1990s). To increase sensitivity for IBD and to better define the first date of diagnosis, we also used colorectal histopathology data from the ESPRESSO cohort (Table S3). The ESPRESSO database is a nationwide initiative to strengthen the validity of Swedish health register data through histopathology. To be classified as childhood‐onset IBD patients had to have ≥2 hits (either two IBD listings in NPR or one IBD listing in NPR and one in the ESPRESSO register) before their 18th birthday. This combination of 1 listing in each of the two registers has been shown to have a positive predictive value of 93% (95% confidence interval [CI], 89%–96%) when using patient chart data‐based diagnosis of childhood‐onset IBD as gold standard. Identified childhood‐onset IBD patients were followed from ≥20 to 30 years of age, until emigration, death or end of study period (2017).

General population reference individuals

For each IBD patient, we randomly selected up to 10 individuals from the Total Population Register. The patients with IBD and the general population reference individuals were matched on sex, birth year, age and place of residence. The reference individuals had to be free of IBD at date of diagnosis of the index patient and stopped contributing person‐time if later diagnosed with IBD.

Patient characteristics during childhood

To categorise childhood‐onset IBD patients and their disease phenotype (subtype and proxies for disease severity) we used all information available from the date of the first IBD diagnosis until the date when the patients turned 18 years. The IBD subtype definition was based on the first two diagnostic listings (or when combined with a colorectal biopsy, on the first IBD ICD diagnosis). Patients with listings of both ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease, or a listing of IBD unclassified (IBD‐U) were defined as IBD‐U (Table S3). Patients who before 18 years of age had a diagnostic or procedure code typical of CD (Table S4) were classified as CD. The patients were further categorised according to year of diagnosis, age at IBD diagnosis, exposure to IBD‐related surgery or inpatient treatment during childhood. Inpatient and outpatient data on validated IBD‐related surgery codes were available during the whole study period. (Table S5).

Patient characteristics at age 30

To categorise IBD patients and general population reference individuals by markers of socioeconomic status (educational level, marital status, unemployment, sick leave and disability pension) at age 30, we used the annually updated longitudinal integrated database for health insurance and labour market studies (LISA).

Outcome measures

Main outcome measure

The main outcome was annual taxable earnings in ages ≥20 to ≤30 years.

Secondary outcome measure

The secondary outcome was annual personalised disposable household income. This measure is the sum of all income in a household (including earnings, income from capital and benefits) minus direct taxes paid, allocated to the individual, based on the size and composition of the household. Information on taxable earnings and personalised disposable household income was also retrieved from the LISA register (Table S6).

Subgroup analyses

In subanalyses, we analysed earnings in patients and general population reference individuals stratified by sex and IBD subtype. We also compared earnings between patients with IBD surgery or long‐term inpatient treatment (>30 days with IBD as the main diagnosis) before age 18 versus their general population reference individuals, as these two exposures were the strongest predictors of lower school grades in the final year of compulsory school in our earlier study on the association of childhood‐onset IBD with school performance.

Statistical Methods

Follow‐up of earnings started when the patients turned 20 years of age. Taxable earnings and personalised disposable household income for each calendar year were converted into Euro and inflation‐adjusted to year 2019. We present results as median values with 95% confidence intervals (CI), as data were not normally distributed. The difference between patients and general population reference individuals was calculated through quantile regression (median regression using the QUANTREG procedure ) and 95% CI's were obtained using resampling. Adjusted median proportional difference in percent of annual taxable earnings and annual personalised disposable household incomes comparing IBD patients and reference individuals were calculated by using the point estimate (of adjusted median difference from the quantile regression) divided by the median (annual taxable earnings, respectively, annual personalised disposable household incomes) in patients with IBD. Chi‐squared analysis was used to compare distributions of dichotomous outcome variables at age 30. All statistical tests were two‐sided and p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. We used statistical software from SAS (version 9.2; SAS Institute Inc.).

Ethics

The regional ethics committee in Stockholm approved the study (DNR 2007/785‐31/5; 2011/1509‐32; 2012/601‐32; 2015/0004‐31; 2015/615‐32; 2014/1287‐31/4). Informed consent was waived since this was a strictly register‐based study.

RESULTS

Background data

We identified 7436 patients who were diagnosed with IBD during childhood (<18 years). Of these, 2019 did not reach 20 years of age during the study period and 13 patients were excluded as no matched comparator could be found (Figure S1). From the remaining 5404 IBD patients, 2818 (52%) were classified as UC, 2328 (43%) as CD and 258 (5%) as IBD‐U. The majority of the IBD patients were boys (n = 3038 [56%]). Almost half of the patients were diagnosed with IBD before 15 years of age (n = 2538 [47%]) and the majority were diagnosed with IBD after 2001 (n = 2538 [59%]). However, as the study window opened in 1990 relatively few of the childhood‐onset IBD patients that reached age 30 during the study period were diagnosed after 2001 (n = 216 [12%]) and only a small minority of them were below 10 years of age when diagnosed with IBD (n = 91 (5%)) (Table 1). A smaller fraction of the IBD patients had been exposed to IBD‐related surgery or inpatient treatment for more than 30 days with IBD as main diagnosis before 18 years of age (n = 923 [17%], IBD‐related surgery n = 634 [12%], long‐term inpatient treatment n = 458 [9%]) (Table 2).
TABLE 1

Characteristics of patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 that during the study period (1990–2017) reached adult age (≥20 years) and general population reference individuals

VariableIBDUCCDReference individuals
N (%)54042818232851,295 (100%)
Sex, n (%)
Women2366 (43.8)1255 (44.5)992 (42.6)22,308 (43.5)
Men3038 (56.2)1563 (55.5)1336 (57.4)28,987 (56.5)
Age at diagnosis, n (%)
<10 years448 (8.3%)280 (9.9%)156 (6.7%)4314 (8.4%)
10 to <15 years2090 (38.7%)1042 (37.0%)971 (41.7%)20,661 (40.3%)
15 to <18 years2866 (53.0%)1496 (53.1%)1201 (51.6%)26,320 (51.3%)
Year of diagnosis, n (%)
1990–1995795 (14.7)442 (15.7)328 (14.1)7638 (14.9)
1996–20011402 (25.9)817 (29.0)549 (23.6)13,408 (26.1)
2002–20071954 (36.2)964 (34.2)919 (39.5)18,734 (36.5)
2008–20141253 (23.2)595 (21.1)532 (22.9)11,515 (22.4)
Start year of follow‐up, n (%)
1992–1997269 (5.0)129 (4.6)132 (5.7)2502 (4.9)
1998–2001497 (9.2)280 (9.9)199 (8.5)4712 (9.2)
2002–20071463 (27.1)846 (30.0)577 (24.8)13,954 (27.2)
2008–20121764 (32.6)894 (31.7)800 (34.4)16,764 (32.7)
2013–20171411 (26.1)669 (23.7)620 (26.6)13,363 (26.1)
IBD subtype, n (%)
Ulcerative colitis2818 (52.1)2818 (100)0
Crohn's disease2328 (43.1)02328 (100)
IBD‐unclassified258 (4.8)00
IBD surgery and hospitalisation during childhood, n (%)
IBD‐related surgery634 (11.7)113 (4.0)497 (21.3)
Hospitalisation >30 days a 458 (8.5)240 (8.5)195 (8.4)
IBD‐related surgery or hospitalisation >30 days923 (17.1)289 (10.3)597 (25.6)
Age at end of follow‐up
Median (range)27.1 (20.0–44.7)27.8 (20.0–44.5)26.8 (20.0–44.7)27.1 (20.0–44.9)

Inpatient treatment during childhood (<18 years) with IBD as the main diagnosis.

TABLE 2

Characteristics at age 30 of patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2004 and general population reference individuals

VariableIBDUCCDReference individuals
N 1809100675017,157
Sex, n (%)
Women808 (44.7)450 (44.7)331 (44.1)7569 (44.1)
Men1001 (55.3)556 (55.3)419 (55.9)9588 (55.9)
Age at diagnosis, n (%)
<10 years93 (5.1)57 (5.7)35 (4.7)859 (5.0)
10 to <15 years614 (33.9)352 (35.0)242 (32.3)6287 (36.6)
15 to <18 years1102 (60.9)597 (59.3)473 (63.1)10,011 (58.3)
Year of diagnosis, n (%)
1990–1995690 (38.1)381 (37.9)287 (38.3)6678 (38.9)
1996–2001903 (49.9)518 (51.5)358 (47.7)8550 (49.8)
2002–2004216 (11.9)107 (10.6)105 (14.0)1929 (11.2)
Education, n (%)
≤9 years158 (8.7)99 (9.8)53 (7.1)1472 (8.6)
10–12 years786 (43.4)425 (42.2)337 (44.9)7494 (43.7)
>12 years858 (47.4)477 (47.4)358 (47.7)8076 (47.1)
Missing7 (0.4)5 (0.5)2 (0.3)115 (0.7)
Married, n (%)
Yes376 (20.8)207 (20.6)158 (21.1)3860 (22.5)
No1433 (79.2)799 (79.4)592 (78.9)13,297 (77.5)
Unemployed, n (%)
Yes123 (6.8)75 (7.5)44 (5.9)1238 (7.2)
No1686 (93.2)931 (92.5)706 (94.1)15,919 (92.8)
Sick leave and disability pension, n (%)
Sick leave301 (16.6)163 (16.2)131 (17.5)1773 (10.3)
Disability pension90 (5.0)47 (4.7)41 (5.5)484 (2.8)
Annual taxable earnings (k€, inflation adjusted to 2019)
Median (IQR)24.2 (9.4–34.2)24.0 (9.9–34.0)24.6 (7.1–34.6)26.4 (11.1–35.2)
Adjusted median earnings difference (k€, 95 CI)−1.3 (−2.2; −0.4)−1.1 (−2.2; 0.0)−1.4 (−3.0; 0.1)Reference
Adjusted median earnings difference (, 95 CI)−5.4 (−9.1; −1.8)−4.5 (−9.0; 0.1)−5.8 (−12.1; 0.5)Reference
N (%) with no taxable earnings209 (11.6)110 (10.9)96 (12.8)1800 (10.5)
Annual personalised disposable household income (k€, inflation adjusted to 2019)
Median (IQR)17.6 (11.6–24.7)17.5 (11.5–24.9)17.8 (11.8–24.6)18.1 (11.5–25.1)
Adjusted median income difference (k€, 95 CI)−0.3 (−0.8; 0.2)−0.3 (−1.0; 0.4)−0.3 (−1.1; 0.5)Reference
Adjusted median income difference (%, 95 CI)−1.3 (−3.4; 0.9)−1.1 (−4.0; 1.8)−1.3 (−4.7; 2.1)Reference
N () with no disposable income23 (1.3)13 (1.3)9 (1.2)174 (1.0)

To reach age 30, the childhood‐onset IBD patients had to be diagnosed no later than 2004.

Characteristics of patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 that during the study period (1990–2017) reached adult age (≥20 years) and general population reference individuals Inpatient treatment during childhood (<18 years) with IBD as the main diagnosis. Characteristics at age 30 of patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2004 and general population reference individuals To reach age 30, the childhood‐onset IBD patients had to be diagnosed no later than 2004. We identified 54,170 matched (by sex, birth year and place of residence) potential general population reference individuals. As the reference individuals were matched on birth year some of these (n = 1979) had already seen their 18th birthday at index date (date of diagnosis for the patient) and some (n = 762) had not turned 20 (in contrast to their index patient) during the study period. These reference individuals were excluded and also those 134 reference individuals that were diagnosed with IBD between ages 18 and 20 (Figure S1). For the analyses, the 5404 childhood‐onset IBD patients were compared to the remaining 51,295 matched IBD‐free general population reference individuals (Table 1).

Socioeconomic status at age 30

The 1809 patients with childhood‐onset IBD that reached age 30 during the study period had similar educational level (>12 years of education: 47.4% vs 47.1%, p = 0.86), marital status (married: 20.8% vs 22.5%, p = 0.10) and unemployment status (unemployed: 6.8% vs 7.2%, p = 0.51) as general population reference individuals. A larger proportion of childhood‐onset IBD patients had disability pension (5.0% vs. 2.8%, p < 0.00001) and were on sick leave (16.6% vs 10.3%, p < 0.00001) compared to the general population reference individuals at age 30 (Table 2). Out of the 403 IBD patients that were exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term inpatient treatment during childhood and reached age 30 during the study period, fewer attained >12 years of education (41.9% vs 47.2%, p = 0.05) but the patients within the subset had similar marital status (married: 20.3% vs 23.7%, p = 0.14) and unemployment status (unemployed: 7.7% vs 8.1%, p = 0.77), compared to general population reference individuals. More patients with severe disease during childhood had disability pension (8.7% vs 2.5%, p < 0.00001) and were on sick leave (22.1% vs 10.5%, p < 0.00001) at age 30 (Table S7).

Annual taxable earnings

Patients with childhood‐onset IBD had statistically significantly lower median annual taxable earnings from ages 20 to 30 years of age (Figure 1). As demonstrated by the trajectory in Figure 1, there was no trend of growing annual difference (nor absolute nor relative) in taxable earnings between childhood‐onset IBD patients and reference individuals with increasing age. The median annual taxable earnings at age 30 in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset IBD was 24,200 € compared to 26,400 € in matched general population reference individuals (Table 2). After adjustment, the annual median difference in taxable earnings at age 30 between childhood‐onset IBD patients and reference individuals was estimated to −1300 € (95% CI −2200 € to −400 €), equivalent to −5.4% (95% CI −9.1% to −1.8%) lower annual taxable earnings.
FIGURE 1

The upper trajectory presents median annual taxable earnings in adult age in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals. The lower trajectory presents adjusted, absolute and relative, median differences in annual taxable earnings between patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset IBD between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals (dots represent median differences and lines the 95 confidence interval for each estimate).

The upper trajectory presents median annual taxable earnings in adult age in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals. The lower trajectory presents adjusted, absolute and relative, median differences in annual taxable earnings between patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset IBD between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals (dots represent median differences and lines the 95 confidence interval for each estimate). Similar trajectory patterns with lower median annual taxable earnings from ages 20 to 30 years, but with no trend for growing annual earning differences by age, were seen in both female and male patients with childhood‐onset IBD (Figure 2).
FIGURE 2

Median annual taxable earnings in adult age by sex in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals

Median annual taxable earnings in adult age by sex in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 and general population reference individuals Separate analyses of patients with childhood‐onset UC and CD also demonstrated similar trajectories for annual taxable earnings, although the statistically significant associations with lower adjusted annual median taxable earnings differences were lost in both strata with increasing age (as the confidence interval gradually widened following the shrinking number of older study subjects) (Figures S2 and S3; Table 2). Larger, and by age increasing, absolute differences in taxable earnings were seen in patients with surgery or long‐term inpatient IBD treatment during childhood (Figure 3). In this subset of patients with more severe disease during childhood, the adjusted median annual difference in taxable earnings at age 30 was −3600 € (95% CI −5500 € to −1800 €) equivalent to −16.3% (95% CI −24.7% to −7.9%) lower earnings (Table S7).
FIGURE 3

The upper trajectory presents median annual taxable earnings in adult age in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term (>30 days) inpatient treatment (with IBD as the main diagnosis) during childhood and general population reference individuals. The lower trajectory presents adjusted, absolute and relative, median differences in annual taxable earnings between patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset IBD between 1990 and 2014 exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term inpatient treatment during childhood and general population reference individuals (dots represent median differences and lines represent the 95 confidence interval for each estimate).

The upper trajectory presents median annual taxable earnings in adult age in patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) between 1990 and 2014 exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term (>30 days) inpatient treatment (with IBD as the main diagnosis) during childhood and general population reference individuals. The lower trajectory presents adjusted, absolute and relative, median differences in annual taxable earnings between patients diagnosed with childhood‐onset IBD between 1990 and 2014 exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term inpatient treatment during childhood and general population reference individuals (dots represent median differences and lines represent the 95 confidence interval for each estimate).

Annual personalised disposable household income

Patients with childhood‐onset IBD had almost similar annual median personalised disposable household income as general population reference individuals in early adult age (Figure S4). The Swedish social security system seemed to compensate also for the substantially lower earnings in patients with more severe disease during childhood, as no statistically significant difference in personalised disposable household income was seen in this subset throughout early adult age (Figure S5).

DISCUSSION

Main findings

In this nationwide cohort study, from a high‐income country with a comprehensive social insurance system covering all residents, we found that childhood‐onset IBD patients overall had significantly lower earnings in early adult age compared to matched general population reference individuals. Although childhood‐onset IBD patients overall had significantly lower earnings already from age 20, the differences in median annual earnings were relatively modest at age 30 (−5%). However, our study also demonstrated that patients with more severe disease during childhood (exposed to IBD‐related surgery or long‐term inpatient treatment) had markedly lower earnings throughout early adult age (−16% at age 30).

Findings compared to earlier studies

To our knowledge, this is the first population‐based study that has explored the association of childhood‐onset of IBD with earnings in adult age. However, there are some earlier studies that have tried to estimate the impact of childhood onset of IBD for later educational level and socioeconomic status. In 2017, El Matary published a questionnaire‐based single‐centre study of 112 adult patients with childhood‐onset IBD versus 565 sex‐ and age‐matched healthy controls recruited from the 2012 Canadian Community Health Survey. The results of that study were reassuring as these patients seemed to achieve higher education levels and receive higher earnings than individuals without IBD. These findings contrasted with a 2006 paper from the Netherlands where 274 adolescents (15–24 years) with IBD, compared to 248 age‐matched controls without gastrointestinal disease randomly selected from general practitioners, more often were unemployed or employed with a part‐time job. However, both these studies suffer from small numbers and incomplete response rates. In a recently published study, we demonstrated that the median annual earnings were lower in women with IBD compared to their healthy sisters from the year of diagnosis and at least 5 years onwards. This contrasted to the findings in men diagnosed with IBD in adult age that had similar annual taxable earnings as their brothers throughout the first years after diagnosis. However, in this childhood‐onset IBD cohort study, the risk of lower earnings was similar in male and female patients. Neither did we find any difference in the pattern of lower earnings in young adult age between patients with UC or CD. This is somewhat noteworthy as follow‐up studies on both childhood‐onset IBD and adult‐onset IBD cohorts have demonstrated that patients with CD more often seem to be burdened by disease than patients with UC. ,

Mechanistic explanations

There are probably several factors why patients with childhood‐onset IBD had lower earnings in adult age compared to general population reference individuals. We have recently shown that patients with childhood‐onset IBD have poorer achievements in school and speculated that this underperformance to a large extent could be explained by lower school attendance (following disabling symptom and frequent hospital visits) but also to some extent might be explained by disease‐associated fatigue. , Lower grades from compulsory and high school constitute a major obstacle for patients to qualify for highly ranked educations and highly paid professional careers. Being diagnosed with IBD in childhood will also foreclose some career paths and some patients will be forced to give up their professional dreams due to an incapacitating disease. Young patients may also experience disappointment and loss of career drive when they realise that their professional plans are no longer in line with their health needs. It is also possible that facing a chronic disease in early age will redirect career dreams to more caring occupations that might be more personally satisfying but less financially rewarding. The lower earnings could also in part be explained by lower labour market involvement in patients with childhood‐onset IBD. Although at age 30, an equal proportion of childhood‐onset IBD patients were employed, sick leave and disability pension were somewhat more common in patients than among general population reference individuals (Table 2).

Strengths and limitations

The major strength of our study is the population‐based design and the identification of a large number of childhood‐onset IBD patients that were diagnosed and treated during the modern era of immunomodulatory therapy. Through the personal identity number, we were able to link nationwide prospectively collected IBD data from routine clinical practice in virtually complete health registers to compulsory nationwide administrative population registers. There are several limitations to our study. The results of our study might not be generalisable to other countries as social security systems and job security regulations differ from among nations. However, by presenting estimates both for taxable earnings and disposable income the results of our study should be relevant to at least other high‐income countries in the world. The social security system in Sweden is more extensive than in many other countries and childhood‐onset IBD might thus have a stronger negative effect on disposable income in countries with less comprehensive social security systems and job security. Another limitation is the lack of high‐resolution data on professional career which might have provided us with information that could further explain why patients with childhood‐onset IBD had lower taxable earnings in early adult age; that is how much of the earnings gap could be explained by personal choice of labour market sector and working hours and how much could be considered a consequence of poorer career development and lower wages? The study period was tailored to estimate the impact of childhood‐onset IBD in the modern immunomodulatory era. Following the narrow time window, few of the study patients that reached age 30 during the study period were diagnosed after 2001 (in the anti‐TNF era) and only a small minority of them were below 10 years of age when diagnosed with IBD. The small number of patients in these stratas precluded meaningful comparisons why we could not provide valid estimates on the associations of earnings at age 30 stratified by date or age at diagnosis.

Clinical implications

Our findings should be reassuring to most children with IBD and their parents, as most young patients can expect a disease course with minor impact on later professional, educational and social career in early adult age. Nevertheless, our study also showed that lower earnings in early adult age were more common in patients with more severe IBD during childhood and that this absolute earnings gap seemed to increase by age. Our study suggests that a dialogue between healthcare and schools should be established early for children with more severe IBD, to minimise the negative impact of chronic disease on educational achievements. Young patients with more disabling disease should preferably be followed at IBD centres with a special interest in transitional (from childhood to adulthood) medicine. These patients at risk should be informed of their expected forthcoming disease burden so that they timely can adapt to a professional career in line with their health needs.

CONCLUSIONS

Although most patients with childhood‐onset IBD had almost comparable earnings in early adult age as their healthy peers, the markedly larger earnings gaps from age 20 to age 30 in patients with more severe IBD during childhood calls for strengthened educational and labour market support for this subset.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Petter Malmborg: Conceptualization (equal); investigation (equal); methodology (equal); project administration (equal); writing – original draft (lead); writing – review and editing (equal). Åsa Everhov: Investigation (equal); methodology (equal); writing – review and editing (equal). Jonas K Söderling: Formal analysis (equal); software (lead); visualization (lead); writing – review and editing (equal). Jonas F Ludvigsson: Data curation (equal); investigation (equal); methodology (equal); writing – review and editing (equal). Gustaf Bruze: Conceptualization (equal); investigation (equal); methodology (equal); supervision (equal); writing – review and editing (equal). Ola Olén: Conceptualization (equal); data curation (lead); formal analysis (equal); funding acquisition (equal); investigation (equal); methodology (equal); project administration (equal); resources (equal); supervision (equal); writing – review and editing (equal).

FUNDING INFORMATION

This project was supported by grants from Karolinska Institutet (KI SÖS), Bengt Ihre Research Foundation, Bengt Ihre Research Fellowship, Mag‐tarmfonden, Vetenskapsrådet, the Young Scholar Award from the Strategic Research Area Epidemiology program at Karolinska Institutet and the Regional Agreement on Medical Training and Clinical Research between Stockholm County Council and Karolinska Institutet (ALF). None of the funding organisations had any role in the design and conduct of the study; in the collection, management and analysis of the data; or in the preparation, review and approval of the manuscript.

AUTHORSHIP

Guarantor of the article: Olén.

STUDY REPORT GUIDELINE

The study is presented according to the recommendation in the STROBE statement on how to report observational studies in epidemiology. Table S1. Table S2. Table S3. Table S4. Table S5. Table S6. Table S7. Figure S1. Figure S2. Figure S3. Figure S4 Figure S5. Click here for additional data file.
  34 in total

1.  Risk factors of work disability in patients with inflammatory bowel disease--a Dutch nationwide web-based survey: work disability in inflammatory bowel disease.

Authors:  Mirthe E van der Valk; Marie-Josée J Mangen; Max Leenders; Gerard Dijkstra; Ad A van Bodegraven; Herma H Fidder; Dirk J de Jong; Marieke Pierik; C Janneke van der Woude; Mariëlle J L Romberg-Camps; Cees H M Clemens; Jeroen M Jansen; Nofel Mahmmod; Paul C van de Meeberg; Andrea E van der Meulen-de Jong; Cyriel Y Ponsioen; Clemens J M Bolwerk; J Reinoud Vermeijden; Peter D Siersema; Martijn G H van Oijen; Bas Oldenburg
Journal:  J Crohns Colitis       Date:  2013-12-16       Impact factor: 9.071

2.  Work disability in inflammatory bowel disease patients 10 years after disease onset: results from the IBSEN Study.

Authors:  Marte Lie Høivik; Bjørn Moum; Inger Camilla Solberg; Magne Henriksen; Milada Cvancarova; Tomm Bernklev
Journal:  Gut       Date:  2012-06-20       Impact factor: 23.059

3.  Child Health Systems in Sweden.

Authors:  Björn Wettergren; Margareta Blennow; Anders Hjern; Olle Söder; Jonas F Ludvigsson
Journal:  J Pediatr       Date:  2016-09-22       Impact factor: 4.406

4.  Childhood onset inflammatory bowel disease and risk of cancer: a Swedish nationwide cohort study 1964-2014.

Authors:  O Olén; J Askling; M C Sachs; P Frumento; M Neovius; K E Smedby; A Ekbom; P Malmborg; J F Ludvigsson
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2017-09-20

Review 5.  The longitudinal integrated database for health insurance and labour market studies (LISA) and its use in medical research.

Authors:  Jonas F Ludvigsson; Pia Svedberg; Ola Olén; Gustaf Bruze; Martin Neovius
Journal:  Eur J Epidemiol       Date:  2019-03-30       Impact factor: 8.082

6.  Value of an outpatient transition clinic for young people with inflammatory bowel disease: a mixed-methods evaluation.

Authors:  Jane N T Sattoe; Mariëlle A C Peeters; Jannie Haitsma; AnneLoes van Staa; Victorien M Wolters; Johanna C Escher
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2020-01-06       Impact factor: 2.692

7.  Identification of Childhood-Onset Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Swedish Healthcare Registers: A Validation Study.

Authors:  Natalia Mouratidou; Petter Malmborg; Jacob Järås; Vignir Sigurdsson; Olof Sandström; Ulrika L Fagerberg; Gabriella Bröms; Jonas F Ludvigsson; Ola Olén
Journal:  Clin Epidemiol       Date:  2022-04-29       Impact factor: 5.814

8.  The Swedish personal identity number: possibilities and pitfalls in healthcare and medical research.

Authors:  Jonas F Ludvigsson; Petra Otterblad-Olausson; Birgitta U Pettersson; Anders Ekbom
Journal:  Eur J Epidemiol       Date:  2009-06-06       Impact factor: 8.082

9.  Determinants in adolescence for adult sickness absence in women and men: a 26-year follow-up of a prospective population based cohort (Northern Swedish cohort).

Authors:  Ellenor Mittendorfer-Rutz; Gunnel Hensing; Hugo Westerlund; Magnus Backheden; Anne Hammarström
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2013-01-26       Impact factor: 3.295

10.  Women's Earnings are more Affected by Inflammatory Bowel Disease than Men's: A Register-Based Swedish Cohort Study.

Authors:  Åsa H Everhov; Gustaf Bruze; Jonas Söderling; Johan Askling; Jonas Halfvarson; Karin Westberg; Petter Malmborg; Caroline Nordenvall; Jonas F Ludvigsson; Ola Olén
Journal:  J Crohns Colitis       Date:  2021-06-22       Impact factor: 9.071

View more
  1 in total

1.  Earnings during adulthood in patients with childhood-onset inflammatory bowel disease: a nationwide population-based cohort study.

Authors:  Petter Malmborg; Åsa H Everhov; Jonas Söderling; Jonas F Ludvigsson; Gustaf Bruze; Ola Olén
Journal:  Aliment Pharmacol Ther       Date:  2022-08-02       Impact factor: 9.524

  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.