Four aliphatic phenothiazine cations (promazinium, promethazinium, chlorpromazinium, and triflupromazinium) were each paired with docusate anions and three different NSAID anions (ibuprofen, salicylate, and naproxen) to form fifteen glassy materials and one solid. The compounds were prepared via the metathesis reaction between the corresponding phenothiazine hydrochloride salts and sodium docusate or sodium NSAID salts and were obtained as liquid co-crystals with various degrees of ionization. The self-diffusion coefficients of several derivatives in 0.06 M DMSO-d 6 solutions were determined using DOSY NMR spectroscopy. The influence of the size, shape of the compounds, and intermolecular forces has been investigated by using the four promazine and the four ibuprofen co-crystals. The ion pairs (or aggregates) were found to be maintained in six out of the seven compounds examined. All fifteen glassy compounds showed reversible glass transitions in the -25 to 10 °C range with the docusate derivatives exhibiting the highest thermal stability (T onset values being at least 40 °C higher than those of the corresponding phenothiazine hydrochlorides).
Four aliphatic phenothiazine cations (promazinium, promethazinium, chlorpromazinium, and triflupromazinium) were each paired with docusate anions and three different NSAID anions (ibuprofen, salicylate, and naproxen) to form fifteen glassy materials and one solid. The compounds were prepared via the metathesis reaction between the corresponding phenothiazine hydrochloride salts and sodium docusate or sodium NSAID salts and were obtained as liquid co-crystals with various degrees of ionization. The self-diffusion coefficients of several derivatives in 0.06 M DMSO-d 6 solutions were determined using DOSY NMR spectroscopy. The influence of the size, shape of the compounds, and intermolecular forces has been investigated by using the four promazine and the four ibuprofen co-crystals. The ion pairs (or aggregates) were found to be maintained in six out of the seven compounds examined. All fifteen glassy compounds showed reversible glass transitions in the -25 to 10 °C range with the docusate derivatives exhibiting the highest thermal stability (T onset values being at least 40 °C higher than those of the corresponding phenothiazine hydrochlorides).
Phenothiazine drugs,
thiazine-based drugs used in pharma since
1950s, are known to have multiple biological effects (e.g., anti-psychotic, antimalarial, antimicrobial, tranquilizers, anti-inflammatory,
anti-psychotropic, and antitumor)[1] with
the aliphatic derivatives (e.g., promazine, chlorpromazine,
triflupromazine, and promethazine) having a moderate biological activity
while the piperidine derivatives (e.g., thioridazine)
having a strong biological activity, and the piperazine derivatives
(e.g., trifluperazine and fluphenazine) having weak
biological activity (Table ).[1] As most pharmaceuticals, these
drugs are administered as solid-state inorganic salts (i.e., hydrochlorides), and they present all the solid-state disadvantages.[2−4] The existence of polymorphic structures (i.e.,
different crystalline structures with different or no biological activity)
is a major issue for the pharmaceutical industry as it can lead to
potential legal ramifications;[5] multiple
court cases addressed the polymorphic transformation of pharmaceuticals
showing that, in USA, many solid forms of pharmaceuticals are different
drugs altogether.[6] Research is currently
focused on minimizing and/or eliminating this issue; numerous directions
are investigated with the conversion of solid-state drugs into (a)
liquid-state salts (aka ionic liquids, ILs, or salts
that melt below 100 °C) and (b) co-crystals being two major approaches.[7] Conversion of pharmaceuticals into a liquid state
was proven by numerous researchers[8−12] as a viable route for eliminating the solid-state
disadvantages. For example, Hough et al. showed that Zantac (ranitidine
hydrochloride), a drug included in court cases due to its polymorphic
conversion, can readily convert into ranitidine docusate, a liquid
form of the ranitidine drug obtained by pairing the ranitidine cation
with the docusate anion.[13] Moreover, there
is also an increased interest in bringing these liquid-state pharmaceuticals
to market; for example, lidocaine etodolac is a dual-active liquid-state
drug that completed phase III clinical trials with randomized testing
being conducted on groups of up to 3000 patients.[14]
Table 1
Cation and Anion Precursors
Sulfonic acids:
very strong acids
(pKa ∼ −7); e.g., methanesulfonic
acid: pKa = −1.85; ** pKa of the conjugated acid.
Sulfonic acids:
very strong acids
(pKa ∼ −7); e.g., methanesulfonic
acid: pKa = −1.85; ** pKa of the conjugated acid.The ionic liquid strategy can be
applied to organic compounds that
contain ionizable groups; the most common groups used in ionic liquid
synthesis are Bronsted precursors such as carboxylic acids (R–CO2H) and carboxylates (R–CO2– M+) as anion sources and amines (1° R–NH2, 2° R2NH, or 3° R3N) and
quaternary ammonium salts (R4N+ aka QUATs) as
cation sources. Depending on the anion and cation sources used, two
types of liquid-state compounds can be obtained: (a) protic ionic
liquids (PILs—obtained either through an acid–base reaction
between a proton donor and a proton acceptor OR through
a metathesis reaction between a carboxylate salt and a hydrochloride
salt of an organic amine) and (b) aprotic ionic liquids (APILs—obtained
through a metathesis reaction between a carboxylate salt and a QUAT).
Although in the case of APILs, a liquid-state behavior is obtained
due to the electrostatic interaction between the cation and the anion,
in the case of PILs, the degree of ionization depends on if there
is a full proton transfer from the Bronsted acid to the Bronsted base
or not. Nuthakki et al.[15] suggested that
a ΔpKa [pKa(conjugated acid)—pKa(acid)]
of at least 4 is needed for a liquid-state behavior to be obtained.
However, a ΔpKa value of at least
7–8 is needed to form PILs with an ionization degree higher
than 99%. If the proton is shared between the anion and cation (i.e., through a N···H–OOC hydrogen
bonding rather than full proton transfer), the compounds are formed
as liquid-state co-crystals (Figure )—according to Rogers et al., just sharing the
hydrogen between the cation and anion can lead to a liquid-state behavior.[10,16] Furthermore, as in the case of solid-state co-crystals, the pharmaceutical
activity of the constituent active ingredients from liquid co-crystals
will not be affected while their physical properties (e.g., solubility) will be improved.[17,18]
Figure 1
(A) Fully ionized
PILs (amminium derivatives) vs (B) liquid co-crystal
PILs.
(A) Fully ionized
PILs (amminium derivatives) vs (B) liquid co-crystal
PILs.Phenothiazine drugs are sold as
hydrochloride salts. Therefore,
they are ideal cation precursors in the synthesis of dual-active PILs.
Currently,[19] there are only three reports
on liquid-state phenothiazine drugs (SciFinder search, “phenothiazine
ionic liquids”); in a first report from 2007, Rogers et al.[20] reported on the synthesis of two double-salt
ionic liquids where the anion is either the docusate or salicylate
anion while the cation is a 1:1 mixture of promethazine and ephedrine
cations held together through an intramolecular hydrogen bond. Second,
in 2010, Dumitriu et al.[21] synthesized
new liquid-state imidazolium-functionalized phenothiazine derivatives.
Finally, Oh et al.[22] used N-substituted
phenothiazines as pendant groups in polymeric ionic liquids. However,
there is no report on investigating the synthesis of liquid-state
dual-functional phenothiazine drugs. Because phenothiazine drugs do
not have an analgesic effect, they are administered together with
analgesics. For example, a combination of the prochlorperazine phenothiazine
drug and an analgesic is required for the target therapy.[23] Here, we explore the possibility of converting
aliphatic phenothiazine drugs into liquid-state dual-functional drugs
by combining aliphatic phenothiazine cations with various organic
anions such as docusate anions and NSAID carboxylates. The new compounds
would potentially aid in drug administration (i.e., single vs multiple administrations) while eliminating polymorphism.
Results
and Discussion
Synthesis
Four aliphatic phenothiazine
drugs, promazine
hydrochloride ([Pro]Cl), chlorpromazine hydrochloride ([CPro]Cl),
promethazine hydrochloride ([Prm]Cl), and triflupromazine hydrochloride
([FPro]Cl), were used as cation precursors (Table ) and were each reacted with sodium docusate
(Na[Doc]) and three NSAIDs in their carboxylate form (i.e., sodium ibuprofen, Na[Ibu]; sodium salicylate, Na[Sal]; and sodium
naproxen, Na[Nap]) as anion precursors (Table ) to potentially form dual functioning PILs
with improved properties. The anion precursors were chosen based on
the ΔpKa between the phenothiazine
hydrochloride salts and the anion-conjugated acids[24−26] while sodium
docusate was chosen due to its known properties as a transdermal penetration
enhancer and its ability to form liquid-state compounds when paired
with various cations. The anion/cation molar ratio was kept the same
as in the commercially available phenothiazine hydrochloride salts,
allowing us to hypothesize that the biological properties of the cations
will remain unaffected.Sixteen new compounds were synthesized
through a metathesis reaction between the cation (phenothiazine hydrochlorides)
and anion precursors (sodium docusate or NSAID carboxylates) (Figure ) as follows: a mixture
of equimolar amounts of anion and cation precursors in acetone was
stirred for 24 h at room temperature. The inorganic byproduct formed
(NaCl) was filtered through a 0.2 μm syringe filter, and the
removal of volatiles via rotary evaporation allowed the formation
of fifteen highly viscous compounds and a solid ([Prm][Sal]) in high
yields (>89%) and purity (Table S1, Supporting Information). All the obtained compounds were characterized
using Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) and nuclear magnetic resonance
spectroscopy [one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) NMR].
Figure 2
Formation
of ILs with docusate anions and aliphatic phenothiazine
drugs.
Formation
of ILs with docusate anions and aliphatic phenothiazine
drugs.
FT-IR Spectroscopy
FT-IR spectra ranging between 650
and 3800 cm–1 (resolution of 1 cm–1) were obtained for neat samples using a Perkin-Elmer attenuated
total reflection (ATR)-IR Instrument. These spectra revealed that
the position of the carboxylate stretches from the anions (labeled
A in sodium salts and A′ in phenothiazine derivatives, Figure A1,A2) is shifted
from ∼1550 cm–1 in sodium salts to ∼1730
cm–1 in the phenothiazine derivatives. For example,
in the case of ibuprofen derivatives, the carboxylate stretch A appears
at 1545 cm–1 in Na[Ibu], and it is shifted to 1730
cm–1 in [Pro][Ibu] and [CPro][Ibu] (Figure B1,B2), to 1708 cm–1 in [Prm][Ibu] (Figure B3), and to 1715 cm–1 in [FPro][Ibu] (Figure B4), these wavenumbers
being similar to the carbonyl stretch from ibuprofen free acid (i.e., H[Ibu], C=O at 1696 cm–1).
Moreover, the C–O stretch (labeled B in sodium salts and B′
in phenothiazine derivatives Figure A1, A2) is shifted from ∼1412 cm–1 in Na[Ibu] to 1448 cm–1 in [Pro][Ibu] and [CPro][Ibu],
to 1462 cm–1 in [Prm][Ibu], and to 1456 cm–1 in [FPro][Ibu] (Figure B1–B4). Moreover, the N–H stretch from the cation
present in all the phenothiazine hydrochlorides between 2300 and 2600
cm–1 seems to also be present in the synthesized
compounds but with a lower intensity, further confirming the sharing
of a hydrogen between the cation and anion (Figure S1, Supporting Information). The IR results can be
explained by a decrease in the electron density around the carbonyl
group from ibuprofen anions due to a decrease in the degree of ionization
in the synthesized compounds. Similar results were observed for all
the phenothiazine compounds synthesized (the full FT-IR spectra are
shown in Figures S2–S5, Supporting Information). These observations are consistent with a “liquid co-crystal”
behavior of all the synthesized compounds, where a hydrogen is shared
between the cation and the anion (refer to Figure A2).
Figure 3
FT-IR spectra: carboxylate stretches in phenothiazine
hydrochlorides
and phenothiazine ILs; [Pro][Ibu], [CPro][Ibu], [Prm][Ibu], and [FPro][Ibu].
FT-IR spectra: carboxylate stretches in phenothiazine
hydrochlorides
and phenothiazine ILs; [Pro][Ibu], [CPro][Ibu], [Prm][Ibu], and [FPro][Ibu].
NMR Spectroscopy
The purity and
formation of the compounds
in a 1:1 stoichiometry were determined using NMR spectroscopy (purity:
Table S1, Supporting Information; full
NMR spectra: Figures S6–S21, Supporting Information). Furthermore, evidence of the co-crystal behavior
of the synthesized compounds was seen through 1D and 2D NMR characterization.
NMR spectra of 0.06 M DMSO-d6 solutions
were recorded using a Bruker 500 MHz spectrometer at 25 °C. NMR
samples were prepared as follows: a pre-weighted amount of the compound
was dissolved in 0.75 mL of DMSO-d6 to
obtain solutions of 0.06 M concentration. To ensure complete solvation
of each compound, the samples were sonicated for 5 min before spectrum
collection.
1H-NMR Spectroscopy: Anion Comparison
Due
to their vicinity to the most basic site from the cation precursor,
the influence of the anion on the chemical shifts of the methyl and
methylene groups from [Pro], [CPro], and [FPro] derivatives (Figure A1) and on the chemical
shifts of the methyl and methine groups from [Prm] derivatives (Figure A2) was investigated. Figure B1 shows the stacked
spectra for [Pro] derivatives. The methyl groups (highlighted in red)
show as one singlet at 2.67 ppm in [Pro]Cl which is shifted downfield
to 2.73 ppm in [Pro][Doc] and at 2.67 ppm in [Pro][Sal] and is shifted
upfield to 2.29 ppm in [Pro][Ibu] and to 2.11 ppm in [Pro][Nap]. Similarly,
the methylene group (highlighted in blue) shows as a triplet at 3.96
ppm in [Pro]Cl, has a similar chemical shift of 3.95 ppm in [Pro][Doc],
and is slightly shifted downfield to 4.01 ppm in [Pro][Sal] and slightly
shifted upfield to 3.91 ppm in [Pro][Ibu] and to 3.88 ppm in [Pro][Nap].
Similar trends were observed for the [CPro] and [FPro] derivatives;
the chemical shifts differences for these compounds are shown in Table and the corresponding
stacked 1H NMR spectra are presented in Figures S22 and
S23 in Supporting Information.
Figure 4
Structures
for [Pro], [CPro], [FPro] (A1), and [Prm] (A2) cations
and stacked 1H NMR spectra for [Pro] (B1) and [Prm] (B2)
derivatives.
Table 2
Chemical Shift Values
for Methyl,
Methylene, and Methine Peaks Present in Promazine, Chlorpromazine,
Triflupromazine, and Promethazine Compounds
1H NMR shifts (ppm) for methyl, CH3, groups in [Pro], [CPro], [Prm] and [FPro] derivatives
[Cl]
[Doc]
[Ibu]
[Sal]
[Nap]
[Pro]
2.67
2.73
2.29
2.67
2.10
[CPro]
2.68
2.73
2.20
2.64
2.11
[Prm]
2.73
2.78
2.21
2.59
2.22
[FPro]
2.67
2.73
2.13
2.64
2.10
1H NMR
shifts (ppm) for methylene, CH2, groups in [Pro], [CPro],
and [FPro] derivatives
[Cl]
[Doc]
[Ibu]
[Sal]
[Nap]
[Pro]
3.96
3.95
4.01
3.91
3.88
[CPro]
3.98
3.96
3.96
3.90
3.89
[FPro]
4.06
4.03
4.04
3.95
3.95
1H NMR shifts (ppm) for methine, CH,
groups in [Prm] derivatives
[Cl]
[Doc]
[Ibu]
[Sal]
[Nap]
[Prm]
3.53
3.60
3.53
2.92
2.93
Structures
for [Pro], [CPro], [FPro] (A1), and [Prm] (A2) cations
and stacked 1H NMR spectra for [Pro] (B1) and [Prm] (B2)
derivatives.Similarly, the methine
group from the [Prm] derivatives (highlighted
in blue, Figure B1)
shows as a multiplet (triplet of quartets) at 3.53 ppm in [Prm]Cl
and is slightly shifted downfield to 3.60 ppm in [Prm][Doc], has a
similar chemical shift of 3.53 ppm in [Prm][Sal], and is shifted upfield
to 2.92 ppm in [Prm][Ibu], and to 2.93 ppm in [Prm][Nap]. These results
further confirm the co-crystal nature of the synthesized compounds
with the hydrogen being shared between the cation and anion. Moreover,
[Pro][Ibu] and [Pro][Nap] show a higher electron density while [Pro][Doc]
and [Pro][Sal] show a lower electron density at the nitrogen site
when compared to [Pro]Cl, further confirming a lower degree of ionization
for [Pro][Ibu] and [Pro][Nap] and a higher degree of ionization for
[Pro][Doc] and [Pro][Sal].
1H NMR Spectroscopy: Cation Comparison
The
cation influence on the anion’s chemical shift differences
further confirmed the co-crystal formation. This was analyzed by comparing
the 1H NMR spectra of the synthesized phenothiazine compounds
with the spectra of the corresponding sodium salts and free acids
of the anion precursors. For example, the chemical shifts of the methine
and methyl groups adjacent to the carboxylate anion from [Pro][Ibu],
[Prm][Ibu], [CPro][Ibu], and [FPro][Ibu] were compared to the chemical
shifts of the same group from Na[Ibu] and ibuprofen free acid, H[Ibu]
(Figure ). A higher
influence was obtained on the methine group: this group (highlighted
in green in Figure ), a quartet at 3.25 ppm in Na[Ibu], was shifted downfield to 3.61
ppm in [Pro][Ibu], 3.56 ppm in [Prm][Ibu], 3.61 ppm in [CPro][Ibu],
and 3.60 ppm in [FPro][Ibu], respectively, chemical shifts that are
similar to the methine group present in ibuprofen free acid, H[Ibu].
Figure 5
Cation
influence on the 1H NMR chemical shifts of the methine and
methyl groups in phenothiazine ibuprofen compounds ([PTZ][Ibu]): (A)
chemical shift values and 1H NMR for H[Ibu] and (B) stacked 1H NMR spectra for ibuprofen derivatives.
Cation
influence on the 1H NMR chemical shifts of the methine and
methyl groups in phenothiazine ibuprofen compounds ([PTZ][Ibu]): (A)
chemical shift values and 1H NMR for H[Ibu] and (B) stacked 1H NMR spectra for ibuprofen derivatives.However, no significant influence is seen for the adjacent methyl
group (highlighted in purple in Figure ); this group shows as a doublet at 2.40 ppm in Na[Ibu]
and at 2.41 ppm in[Pro][Ibu], 2.39 ppm in [Prm][Ibu], 2.40 ppm in
[CPro][Ibu], and 2.39 ppm in [FPro][Ibu]. This is most likely due
to a higher distance between this group and the basic site. The more
downfield chemical shift values for the methine group in the synthesized
phenothiazine ibuprofen compounds is consistent with a decrease in
the electron density around the carboxylate anion, which further confirms
their lower degree of ionization when compared to Na[Ibu] and therefore
their existence as co-crystals.
Diffusion-Ordered (DOSY)
NMR Spectroscopy
1H DOSY NMR is a powerful technique
used to investigate the existence
of individual species in a solution; in the case of ionic compounds,
it can be used to determine if the cation and anion remain associated
in solutions.[27] This can provide information
on the transport properties and helps with the structural characterization
of the compounds. The self-diffusion coefficients for the ion pair
or the cation and anion present in the 0.06 M DMSO-d6 solutions of each of the promazine derivatives ([Pro]Cl,
[Pro][Doc], [Pro][Sal], [Pro][Ibu], and [Pro]Nap]) (Figures S24–S29, Supporting Information) and ibuprofen derivatives
([CPro][Ibu], [FPro][Ibu], and [Prm][Ibu]) (Table S4, Supporting Information) were determined by acquiring
the corresponding 1H DOSY NMR spectra at 298 K.Self-diffusion
coefficients are affected by the intermolecular interactions, size
(i.e., cross-sectional area Stokes Einstein equation),
and shape of the compounds. As expected, the 1H DOSY NMR
spectrum of [Pro]Cl shows the presence of two different species, the
[Pro] cation, and chloride anion (Cl) (Supporting Information, Figure S24A), with the [Pro] cation diffusion
coefficient being 3.39 × 10–10 m2/s (Figure ). Only
one species is seen in the 0.06 M [Pro][Doc], [Pro][Ibu], and [Pro][Nap]
DMSO-d6 solutions (Supporting Information, Figure S24B,C,E), consistent with
their existence in an associated form (or a co-crystal form) with
the cation and anion being held together through a low-barrier-type
hydrogen bond. Moreover, the diffusion coefficient for these compounds
increases with their decreasing size, with the lower-molecular weight
compounds diffusing faster in the order: [Pro][Doc] (D = 3.21 × 10–10 m2/s) < [Pro][Nap]
(D = 3.68 × 10–10 m2/s) < [Pro][Ibu] (D = 4.23 × 10–10 m2/s) (Figure ). These results confirm that the cation and anion in these
compounds remain associated.
Figure 6
Diffusion coefficient data for [Pro] derivatives.
Diffusion coefficient data for [Pro] derivatives.However, [Pro][Sal] exhibits a different behavior;
two species
with different diffusion rates are seen in the 0.06 M DMSO-d6 [Pro][Sal] solution (Supporting Information, Figure S24D); these can be attributed to the existence
of the [Pro] cation and [Sal] anion as individual species rather than
in an associated form. Moreover, the obtained D value for the [Pro]
cation (i.e., D = 3.39 × 10–10 m2/s) matches the one obtained for the
cation in the 1H DOSY spectrum for [Pro]Cl (i.e., D = 3.30 × 10–10 m2/s). This further confirms that [Pro][Sal] has a degree of
ionization similar to [Pro]Cl.The diffusion coefficients, D, for [Ibu] derivatives
[Prm][Ibu], [CPro][Ibu], and [FPro][Ibu] was also determined using 1H DOSY NMR (Supporting Information, Figures S24F–H). Each spectrum shows the presence of only
one species consistent with the existence of the cation and anion
from the [Ibu] derivatives in an associated form. Moreover, D values obtained for these derivatives show a similar trend
as in the case of [Pro] derivatives: D increases
with the decreasing size of the cation in the following order: [FPro][Ibu]
(D = 4.13 × 10–10 m2/s) < [CPro][Ibu] (D = 4.18 × 10–10 m2/s) < [Pro][Ibu] (D = 4.23 ×
10–10 m2/s) (Figure ).
Figure 7
Diffusion coefficient data for [Ibu] derivatives.
Diffusion coefficient data for [Ibu] derivatives.The diffusion coefficient is also affected by the
shape of the
cation and therefore by the intermolecular forces between solute molecules;
a lower D value (4.10 × 10–10 m2/s) was obtained for [Prm][Ibu], a constitutional isomer
of [Pro][Ibu], suggesting that molecules with weaker IMFs diffuse
more slowly.
Thermal Characterization
The thermal
behavior of the
synthesized compounds was further investigated. Decomposition temperatures
(Tonset and Tendset) were determined using thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) while phase
transitions (glass transitions, Tg, solid–solid
transitions, Ttransition, and/or melting
points, Tm) were determined using differential scanning
calorimetry (DSC). The obtained Tonset and Tendset values are shown in Figure and Table , the Tg values are shown in Table , while the full TGA and DSC graphs are shown in Figures
S30–S37 from Supporting Information.
Figure 8
Thermal stability of (A) [Pro], (B) [Prm], (C) [CPro], and (D)
[FPro] compounds: anion influence.
Table 3
Thermal Analyses of Phenothiazine
Co-crystals
ND—not detected in the (−90)
to (+90) °C range.
Safety data sheet.
Thermal stability of (A) [Pro], (B) [Prm], (C) [CPro], and (D)
[FPro] compounds: anion influence.ND—not detected in the (−90)
to (+90) °C range.Safety data sheet.
TGA
All the synthesized compounds but [Pro][Sal] underwent
a one-step decomposition. The highest thermal stability was obtained
for the docusate derivatives, where Tonset (°C) values were at least 40 °C higher than those of the
corresponding phenothiazine hydrochloride salts; the highest difference
(∼87 °C) was obtained for the [FPro] derivative (Tonset of 267.69 °C for [FPro][Doc] vs Tonset of 179.74 °C for [FPro]Cl).
Anion
Influence on Thermal Stability (Figure )
In the case of [Prm], [CPro],
and [FPro] derivatives, the same thermal stability trend was observed
with the decomposition temperatures increasing in the following order:
[Ibu] < [Sal] < [Nap] < [Doc] derivatives. In the case of
[Pro] derivatives, the [Pro][Ibu] (Tonset of 164.72 °C) showed a higher thermal stability than [Pro]Sal]
(Tonset of 121.93 °C) while the higher-molecular
weight compounds, [Pro][Doc] (Tonset of
265.04 °C) and [Pro]Nap] (Tonset of
177.23 °C), still showed the highest thermal stability.
Cation
Influence on Thermal Stability (Figure )
In the case of [Ibu] (cyan line
in Figure ) and [Doc] (red line in Figure ) derivatives, the Tonset values for [Prm][Ibu] and [Prm][Doc] derivatives were
observed to be lower than the corresponding Tonset values obtained for the less bulky constitutional isomers,
[Pro][Ibu] and [Pro][Doc], respectively. For example, the Tonset for [Prm][Doc] was 237.24 °C while Tonset for [Pro][Doc] was 265.04 °C; this
can be attributed to the higher degree of branching present in the
carbon chain between the two nitrogen sites of the [Prm] cation (and
therefore weaker intermolecular forces between identical molecules).
Thermal
stability of Cl (green line), [Doc] (red line), [Ibu] (cyan
line), [Sal] (black line), and [Nap] (magenta line) compounds: cation
influence.The corresponding [CPro] and [FPro]
derivatives ([CPro][Ibu], [CPro][Doc],
[FPro][Ibu], and [FPro][Doc]) showed similar or slightly higher thermal
stability when compared to the corresponding [Pro][Ibu] and [Pro][Doc]
derivatives, most likely due to the presence of stronger intermolecular
forces between the cations, which can be attributed to the presence
of −Cl and −CF3 groups in their structures
(i.e., stronger dipole–dipole forces). However,
in the case of [Sal] (black line in Figure ) and [Nap] (magenta line in Figure ) derivatives, the Tonset values for [Prm], [CPro], and [FPro] derivatives
were observed to be higher than the Tonset values obtained for the corresponding [Pro] derivatives. This suggests
a synergistic effect of the cation and anion on the thermal stability
of these compounds.
Differential Scanning Calorimetry
Fifteen out of the
sixteen prepared compounds were obtained as glassy materials. All
compounds but [Prm][Sal] showed only a reversible glass transition, Tg, in the −90 to +90 °C range. This
transition was present in all the three cycles of the DSC curve. For
all the phenothiazine derivatives but [Pro] compounds (Figure ), the lowest Tg value was obtained for the [Doc] derivative ([Prm][Doc], Tg = −15.44 °C; [CPro][Doc], Tg = −18.81 °C; and [FPro][Doc], Tg = −21.73 °C). In the case of [Pro]
compounds, [Pro][Ibu] shows the lowest Tg of −21.54 °C. Similar trends were obtained for all the
phenothiazine compounds with [Ibu], [Sal], and [Nap] derivatives showing
higher Tg values compared to those of
the corresponding [Doc] compounds. No significant trend could be identified
when analyzing the cation influence on the Tg values of the investigated compounds (Figure ). For example, the [CPro][Doc], [CPro[Nap],
[FPro][Doc], and [FPro][Nap] compounds show lower Tg values compared to [Pro][Doc] and [Pro][Nap]. Opposite
is obtained in the case of [Ibu] and [Sal] derivatives: the [CPro][Ibu],
[CPro[Sal], [FPro][Ibu], and [FPro][Sal] compounds show higher Tg values compared to [Pro][Ibu] and [Pro][Sal].
[Prm][Ibu] and [Prm][Doc] show the highest Tg values when compared to those of the corresponding [Pro],
[CPro], or [FPro] derivatives while [Prm][Sal] showed no glass transition
or melting point in the investigated temperature range.
Figure 10
Glass transitions, Tg (°C), for
(A) [Pro], (B) [Prm], (C) [CPro], and (D) [FPro] compounds: anion
influence.
Glass transitions, Tg (°C), for
(A) [Pro], (B) [Prm], (C) [CPro], and (D) [FPro] compounds: anion
influence.Glass transitions, Tg (°C), for
[Doc] (red line), [Ibu] (cyan line), [Sal] (black line), and [Nap]
(magenta line) compounds: cation influence.
Conclusions
Phenothiazine drugs are known to have multiple
pharmacological
effects but no known analgesic effect. Therefore, these drugs are
administered in combination with NSAIDs. Combining the two types of
drugs into one single, liquid-state, compound would potentially aid
with the drug administration while addressing other inherent solid-state
issues such as polymorphism. The ΔpKa difference between the pKa of the conjugated
acids and the acids used in this study (>5) suggests that a liquid-state
behavior is indeed expected. In our search for new phenothiazine ionic
liquids, we have found that aliphatic phenothiazine drugs (cation
precursors) can be paired with various NSAIDs (anion precursors) to
form dual functional PILs with various degrees of proton transfer
between the cation and anion (i.e., various degree
of ionization), species also known as liquid co-crystals. According
to various reports, co-crystal pharmaceuticals will keep the pharmacological
properties of the component drugs. Therefore, the new liquid co-crystals
reported here will not only benefit from dual functionality but will
also show potential synergistic effects (i.e., similar
to the dual-active lidocaine etodolac IL that completed phase III
clinical trials). Moreover, the cation and anion remain associated
in the 0.06 M DMSO-d6 solutions (298 K)
of the less-ionized compounds and not associated in a 0.06 M DMSO-d6 solution (298 K) in the case of the highly
ionized compounds. This information is the first step toward providing
an insight into the transport properties of these compounds (i.e., transdermal delivery): PILs have been shown to permeate
through a skin-mimicking membrane faster than their corresponding
ionic salts. Therefore, investigating the transdermal delivery of
these compounds is currently on-going in our laboratory.
Methods
Chemicals
All the cation precursors used in this study
were purchased from Fisher Scientific (chlorpromazine hydrochloride
98% and triflupromazine hydrochloride 98%), TCI (promethazine hydrochloride
98%), and Aldrich (promazine hydrochloride 98%). The anion precursors
were purchased from Acros Organics (sodium naproxen; 98%), Aldrich
(sodium ibuprofen, 98%), and Fisher Scientific (sodium docusate, 99%).
The compounds were used as received.
Characterization
NMR Spectroscopy
All the NMR spectra (1H, 13C, 19F, and the 1H–15N HSQC) were acquired
as follows: 0.06 M solutions of the investigated
compounds in DMSO-d6 were prepared, and
the spectra were recorded at 25 °C using a Bruker 500 MHz spectrometer.
FT-IR Spectroscopy
FT-IR spectra ranging between 650
and 3800 cm–1 were obtained from neat aliquots of
each API-IL by using a Perkin Elmer ATR-IR Instrument. The resolution
for the spectra was of 1 cm–1.
TGA
TGA experiments were performed on a Thermal Analysis
Discovery TGA550 instrument. Samples (2–15 mg) were placed
in 70 μL platinum pans and were analyzed as follows: the samples
were heated under a flow of nitrogen from 25 to 800 °C in a dynamic
heating regime by using a 5 °C/min heating ramp and an isotherm
of 30 min at 75 °C.
DSC Analyses
DSC data were collected
using a Thermal
Analysis Discovery DSC250 instrument under a continuous flow of nitrogen.
DSC samples were prepared by placing 2–15 mg of compound into
sealed T Zero pans covered with hermetic Al lids
and sealed using a T-Zero press. The data collection
involved three cycles each consisting of four steps: (1) heating to
90 °C at a 5 °C/min heating rate; (2) a 5 min isotherm at
90 °C; (3) cooling at a 5 °C/min rate to −90 °C;
and (4) a 5 min isotherm at −90 °C.
Syntheses
General
Synthesis of Phenothiazine Compounds
Phenothiazine
hydrochloride was suspended in anhydrous acetone, and an equimolar
amount of anion precursor was added. The resulting suspension was
stirred for 20–24 h at room temperature. The inorganic salt
formed (NaCl) was removed by filtration through a 0.2 μm filter,
and the solvent from the obtained solution was removed using a Buchi
rotary evaporator under high vacuum (42 mbar and 50 °C), leaving
behind highly viscous or glassy masses.
Authors: Saejin Oh; Andrei Nikolaev; Kan Tagami; Thi Tran; Dongwook Lee; Sanjoy Mukherjee; Rachel A Segalman; Songi Han; Javier Read de Alaniz; Michael L Chabinyc Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2021-01-22 Impact factor: 9.229
Authors: Marcileia Zanatta; Víctor U Antunes; Cláudio F Tormena; Jairton Dupont; Francisco P Dos Santos Journal: Phys Chem Chem Phys Date: 2019-01-30 Impact factor: 3.676
Authors: Christina W Yde; Mathias P Clausen; Martin V Bennetzen; Anne E Lykkesfeldt; Ole G Mouritsen; Barbara Guerra Journal: Anticancer Drugs Date: 2009-09 Impact factor: 2.248