J M Amici1, C Taïeb2, C LeFloc'h3, A-L Demessant-Flavigny3, S Seité3, O Cogrel1,4. 1. Dermatology Department, CHU Bordeaux, Hôpital Saint-André, Bordeaux, France. 2. Patients Priority, European Market Maintenance Assessment, Fontenay-sous-Bois, France. 3. La Roche-Posay, Levallois-Perret, France. 4. Groupe Chirurgical de Dermatologie, French Society of Dermatological Surgery, Paris, France.
Dear Editor,Skin is the most vulnerable organ that is constantly exposed to potential injury, and wound healing is a vital process for the survival of all higher organisms.
Scarring is most noticeable in the skin, but it also affects almost all adult mammalian and human tissues and organs.
They may result from surgery, skin injury, burning or inflammatory skin diseases, such as acne, chickenpox or shingles.
Scars may be extensive, dystrophic, appearing on areas not covered by clothes and considered embarrassing. They may also be associated with symptoms such as pruritus, pain or other discomforts. According to a study conducted in the United Kingdom, 26% and 44% of patients reported pain and itching related to their scars, impacting their physical comfort and functioning.
Usually, scars are composed of loose fibrous connective tissue and are remodelled during healing.
Chronic inflammation of the dermis and uncontrolled activation of myofibroblasts may result in abnormal scar overgrowth leading to a hypertrophic scar or a keloid with an excess of extracellular matrix proteins.
Despite being common throughout the world, the epidemiology of scars has not yet been properly investigated.The aim of this international epidemiological study was to assess the prevalence of scars worldwide. The present article describes the general population with participants reporting at least one scar having appeared during the year prior to this study.Our participants were selected via a stratified random sampling method of internet users who agreed to participate in panel surveys. Data about sociodemography, presence, origin and symptoms of scars using an internet survey were collected between April and May 2020. The survey focused on the most recent scars reported in order to simplify data collection.Overall, 11 100 individuals from Brazil (2000), China (3050), France (2000), Russia (2000) and the United States (2050) answered the survey; 48.5% of subjects reported at least one scar, and in 22%, the most recent scar was less than one‐year‐old. The most often reported location of recent scars in women was the abdomen (20.4%) and face (15.9%); in men, it was the face (18.7%) and abdomen (13.2%). Significantly more men (13.3%, P < 0.00001) than women (8.4%) reported scars on their hands. For 50.8%, the origin of the most recent scar was accidental or due to a disease (women: 50.8%, men: 60.5%, P < 0.0001); 35% of women and 28% of men indicated that general or orthopaedic surgery caused the scarring (P < 0.0001). Details are given in Table 1. Overall, 12.3% of men and 10.7% of women who reported scars also reported pain (P < 0.03). Table 2 provides details about symptoms. In 2014, international guidelines on the management of scars were issued. However, these guidelines have not yet been updated.
,
Currently, some procedures are available to manage scars, such as intralesional injections of corticosteroids and/or 5‐fluorouracil, cryotherapy, radiotherapy, laser therapy and surgical interventions, together with additional measures such as sun protection, silicone‐based dressings or gels.
,
Scar management mainly consisted in the use of topical products such as healing creams (13.2%), antiseptic solutions (11.2%) or a topical antibiotic (11.9%). Medical care was significantly (P < 0.001) more frequently provided to subjects with painful scars.
Table 1
Sociodemographic data and general data about scars
Global
Men
Women
N = 11 100
N = 5486
N = 5614
Age
43.0 ± 14.9
42.8 ± 14.9
43.2 ± 14.9
mean ± SD
n
%
n
%
n
%
Age range (years)
18–24
1367
12.32
694
12.65
673
13.67
25–34
2430
21.89
1214
22.13
1216
24.30
35–44
2289
20.62
1126
20.52
1163
22.89
45–54
2093
18.86
1036
18.88
1057
20.93
55–64
1781
16.05
893
16.27
888
17.81
>65
1140
10.27
523
9.53
617
11.40
Mean number of scars ± SD
4.1 ± 4.9
4.0 ± 4.5
4.2 ± 5.0
Number of scars
< one year
1196
22.2
602
22.7
594
21.7
> one year
4186
77.8
2046
77.3
2140
78.3
Time since presence, if > one year (years)
12.4 ± 12.7
12.5 ± 13.0
12.3 ± 12.4
Origin of scars
Accident
2992
55.59
1604
60.57
1388
50.77
General/orthopaedic surgery
1712
31.81
741
27.98
971
35.52
Skin excision
299
5.56
132
4.98
167
6.11
Restorative/cosmetic surgery
251
4.66
125
4.72
126
4.61
Cosmetic procedure
128
2.38
46
1.74
82
3.00
Type of scars
Hyperthropic or keloid scar
671
12.47
335
12.65
336
12.29
Did not know
1897
35.25
1897
35.25
949
34.71
SD, standard deviation.
Table 2
Prevalence of clinical symptoms
Global
Men
Women
n
%
Intensity>5 (0–10)
n
%
Intensity>5 (0–10)
n
%
Intensity>5 (0–10)
Presence of cracks or fissures
1774
32.96%
10.80%
963
36.37%
12.61%
1198
43.82%
10.80%
Visible detachment of thin skin flakes
2067
38.41%
15.09%
1094
41.31%
17.03%
736
26.92%
15.09%
Redness
2712
50.39%
20.09%
1389
52.45%
21.30%
1192
43.60%
20.09%
Drought or dryness
2519
46.80%
19.18%
1279
48.30%
20.43%
1240
45.35%
19.18%
Pruritus
2446
45.45%
17.58%
1254
47.36%
18.73%
1323
48.39%
17.58%
Burning sensation
1631
3030%
10.18%
895
33.80%
12.01%
973
35.59%
10.18%
Pulling
2453
45.58%
18.80%
1255
47.39%
19.86%
811
26.66%
18.80%
Sociodemographic data and general data about scarsSD, standard deviation.Prevalence of clinical symptomsTo our knowledge, this is the first international epidemiological survey on the prevalence, origin, location and impact of scars. Further investigations need to be performed.
Funding sources
This project was funded by La Roche Posay.
Conflict of interest
S. Seité, AL Demessant‐Flavigny and C. LeFloc'h are employees of La Roche‐Posay.
Authors: Michael H Gold; Michael McGuire; Thomas A Mustoe; Andrea Pusic; Mukta Sachdev; Jill Waibel; Crystal Murcia Journal: Dermatol Surg Date: 2014-08 Impact factor: 3.398
Authors: Jagannath Padmanabhan; Zeshaan N Maan; Sun Hyung Kwon; Revanth Kosaraju; Clark A Bonham; Geoffrey C Gurtner Journal: Adv Wound Care (New Rochelle) Date: 2019-11-06 Impact factor: 4.730