Gretchen Guaglianone1, Belén Torrado2, Yu-Fu Lin3,4, Matthew C Watkins1, Vicki H Wysocki3,4, Enrico Gratton2, James S Nowick1,5. 1. Department of Chemistry, University of California, Irvine, Irvine, California 92697, United States. 2. Laboratory for Fluorescence Dynamics, Biomedical Engineering, University of California, Irvine, California 92697, United States. 3. Resource for Native MS Guided Structural Biology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, United States. 4. Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, United States. 5. Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of California, Irvine, Irvine, California 92697, United States.
Abstract
Aβ oligomers play a central role in the neurodegeneration observed with Alzheimer's disease. Our laboratory has developed covalently stabilized trimers derived from residues 17-36 of Aβ as model systems for studying Aβ oligomers. In the current study, we apply the emerging techniques of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) and native mass spectrometry (native MS) to better understand the assembly and interactions of the oligomer model system 2AT-L in aqueous solutions and with cells. 2AT-L and fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues assemble in the membrane-like environment of SDS-PAGE, showing diffuse bands of oligomers in equilibrium. Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (native IM-MS) of 2AT-L allows for the identification of discrete oligomers in solution and shows similar patterns of oligomer formation between 2AT-L and fluorescently labeled analogues. Fluorescence microscopy with SH-SY5Y cells reveals that fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues colocalize within lysosomes. FLIM studies with phasor analysis further elucidate the assembly of 2AT-L within cells and establish the occurrence of FRET, indicating the presence of oligomers within cells. Collectively, these multiple complementary techniques help better understand the complex behavior of the 2AT-L model system.
Aβ oligomers play a central role in the neurodegeneration observed with Alzheimer's disease. Our laboratory has developed covalently stabilized trimers derived from residues 17-36 of Aβ as model systems for studying Aβ oligomers. In the current study, we apply the emerging techniques of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) and native mass spectrometry (native MS) to better understand the assembly and interactions of the oligomer model system 2AT-L in aqueous solutions and with cells. 2AT-L and fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues assemble in the membrane-like environment of SDS-PAGE, showing diffuse bands of oligomers in equilibrium. Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (native IM-MS) of 2AT-L allows for the identification of discrete oligomers in solution and shows similar patterns of oligomer formation between 2AT-L and fluorescently labeled analogues. Fluorescence microscopy with SH-SY5Y cells reveals that fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues colocalize within lysosomes. FLIM studies with phasor analysis further elucidate the assembly of 2AT-L within cells and establish the occurrence of FRET, indicating the presence of oligomers within cells. Collectively, these multiple complementary techniques help better understand the complex behavior of the 2AT-L model system.
Elucidating the biological properties
of Aβ oligomers and
understanding their solution-phase behavior are essential to better
understanding Alzheimer’s disease.[1] Accumulation of the β-amyloid peptide (Aβ) in the brain
is a hallmark of Alzheimer’s disease and is a key contributor
to neurodegeneration.[2] Aβ aggregates
to form toxic oligomers and the fibrils that make up the characteristic
plaques observed in the brains from those with Alzheimer’s
disease.[3] These oligomers are thought to
be the main synaptotoxic species but have proven difficult to study
as they are inherently heterogeneous and metastable with a high propensity
to form fibrils.[4−9] Trimers of Aβ42 are among the most toxic oligomers
and are implicated in neuronal cell death.[7,10−13]Model systems of stabilized Aβ-derived oligomers have
emerged
as tools to better understand endogenous oligomers and provide further
insight into the molecular basis of Alzheimer’s disease.[13−15] Our laboratory has developed a series of covalently stabilized trimers
derived from residues 17–36 of Aβ as chemical models
of toxic amyloid oligomers associated with neurodegeneration in Alzheimer’s
disease.[16−21] One of the trimers, termed 4AT-L, is composed of three β-hairpins
formed by an Aβ17–36 peptide, with molecular
templates designed to induce β-hairpin folding, block uncontrolled
aggregation, and allow disulfide crosslinking of three β-hairpins
to form a covalent trimer.[21] Trimer 4AT-L
is toxic toward the neuronal cell line SH-SY5Y, assembles to form
ball-shaped dodecamers composed of four trimers in the crystal state,
and forms dodecamers in SDS-PAGE.Fluorescence lifetime imaging
microscopy (FLIM) and native mass
spectrometry (native MS) have emerged as important new tools to probe
the assembly and interactions of peptides and proteins.[22−26] Native MS provides information about the stoichiometry of oligomeric
assemblies present in solution and can thus complement the structural
information elucidated from X-ray crystallography and SDS-PAGE to
build a broader understanding of the solution-phase assembly of Aβ-derived
oligomers.[27,28] Fluorescence microscopy to visualize
Aβ-derived oligomers in the presence of cells and the application
of FLIM to determine the occurrence of Förster resonance energy
transfer (FRET) can complement the previously observed cellular cytotoxicity.[29−35] In the current study, we set out to apply these and other techniques
to better understand the assembly and interactions of a covalently
stabilized trimer derived from residues 17–36 of Aβ in
aqueous solutions and with cells.
Results and Discussion
Design and Synthesis of 2AT-L
In trimer 4AT-L, the
native phenylalanine at position 20 is replaced with cyclohexylalanine.
For the current study, we prepared homologue 2AT-L, which behaves
similarly but has the native phenylalanine at position 20. Trimer
2AT-L is composed of three crosslinked Aβ17–36 β-hairpins. In each β-hairpin, a δ-linked ornithine
(δOrn) turn unit between residues 17 and 36 helps
enforce a folded β-hairpin conformation, and an N-methyl group on phenylalanine 20 helps block uncontrolled aggregation
(Figure A). In 2AT-L,
residues 17 and 21 are replaced by cysteines, which provide covalent
crosslinks that hold the trimer together by connecting the monomer
subunits at the vertices (Figure B,C). The crosslinked trimers are homogeneous, stable,
and mimic some of the biological properties of Aβ oligomers.[19,21]
Figure 1
Chemical
structures of β-hairpin peptides and a trimer derived
from Aβ17–36. (A) Macrocyclic β-hairpin
2AM-L incorporating an N-methyl residue to prevent
uncontrolled aggregation and a δOrn turn (blue) mimic
to constrain the N- and C-termini. (B) β-Hairpin 2AM-LCC incorporates cysteine mutations at residues 17 and 21. (C) Three
2AM-LCC β-hairpins form covalently stabilized trimer
2AT-L through disulfide bonds.
Chemical
structures of β-hairpin peptides and a trimer derived
from Aβ17–36. (A) Macrocyclic β-hairpin
2AM-L incorporating an N-methyl residue to prevent
uncontrolled aggregation and a δOrn turn (blue) mimic
to constrain the N- and C-termini. (B) β-Hairpin 2AM-LCC incorporates cysteine mutations at residues 17 and 21. (C) Three
2AM-LCC β-hairpins form covalently stabilized trimer
2AT-L through disulfide bonds.We synthesized trimer 2AT-L by the same procedures
that we previously
used to prepare trimer 4AT-L. We first prepared macrocyclic peptide
2AM-LCC by solid-phase peptide synthesis of the corresponding
linear peptide on 2-chlorotrityl resin, followed by cleavage of the
protected peptide from the resin, solution-phase macrocyclization,
deprotection, and purification by RP-HPLC. 2AM-LCC was
oxidized at 6 mM in 20% aqueous DMSO with 60 mM triethylamine for
48 h. 2AT-L was isolated from the oxidation reaction by RP-HPLC. Pure
fractions were lyophilized, affording >95% pure 2AT-L as the trifluoroacetate
(TFA) salt.
Preparation of Fluorescently Labeled 2AT-L
Substoichiometric
labeling of 2AT-L with fluorophore NHS esters permits the isolation
of singly labeled 2AT-L.[36] We developed
a labeling procedure in which 2AT-L is treated with 0.05 molar equivalents
of the commercially available sulfo-cyanine3 (sCy3) or sulfo-cyanine5
(sCy5) NHS esters, and the singly labeled trimer is isolated by RP-HPLC,
and the unlabeled trimer is recycled. We found that heating the HPLC
column greatly facilitates the separation of the labeled trimer from
the unlabeled trimer and also permits the removal of the small amounts
of doubly labeled trimer that form. We selected the bis-sulfonated
analogues of the commonly used FRET partners Cy3 and Cy5 as fluorophores
because they provide enhanced aqueous solubility and reduced aggregation.
Labeling 3 mg of trimer by this procedure typically permits isolation
of ca. 150 μg of singly labeled trimer 2AT-L-sCy3 or 2AT-L-sCy5
as the TFA salt, which was sufficient for many of the experiments
described below.
Oligomerization of 2AT-L and Fluorescently Labeled 2AT-L Analogues
by SDS-PAGE
We used SDS-PAGE to initially assess the effect
of the sCy3 and sCy5 fluorophores on the assembly of 2AT-L into higher-order
oligomers. In SDS-PAGE, trimer 2AT-L assembles to form higher-order
oligomers. When 2AT-L (6.6 kDa) is run in SDS-PAGE and visualized
by silver staining, it forms a downward-streaking band from ca. 32
kDa to ca. 13 kDa, suggesting assembly into oligomers ca. 2–5
trimers in size (Figure A). In contrast, the monomer 2AM-L (2.2 kDa) migrates at ca. 3 kDa,
indicating the absence of assembly into oligomers. 2AT-L-sCy3 (7.2
kDa) migrates as a compact band at ca. 14 kDa, suggesting hexamer
formation (2 trimers), while 2AT-L-sCy5 (7.2 kDa) migrates as a more
diffuse band, from ca. 21 kDa to ca. 13 kDa, suggesting the formation
of hexamers or perhaps hexamers and nonamers (2–3 trimers).
Figure 2
SDS-PAGE
of peptides 2AM-L, 2AT-L, 2AT-L-sCy3, and 2AT-L-sCy5.
(A) Silver-stained image. (B) Fluorescence image in the Cy3 channel.
(C) Fluorescence image in the Cy5 channel. SDS-PAGE was performed
in Tris buffer at pH 6.8 with 2% (w/v) SDS on a 16% polyacrylamide
gel with 50 μM solutions of peptide in each lane. Fluorescence
imaging was performed before silver staining.
SDS-PAGE
of peptides 2AM-L, 2AT-L, 2AT-L-sCy3, and 2AT-L-sCy5.
(A) Silver-stained image. (B) Fluorescence image in the Cy3 channel.
(C) Fluorescence image in the Cy5 channel. SDS-PAGE was performed
in Tris buffer at pH 6.8 with 2% (w/v) SDS on a 16% polyacrylamide
gel with 50 μM solutions of peptide in each lane. Fluorescence
imaging was performed before silver staining.Fluorescence imaging provides additional insights
into the bands
formed by the trimers (Figure B,C). Notably, the diffuse band formed by 2AT-L-sCy5 shows
an intense component at ca. 14 kDa and a weaker component at ca. 21
kDa. The difference in shape between the bands formed by 2AT-L-sCy5
and 2AT-L-sCy3 may reflect the greater hydrophobicity and flat hydrophobic
surface area provided by the larger sCy5 fluorophore. Both the sCy3
and sCy5 labels appear to impede the assembly, with hexamers as the
main species observed, while the unlabeled 2AT-L forms predominantly
larger oligomers.[37]
Oligomerization of 2AT-L and Fluorescently Labeled 2AT-L Analogues
by Native IM-MS
We used native MS coupled with ion mobility
spectrometry (IM) to investigate the oligomeric assembly of the trimers
to complement the SDS-PAGE studies and avoid SDS-induced oligomer
formation.[38] In native IM-MS, oligomers
and noncovalent assemblies are ionized and separated without dissociation.[39] IM separates ionized oligomers of different
sizes, shapes, and charges in the gas phase as they travel through
the ion mobility device at different rates, and their arrival times
are measured.[40] The ions then are analyzed
by a mass analyzer to determine their mass-to-charge ratio, m/z (Figure A). Trimer 2AT-L and fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues
show a charge state distribution in the mass spectrum, leading to
many overlapping m/z peaks that
arise from multiple assemblies of trimers. The separation by arrival
times that occurs in the ion mobility device permits the separation
of species with identical mass-to-charge ratios into their component
oligomers.
Figure 3
Native IM-MS of 2AT-L and labeled analogues. (A) Diagram of the
cIMS instrument used to run native IM-MS experiments. Molecules are
ionized through nano-electrospray ionization (nano-ESI) and then travel
through an ion guide and quadrupole. Ions reach a trap cell before
entering the cyclic ion mobility device in which species are separated
by size, shape, and charge. Ions exit the mobility device and proceed
through a reflectron time-of-flight (TOF) mass analyzer to separate
ions by mass-to-charge ratio. The time for an ion to travel through
the mobility cell to detection is recorded as the arrival time. (B–D)
Mobiligrams of 2AT-L, 2AT-L-sCy3, and 2AT-L-sCy5. Native IM-MS was
performed on a SELECT SERIES Cyclic IMS Q-cIMS-TOF (cIMS) instrument
(Waters Corporation). Numeric labels indicate the charge state of
the corresponding oligomeric species. Samples of 2AT-L and fluorescently
labeled 2AT-L analogues were prepared at a concentration of 40 μM
in 400 mM ammonium acetate.
Native IM-MS of 2AT-L and labeled analogues. (A) Diagram of the
cIMS instrument used to run native IM-MS experiments. Molecules are
ionized through nano-electrospray ionization (nano-ESI) and then travel
through an ion guide and quadrupole. Ions reach a trap cell before
entering the cyclic ion mobility device in which species are separated
by size, shape, and charge. Ions exit the mobility device and proceed
through a reflectron time-of-flight (TOF) mass analyzer to separate
ions by mass-to-charge ratio. The time for an ion to travel through
the mobility cell to detection is recorded as the arrival time. (B–D)
Mobiligrams of 2AT-L, 2AT-L-sCy3, and 2AT-L-sCy5. Native IM-MS was
performed on a SELECT SERIES Cyclic IMS Q-cIMS-TOF (cIMS) instrument
(Waters Corporation). Numeric labels indicate the charge state of
the corresponding oligomeric species. Samples of 2AT-L and fluorescently
labeled 2AT-L analogues were prepared at a concentration of 40 μM
in 400 mM ammonium acetate.Native IM-MS reveals that 2AT-L and fluorescently
labeled 2AT-L
analogues also assemble to form oligomers in aqueous solution. Each
IM-MS experiment generates a mobiligram, in which the arrival time
is plotted against mass-to-charge ratio, with the relative intensity
displayed as a heat map. The IM-MS mobiligram for trimer 2AT-L shows
that 2AT-L forms hexamers and nonamers, in addition to the trimer
(Figure B). IM-MS
shows that 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 also undergo assembly. The mobiligram
for 2AT-L-sCy3 shows the formation of hexamers, as well as a low abundance
of nonamers and dodecamers, in addition to the trimer (Figure C). The mobiligram for 2AT-L-sCy5
also shows the formation of hexamers, nonamers, and dodecamers, in
addition to the trimer (Figure D).[41]Together, the SDS-PAGE
and native IM-MS experiments reveal that
oligomers of 2AT-L and the fluorescently labeled 2AT-L analogues can
form in either the presence or absence of SDS. Although the fluorophore
labels appear to perturb the formation of higher-order oligomers in
SDS-PAGE, a similar perturbation is not seen in native IM-MS.
Co-Oligomerization of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 by FRET
We performed steady-state FRET experiments with mixtures of 2AT-L-sCy3
(donor) and 2AT-L-sCy5 (acceptor) to further assess the assembly of
2AT-L into higher-order oligomers in solution. The occurrence of FRET
can be determined by selectively exciting at a wavelength absorbed
by the donor and observing fluorescence at a wavelength emitted by
the acceptor. In practice, it is often difficult to selectively excite
only the donor. Thus, we used an excitation wavelength of 490 nm—which
is well below the 548 nm λmax of sCy3—to minimize
direct excitation of sCy5.[42] We monitored
fluorescence emission at 662 nm—the emission maximum of sCy5—and
varied the ratio of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 from 100:0 to 0:100
while maintaining a total concentration of 5 μM.When
2AT-L-sCy3 alone (100:0) is irradiated at 490 nm, emission (0.57 rfu)
occurs at 662 nm (Figure ). This emission results from the sCy3 fluorophore, which
has an emission maximum of 556 nm, but which extends weakly to 662
nm and beyond. When a 50:50 mixture of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 is
irradiated, the emission at 662 nm increases (1.00 rfu). The enhanced
fluorescence reflects the occurrence of FRET and thus demonstrates
the co-oligomerization of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5. Only modest emission
(0.29 rfu) occurs from excitation of 2AT-L-sCy5 alone (0:100) at 490
nm, providing further evidence that the enhanced fluorescence in the
50:50 mixture results from FRET. Additional mixtures of 2AT-L-sCy3
and 2AT-L-sCy5 (80:20, 60:40, 40:60, 20:80) show intermediate levels
of emission, providing further evidence for co-oligomerization and
FRET.
Figure 4
Fluorescence at the emission maximum of 2AT-L-sCy5 as a function
of the percentage of 2AT-L-sCy3. Fluorescence spectra of mixtures
of varying ratios of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 were acquired with
excitation at 490 nm and observation at 662 nm. All spectra were collected
on aqueous solutions of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 with a total concentration
of 5 μM.
Fluorescence at the emission maximum of 2AT-L-sCy5 as a function
of the percentage of 2AT-L-sCy3. Fluorescence spectra of mixtures
of varying ratios of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 were acquired with
excitation at 490 nm and observation at 662 nm. All spectra were collected
on aqueous solutions of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 with a total concentration
of 5 μM.
Fluorescence Microscopy of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5
To gain insights into the biological roles of the oligomers observed
by SDS-PAGE, native IM-MS, and steady-state FRET experiments, we performed
fluorescence microscopy with SH-SY5Y cells. Trimer 4AT-L is toxic
toward SH-SY5Y cells, and trimer 2AT-L exhibits similar toxicity.[21] To further explore the interaction of Aβ-derived
trimers with mammalian cells, we used fluorescence microscopy. SH-SY5Y
cells were incubated with fluorescent analogues of 2AT-L at a total
concentration of 5 μM. Cells were then counterstained with Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue), washed with phenol red-free DMEM:F12 media,
and imaged. Fluorescence micrographs were collected with emissions
observed in the respective Cyanine3 and Cyanine5 channels.Fluorescence
microscopy reveals that both 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 are internalized
by cells. Incubation of SH-SY5Y cells with 2AT-L-sCy3 resulted in
defined intracellular puncta and some small fluorescent features bound
to the cell membrane (Figure S2). Incubation
of SH-SY5Y cells with 2AT-L-sCy5 resulted in similar features (Figure S3). Incubation of SH-SY5Y cells with
both 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 also resulted in similar features (Figure ). Merged images,
showing both the green (2AT-L-sCy3) and red (2AT-L-sCy5) channels,
show a yellow hue, indicating co-localization of the fluorescently
labeled trimers. Punctate features were observed as early as 5 h after
treatment and at concentrations of fluorescently labeled 2AT-L as
low as 8 nM (Figure S4).
Figure 5
Micrographs illustrating
intracellular co-localization of fluorescently
labeled 2AT-L analogues in SH-SY5Y cells. (A) 2AT-L-sCy5 (red) and
Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain (blue). (B) 2AT-L-sCy3 (green) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (C) Brightfield image. (D) Merged fluorescent
images with brightfield images. Cells were incubated with 5 μM
2AT-L-sCy3 and 5 μM 2AT-L-sCy5 for 6 h at 37°C, counterstained
with Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain, and imaged.
Micrographs illustrating
intracellular co-localization of fluorescently
labeled 2AT-L analogues in SH-SY5Y cells. (A) 2AT-L-sCy5 (red) and
Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain (blue). (B) 2AT-L-sCy3 (green) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (C) Brightfield image. (D) Merged fluorescent
images with brightfield images. Cells were incubated with 5 μM
2AT-L-sCy3 and 5 μM 2AT-L-sCy5 for 6 h at 37°C, counterstained
with Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain, and imaged.The punctate intracellular features observed for
the labeled 2AT-L
are similar to those reported for fluorescently labeled Aβ42, where uptake occurred primarily through endocytosis.[43−50] These studies have shown that Aβ localizes in lysosomes. To
assess whether 2AT-L also localizes into lysosomes, we performed further
experiments using the lysosomal marker Lysotracker Green. Treatment
of SH-SY5Y cells with Lysotracker Green and either 2AT-L-sCy3 or 2AT-L-sCy5
showed co-localization, indicating sequestration in the lysosomes
(Figures S5 and 6). Thus, it appears that the uptake of 2AT-L occurs through endocytosis,
in a fashion similar to that of Aβ.
Figure 6
Micrographs illustrating
intracellular co-localization of 2AT-L-sCy5
and Lysotracker Green in SH-SY5Y cells. (A) 2AT-L-sCy5 (red) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (B) Lysotracker Green (green) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (C) Brightfield image. (D) Merged fluorescent
images with brightfield images. Cells were incubated with 5 μM
2AT-L-sCy5 and 100 nM Lysotracker Green for 6 h at 37°C, counterstained
with Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain, and imaged.
Micrographs illustrating
intracellular co-localization of 2AT-L-sCy5
and Lysotracker Green in SH-SY5Y cells. (A) 2AT-L-sCy5 (red) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (B) Lysotracker Green (green) and Hoechst
33342 nuclear stain (blue). (C) Brightfield image. (D) Merged fluorescent
images with brightfield images. Cells were incubated with 5 μM
2AT-L-sCy5 and 100 nM Lysotracker Green for 6 h at 37°C, counterstained
with Hoechst 33342 nuclear stain, and imaged.Previous reports have suggested that oligomerization
is a prerequisite
for the cellular uptake of Aβ.[51] The
covalently stabilized oligomer model 2AT-L is readily taken up by
cells and may thus serve as a model to further study the cellular
uptake of Aβ oligomers. To continue to probe the assembly state
of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 and assess for higher-order oligomer
formation, we turned to FRET microscopy.
FLIM-FRET Studies of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5
We used
fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) to further investigate
the intracellular puncta observed when fluorescently labeled 2AT-L
analogues are incubated with cells. FLIM allows the detection of FRET
and can thus reveal molecular co-localization at a resolution higher
than can be achieved through confocal microscopy. If 2AT-L molecules
bearing FRET partners co-assemble or are otherwise in close proximity
(<10 nm), FRET can occur and will manifest as a reduction in the
fluorescence lifetime of the FRET donor through fluorescence quenching.[52] Measurement of fluorescence lifetimes through
FLIM-FRET offers advantages over intensity-based FRET measurements
because the measurement of the lifetime is generally independent of
the concentration of the fluorophores and does not require correction
for spectral crosstalk.[53]To assess
FRET inside cells, we treated SH-SY5Y cells with either 2AT-L-sCy3
(donor) alone or with mixtures of 2AT-L-sCy5 (acceptor) and 2AT-L-sCy3
and looked for decreases in the fluorescence lifetime of sCy3 with
increasing mole fraction of sCy5. Although 2AT-L-sCy3 oligomers or
2AT-L-sCy5 oligomers can form, only oligomers containing both 2AT-L-sCy3
and 2AT-L-sCy5 are expected to show decreased fluorescence lifetime
(Figure A).[54] We used the phasor approach to analyze changes
in the fluorescence lifetime of sCy3. In this method, each pixel of
a FLIM image is transformed to a point on a phasor plot, allowing
for simple visualization of changes in the donor lifetime in a micrograph
and thus facilitating the assessment of FRET.[55−58] Changes in fluorescence lifetime
with increases in mole fraction of sCy5 manifest as changes in the
positions of points on the phasor plot (Figure B), with greater changes corresponding to
a greater fraction of molecules undergoing FRET.[55,59,60]
Figure 7
Phasor analysis of FLIM micrographs of SH-SY5Y
cells treated with
2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5. Oligomeric assemblies of 2AT-L-sCy3 and
2AT-L-sCy5 within cells were analyzed by FLIM-FRET and the phasor
approach. (A) Representation of the co-assembly of 2AT-L-sCy3 (donor)
and 2AT-L-sCy5 (acceptor) and the occurrence of FRET. (B) Representation
of the phasor transformation of FLIM images. Fluorescence lifetime
of each pixel of each image is analyzed and plotted on a phasor plot.
When FRET occurs, the excited state lifetime of the donor decreases
and the phasor position shifts toward shorter lifetimes. The curved
FRET trajectory (dotted line) follows the classical definition of
FRET efficiency and is influenced by the background fluorescence lifetime.
(C) Representative images showing photon intensity of SH-SY5Y cells
treated with 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 in 100:0, 50:50, and 25:75
ratios. Images were acquired in the donor (sCy3) channel. Scale bar
= 5 μm. (D) Phasor plot illustrating the average
phasor position in each image. Images collected for the 100:0 ratio
are represented by red points and correspond to unquenched donor (Dunq). Images collected for the 50:50 ratio are
represented by green points. Images collected for the 25:75 ratio
are represented by violet points and correspond to increased donor
quenching (Dq). (E) Details of phasor
plot in panel (D). Average phasor plot positions (±SD) from each
image. (F) Representative images of SH-SY5Y cells with false color
illustrating fluorescence lifetime. Longer fluorescence lifetimes
are represented in red and orange, while shorter fluorescence lifetimes
reflecting increased FRET are represented progressively in yellow,
green, blue, and violet.
Phasor analysis of FLIM micrographs of SH-SY5Y
cells treated with
2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5. Oligomeric assemblies of 2AT-L-sCy3 and
2AT-L-sCy5 within cells were analyzed by FLIM-FRET and the phasor
approach. (A) Representation of the co-assembly of 2AT-L-sCy3 (donor)
and 2AT-L-sCy5 (acceptor) and the occurrence of FRET. (B) Representation
of the phasor transformation of FLIM images. Fluorescence lifetime
of each pixel of each image is analyzed and plotted on a phasor plot.
When FRET occurs, the excited state lifetime of the donor decreases
and the phasor position shifts toward shorter lifetimes. The curved
FRET trajectory (dotted line) follows the classical definition of
FRET efficiency and is influenced by the background fluorescence lifetime.
(C) Representative images showing photon intensity of SH-SY5Y cells
treated with 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 in 100:0, 50:50, and 25:75
ratios. Images were acquired in the donor (sCy3) channel. Scale bar
= 5 μm. (D) Phasor plot illustrating the average
phasor position in each image. Images collected for the 100:0 ratio
are represented by red points and correspond to unquenched donor (Dunq). Images collected for the 50:50 ratio are
represented by green points. Images collected for the 25:75 ratio
are represented by violet points and correspond to increased donor
quenching (Dq). (E) Details of phasor
plot in panel (D). Average phasor plot positions (±SD) from each
image. (F) Representative images of SH-SY5Y cells with false color
illustrating fluorescence lifetime. Longer fluorescence lifetimes
are represented in red and orange, while shorter fluorescence lifetimes
reflecting increased FRET are represented progressively in yellow,
green, blue, and violet.We performed three sets of experiments, in which
SH-SY5Y cells
were treated with 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 in 100:0, 50:50, and 25:75
ratios while maintaining a total concentration of 5 μM. For
each ratio, we collected 25–26 images of individual cells.
We observed the photon intensity in the donor channel decrease as
the fraction of 2AT-L-sCy5 increased (Figure C). The fluorescence decay from each pixel
was determined, and the average from each image was plotted onto a
phasor plot, with different colors (red, green, and violet) representing
the three sets of ratios studied (Figure D,E). The resulting phasor plot shows significant
decreases in fluorescence lifetime with an increasing fraction of
sCy5 and thus provides compelling evidence for FRET and hence intimate
proximity of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 in the cells.The fluorescence
lifetimes measured in FLIM-FRET can also be represented
as a heat map, with each pixel of an image colored to reflect its
relative fluorescence lifetime. We have thus represented the distribution
of fluorescence lifetimes on three representative images at the 100:0,
50:50, and 25:75 ratios, with red representing the longest lifetimes
and violet representing the shortest lifetimes, and colors ranging
from orange to blue representing intermediate lifetimes (Figure F). The shift from
red toward violet across the series of images reflects the decrease
in fluorescence lifetime with an increasing fraction of 2AT-L-sCy5
and further demonstrates that FRET increases with the addition of
sCy5. Collectively, these FLIM-FRET experiments provide further evidence
that 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5 co-oligomerize in cells.
Summary and Conclusions
Our covalently stabilized Aβ-derived
trimers mimic some of
the assembly and biological properties of Aβ oligomers. In the
crystal state, 2AT-L and homologue 4AT-L assemble to form ball-shaped
dodecamers. In the membrane-like environment of SDS-PAGE, 2AT-L dodecamers
are also observed but appear to be in equilibrium with oligomers ca.
2–5 trimers in size. Labeling 2AT-L with sCy3 and sCy5 appears
to attenuate assembly in SDS-PAGE, with 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5
migrating mainly as hexamers. Native IM-MS of 2AT-L identifies discrete
hexamers and nonamers in solution. Native IM-MS of 2AT-L-sCy3 and
2AT-L-sCy5 shows similar oligomer formation to 2AT-L.[61]Steady-state FRET experiments also show that 2AT-L-sCy3
and 2AT-L-sCy5
form oligomers in solution. Fluorescence microscopy shows that 2AT-L-sCy3
and 2AT-L-sCy5 form intracellular puncta in SH-SY5Y cells, which co-localize
with a lysosomal marker, suggesting an uptake mechanism through endocytotic
vesicles that is consistent with previous studies of Aβ.[49] FLIM studies and phasor analysis establish the
occurrence of FRET within cells treated with both 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5,
suggesting oligomerization within cellular vesicles.The aggregation
of Aβ to form oligomers is difficult to study
in detail due to the complexity of the different species that form
and the propensity of Aβ to ultimately form insoluble fibrils.
The constraint of an Aβ-derived peptide into a stable trimer,
2AT-L, provides a model system that is easier to study and can be
explored by a variety of biophysical and biological techniques. While
X-ray crystallography provides a simple answer that assemblies of
dodecamers form in the crystal state, the behavior in the solution
state is more complex. SDS-PAGE shows multiple oligomeric states in
equilibrium but does not allow the identification of discrete oligomers.
Native IM-MS, on the other hand, allows the identification of individual
oligomers. The addition of fluorescent labels is required to visualize
the interactions of 2AT-L in cells, although SDS-PAGE shows that these
labels can alter the oligomerization, at least somewhat. FLIM-FRET
experiments with phasor analysis allow the observation of oligomerization
of the labeled 2AT-L in cells. Collectively, the application of multiple
complementary techniques helps better elucidate the complex behavior
of the 2AT-L model system. We anticipate that these techniques may
also be useful for understanding the yet more complex oligomerization
of Aβ.
Materials and Methods
Peptides 2AM-L, 2AM-LCC, and 2AT-L were synthesized
by procedures analogous to those described previously.[19] SDS-PAGE and silver staining were performed
as described previously.[21] Procedures detailing
the preparation of 2AT-L-sCy3 and 2AT-L-sCy5, native mass spectrometry
studies, steady-state FRET experiments, fluorescence microscopy, and
FLIM-FRET can be found in the Supporting Information.
Authors: Sheng Zhang; Gretchen Guaglianone; Michael A Morris; Stan Yoo; William J Howitz; Li Xing; Jian-Guo Zheng; Hannah Jusuf; Grace Huizar; Jonathan Lin; Adam G Kreutzer; James S Nowick Journal: Biochemistry Date: 2021-04-01 Impact factor: 3.321
Authors: Adam G Kreutzer; Ryan K Spencer; Kate J McKnelly; Stan Yoo; Imane L Hamza; Patrick J Salveson; James S Nowick Journal: Biochemistry Date: 2017-10-27 Impact factor: 3.162