| Literature DB >> 35706438 |
Aishwarya Raman1, Manish Uprety1, Maria Jose Calero2, Maria Resah B Villanueva3, Narges Joshaghani4, Nicole Villa1, Omar Badla5, Raman Goit1, Samia E Saddik6, Sarah N Dawood7, Ahmad M Rabih1, Ahmad Mohammed3, Tharun Yadhav Selvamani5, Jihan Mostafa1.
Abstract
In brain arteriovenous malformations (AVMs), there is mismatched communication between arteries and veins, causing a nidal bed between them. This systematic review explores whether a magnetic resonance angiogram (MRA) can be used as a diagnostic imaging tool instead of a digital subtraction angiogram (DSA). Utilizing PubMed, Cochrane, and Google Scholar, as well as the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines for article selection, a literature search was conducted over the past five years. Eleven studies were included, with a majority of the articles suggesting a potential for consideration. Arterial spin labeling (ASL) versus time-of-flight (TOF) scans was a comparison study, in addition to the study on pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling (pc-ASL), which proved its high sensitivity in comparison with DSA scans. Other studies included quantitative magnetic resonance angiogram (Q-MRA) measuring the blood flow and susceptibility weighted imaging (SWI) modality. Although promising, digital subtraction angiogram (DSA) scans have diagnostic superiority. In addition, articles discussed follow-up magnetic resonance angiogram (MRA) scans after surgery. Overall, digital subtraction angiogram remains the gold standard due to its superior spatial resolution and hemodynamic properties; these are the key limitations of magnetic resonance studies. MRA has demonstrated its ability to reproduce high-quality diagnostic images for arteriovenous malformation (AVM) angioarchitecture; however, coupled with their limitations, not many studies with large sample sizes over longer periods have been conducted, and we urge more research into it.Entities:
Keywords: 4d dsa; asl-mra; avm; brain avm; dsa; mra; swi; tof-mra
Year: 2022 PMID: 35706438 PMCID: PMC9187205 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.25803
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Figure 1PRISMA flow diagram detailing the study selection process
Description of the studies that met the inclusion criteria for this review
ASL: arterial spin labeling, 7T: 7-Tesla magnetic resonance scan, 3T: 3-Tesla magnetic resonance scan, SOS angle: stack-of-stars angle, MRA: magnetic resonance angiogram, TOF: time-of-flight scans, AVM: arteriovenous malformation, DSA: digital subtraction angiogram, SWI: susceptibility weighted imaging, Q-MRA: quantitative magnetic resonance angiogram, TT: time density time, pc-ASL: pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling
| Author | Purpose of the study | Study type | Sample size | Main findings |
| Cong et al. [ | Arterial spin labeling-based 4D MRA scan compared in 3T and 7T | Prospective | 14 | Demonstration of ASL-based 4D MRA in 7T scan with both Cartesian and SOS angle. Also, a comparison of 3T and 7T with regard to 4D MRA was made, suggestive of the superiority of 7T studies. |
| Arai et al. [ | Time-of-flight versus silent MRA scan | Retrospective | 29 | Comparative study between MRA TOF versus silent MRA for patients diagnosed with AVM. Silent MRA was very efficient in visualizing AVM nidus. Also, TOF-MRA was significantly low by 41.3% in comparison with the former based on Spetzler-Martin’s AVM grading. |
| Cuong et al. [ | MRI DSA in comparison with conventional DSA | Retrospective | 14 | MRI DSA, a noninvasive procedure in locating the AVM compared with traditional DSA, is relatively similar (100%) to the conventional scans. |
| Wu et al. [ | Comparison of SWI sequencing in MR studies with gold standard scan | Retrospective | 120 | In cases of unruptured AVM, it showed that DSA does not play a key role. However, SWI sequencing in MRA illustrated draining veins and other architecture of AVM (e.g., deep venous draining, ectasia in veins, varices of the veins, and associated aneurysms, which were 1, 0.93, 0.94, and 0.83, respectively). Also, 48.15% of silent intralesional microhemorrhages were detected by this MRA sequence. |
| Brunozzi et al. [ | Modality of quantitative MRA to diagnose AVM | Retrospective | 28 | Time density time on Q-MRA correlates with DSA scanning modalities. TT could be used in AVM flow rate as an inversely proportional factor, and more information on the characteristics of AVM, venous stenosis, and rupturing risk could be established by the technique. |
| Schubert et al. [ | Comparing pseudo-ASL scan with other MRA scans | Retrospective | 32 (8 AVM) | pc-ASL with radial acquisition 3D in comparison with other MRA sequences could have a potential for the characterization of AVM as their sensitivities and specificity are equal with the latter or, in some cases, even higher. |
| Sandoval-Garcia et al. [ | Development of DSA | Retrospective comparative study | 26 (8 AVM) | 2D DSA with concurrent use of 3D DSA for diagnosing AVM features; however, the vascular overlap was its major disadvantage. This is where 4D DSA overcomes such limitations and also helps in the reduction of contrast used for the procedure and the procedure time and thereby reduction in radiation time for the physician. |
| Lang et al. [ | Advancement of DSA and comparison with MRA studies | Retrospective | 26 | Comparing current 2D DSA and 3D DSA with 4D DSA in terms of multiple draining vessels, which the former fails to recognize, causing vascular overlap. Nidal size and blood vessel diameters are the other limitations. DSA versus MRA studies showcase how MRA fails in comprehending tiny blood vessels that are vital in AVM diagnosis. Ferromagnetic implants bring one of the restrictive factors of MRA scans. |
| Moon et al. [ | Arterial spin labeling with conventional DSA | Literature review | 1 | Silent MRA including the arterial spin labeling is the main focus of identifying AVM blood flow. Also mentions its advantages over TOF-MRA. This study concluded by saying that this scan, being a noninvasive one, could be used for AVM diagnosis given its high sensitivity in comparison with conventional DSA. |
| Chen et al. [ | DSA in comparison with MRA post-surgery | Retrospective | 20 | This study focuses on patients who have been scanned with time-resolved DSA post-surgery. This scan shows superior data in comparison with conventional MR studies in identifying the volume of the remnant nidus of AVM. |
| Finitsis et al. [ | Post-surgical use of SWI | Prospective | 26 | SWI as a follow-up scan demonstrates its high sensitivities of approximately 80% and specificity around the range of 88.9% to 95%. |
Figure 2Retrospective study on quantitative MRA imaging scan reporting the time density time (TT) and its subcategories in comparison to AVM hemodynamics
TT: time density time, AVM: arteriovenous malformation