Nanda Perdana1, Christof Holzer1, Carsten Rockstuhl1,2. 1. Institute of Theoretical Solid State Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. 2. Institute of Nanotechnology, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76021 Karlsruhe, Germany.
Abstract
The modeling of functional photonic devices that rely on molecular materials continues to be a major contemporary challenge. It is a challenge because, in the Maxwell equations, which govern the light-matter interaction, material properties are primarily introduced on phenomenological grounds and not from first principles. To overcome such limitations, we outline a multiscale modeling approach that bridges multiple length scales. We can predict with our approach the optical response of a photonic device that exploits in its design molecular materials whose properties were determined using time-dependent density functional theory. The specifically considered device is a broadband perfect absorber that uses in part a thin film comprising gold molecules made from 144 atoms. Our methodology discloses various chemical and physical effects that define such a device's response. Our methodology is versatile, and a larger number of applications will profit from this development.
The modeling of functional photonic devices that rely on molecular materials continues to be a major contemporary challenge. It is a challenge because, in the Maxwell equations, which govern the light-matter interaction, material properties are primarily introduced on phenomenological grounds and not from first principles. To overcome such limitations, we outline a multiscale modeling approach that bridges multiple length scales. We can predict with our approach the optical response of a photonic device that exploits in its design molecular materials whose properties were determined using time-dependent density functional theory. The specifically considered device is a broadband perfect absorber that uses in part a thin film comprising gold molecules made from 144 atoms. Our methodology discloses various chemical and physical effects that define such a device's response. Our methodology is versatile, and a larger number of applications will profit from this development.
Nanotechnology
links atomic constituents to macroscopic applications
and devices. While nanotechnological systems require a quantum mechanical
description to capture their properties, classical and continuum descriptions
are required when considering the devices at the macroscopic scale.
The development of a scale-bridging computational methodology to predict
the properties of such systems is a prime scientific challenge. The
developments are worth spending and motivated by many promising devices
applicable to selected needs.Generally, scale-bridging computational
methods have been developed
in multiple application areas. One approach is simultaneously solving
quantum mechanics (QM) and electromagnetic (EM) equations to study
electronic devices, known as the QM/EM method.[1] The quantum part explains the device’s electronic structure,
and the classical electrodynamic part describes the electrodynamic
interaction between the device and its background. Molecular dynamics
(MD) has been used to understand the mechanics of molecules at the
atomic scale.[2] Using the outcomes from
MD simulations, multiscale physics problems in objects such as nanopores
can be bridged to an object on a larger scale,[3,4] or
when studying nucleation processes of metals and colloids.[5] The finite-element method can also be used to
study microstructures like grains[6] or analyze
the linear elastodynamics properties of objects across different scales.[7]In the current work, we are interested
in optical devices based
on metallic nanoparticles as the molecular building blocks. Nanoparticles
constitute a versatile platform where sizes, shapes, and materials
can be deterministically tailored to create and enhance selected applications.
For example, controlling protein orientations[8] and measuring gravity has been implemented using quantum levitated
nanoparticles.[9] Sensing a few kinds of
small bio-objects is now possible thanks to the strong and narrow
optical resonances of the nanoparticles at desired frequencies.[10−13] A metal nanoparticle coupled to a quantum emitter can emit single
photons at a high repetition rate.[14]The system we are interested in utilizes metal nanoparticles as
a core in a thin film device that perfectly absorbs light in an extended
spectral region. Experimentally, synthesizing the nanoparticles is
possible through self-assembly of the nanoparticles,[15] which has been reported for perfect absorber application.[16] These perfect broadband absorbers shall have
an operating frequency between the near-infrared and the UV region.[17−19] The requirement for their functionality is simple: Absorb as much
as possible light in a predefined spectral range. While many variations
can be considered, a generic perfect absorber consists of three layers.
At the bottom, there is a sufficiently thick metallic film that serves
as a ground plate. It reflects the light and prevents transmission
through the thin film stack. The top layer contains lossy metallic
nanoparticles. Here, the light shall be predominantly absorbed where
it can be harvested for selected applications. Finally, the central
layer, frequently called the spacer layer, is a dielectric layer with
a carefully chosen thickness.[20] The dispersive
response of the system allows achieving this effect spectrally broadband.[21] But of course, this requires dedicated adjustments
of all degrees of freedom, such as size, shape, and material of individual
nanoparticles, the density of the nanoparticles in the top layer,
and the material and the thickness of the spacer layers, not to mention
the polarization and the angle of incidence of the incoming light.For a deterministic design, we need to implement a methodology
that reliably predicts the macroscopic response of such systems from
an accurate description of its constituents. As the nanoparticles
can be extremely tiny, when fabricated as clusters,[22−24] such description
shall start from a quantum-chemical description of the metallic molecules.
Then, the outcome from such analysis is fueled into an optical simulation
of the device that allows its optimization. Such scale-bridging simulation
has not yet been reported and is developed in this work.The
perfect absorber contains metallic nanoparticles in the form
of what we call metallic molecules. The considered metallic molecules
consist of 144 gold atoms (Au144).[25,26] However, this should merely be taken as an example. Au144 is a stable gold structure, and it corresponds to the bulk gold
nanoparticles that would have been considered in a pure classical
simulation.The quantum mechanical description can be based
on time-dependent
density functional theory (TDDFT), density functional tight binding,
empirical tight-binding, or fragment molecular-orbital. In our case,
TDDFT is already proven to be able to analyze the plasmon response
from resonant excitation of a superposition of single-electron transitions
of a molecule.[27] Afterward, we use the
notion of a T-matrix[28] to bridge the calculation
from the quantum mechanical-based simulation to the classical Maxwell
equation-based simulations if we start to look at a cluster of metal
molecules in a thin film. The T-matrix is a matrix that expresses
the electromagnetic response of a scatterer and/or a system of scatterers
in a suitable algebraic language.With the purpose to bridge
multiple length scales, we first consider
a larger number of metallic molecules and let them form a cluster,
i.e., an assembly of metallic nanoparticles. The cluster is sufficiently
large to capture the statistical details of the nanoparticle arrangement
while sufficiently small so that we can still apply a full-wave solution
of Maxwell’s equations to capture its response. The optical
properties of such a cluster are expressed in terms of a global T-matrix.Afterward, we compute the optical response from a periodic and
dense arrangement of such a cluster of nanoparticles. We do so by
solving the self-consistent scattering problem where the renormalization
of the T-matrix, thanks to the interaction with all clusters forming
the film, is considered. To bridge a further length scale and neglect
the very fine details of the layer containing the metallic molecules,
we invert the reflection and transmission coefficients from the thin
film using a methodology from the field of metamaterials to assign
an effective permittivity to it.Using this effective property,
we can use a thin film transfer
matrix technique to study the optical response from the considered
layer stacks. While suitably adjusting the individual layer thicknesses,
we can maximize the objective function. Following the motivation,
we consider exemplarily the absorption of light in an extended spectral
region as the objective function.With this approach, we describe
a flexible and versatile methodology
for the multiscale modeling of optical devices made from constituents
that require a quantum mechanical treatment. Objects with smaller
length scales, like molecules, are studied in detail, and only their
primary optical response is considered to represent these objects
at the following larger length scale. We stress that material properties
are not introduced here on phenomenological grounds. In contrast,
we consider materials explicitly using quantum mechanical methods.
As a result, our work can be applied to a multitude of further considerations.
Despite this, some approximations need to be done to describe the
system as reliable and to predict macroscopic properties.The
article is structured into an extended Methods section, where
we describe the considered methods used in our workflow, and a Results
and Discussion section, where we present and discuss the actual results
when considering a specific structure.
Methods
Quantum Simulations
Polarizabilities
from Linear Response DFT
The frequency-dependent
electronic polarizability tensor needed to construct the T-matrix for the
individual metallic molecule is obtained from a first-principles approach.
Using linear-response time-dependent density functional theory (LR-TDDFT),
the frequency-dependent response equation can be formulated as a coupled-perturbed
Kohn–Sham (CPKS) for each Cartesian component γ as equation[29−31]with
the 2 × 2 supermatricesXγ and Yγ in eq are the solution vectors
needed to obtain the desired polarizability. Furthermore, Pγ and Qγ collect the integrals describing the external perturbation. In the
case of (frequency-dependent) dipole polarizabilities, these are the
electric dipole integrals given bywhere ϕκ are the orbital basis
functions and Cκ and Cλ are the atomic-orbital to
molecular-orbital transformation coefficients obtained from solving
the Kohn–Sham equations for the ground state. Note that the
integrals ⟨ϕκ | μγ | ϕλ⟩ are equivalent with those used
to calculate the ground state electric dipole moment for the three
Cartesian components γ ∈ {x, y, z}. Within the adiabatic approximation
and further assuming that the wavelength of the perturbation is significantly
longer than the size of the nanostructures investigated in this work,
the coupling matrices in eq are given asϵ and ϵ in eq refer
to the occupied and virtual Kohn–Sham orbital energies respectively, v is a standard Coulomb integral describing electron repulsionand fXC is the second derivative of the exchange-correlation
(XC) energywhere EXC is the exchange-correlation energy expression within the
chosen density functional approximation. vCOSMO is the potential energy contribution
of the implicit conductor-like screening model (COSMO) used to incorporate
effects of the chemical surrounding.[32,33] The COSMO
term is convenient, as it is far more efficient to describe the surrounding
by a polarizable medium, modeled by its dielectric function and the
refractive index, instead of adding further atomistic regions to the ab initio DFT region. For a detailed discussion of COSMO,
we refer the reader to ref (32). Finally, the frequency-dependent dipole polarizability
αeγγ′(ω) tensor is obtained from the solution vectors {Xγ(ω), Yγ(ω)} of eq for
each Cartesian component γ, and the integrals {Pγ′, Qγ′} for each Cartesian component γ′ by means
of the direct productTo obtain the polarizability tensor of a
molecule at a given complex frequency
ω, where the real part marks the absorption/emission frequency
and the imaginary part determines the line broadening, one CPKS equation
at eq needs to be solved
for each Cartesian direction. In total, for N frequencies
of interest, 3N CPKS equations need to be solved.
The outcome from the analysis is the polarizability tensor that expresses how the
molecular object,
i.e., an individual metallic molecule, responds to an external electromagnetic
field. We have considered here only the electric dipole approximation.
Such electric dipole approximation is, nevertheless, entirely sufficient
for the particles at stake. Also, while outlined for TD-DFT in this
work, recent developments have shown that also the GW–Bethe–Salpeter equation method can be applied to solve eq .[31,34]As outlined in the following subsections, it is straightforward
to convert the obtained electric dipole polarizabilities to T-matrices,
which can be injected into an appropriate framework to simulate properties
of larger ensembles of molecules, which are difficult to tackle using
DFT alone due to their size.
Classical Simulations
Using the polarizability of the
object calculated on quantum mechanical grounds, we can study the
optical response of the more macroscopic system on classical grounds.
A sequence of tools is applied to climb up the ladder of length scales.
First, we start from the classical description of the individual metallic
molecule. Next, we go to a cluster of such metallic molecules and
afterward to a thin film of such clusters to which we assign effective
properties. Finally, using such a homogeneous description, we study
and optimize the optical response of the perfect absorber by considering
reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance of a suitably chosen layer
stack.
Description of an Individual Metallic Molecule
At first,
we consider an isolated metallic molecule, i.e., the individual nanoparticle,
to be placed in homogeneous and isotropic media and illuminated by
a time-harmonic plane wave. We describe its optical action classically
using a T-matrix that we obtain from the quantum-chemical simulations
described above. For that, all we need to do is to convert the electric
dipolar polarizability to the T-matrix. Keeping in mind that our scattering
problem is formulated in spherical coordinates while the polarizability
has been calculated in a Cartesian, this is merely a basis change
written as[28]where is the
electric polarizability tensor in
dipole approximation obtained from the quantum-chemical simulation, c is the speed of light in the background medium, Z is the impedance of the background medium, and is the inverse of the
3 × 3 unitary
change of basis matrix that goes from the Cartesian to the spherical
basis, for the dipole term.When describing the light scattering
from a spatially confined object in the T-matrix approach, we expand
the incident and scattered electric field at a specific frequency
ω using vector spherical harmonics (VSH)where N(ω, r) are the electric
VSHs and M(ω, r) are the magnetic VSHs. The VSHs are chosen to ensure boundary
conditions for the different fields, expressed in the respective superscript
(1) and (3). The VSH expand the fields relative to the center of the
considered nanoparticle.The expansion comes with their respective
expansion coefficients
{a, b}
for the incident field and {p, q} for the scattered field. The index n characterizes the multipolar order of the expansion. n = 1 corresponds to the dipole term, n = 2 to the quadrupolar term etc. The sum of the field from all the
multipolar terms results in the full incident or scattered field.
When considering an isolated metallic molecule, we truncate the expansion
to the electric dipole term. However, higher-order multipole moments
are also considered when considering a larger number of metallic molecules
to form a cluster.Now, the T-matrix relates the incident field
to the scattered field
by a matrix equationIt implies
that a matrix multiplication can compute the scattered
field for a given incident field and a known object, characterized
by its T-matrix. From that, observable properties can be calculated.
Ensemble-averaged values that consider a possible random orientation
of the nanoparticles relative to the incident field are defined on
the base of a trace over the T-matrix. For example, the extinction
cross section is defined as[35]and the scattering cross
section can be defined aswhere is the wavenumber in the background
medium.
The absorption cross section is then the difference between extinction
and scattering cross section
Description of a Cluster
of Metallic Molecules
At this
stage, we can classically describe the interaction of light with an
individual metallic molecule placed in SiO2 as the background
medium. This was considered throughout this work as the host medium
in both the quantum-chemical and the classical Maxwell simulations.However, Au144 has a diameter of roughly 1.5 nm, which
is still extremely tiny. Nevertheless, at this length scale, the interaction
to the nearest neighbor matters, and we wish to quantify that interaction
precisely while being on the grounds of Maxwell’s equations.
We stress that we can no longer describe charge transfer effects among
adjacent metallic molecules. However, that is also safely supposed
to be negligible since neighboring metallic molecules have a greater
distance than the atomic spacing. Therefore, we consider a larger
number of clustered metallic molecules and describe their interaction
with light at the level of a Maxwell full-wave solver. The purpose
is to assign to that cluster a T-matrix that describes the interaction
of light with the cluster. In contrast to the discussion in the previous
sub-subsection, this global T-matrix captures the optical action from
many metallic molecules. Therefore, while a description in the electric
dipole approximation was sufficient for the individual metallic molecule,
we consider now an electric dipolar and a magnetic dipolar contribution
to the scattering response. Higher-order terms could have been considered
as well but are, indeed, negligible for our metallic cluster.In anticipation of the description at the next higher level of
aggregation, we pack the Au144 gold molecules into a cubical
unit cell. At this level, the metallic molecules are approximated
as individual spherical nanoparticles (please see Figure a). We will consider the Au144 molecular structure as a sphere. More detailed information
about the Au144 molecular structure is included in the
Supporting Information. Further, the cubical unit cell has a 12.5
nm side length and contains 500 metallic molecules that share a 0.7516
nm identical radius. This considered cluster is shown in Figure b. The volume filling
fraction of 45% ensures an optically strong response at the macroscopic
level. The random packing had been generated by considering periodic
boundary conditions with a dedicated code.[36] It implies that the object can cross the boundary of the cube. This
maintains at the next level of our description in that no artificial
gaps between adjacent unit cells are introduced when periodically
arranging the unit cells to form a continuous film. Then, T-matrices
for all Au144 nanoparticles positioned randomly inside
the box are combined to create a global T-matrix for the entire cluster.
Figure 1
(a) Au144 molecule that is constructed by the quantum
chemical method is approximated with a sphere in the Maxwell equation-type
computational method. (b) Cubical unit cell for a cluster containing
500 metallic molecules classically described as small metallic nanoparticles.
(a) Au144 molecule that is constructed by the quantum
chemical method is approximated with a sphere in the Maxwell equation-type
computational method. (b) Cubical unit cell for a cluster containing
500 metallic molecules classically described as small metallic nanoparticles.For this purpose, a Au144 nanoparticle
T-matrix obtained
through LR-TDDFT to represent the Au144 nanoparticle is
set in the center of the global coordinate, and the nanoparticle position
data are applied in the T-matrix combining process. The global T-matrix
of an ensemble of particle creation is possible by translation theory
of vector spherical harmonics.[37] Considering
nonchiral materials, the translation coefficient matrices are transformed to the global coordinate
as matrix and applied to eq for getting the global
T-matrixin which is defined as the matrix
including sub-T-matrices
of every scatterers in the cluster.In this way, the calculation
of the response is much more effective
and efficient than the quantum-mechanical simulation for multiple
objects.
Description of a Thin Film of Clusters of
Metallic Molecules
At this stage, we can classically describe
the interaction of light
with a cluster of metallic molecules placed in silica (SiO2) as the background medium. Now, we wish to describe the reflection
and transmission from a thin film of periodically arranged clusters
of metallic molecules at a next higher level of aggregation. Please
note that at this stage, an assumption enters the description that
shall be shortly discussed. Of course, the periodic arrangement of
identical clusters will not occur in reality. However, the individual
metallic molecules will mostly interact with their nearest neighbors.
They will not explicitly interact with particles that are much further
away. Therefore, the explicit arrangement on these longer scales will
not affect the response, and the periodic arrangement will have no
impact. A notable interaction across neighboring unit cells would
only be encountered if lattice resonances would have been expected.
However, they rather appear for lattices characterized by a period
comparable to the wavelength. When compared to these scales, we are
still having periods much smaller.To solve the reflection and
transmission from a thin film made from periodically arranged clusters,
we solve the multiple scattering problem again but consider now (a)
that all the particles are identical and (b) they are perfectly periodically
arranged. In this case, we utilize lattice summation techniques for
simulation multiscattering of an array of identical scatterers. Using
the integral representation of the VSH and the direct application
of Poisson’s formula, the scattered field from all lattice
points R at normal incidence is[37]where and k∥ is the tangential component of the incoming plane
wave. The infinite
lattice sums are partially evaluated in real space and partially in
reciprocal space to assure convergence.At this stage, we can
describe classically the reflection and transmission
from a slab containing the metallic molecules with a finite thickness.
The slab is illuminated by linearly polarized plane-wave propagating
in the +z direction and with an amplitude Ẽinc. The vectorial reflection (r) and transmission
coefficients (t) can be obtained by transforming the
scattered field in eq from the real space to the reciprocal space and using the definition
of the coefficients,Ẽsca, implies the vectorial amplitude
of the reflected field for the – index and the transmitted
field for the + index in reciprocal space if the incident field is
considered propagating along the positive z axis.
The reflected field comes from the superposition of scattered field
in the negative z axis, while the transmitted field
is generated in the positive z axis. The linear polarization
of the incident field, of course, is preserved for the reflected and
transmitted field. Alternatively, the reflection and transmission
coefficient also can be directly obtained from expansion coefficients
{a, b}
from the nanoparticle layer,[38] if its T-matrix
is known. Then, the reflectance (R) and transmittance
(T) for normal incidence can be stated toThe indices {s, c} in eq represent the substrate and cladding in order. The
incoming
wave travels in the substrate, and the cladding is defined as the
second layer parallel to the film. Finally, the absorptance (A) is defined as
Effective
Description of a Thin Film of Clusters of Metallic
Molecules
At this stage, we can describe classically the
reflection and transmission from a slab containing the metallic molecules
with a finite thickness. We aim to describe this material using an
effective dielectric function to advance toward the next length scale.
Using such an effective dielectric function, we can consider the material
in designing arbitrary functional devices. In our case, this is the
perfect broadband absorber. The huge advantage would be that we can
also change the thickness of the slab continuously in the design without
being required to consider always a unit cell with a suitable thickness.
Since the critical length scale is much smaller than the wavelength,
we can treat it as a metamaterial to which we assign effective properties.While considering reflection and transmission from a slab with
a given thickness, corresponding in our case to the size of the cubical
unit cell considered as the cluster, we can derive from the complex
reflection and transmission coefficients (r, t), the effective electric permittivity (ϵeff), and the effective magnetic permeability (μeff) for a normal linear-polarized plane-wave illumination assuming
an isotropic, homogeneous, local medium, without electromagnetic coupling
as[39,40]where parameters k and
ζ are
defined asandm is the
integer user-chosen branch order to ensure continuity of the wave
vector in the respective medium. The parameter J in eqs and 25 isIn our case, the substrate and the cladding are in vacuum medium,
so that [ϵ, ϵ, μ, μ] = 1. Therefore, we can treat the material
comprising Au144 metallic molecules as a homogeneous material
and consider it in the next level of our description.
Optimization
of the Actual Perfect Absorber
Finally,
a multilayer thin film system is studied to model a device. All materials
involved are described at the level of a dielectric function. The
Au144 cluster embedded into a SiO2 matrix is
deposited on top of a pure SiO2 spacer and gold mirror.
By assuming that the sum of reflectance (R), transmittance
(T), and absorptance (A) is always
unity, a classical thin film transfer matrix method[41] is used to calculate the absorptance of the thin film system.
Then, the area below the resulting absorption curve is determined
and normalized to get the most optimal thin film thickness to get
the best broadband absorption. We aim to find the optimal absorption
by varying the thickness of the thin film containing the metallic
molecules and the spacer layer (dnp, dspacer) by maximizing the objective function
over the area below the resulting absorption curveTaken all aspects
together, we have sketched above a computational approach to predict
an optimal broadband perfect absorber while starting from the consideration
of its constituents within a quantum-chemical description. It is a
true multiscale modeling since we start from the electronic details
of an individual metallic molecule and go up to a macroscopic device.
The thin film thickness may be in the order of 100 nm, but of course,
also thicker films could have been considered. This thickness was
chosen exemplary for that specific device, other values could be set
as well. In the next section, we present the results of the analysis.
Results and Discussion
Properties of an Individual Metallic Molecule
As outlined
in the previous section, using the T-matrix obtained from LR-TDDFT,
we apply eq to determine
the electric polarizability from a Au144 metallic molecule.
The results are shown in Figure . For the DFT part, we employed the PBE functional[42,43] together with the def2-TZVP basis set.[44] The def2-TZVP basis set is used in conjunction with an effective
core potential (ECP60MWB),[45] where 60 electrons
are placed inside the ECP. The ECP introduces scalar-relativistic
effects, which are, therefore, properly accounted for. Spin-orbit
interactions are neglected due to the vast computational effort that
would be needed to carry out fully relativistic calculations at the
given molecular sizes. Equation was solved using the efficient semi-numerical semiJK algorithm,[46] employing fine grids for the Coulomb potential
and a grid of size 4 for the exchange-correlation part.[47] For the simulations of Au144 embedded
in SiO2, a refractive index of 1.46 and an ϵ of 3.90
have been used to simulate the SiO2 surrounding. For the
cavity construction, a radius of r = 2.223 bohr was
used for Au. All calculations have been performed with a development
version of Turbomole V7.6.[48]
Figure 2
(a) Magnitude
of the electric dipolar polarizability of a Au144 nanoparticle
in air and SiO2. (b) Transition
density for the plasmonic peak of the Au144 generated from
the polarizabilities from 2.0 to 2.5 eV. An isovalue of 0.00015 a.u.
was used.
(a) Magnitude
of the electric dipolar polarizability of a Au144 nanoparticle
in air and SiO2. (b) Transition
density for the plasmonic peak of the Au144 generated from
the polarizabilities from 2.0 to 2.5 eV. An isovalue of 0.00015 a.u.
was used.The polarizability curve displayed
in Figure a exhibits
several maxima, corresponding
to peaks in light absorption at the frequencies where they occur.
When embedded into a matrix, a significant shift of the peaks
is observed. Especially the peaks found at λ = 460 nm and λ
= 565 nm are shifted to a longer wavelength compared to vacuum/air.
Also, a distinct increase in the polarizability is observed if the nanoparticle is embedded in the matrix.The polarizability obtained from
DFT is closely connected to standard
excited-state TD-DFT. Therefore, similarly, peaks can be analyzed
by calculating a transition-density like property. This is done by
summing the eigenvectors described in eq and weighting them by the trace of the polarizability
tensor. The latter is directly related to the oscillator strength
used in standard TD-DFT excited state spectra. The corresponding transition
density for the peak starting at above 400 nm in Figure a is shown in Figure b. The resulting transition
density outlines the average charge movement away from the gold atoms
in this band. For bulk gold, the corresponding band at 2.2 eV exhibits
a distinct plasmonic character, and the charge movement in Figure b hints at this excitation
also having a significant plasmonic character already. This is in
agreement with general findings for small noble metal clusters.[49]
Properties of a Cluster of Metallic Molecules
As the
next target of this study is an ab initio based multiscale
modeling approach, we now focus on the effects of the interaction
of multiple neighboring Au144 nanoparticles on the optical
response. For this purpose, we compare the classically calculated
absorption cross section of a Au144 nanoparticle to a cluster
comprising a larger number of the nanoparticles. The combined T-matrix
for a given number of nanoparticles is obtained and subsequently used
to calculate the absorption cross section of the cluster of nanoparticles
through eqs –16. It turns out that the interaction between the
nanoparticles does not induce new resonance peaks in the optical absorption
spectrum, as shown in Figure . The absorption curves are dominated by the usual scaling
in the Rayleigh regime, but subtle underlying features are still affected.
Figure 3
Absorption
cross-section from a single Au144 nanoparticle
(left y axis) and a cluster comprising 101 Au144 nanoparticles (right y axis).
Absorption
cross-section from a single Au144 nanoparticle
(left y axis) and a cluster comprising 101 Au144 nanoparticles (right y axis).Instead, the magnitude of absorption is enhanced. This is
the expected
effect for gold nanoparticles, which by themselves are only weakly
interacting with each other through van der Waals forces. Moreover,
since the particles are so small that scattering is negligible, a
possible radiative interaction among the metallic molecules is absent.
In that sense, the results are consistent with physical expectations.
Nevertheless, the effect of interaction is fully considered and accommodated
in our approach.
Properties of a Thin Film of Clusters of
Metallic Molecules
Next, we consider a periodic arrangement
of nanoparticle clusters
when assembled into a thin film. We choose air as the surrounding
material when considering reflection and transmission from this thin
film. The thickness of the layer is the actual domain side length
of the cubical cluster of the metallic molecules. We choose here a
side length of dnp = 13.9 nm. We also
want to study the optical response when considering thin films with
different thicknesses. For this purpose, we consider layers comprising
a different number of clusters of metallic molecules as previously
considered. Figure shows reflectance, transmittance, and absorptance when considering
thin films made from 1, 2, or 4 layers, respectively. The thin films
have a thickness of L ≈ {13.9,27.8,55.7} nm,
respectively. According to Figure , the absorptance is getting stronger, and the transmittance
becomes weaker as the number of layer stacks increases as expected.
Also, all three quantities are strongly affected in the spectral region
for which the metallic molecules sustain localized plasmon interaction
as mentioned before, i.e., most notably in the spectral region between
400 and 600 nm. Reflectance and transmittance decrease while absorptance
enhances.
Figure 4
(a) Reflectance, (b) transmittance, and (c) absorptance for Au144 nanoparticle thin film stacks depending on the thickness.
Please note that the thickness corresponds to an integer multiply
of the thickness of the previously considered cluster of metallic
molecules.
(a) Reflectance, (b) transmittance, and (c) absorptance for Au144 nanoparticle thin film stacks depending on the thickness.
Please note that the thickness corresponds to an integer multiply
of the thickness of the previously considered cluster of metallic
molecules.Using the reflection and transmission
coefficient data of the nanoparticle
layer, the effective relative electric permittivity of the material
made from densely packed Au144 nanoparticles is calculated. Figure shows the real and
imaginary parts of the retrieved effective permittivity. The real
part of the permittivity is high around λ > 600 nm and the
imaginary
part of the permittivity has a roughly similar feature to the polarizability
curve in Figure a.
Eventually, the excitation of localized plasmon polaritons in the
metallic molecule translates to a Lorentzian resonance in the effective
permittivity. The spectral position is best identified from the peaks
in the imaginary part. The real part shows the respective dispersion.
It attains high values at wavelengths longer than the resonance wavelength,
which agrees with common expectations of a Lorentz oscillator. We
carefully checked that the number of layer stacks does not change
the relative permittivity. We can conclude from this observation that
the material can nicely be described at the effective level using
a dielectric function as retrieved. A nearly identical dispersion
of the effective permittivity that is independent of the thickness
of the considered thin film is also an indication that the interface
effect between air and the nanoparticle layer has a vanishing impact
on the response in these optical considerations. Therefore, the nanoparticle
thin film layer is considered homogeneous.
Figure 5
Real and imaginary parts
of the effective relative electric permittivity
of the Au144 nanoparticles in SiO matrix thin film stacks.
Real and imaginary parts
of the effective relative electric permittivity
of the Au144 nanoparticles in SiO matrix thin film stacks.
Properties of the Broadband Perfect Absorber
Lastly,
we regard a multilayer thin film system to create a broadband perfect
absorber. The thin film system, illustrated in Figure , consists of a layer comprising the Au144 metallic molecules, considered in the optical simulations
as nanoparticles, embedded into a SiO2 matrix, a SiO2 spacer layer, and a semi-infinite gold mirror.
Figure 6
Scheme of the
considered multilayer thin film system.
Scheme of the
considered multilayer thin film system.Realizing such a geometry is entirely feasible with existing technologies.
The metallic nanoparticles have to be co-deposited with the dielectric
host to make the nanoparticles act as a functional plasmonic material.
For example, Vahl et al.[50] have demonstrated
the fabrication of a thin film containing alloyed metallic nanoparticles
in a SiO2 matrix. The metallic nanoparticles were deposited
via a Haberland-type gas aggregation cluster source, and the SiO2 was deposited through an RF sputtering method. Both of these
materials are continuously deposited, and the SiO2 as a
host material builds up as a film with time passing. Details of the
nanoparticles deposited with such techniques can be controlled quite
flexibly. For example, the filling fraction can be easily controlled
by the deposition rates, so that the nanoparticles can be made densely
or loosely packed in the dielectric matrix. Also, the deposited nanoparticles
do not have any specific spatial arrangement with respect to each
other, so the spherical nanoparticles approximation applies here.The specific thickness of the Au144 nanoparticle layer
and the spacer layer is going to be determined to have an optimal
broad and strong absorption from UV to visible light region, i.e.,
from 300 to 800 nm. While considering the material comprising the
metallic molecules at the effective level and relying on a transfer
matrix method to compute the optical response from a thin film stack,
the computations are extremely fast and efficient. With this approach,
the area of the absorption curve is obtained for each variation of
layer thicknesses within a feasible range, i.e. dnp = 0 – 100 nm and dspacer = 0 – 100 nm. To quantify the broadband absorptance, we integrate
it across the relevant spectral domain and normalize it to the absorptance
of a perfectly functioning device in the same spectral region. This
normalized integrated absorptance is hence a quantity between 0 and
1. The normalized integrated absorptance depending on the thickness
of the spacer and the thin film comprising the metallic molecules
is shown in Figure a. The figure clearly reveals an optimal absorptance for a system
made from dnp = 15 nm and dspacer = 39 nm. Figure b shows the optical response of the perfect absorber
comprising the optimized layer thicknesses. We see that the very high
absorption of visible light is key to broadband absorptance in general.
At infrared wavelengths, we predict that the overall response gets
weaker. This is not surprising considering the weaker plasmonic response
of the metallic molecules at these wavelengths.
Figure 7
(a) Absorption colormap
of variation of Au144 nanoparticle
thin films and dielectric spacer layer thicknesses. A blue ring points
to the optimal nanoparticle layer and spacer layer thickness. (b)
Reflectance, transmittance, and absorption curve at optimal thin film
layer thicknesses.
(a) Absorption colormap
of variation of Au144 nanoparticle
thin films and dielectric spacer layer thicknesses. A blue ring points
to the optimal nanoparticle layer and spacer layer thickness. (b)
Reflectance, transmittance, and absorption curve at optimal thin film
layer thicknesses.
Conclusions
We
have demonstrated the multiscale modeling of a broadband perfect
absorber made from Au144 molecules. It starts with a quantum-chemical
analysis of the gold molecules using TDDFT. This analysis provides
information on the electric dipole polarizabilities of the metallic
molecule that is converted to a T-matrix appropriate for classical
optical simulations. Next, a cluster of Au144 is generated
to describe the interaction of light between the metallic molecules.
Afterward, we periodically arrange these clusters to let them form
a thin film from which reflection and transmission are calculated.
Inverting these optical coefficients allows for homogenizing the thin
film and treating it in subsequent optical simulations as a homogeneous
material characterized by a dielectric function. Finally, a broadband
perfect absorber device is considered by stacking layers containing
metallic molecules, silica, and a semi-infinite gold mirror above
each other. Varying the thicknesses of the layers allows for finding
a configuration where the absorption is optimal within some predefined
spectral region.The suggested architecture has multiple advantages
with respect
to other devices designed for a similar purpose. For example, by exploiting
the multiple reflections in the thin film layers that lead to a vanishing
reflection due to destructive interference, the proposed broadband
absorber can be designed to be very thin. When compared to experimentally
fabricated metallic broadband absorbers with an equivalent configuration
and layer thicknesses,[17,51] the absorption curve is analogously
almost perfect across the entire visible part of the spectrum. Experimentally,
it is also possible to fabricate the ultrathin metallic film on a
large scale and in a self-assembly manner, which ultimately implies
also rather low costs. This is in contrast to alternative approaches
that rely on top-down nanofabrication techniques. Combining all these
benefits suggests that more applications can profit from an accessible
functionality, well beyond those demonstrated in the current work.
For instance, small organic molecules can be considered for photovoltaic
devices[52] or chiral materials[53] can be studied on a macroscopical scale.We believe that our results can be used as a reference for future
design studies of ultrathin perfect absorbers. Compared to our results,
the absorption can be stronger at longer wavelengths by considering
nanoparticles other than Au144, such as tungsten,[54] to cover also the near infra-red absorption
spectrum. They could also be arranged denser to increase the interactions
between the nanoparticles. The bottom line is that with this methodology,
effects in the investigated and related systems occurring on chemical
or physical grounds can be simultaneously considered and accurately
modeled.
Authors: Wayne Lin; Thomas Insley; Marcus D Tuttle; Lingyang Zhu; Deborah A Berthold; Petr Král; Chad M Rienstra; Catherine J Murphy Journal: J Phys Chem C Nanomater Interfaces Date: 2015-08-18 Impact factor: 4.126