| Literature DB >> 35848874 |
Sagun Tiwari1,2,3, Namrata Sapkota4,5,6, Zhenxiang Han1.
Abstract
Emerging evidence suggests that fasting could play a key role in cancer treatment by fostering conditions that limit cancer cells' adaptability, survival, and growth. Fasting could increase the effectiveness of cancer treatments and limit adverse events. Yet, we lack an integrated mechanistic model for how these two complicated systems interact, limiting our ability to understand, prevent, and treat cancer using fasting. Here, we review recent findings at the interface of oncology and fasting metabolism, with an emphasis on human clinical studies of intermittent fasting. We recommend combining prolonged periodic fasting with a standard conventional therapeutic approach to promote cancer-free survival, treatment efficacy and reduce side effects in cancer patients.Entities:
Keywords: cancer; diet; fasting; intermittent fasting; oncology; review
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35848874 PMCID: PMC9530862 DOI: 10.1111/cas.15492
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cancer Sci ISSN: 1347-9032 Impact factor: 6.518
FIGURE 1Effect of prolonged fasting on different systems of the body on patients. During fasting, the breakdown of liver glycogen reserves (into glucose) and triglycerides (into glycerol and free fatty acids) occurs. The brain progressively adjusts using the ketone bodies in addition to glucose to satisfy its energy requirements, while other tissues use fatty acids for energy. Gluconeogenesis is fueled by ketone bodies created in the liver from fatty acids, fat‐derived glycerol, and amino acids during the ketogenic phase of fasting.
FIGURE 2Mechanisms of fasting on cancer cells. Fasting suppresses glucose, IGF1, insulin, the MAPK pathway, and heme oxygenase 1 while increasing many autophagy‐regulating components (Atgs, LC3, Beclin1, p62, Sirt1, and LAMP2). Fasting causes cancer cells to release oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) through aerobic glycolysis, which leads to an increase in reactive oxygen species (ROS), p53 activation, DNA damage, and cell death in response to chemotherapy. Fasting activates the autophagic process, which induces cell death through a variety of mechanisms. It also suppresses CD73 and CD39 expression and causes extracellular ATP accumulation, which inhibits Treg cells and the M2 phenotype while activating CD8+ cytotoxic T cells. Fasting also inhibits hemoxygenase 1. It accelerates cellular death and activates CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes, which drive the apoptosis cycle once again.
Intermittent fasting on cancer patients
| Author and Year | Type of cancer | Enrolled patient details | Fasting regime | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schreck et al. | 2–4 grade astrocytoma | A total of 25 patients were recruited in an 8‐week glioma Atkins diet. | Two fasting days (calories <20% calculated estimated needs) interleaved between 5 modified Atkins diet days (net carbohydrates ≤20 g/d) each week. |
Diet was generally tolerated, with only two grade 3 side effects (neutropenia and seizure) Systemic activity measurements, such as hemoglobin A1c, insulin, and fat body mass, all declined, while lean body mass increased. Higher ketone concentrations in both the lesional and contralateral brain as compared to baseline. |
| de Groot et al. | HER2‐negative breast cancer, Stage II/III | In total, 131 individuals received neoadjuvant chemotherapy. | Fasting mimicking diet 3 days before and during neoadjuvant chemotherapy |
There were no differences in grade ¾ toxicity during chemotherapy between participants in the fasting and usual care groups. Miller‐Payne 4/5 pathologic response is more common in the FMD cohort. Patients who followed the FMD more closely had a more significant percentage of Miller–Payne 4/5 scores. |
| Zorn et al. | Gynecological cancers at any stage | Thirty patients receiving (neo)‐adjuvant chemotherapy for a minimum of four cycles of the same treatment | Ninety‐six‐hour fasting for half of scheduled chemotherapy cycles, followed by a regular diet for the remaining cycles |
Fasting is linked to greater ketone bodies and lower insulin and IGF‐1 levels in the blood. Less stomatitis, headaches, and weakness; lower overall toxicity score; and fewer chemotherapy delays while fasting. No improvement in patient‐reported quality of life, chemotherapy‐induced neuropathy, or fatigue |
| Bauersfeld et al. | Breast and ovarian cancer at any stage | A total of 34 individuals are undergoing chemotherapy. | Patients were randomly assigned to either a short‐term fasting diet followed by a normal caloric diet or a normal caloric diet followed by a short‐term fasting diet in the first half of chemotherapy. |
Within 8 hours after treatment, patients on the fasting diet reported improved quality of life and tiredness. |
| Marinac et al. | Breast cancer at an early stage | At baseline, year 1 and year 4, 2413 patients completed 24‐h dietary recalls. | Dietary recalls were utilized to calculate the length of time spent fasting at night. |
Fasting for less than 13 hours per night is connected with a 36% greater risk of recurrence of breast cancer when compared to individuals fasting for ≥13 hours per night |
| Dorff et al. | Breast, ovarian, and uterine cancer at any stage | Twenty individuals are being treated with platinum‐based chemotherapy. | Fasting for 24 hours, 48 hours, or 72 hours before chemotherapy |
Fasting is doable and safe. Fasting cohorts had lower incidences of neutropenia and neuropathy. Fasting cohorts have less DNA damage. |
| De Groot et al. | HER2‐negative breast cancer II/III | Thirteen patients are being treated with (neo)‐adjuvant chemotherapy. | Before and after chemotherapy, patients were randomly assigned to either a 24‐hour fast or a diet that followed appropriate dietary standards. |
Fasting was well tolerated, and it decreased hematologic toxicity. Fasting may aid in the healing of DNA damage caused by chemotherapy. |
| Badar et al. | Breast, non‐Hodgkin lymphoma, acute myeloid leukemia, nasopharynx, ovarian, and colon | Chemotherapy is given to 11 patients. | During Ramadan, patients received chemotherapy. |
Fasting is a safe and well‐tolerated practice. |
| Safdie et al. | Breast, prostate, ovarian, uterine, non‐small cell lung, and esophagus | Ten patients who are undergoing chemotherapy | Fasting was required before (48–140 hours) and/or after (5–56 hour) treatment. |
Fasting is safe and well tolerated. Fasting has been linked to decreased tiredness, weakness, and gastrointestinal side effects. |
Clinical trials of cancer using intermittent fasting
| Clinical trial | Study title | Trial phase/total participants | Status | Primary outcome measure | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NCT05023967 | Metformin and Nightly Fasting in Women with Early Breast Cancer | Phase 2/120 | Not yet recruiting |
Change in pre‐post treatment Ki67 labeling index in invasive breast cancer (IBC) or ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) (in the absence of IBC) Difference in post‐treatment adjacent DCIS (in the presence of IBC), if present, or intraepithelial neoplasia Ki67 between arms Frequency of occurrence of dose‐limiting toxicity |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: Female Study start: April 1, 2022 Study completion: November 30, 2024 |
| NCT04626843 | Intermittent Fasting and CLL/SLL | Phase 1/20 | Recruiting |
Change in lymphocyte, quality of life, inflammation, metabolic profiles, autophagy status Immune cell gene expression profiles |
Age: 19–85 years Gender: All Study start: February 3, 2021 Study completion: December 2021 |
| NCT04560439 | Diabetes Prevention Program (METFIT) in Reducing Insulin Resistance in Stage I‐III Breast Cancer Survivors | NA/25 | Recruiting |
Fidelity Retention Change in insulin resistance (IR) |
Age: 18–75 years Gender: Female Study start: June 15, 2022 Study completion: June 15, 2023 |
| NCT02710721 | Fasting and Nutritional Therapy in Patients with Advanced Metastatic Prostate Cancer | NA/60 | Active, not recruiting |
FACT‐P/‐Taxane/−A sum score HADS |
Age: 25–89 years Gender: Male Study start: April 2016 Study completion: December 2021 |
| NCT05114798 | Time‐restricted Eating Versus Daily Continuous Calorie Restriction on Body Weight and Colorectal Cancer Risk Markers | NA/255 | Not yet recruiting |
Weight change (% kg) |
Age: 25–89 years Gender: All Study start: April 2022 Study completion: September 2026 |
| NCT03523377 | Overnight Fasting After Completion of Therapy: The OnFACT Study | NA/40 | Recruiting |
Participation completion measure of glucose metabolism |
Age: 18 years and older Years Gender: All Study start: April 27, 2018 Study completion: April 2024 |
| NCT04387084 | Short‐term Fasting Prior to PD‐1/PD‐L1 Inhibitor Therapy for of Advanced or Metastatic Skin malignancy | Phase 1 /16 | Recruiting |
Percentage of patients completely adhering to three cycles of short‐term fasting (STF) (9 days of fasting) Percentage of patients who develop unacceptable fasting‐related toxicity Percentage of patients who can partially adhere to three cycles of STF (9 days of fasting) Incidence of acceptable fasting related toxicity |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: All Study start: August 12, 2020 Study Completion: August 12, 2023 |
| NCT02286167 | Glioma Modified Atkins‐based Diet in Patients with Glioblastoma | NA/25 | Completed |
Feasibility of intermittent modified Atkins diet in patients with GBM assessed by percent of patients able to remain on a diet and achieve nutritional goals Biologic activity measured by pre‐and post‐study cerebral glutamate and glutamine concentrations assessed by MRS. Tolerability assessed by percent of patients who have an adverse reaction of any grade attributed to the diet of possible, probable, or definite Dietary activity |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: All Study start: November 2014 Study completion: July 12, 2019 |
| NCT03151161 | Intermittent and Maintenance of Icotinib in Combination with Pemetrexed/Carboplatin Compared With Icotinib Single Drug in IIIb/IV Non‐Small Cell Lung Cancer With Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (EGFR) Mutation | Phase 2/118 | Unknown | Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors (RECIST) 1.1 |
Age: 18–75 years Gender: All Study Start: December 2015 Study completion: May 2019 |
| NCT02066038 | Intermittent and Maintenance of Erlotinib in Combination With Pemetrexed/Carboplatin in IIIb/IV Non Small Cell Lung Cancer With Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (EGFR) Mutation | Phase 2/60 | Unknown | Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors (RECIST) 1.1 |
Age: 18–75 years Gender: All Study Start: January 2014 Study completion: March 2016 |
| NCT04691999 | The Effect of Intermittent Fasting on Body Composition in Women With Breast Cancer | NA/0 | Withdrawn |
Adherence to the intermittent fasting program Change in body fat |
Age: 20–70 years Gender: Female Study start: December 2, 2021 Study completion: August 2023 |
| NCT04288336 | Daily, Long‐Term Intermittent Fasting for the Prevention of PSA‐Recurrence in Patients with Localized Prostate Cancer After Radical Prostatectomy | Early Phase 1/25 | Recruiting |
Adherence to the daily intermittent fasting regimen Prostate specific antigen (PSA) kinetics and/or doubling time |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: Male Study start: January 8, 2020 Study completion: June 1, 2022 |
| NCT03162289 | Intermittent Fasting Accompanying Chemotherapy in Gynecological Cancers | NA/150 | Recruiting |
FACT‐G Complete remissions Millar Payne classification |
Age: 18–75 years Gender: Female Study start: May 10, 2017 Study completion: June 10, 2022 |
| NCT05083416 | Effect of Prolonged Nightly Fasting on Immunotherapy Outcomes in HNSCC ‐ Role of Gut Microbiome | NA/52 | Recruiting |
Rates of prolonged nightly fasting (PNF) compliance Change in gut microbiome and microbial metabolites |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: All Study start: September 28, 2021 Study completion: August 2022 |
| NCT04708860 | Feasibility of Fasting & Exercise in Pts With HR+ MBC | NA/30 | Recruiting |
Rate of enrollment Rate of adherence to prolonged overnight fasting (POF) intervention goals Rate of adherence to exercise intervention goals |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: Female Study start: January 15, 2021 Study completion: July 31, 2023 |
| NCT04557540 | Weight Loss Interventions for Black Adults of Faith | NA/60 | Recruiting |
Obesity‐related malignant neoplasm Change in body weight, body composition, height, heart rate, blood pressure, waist circumference, hip circumference |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: All Study start: August 25, 2020 Study completion: September 15, 2023 |
| NCT04330339 | Prolonged Nightly Fasting in Breast Cancer Survivors | NA/40 | Active, not recruiting |
Baseline assessment (measurements of weight, height, quality of life, fatigue, mood, levels of physical activity, and blood markers) prior to the intervention and after completion of 12 week intervention |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: female Study start: July 24,2020 Study completion: August 31, 2021 |
| NCT04345978 | Effects of Fasting Strategies on Postoperative Recovery and Long‐term Prognosis in Patients with Colorectal Cancer | NA/2400 | Active, not recruiting |
Disease free survival |
Age: 20–70 years Gender: All Study start: January 1,2020 Study completion: September 30,2023 |
| NCT04461938 | Characterization of Metabolic Changes in the Glioma Tumor Tissue Induced by Transient Fasting (ERGO3) | NA/15 | Recruiting |
Changes in metabolism‐induction of ketosis General metabolic change Immunological change Alterations in electric brain activity |
Age: 18 years and older Gender: All Study start: August 19, 2020 Study completion: March 2022 |
| NCT03700437 | Fasting‐mimicking Diet With Chemo‐immunotherapy in Non‐small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) | NA/10 | Recruiting |
Proportion of the patients who can finish the FMD without serious adverse events |
Age: 18–70 years Gender: All Study start: November 2, 2018 Study completion: December 2024 |