| Literature DB >> 35564366 |
Thomas Gerhard Wolf1,2, Leonardo de Col1, Seyed Ahmad Banihashem Rad1, Paolo Castiglia3,4, Antonella Arghittu3,4, Mina Cannavale5, Guglielmo Campus1,3.
Abstract
Dentists are on the frontline of infection, especially when it comes to respiratory viruses like the new coronavirus. The purpose of this paper is to conduct a scoping review to better understand dentists' risk awareness, awareness of COVID-19 symptoms, preventive measures, and effective methods of COVID-19 infection prevention and management. This paper systematically assesses the published literature on dentistry and COVID-19. Various electronic databases including Ovid MEDLINE, Scopus, Embase, and MEDLINE via PubMed were searched up to 9 September 2021. Overall, 39 papers were included. Almost the entirety of dentists (94.5%) reported awareness of the three most common COVID-19 symptoms, and a risk awareness score of about 90% was shown, while 88.2% of dentists reported adopting preventive measures. More than 50% did not want to treat infected people. While 70.3% of dentists recommended usage of N95 masks, the rate of dentists using them was below 40%. Sufficient awareness of risks during the pandemic was found in dentists. Although they were using preventive measures, there remains upside potential for adopting all recommended measures. Further, the usage of N95 masks is improvable, even though the benefit of wearing them could not be confirmed.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; dentist; dentistry; review; risk awareness
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35564366 PMCID: PMC9103177 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19094971
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 4.614
Database search procedure.
| Database | Ovid Medline | Scopus | Embase | Medline via PubMED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Search field | Multi-Field-Search | Search | Titel, Abstract, Author, Keywords | Title, Abstract |
| Search terms | COVID-19, dental, dentistry, dentist | COVID-19, dental, dentistry, dentist | COVID-19, dental, dentistry, dentist | COVID-19, dental, dentistry, dentist |
| Search constellation | (Dentistry OR dental OR dentist) AND COVID-19 | COVID-19 AND dental OR dentistry OR dentist | (Dentist OR dentistry OR dental) AND COVID-19 | (Dentist OR dentistry OR dental) AND COVID-19 |
| Results | 175 | 27 | 670 | 1176 |
Figure 1Flow Chart of the search procedure.
National surveys included sorted by Country, period of the surveys, Relative changes (%) COVID-19 cases and number of dentists participating in the surveys.
|
| ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
| ||
| Bekes et al. [ | Austria | June 2020 | −12 | 58 |
| Gomes et al. [ | Brazil | May 2020 | +44 | 1105 |
| Rossato et al. [ | Brazil | June–July 2020 | +174 | 1357 |
| Hua et al. [ | China | April 2020 | 8 | 2669 |
| Önöral et al. [ | Cyprus | April–May 2020 | −33 | 228 |
| Widyarman et al. [ | Indonesia | June 2020 | +2 | 632 |
| Alduwayhi et al. [ | India | July–August 2020 | +205 | 459 |
| Arif et al. [ | India | April 2020 | +860 | 302 |
| Srivastava et al. [ | India | April 2020 | +1243 | 311 |
| Banerjee et al. [ | India | May 2020 | +2028 | 493 |
| Izna et al. [ | India | July 2020 | +79 | 124 |
| Kanaparthi et al. [ | India | July 2020 | +79 | 385 |
| Sajjanar et al. [ | India | July 2020 | +79 | 355 |
| Ravi et al. [ | India | May 2020 | +2028 | 825 |
| De Stefani et al. [ | Italy | April 2020 | +21 | 1500 |
| Cagetti et al. [ | Italy | April 2020 | +21 | 3599 |
| Gambarini et al. [ | Italy | April 2020 | +21 | 700 |
| Putrino et al. [ | Italy | February–March 2020 | +91 | 535 |
| Sinjari et al. [ | Italy | March–May 2020 | +53 | 1185 |
| Khader et al. [ | Jordan | May–June 2020 | +15 | 368 |
| Nasser et al. [ | Lebanon | April–May 2020 | -- | 358 |
| Hleyhel et al. [ | Lebanon | May–August, 2020 | -- | 323 |
| Santana et al. [ | Mexico | June 2020 | +228 | 336 |
| Gómez-Clavel [ | Mexico | May–July 2020 | +43 | 703 |
| Pandey et al. [ | Nepal | June–August 2020 | +584 | 384 |
| Imran et al. [ | Pakistan | July 2020 | −9 | 822 |
| Chaudhary et al. [ | Pakistan | March–June 2020 | +16 | 583 |
| Almas et al. [ | Pakistan | April–May 2020 | 9 | 343 |
| Khan et al. [ | Pakistan | May-June 2020 | +15 | 306 |
| Alwazzan et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | July 2020 | +35 | 686 |
| Srivastava et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | March 2020 | +96 | 318 |
| Mustafa et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | March 2020 | +96 | 269 |
| Al-Khalifa et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | May 2020 | +14 | 287 |
| Martínez-Beneyto et al. [ | Spain | April 2020 | −49 | 4298 |
| Wolf et al. [ | Switzerland | July–August 2020 | +195 | 1324 |
| Tokuç et Coskunses [ | Turkey | March–April 2020 | +13 | 590 |
| Karayürek et al. [ | Turkey | July–August 2020 | +110 | 947 |
| Afraa et al. [ | UAE | June 2020 | −32 | 297 |
|
|
| |||
Awareness percentage of symptoms in the included studies.
|
|
| |
|---|---|---|
| Bekes et al. [ | Austria | 84.5 |
| Alduwayhi et al. [ | India | 99.0 |
| Arif et al. [ | India | 98.7 |
| Srivastava et al. [ | India | 88.0 |
| De Stefani et al. [ | Italy | 93.7 |
| Cagetti et al. [ | Italy | 93.4 |
| Khader et al. [ | Jordan | 91.8 |
| Nasser et al. [ | Lebanon | 93.9 |
| Santana et al. [ | Mexico | 99.4 |
| Alwazzan et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | 96.9 |
| Srivastava et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | 97.5 |
| Tokuç et Coskunses [ | Turkey | 96.3 |
|
|
|
Shows the risk awareness of dentists.
| Author | Risk Awareness |
|---|---|
| Ahmed et al. [ | 86% expressed fear after learning about COVID-19-related fatalities. A significant proportion of dentists (66%) expressed a desire to stop their clinics until the number of COVID-19 cases began to decline. |
| Alduwayhi et al. [ | 80.7% of dentists feel coronavirus is fatal, and 99% believe they are at higher risk. |
| Alwazzan et al. [ | The virus was assessed as dangerous by 90.2% of dentists, and 96.1% believe it is a significant public health concern. More experienced and male dentists had greater levels of awareness. |
| Banerjee et al. [ | Among respondent dentists 87% fall into the very high-risk group, 58 (10%) indicated that they belong to the high-risk category, and 17 (3%) stated that they belonged into the low-risk category. |
| Bekes et al. [ | Over two-thirds (67.2%) rated the infection as fairly dangerous in general, while one-half (55.2%) assessed the chance of catching the infection as moderately dangerous. |
| Chaudhary et al. [ | The odds of having awareness about the risk of exposure to COVID-19 and fear of getting infected were greater in clinical than non-clinical OHCW (OR: 52.6; OR: 15.9, respectively). |
| Imran et al. [ | In general, most of the participants were aware of the COVID-19 pandemic and concerned about the risk to their families. |
| De Stefani et al. [ | Becoming personally infected is moderately dangerous. |
| Gambarini et al. [ | While 54% of dentists thought there was a higher risk for the patient and 43% thought the risk higher for dental professionals, only 3% evaluated the risk as equal. |
| Gambarini et al. [ | Overall, 70% of dentists believed that dental settings are more dangerous for the spread of COVID-19 than other social behaviors. The majority of respondents believed that dentists faced the greatest risks, while only 5% believed patients faced the greatest risks; a significant number of respondents believed risks were evenly distributed between patients and dentists. |
| Gomes et al. [ | A total of 1011 (91.5%) respondents identified high risk of COVID-19 infection to dentists. |
| Gomez-Clavel et al. [ | Risk awareness score was 97.2% |
| Hleyhel et al. [ | While 18.6% of the respondents reported perceiving COVID-19 as very dangerous, 46.4% and 35% reported perceiving it as moderately dangerous and not dangerous. |
| Hua et al. [ | COVID-19 risk to patients and HCWs (84.1%) |
| Imran et al. [ | Most dental practitioners (71%) agreed that they are at greatest risk of coronavirus infection due to their close contact with infected patients and aerosol inhalation. |
| Izna et al. [ | Numerous dentists (80.6%) were aware of having the greatest risk of catching COVID-19 infections of any profession. |
| Kamate et al. [ | COVID-19 was thought to be deadly by 95.9% of dentists, and 99.8% stated that using face masks may prevent transmission. |
| Kanaparthi et al. [ | Overall, 93.5% were aware that dentists were at risk. |
| Karayürek et al. [ | When asked whether dental procedures may increase COVID-19 infections, 40.9% answered yes. Older dentists thought dental procedures could not raise COVID-19 infection risk. Although specialized dentists performed fewer dental examinations than general dentists during the pandemic, they believed dental treatments increased COVID-19 infection risk. |
| Mustafa et al. [ | Participants in the age groups “over 60”, “50–59”, and “20–29” were more likely to perceive it as a very dangerous disease (80.0%, 80.4%, and 65.8% of participants, respectively) compared to the 30–39 and 40–49 age groups (45.2% and 48.8% of participants, respectively) |
Preventive measures scores.
|
|
| ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Afraa et al. [ | UAE | 297 | 95.7 |
| Almas et al. [ | Pakistan | 343 | 54.8 |
| Alwazzan et al. [ | Saudi Arabia | 686 | 83.1 |
| Hleyhel et al. [ | Lebanon | 323 | 71.2 |
| Hua et al. [ | China | 2669 | 76.1 |
| Kamate et al. [ | Asia | 260 | 98.5 |
| Kamate et al. [ | Americas (North and South) | 212 | 98.6 |
| Kamate et al. [ | Europe | 139 | 99.3 |
| Kamate et al. [ | Africa | 193 | 99.5 |
| Kamate et al. [ | Other continents (Australia and Antarctica) | 46 | 97.9 |
| Nasser et al. [ | Lebanon | 358 | 96.4 |
| Putrino et al. [ | Italy | 535 | 69 |
| Rossato et al. [ | Brazil | 1178 | 98 |
| Widyarman et al. [ | Indonesia | 632 | 96 |
|
|
| ||
|
|
| ||
Figure 2Shows a map of countries with the scores of how many dentists were willing to treat COVID-19 affected subjects in evaluated papers [20,23,29,32,41,47,49,56,57,61].
Recommendation and use of N95 masks expressed as percentage of dentists.
| N95 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Author | Countries | Participants ( | Recommendation | Use |
| Ahmed et al. [ | Australia, Bahrain, Bulgaria, Canada, China, Egypt, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, India, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Kuwait, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Pakistan, Poland, Republic of Congo, Romania, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Switzerland, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, and the United States of America | 650 | 84 | N/A |
| Alduwayhi et al. [ | India | 459 | 79 | 10 |
| Al-Khalifa et al. [ | Saudia Arabia | 287 | 72 | N/A |
| Bakaeen et al. [ | Eastern Mediterranean | 347 | 63.2 | 34.4 |
| Bakaeen et al. [ | Europe | 449 | 41.6 | 8.3 |
| Bakaeen et al. [ | North America | 234 | 67.8 | 16.4 |
| Bakaeen et al. [ | Western Pacific | 158 | 40.5 | 25.3 |
| Bekes et al. [ | Austria | 58 | N/A | 89.7 |
| Kanaparthi et al. [ | India | 358 | 94.8 | N/A |
| Karayürek et al. [ | Turkey | 947 | N/A | 47.6 |
| Khan et al. [ | Pakistan | 306 | 89.5 | N/A |
| Martinez-Beneyto et al. [ | Spain | 6470 | 25.3 | N/A |
| Nasser et al. [ | Lebanon | 358 | 80 | N/A |
| Pandey et al. [ | Nepal | 384 | 81.7 | N/A |
| Ravi et al. [ | India | 808 | 95 | N/A |
| Casillas Santana et al. [ | Mexico | 339 | N/A | 70.2 |
|
|
| |||
|
|
|
| ||