| Literature DB >> 35575417 |
Arpi Manookian1,2, Nahid Dehghan Nayeri3, Mehraban Shahmari4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: It is widely believed that using personal protective equipment (PPE) provides high levels of protection for healthcare workers (HCWs) in the fight against coronavirus disease (COVID-19). However, the long-term use of PPE is inconvenient for HCWs and may cause physical discomfort. These factors could result in poor compliance and disrupt the health and safety of HCWs, which may negatively affect the patient's safety.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; healthcare workers; nurses; occupational health; personal protective equipment
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35575417 PMCID: PMC9347983 DOI: 10.1111/nuf.12735
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nurs Forum ISSN: 0029-6473
Search strategy.
| (((((“COVID‐19”[Mesh]) OR “Coronavirus”[Mesh]) OR “SARS‐CoV‐2”[Mesh]) AND “Health Personnel”[Mesh]) AND “Occupational Health”[Mesh]) AND “Personal Protective Equipment”[Mesh] | PubMed |
| (health AND personal OR (healthcare AND workers)) AND 'covid‐19' AND occupational AND health AND personal AND protective AND equipment: ab, ti | Embase |
Figure 1PRISMA‐ScR flow diagram for database search of studies. COVID‐19, coronavirus diseases; PRISMA‐ScR, Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta‐Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews.
Characteristics of selected literature (Research literature)
| No. | References | Country | Literature type | Sample characteristics | Type of PPE and duration of use | Key findings | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Yánez Benítez et al. | 26 countries from four continents: Europe, America, Asia, and Africa | Survey |
Surgical specialists and surgical trainees. | Gloves, goggles, facemask, surgical face shield, and gown. | Type of problem: Visual impairment and fatigue. | |
| 2 | Davey et al. | United Kingdom | Survey |
Physiotherapists, medical groups, nurses, healthcare assistants, admin/managerial/research, radiographers, psychiatrists, and dieticians. |
Surgical mask, visor, filtering facepiece (FFP), gowns, and gloves
| Type of problem: Heat stress symptom, feel hot: 72.3%, feel uncomfortable: 89.7%, sweating: 98.7%, dizziness, fatigue, headache, contact dermatitis, reduced visibility, and discomfort in breathing. | |
| 3 | Parush et al. | Portugal and Israel | Survey |
Physicians, nurses, paramedics, medics, and other occupations. | N95 masks, masks, goggles, face shields, gown, and gloves. | Type of problem: Physical discomfort, seeing, and hearing problems. | |
| 4 | Tabah et al. | Australia | Survey |
Physicians, nurses, and allied HCWs. |
FFP2/N95 masks, surgical masks, sleeve gowns, PAPR, hazmat suit, goggles, hair cover, and face shields/visor median 4 h. |
Type of problem: Heat, thirst, pressure areas, headaches, and extreme exhaustion. Site of problem:‐ | |
| 5 | Daye et al. | Turkey | Survey |
Nurse, doctor, cleaning staff, secretary, other. | PPE (masks, gloves, protective glasses, and visors). |
Type of problem: Skin problems: dryness, itching, cracking, burning, flaking, acne, lichenification suggesting irritant contact dermatitis, and exacerbation of skin diseases, and previous allergies. Site of problem: Nose bridge, cheek, ear, chin, hands, forehead, and scalp. | |
| 6 | Metin et al. | Turkey | Retrospective study |
Doctors and nurses. |
N95 masks, masks, goggles, face shields, and gloves >8 h. |
Type of problem: Xerosis or eczema, acne, redness, or erosion Site of problem: Around the nose, forehead, eyes, and ears. | |
| 7 | Çiriş Yildiz et al. | Turkey | Quantitative descriptive |
Doctors, nurses, midwives, laboratory assistants, paramedics, anesthesia technicians, and medical staff assistant. | N95 masks, medical mask, gowns, goggles, and gloves. |
Type of problem: Dryness, irritation, wound scar, pain, redness, sores, and dehydration. Site of problem: Hands, face, eyes, ears, nose, and throat. | |
| 8 | Yıldız A et al. | Turkey | Comparative observational |
Nurses, physicians, others (emergency medical technician, auxiliary support personnel, and medical secretary) Intervention: Prophylactic dressing on the face and nasal strip sticky. |
Mask, face shield, and goggle >3 h. |
Type of problem: Discomfort in breathing, skin injuries 47.9%, pressure injuries (PIs), erythema of intact skin, itching, papule, or pustule type skin lesions. Site of problem: Nasal bridge, right cheek, left cheek, forehead, chin, and posterior part of the head. | |
| 9 | Lee et al. | India and Singapore | Cross‐sectional |
Medical groups, nurses, operations, sanitary, and others. |
N95 masks, surgical masks, goggles, face shields, gown, and gloves >6 h. | Type of problem: Symptoms associated with thermal stress: thirst, excessive sweating, exhaustion, headaches, dizziness, breathing difficulties, and dehydration. | |
| 10 | Ong JJY et al. | Singapore | Cross‐sectional |
Nurses, doctors, and paramedical staff. |
N95 facemask and goggles >5 h. | Type of problem: Headaches or exacerbation pre‐existing headache disorders. | |
| 11 | Lin et al. | China | Cross‐sectional |
Doctors and nurses. | N95 respirator, surgical masks, and double gloves. |
Type of problem: Adverse skin reactions (74.5%): Most common reactions dryness or scale > papules or erythema > maceration. Site of problem: Hands, cheeks, nasal, and bridge, respectively. | |
| 12 | Lan et al. | China | Cross‐sectional |
Physicians and nurses. |
N95 mask, goggles, Face shield, and Gloves > 6 h. |
Type of problem: Skin damage (97%), dryness and tightness (70.30%), and desquamation (61.60%). Site of problem: Nasal bridge (83.1%); hands, cheeks, and forehead. | |
| 13 | Bharatendu et al. | Singapore | Cross‐sectional |
HCWs. | N95 respirator‐mask alone and N95 Combined with PAPR. | Type of problem: N95 respirator‐mask alone results in significant alterations in cerebral hemodynamics and headache. | |
| 14 | Atay et al. | Turkey | Cross‐sectional |
Nurses. |
N95 masks, surgical masks, gloves, gown, and goggles/face shields >4 h. |
Type of problem: Redness, dryness, sweating, headaches, and vision problems. Site of problem: Mouth, cheeks, nose bridge, and ears. | |
| 15 | Xia et al. | China | Cross‐sectional |
Physicians, nurses, medical technicians, and other. |
Mask, goggles or glasses, and glove >6 h. |
Type of problem: Physical discomfort, pressure sores, retro auricular pain, chest distress or dyspnea, thirst or dry throat, dizziness or palpitation, micturition desire, nausea or vomiting, skin damage, eczema, dry skin, and skin erosion. Site of problem: Nose, cheek, forehead, retro auricular areas, respectively. | |
| 16 | Jiang et al. | China | Cross‐sectional |
Doctors and nurses. |
PPE >4 h. |
Type of problem: Skin injuries (42.8%), (PIs), moist‐associated skin damage, and skin tear. Site of problem: Nose bridge, cheeks, ear, forehead, armpit, groin, hands, and extremity. | |
| 17 | Kiely et al. | Ireland | Cross‐sectional |
Nurse, doctor, allied health members, and healthcare assistants. | PPE. |
Type of problem: Dry skin, redness, and itching, irritant contact dermatitis (ICD). Site of problem: with symptoms; hands, nose, cheeks, and forehead. | |
| 18 | Zuo et al. | China | Cross‐sectional |
HCWs. | N95 masks and medial masks. |
Type of problem: Skin reactions: itch, redness, and rashes. Site of problem: face. | |
| 19 | Hu et al. | China | Quantitative descriptive |
Doctors and nurses. |
N95 masks, latex gloves, and protective clothing the long period. |
Type of problem: scarring, itching, dry skin, rash. Site of problem: nasal bridge and face. | |
| 20 | Vidua et al. | India | Case report |
Forensic team. | protective clothing, helmets, goggles, mask, and gloves. | Type of problem: Discomfort feeling, feeling excessively hot, nausea, headache, backache, neck spasm, fatigue, dizziness, enhanced perspiration, dyspnea, suffocation, dehydration or facial redness, and faintness. | |
| 21 | Saffari et al. | Iran | Qualitative conventional content analysis |
Nursing staff. | N95 masks and surgical masks. |
Type of problem: Dehydration, ulcers, and shortness of breath. Site of problem: Nose and face. | |
| 22 | Lee et al. | Singapore | Narrative review | HCWs. |
N95 mask, goggles, gloves, surgical cap, and gown >6 h. |
Type of problem: Acne, skin indentations and PIs, urticaria, cheilitis, facial pigmentation, seborrheic dermatitis, frictional dermatitis, ICD, eczema flare, the flare of sebopsoriasis, and intertrigo. Site of problem: Nasal bridge, cheeks, neck, occiput, and toe. | |
| 23 | Singh et al. | India | Letter to the editor | Physicians, nurses, and paramedical staff. |
goggles, N95 masks, and face‐shield. |
Type of problem: Type of dermatoses: ICD, friction dermatitis, allergic dermatitis, sweat dermatitis, facial acne, lip lick dermatitis, and pressure/friction marks/rhagades with symptoms: pruritus, erythema. Site of problem: Nasal bridge, cheeks, and chin. | |
| 24 | Pei et al. | China | Letter to the editor | HCWs. | Overalls, disposable hats, disposable surgical masks, disposable isolation clothing, N95, goggles or protective masks, and disposable gloves. |
Type of problem: Erythema, prurigo, bulla, papule/edema, exudation/dryness, and lichenification. Site of problem: face, hands, legs, trunk, and the whole body. | |
| 25 | Yin et al. | China | Letter to the editor | ‐ | N95 mask. |
Type of problem: Pressure sore. Site of problem: Nose bridge. | |
| 26 | Atzori et al. | Italy | Letter to the editor | HCWs. |
Masks and goggles >6 h. |
Type of problem: facial dermatitis, hands contact dermatitis, contact dermatitis, skin injuries, dryness, itching, stinging sensations, pressure erythema, eczematous lesions, acneiform eruptions. Site of problem: Nasal bridge, hands, cheek, periocular, and perioral, and zygomatic. | |
| 27 | Ferguson et al. | United Kingdom | Research letters | The administrative, allied health professional, doctor, healthcare assistant, nurse, pharmacist, support (porter/cleaner), and other. | FFP3 mask, medical mask, gloves. |
Type of problem: Hand dermatitis, facial dermatoses, atopic eczema, occlusive acne, pressure urticaria, rosacea, atopic dermatitis, ICD, and psoriasis. Site of problem: Hands and face. | |
| 28 | Zhang et al. | China | Letter to the editor | HCWs. |
N95 masks, goggles, and face shields >8 h. |
Type of problem: Blisters, itching, sweating dermatitis, folliculitis, fungal infections, skin injuries, lesions, and erosions. Site of injury: Feet, the forehead, nasal bridge, and zygomatic bone. | |
| 29 | Long et al. | China | Commentary | HCWs. |
Gloves, masks, goggles, protective clothing and coveralls, rubber boots, and shoe covers. |
Type of problem: Skin Injury, skin maceration, secondary superficial fungal infection, pompholyx, itching, tingling or burning, indentations, frictions and scratches, allergic contact dermatitis, and acne. Site of problem: Hands and feet, cheeks, nose, and ears. | |
Abbreviations: HCWs, healthcare workers; PPE, personal protective equipment.
greater‐than sign