Mahdieh Anoush1, Zeinab Pourmansouri2, Rafi Javadi1, Benyamin GhorbanPour1, Ali Sharafi3, Hamed Mohamadpour4, Iraj Jafari Anarkooli5, Sina Andalib1. 1. Department of Pharmacology and toxicology, School of Pharmacy, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Zanjan 4515613191, Iran. 2. Department of Pharmacology, School of Medicine, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Zanjan 4515613191, Iran. 3. Zanjan Pharmaceutical Biotechnology Research Center, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Zanjan 4515613191, Iran. 4. Department of Pharmaceutical Nanotechnology, School of Pharmacy, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Zanjan 4515613191, Iran. 5. Department of Biology and Anatomical Sciences, School of Medicine, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences, Zanjan 4515613191, Iran.
Abstract
Background and Aim: Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common form of dementia in the elderly. It is characterized as a multifaced disorder with a greater genetic contribution. The contribution of many genes such as BDNF, Sirtuin 6, and Seladin 1 has been reported in the pathogenesis of AD. Current therapies include acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor antagonists, which are only temporarily beneficial. Therefore, it seems that more studies should be conducted to determine the exact mechanisms of drugs to deal with the diseases' multifactorial features that we face. Methods: In this study, 42 adult rats were randomly divided into 7 groups and received drugs intraperitoneally and orally according to the protocol as follows: scopolamine group, clavulanic acid group, memantine group, scopolamine + memantine group, clavulanic acid pre- and post-treatment, and normal saline group. The Morris water maze method was performed to evaluate the spatial memory of animals, and the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling assay and real-time polymerase chain reaction were performed to study neuronal cell apoptosis and gene expression, respectively. Results: Significant differences were observed in the spatial memory of rats that received clavulanic acid prophylactically compared to the Alzheimer's model on the day of the test. Moreover, the results obtained during the training showed that both memantine and clavulanic acid improved spatial memory by increasing the time of rats present in the platform position and by reducing the swimming time in the scopolamine-induced Alzheimer's group. Besides, rats that received clavulanic acid and memantine had a greater percentage of healthy cells in comparison with the scopolamine-induced Alzheimer's group; however, the results were more significant for clavulanic acid. Furthermore, the expressions of BDNF, Seladin 1, and Sirtuin 6 as neuroprotective target genes were modified after clavulanic acid and memantine administrations; similarly, the results obtained from clavulanic acid were more significant. Conclusion: The results show that the administration of clavulanic acid before and after the use of scopolamine can reduce the percentage of apoptotic cells in the hippocampus and also improve the parameters related to learning and spatial memory; however, its effect in the prophylactic state was stronger. The results obtained from memantine revealed that it has neuroprotective potency against AD; however, clavulanic acid had a greater effect. Also, with increased expression of the neuroprotective genes, clavulanic acid could be considered as an option in the upcoming preclinical and clinical research about Alzheimer's disease.
Background and Aim: Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common form of dementia in the elderly. It is characterized as a multifaced disorder with a greater genetic contribution. The contribution of many genes such as BDNF, Sirtuin 6, and Seladin 1 has been reported in the pathogenesis of AD. Current therapies include acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor antagonists, which are only temporarily beneficial. Therefore, it seems that more studies should be conducted to determine the exact mechanisms of drugs to deal with the diseases' multifactorial features that we face. Methods: In this study, 42 adult rats were randomly divided into 7 groups and received drugs intraperitoneally and orally according to the protocol as follows: scopolamine group, clavulanic acid group, memantine group, scopolamine + memantine group, clavulanic acid pre- and post-treatment, and normal saline group. The Morris water maze method was performed to evaluate the spatial memory of animals, and the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling assay and real-time polymerase chain reaction were performed to study neuronal cell apoptosis and gene expression, respectively. Results: Significant differences were observed in the spatial memory of rats that received clavulanic acid prophylactically compared to the Alzheimer's model on the day of the test. Moreover, the results obtained during the training showed that both memantine and clavulanic acid improved spatial memory by increasing the time of rats present in the platform position and by reducing the swimming time in the scopolamine-induced Alzheimer's group. Besides, rats that received clavulanic acid and memantine had a greater percentage of healthy cells in comparison with the scopolamine-induced Alzheimer's group; however, the results were more significant for clavulanic acid. Furthermore, the expressions of BDNF, Seladin 1, and Sirtuin 6 as neuroprotective target genes were modified after clavulanic acid and memantine administrations; similarly, the results obtained from clavulanic acid were more significant. Conclusion: The results show that the administration of clavulanic acid before and after the use of scopolamine can reduce the percentage of apoptotic cells in the hippocampus and also improve the parameters related to learning and spatial memory; however, its effect in the prophylactic state was stronger. The results obtained from memantine revealed that it has neuroprotective potency against AD; however, clavulanic acid had a greater effect. Also, with increased expression of the neuroprotective genes, clavulanic acid could be considered as an option in the upcoming preclinical and clinical research about Alzheimer's disease.
Alzheimer’s disease
(AD) is a type of brain disease that
usually begins in the elderly; the risk of catching the disease increases
with age. It is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder characterized
clinically by a decline in cognitive activity and behavior. AD is
the most common form of dementia that begins with many symptoms such
as loss of information, especially temporary memory in old age, face
recognition difficulties, depression, loss of speech, and finally
ends with respiratory distress and death.[1,2] The
respiratory distress is the result of a disruption of the creation
of nerve synapses and the necrosis of brain cells in some areas of
the brain and the formation of spherical protein structures called
aging plaques along with the neurofibrillary tangles in the neuron’s
core.[3] Studies have shown that the expression
of some genes, such as BDNF, Sirtuin 6, and Seladin 1, are dysregulated in patients with
AD.[4−7]Patients who suffer from Alzheimer’s disease are treated
with symptomatic and disease-modifying therapies. All approved drugs
for the treatment of AD modulate neurotransmitters such as acetylcholine
and glutamate. These medications delay the onset and slow the progression
of the disease. Several research efforts have been performed to ameliorate
memory and promote the clearance of insoluble tau and Ab in transgenic
AD mice models.[8−10]Standard drug treatments for Alzheimer’s
disease include
acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) antagonists.[11,12] Cholinesterase inhibitors regulate information processing in the
hippocampus and neocortex that are impaired in AD, which itself arises
from the loss of cholinergic nerve fibers in the cerebral cortex.
The medications in this group are donepezil, galantamine, and rivastigmine.[13] Among the approved NMDAR antagonist drugs, memantine
is used nowadays as a therapeutic agent for Alzheimer’s disease.
Memantine is a noncompetitive inhibitor of NMDAR that blocks the transmission
of glutaminergic messages by antagonizing these receptors.[14,15] Clavulanic acid is a potent semisynthetic β-lactamase inhibitor
isolated from Streptomyces clavuligerus. This drug
is used in combination with amoxicilline in order to decrease the
betalactasmase enzyme degradative effects. Its most common form is
a combination of potassium salts called potassium clavulanate. Clavulanic
acid, as a glutaminergic system inhibitor, has been selected as a
target drug to evaluate its efficacy in this research.[16]Combining input information to the brain
and phenomenon-based learning
creates spatial memory. This information can be stored in many parts
of the brain, including the neocortex and hippocampus, so these parts
have a fundamental role in creating spatial memory. Spatial memory
helps animals remember and recall the information that they have acquired.[17,18] Many evidence-based studies have shown that spatial memory is being
gradually decreased with age and other reasons, most of which are
deficiencies that impair learning and spatial memory due to altering
the hippocampal morphology and function.[19,20] It has been proven that patients who suffer from AD often show spatial
memory loss, including that they do not know where they are and forget
where they left their belongings. They often show signs of confusion,
which is also a feature of spatial memory impairment.[21]To create models of Alzheimer’s disease, a
tropane alkaloid
called scopolamine with antagonistic properties on muscarinic receptors
is used in the laboratory animal models. After an intraperitoneal
(i.p) injection of scopolamine, the cholinergic neurotransmitter system
is blocked, causing cholinergic deficiency and memory impairment in
the rats. Recently, it has been reported that memory loss by scopolamine
causes oxidative stress in the rat’s brain. Thus, scopolamine-treated
rats are used as animal models for the study of antidementia medicines
and AD.[22−24] Scopolamine can also cause apoptosis in rat hippocampal
cells.[25,26]Because of the increasing prevalence
of AD and reduced spatial
memory performance in these patients, especially in industrialized
societies, and the report of the World Health Organization (WHO) on
an increasing number of early-onset Alzheimer’s disease, we
aimed to investigate the possible prophylactic and therapeutic effects
of clavulanic acid on AD.
Results
Clavulanic
Acid and Memantine’s Effect
on the Spatial Memory of Rats
In the control groups, rats
received normal saline with a volume of 30 international units i.p
for 10 d. From the seventh day, the training in the Morris water maze
was begun. The training was 3 d for each rat, and each one was trained
only once a day. The duration of each experiment was 60 s, and if
the rat could find the position, the experiment was completed; otherwise,
the experiment was extended until the end of the test (60 s), so every
rat had the opportunity to stay in the position for 20 s to learn
the spatial position of the platform. Finally, the average percentage
of time the rats spent in the target position was reported relative
to the total time of the experiment. The results obtained from the
control group showed that the rats spent more time in the platform
position in the following days of the experiment by finding the spatial
position of the platform in the maze, and if they could find the platform,
they tended to stay on that position until the experiment was ended.
This indicated that the learning pathway and spatial memory were normal
in this group of rats (Figure ).
Figure 1
Behavioral evaluation of the healthy group (received normal saline
with a volume of 30 international units i.p for 10 d) in the first
3 d of the experiment. (A) The mean percentage of the time that rats
spent in the Q2. (B) Mean swimming time * p <
0.05, ** p < 0.01.
Behavioral evaluation of the healthy group (received normal saline
with a volume of 30 international units i.p for 10 d) in the first
3 d of the experiment. (A) The mean percentage of the time that rats
spent in the Q2. (B) Mean swimming time * p <
0.05, ** p < 0.01.In the group of rats that received memantine and clavulanic acid,
control rats received 10 mg/kg of both drugs for 10 consecutive days.
During the training, the average percentage of time the rats spent
in the target position was calculated relative to the total time of
the experiment. The results of the study in these groups showed that
these rats had an improved learning process and that the time that
animals spent on the target platform on the third day of the training
was significantly increased compared to the first day of the training
and control group. Also, the results of studying the learning process
in this group of rats indicated that swimming time during the training
had a decreasing trend in comparison with the first day of the training
and control group (Figure ).
Figure 2
Effect of memantine and clavulanic acid on swimming time and the
time that mice remained in Q2 during the first 3 d of the experiment.
(A, C) Mean percentage of the time that rats spent in the Q2 to the
total time of experiment for memantine and clavulanic acid-treated
groups, respectively. (B, D) Mean swimming time for memantine and
clavulanic acid-treated groups, respectively. Control rats received
10 mg/kg of drug for 10 consecutive days. * p <
0.05, *** p < 0.001.
Effect of memantine and clavulanic acid on swimming time and the
time that mice remained in Q2 during the first 3 d of the experiment.
(A, C) Mean percentage of the time that rats spent in the Q2 to the
total time of experiment for memantine and clavulanic acid-treated
groups, respectively. (B, D) Mean swimming time for memantine and
clavulanic acid-treated groups, respectively. Control rats received
10 mg/kg of drug for 10 consecutive days. * p <
0.05, *** p < 0.001.
Scopolamine Induced an Alzheimer’s
Disease-like Condition in Rats
The results of the training
in rats receiving scopolamine showed that the average percentage of
time the rats spent in the target position did not change during the
training, indicating that rats were unable to learn the spatial position
of the platform. Also, the duration of swimming on the third day of
the training did not change in comparison with the first day, indicating
that scopolamine disrupted the learning mechanism in these animals.
In fact, the scopolamine disrupts the learning ability in rats, causing
them to lose the ability to maintain and recall the position in the
Morris water maze (Figure ).
Figure 3
Evaluation of rats with AD by injection of scopolamine and its
destructive effect on behavioral learning. (A) Mean percentage of
the time that rats spent in the Q2 to the total time of experiment.
(B) Mean swimming time. Alzheimeric rats were injected with 2 mg/kg
of scopolamine i.p for 10 consecutive days.
Evaluation of rats with AD by injection of scopolamine and its
destructive effect on behavioral learning. (A) Mean percentage of
the time that rats spent in the Q2 to the total time of experiment.
(B) Mean swimming time. Alzheimeric rats were injected with 2 mg/kg
of scopolamine i.p for 10 consecutive days.
Clavulanic Acid and Memantine’s Effect
on Spatial Memory in Scopolamine-Induced Alzheimeric Rats
To evaluate the effects of memantine and clavulanic acid on scopolamine-induced
Alzheimeric rats, rats that had received scopolamine were treated
with memantine and clavulanic acid for 10 consecutive days. The results
showed that both memantine and clavulanic acid improved the spatial
memory performance of rats in scopolamine-injected groups to remind
the rats of the spatial position of the platform, which was deduced
by increasing the time that rats spent in the target position during
the training. It was also indicated that the ability of rats in this
group to learn the spatial position of the platform was improved after
the consumption of memantine and the injection of clavulanic acid,
obtained from the reduced swimming time of rats during the training.
However, the results were more significant for rats treated with clavulanic
acid compared to memantine-treated groups (Figure ).
Figure 4
Effects of memantine and clavulanic acid post-treatment
on the
rats’ learning abilities. (A, C) Mean percentage of the time
that rats spent in the Q2 to the total time of experiment for the
scopolamine-memantine group and clavulanic acid post-treatment group,
respectively. (B, D) Mean swimming time for the scopolamine-memantine
group and clavulanic acid post-treatment group, respectively. Rats
were injected with 2 mg/kg of scopolamine i.p for 10 consecutive days,
and then they received either clavulanic acid or memantine, respectively.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001.
Effects of memantine and clavulanic acid post-treatment
on the
rats’ learning abilities. (A, C) Mean percentage of the time
that rats spent in the Q2 to the total time of experiment for the
scopolamine-memantine group and clavulanic acid post-treatment group,
respectively. (B, D) Mean swimming time for the scopolamine-memantine
group and clavulanic acid post-treatment group, respectively. Rats
were injected with 2 mg/kg of scopolamine i.p for 10 consecutive days,
and then they received either clavulanic acid or memantine, respectively.
* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001.Despite the results obtained
during the training, the results obtained
from the probe trial, the day that platform was removed from the maze,
showed that the spatial memory in clavulanic acid-treated Alzheimeric
rats had no significant difference with the scopolamine-induced Alzheimeric
group, while the results were significant for the memantine-treated
ones (Figure ).
Figure 5
Effects of
memantine, clavulanic acid, scopolamine, and post- and
pretreatments performed by clavulanic acid, and memantine post-treatment
on rats’ remaining time in Q2 on the day of the experiment.
* p < 0.05, *** p < 0.001.
Effects of
memantine, clavulanic acid, scopolamine, and post- and
pretreatments performed by clavulanic acid, and memantine post-treatment
on rats’ remaining time in Q2 on the day of the experiment.
* p < 0.05, *** p < 0.001.
Clavulanic Acid Pretreatment’s
Effect
on the Reduction of Spatial Memory Performance on Scopolamine-Induced
Rats
The results of this group showed that injection of clavulanic
acid before scopolamine modulates the destructive effect of scopolamine
on spatial memory in rats. These results were obtained by increasing
the time that rats spent on the target platform during the training
and also by decreasing the average swimming time of the animals during
the training (Figure ). Similarly, the results showed that the group receiving a clavulanic
acid pretreatment could delay the Alzheimer’s disease onset
by inhibiting the effects of scopolamine (Figure ).
Figure 6
Protective effects of clavulanic acid pretreatment
against scopolamine
by evaluating the swimming time and the time that rats stayed in Q2
during the first 3 d of the experiment. (A) The mean percentage of
the time that rats spent in the Q2. (B) Mean swimming time. (10 mg/kg
of clavulanic acid was injected, and half an hour later, 2 mg/kg of
scopolamine was injected i.p) * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
Protective effects of clavulanic acid pretreatment
against scopolamine
by evaluating the swimming time and the time that rats stayed in Q2
during the first 3 d of the experiment. (A) The mean percentage of
the time that rats spent in the Q2. (B) Mean swimming time. (10 mg/kg
of clavulanic acid was injected, and half an hour later, 2 mg/kg of
scopolamine was injected i.p) * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
Memantine
and Clavulanic Acid’s Effect
on Neuroprotective Target Genes downregulated in Rats with AD
On the one hand, the results obtained from real-time polymerase chain
reaction (PCR) showed that memantine and clavulanic acid, except for
clavulanic acid on Sirtunin, had no significant effect on neuroprotective
target genes including BDNF, Sirtuin 6, and Seladin 1 in normal rats who received these
drugs compared with the control group. On the other hand, the results
for these drugs were significant when injected post-treatment and
revealed that they could increase all target genes’ expression;
however, the result of clavulanic acid was more significant for all
three genes than that of memantine when compared to scopolamine-induced
positive groups. The results for pretreatment of clavulanic acid showed
that its pretreatment administration could increase the expression
of all three genes in comparison with rats that only received scopolamine
(positive group) (Figure ).
Figure 7
Memantine and clavulanic acid regulate neuroprotective-related
target genes in rats with AD. (A) Relative BDNF gene
expression. (B) Relative Seladin 1 gene expression.
(C) Relative Sirtuin 6 gene expression. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001, **** p < 0.0001.
Memantine and clavulanic acid regulate neuroprotective-related
target genes in rats with AD. (A) Relative BDNF gene
expression. (B) Relative Seladin 1 gene expression.
(C) Relative Sirtuin 6 gene expression. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001, **** p < 0.0001.
Post-Treatment with Memantine
and Pretreatment
with Clavulanic Acid Reduces Scopolamine-Induced Hippocampal Cell
Apoptosis
The results of the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase
dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) test showed that clavulanic acid injections
before and after a scopolamine injection reduced scopolamine-induced
cell death in both states, although this effect was stronger when
administered prophylactically. The results also showed that memantine
post-treatment could reduce the rate of scopolamine-induced apoptotic
cells in comparison with the scopolamine-injected group (Figure ).
Figure 8
TUNEL assay results for
clavulanic acid pre- and post-treatment
and memantine post-treatment. (A) Light microscope images of the stained
cells. (B) Bar plot of TUNEL positive cells against the treated groups.
Images were taken by an optical microscope with a magnification of
40×. * p < 0.05, **** p <
0.0001.
TUNEL assay results for
clavulanic acid pre- and post-treatment
and memantine post-treatment. (A) Light microscope images of the stained
cells. (B) Bar plot of TUNEL positive cells against the treated groups.
Images were taken by an optical microscope with a magnification of
40×. * p < 0.05, **** p <
0.0001.
Materials
and Methods
Drugs Treatment and In Vitro Modeling of Alzheimer’s
Disease in Rats
The experimental study was performed on adult
male Sprague–Dawley (SD) rats that weighed 150–200 g.
Animals were obtained from the pharmacology department of the Zanajn
University of Medical Sciences. Rats were kept in special clear plastic
cages at 23 °C. Adequate water and food were supplied except
during the training. Each animal was used only once and was excluded
from further experimentation under the ethical principles of working
with animals (Ethics Code No. IR.ZUMS.REC.1396.227). Scopolamine has
a role in learning/memory impairments as well as in the induction
of amyloid-beta deposition, synaptic dysfunction, and oxidative stress,
all of which are the most common forms of dementia affecting people
with AD, so it is used to create a laboratory animal model for memory
disorders including AD. Scopolamine hydrobromide was purchased from
Sigma Inc. and diluted according to the manufacturer’s protocol
and used i.p (2 mg/kg). Then, memantine under the brand name Namenda
and clavulanic acid under the brand name potassium clavulanate was
purchased from Sigma Inc. and diluted in normal saline to the recommended
amount of the manufacturer and injected i.p to rats (10 mg/kg). They
were prepared daily to minimize the possibility of any contamination.
Rats Grouping
Rats were randomly
divided into seven groups to implement memory assessment models, and
experiments were done. Each group consisted of six adult male SD rats
weighing 150–200 g. The groups were as follows:Healthy rats receiving
normal saline.Memantine-receiving
rats.Clavulanic acid-receiving
rats.Scopolamine-injected
rats (Alzheimer’s
model).Scopolamine-injected
rats receiving
memantine.Pretreatment
of clavulanic acid in
scopolamine-injected ratsPost-treatment of clavulanic acid in
scopolamine-injected rats.Briefly, in
rats that did not receive scopolamine, 10
mg/kg clavulanic acid and 10 mg/kg memantine by i.p injection were
given for 10 consecutive days, and the experiments were performed
from the seventh to the ninth day of the injection according to the
protocol. In scopolamine-induced Alzhimeric rats, first, they were
injected with 2 mg/kg of scopolamine intraperitoneally for 10 consecutive
days, then they received clavulanic acid and memantine as described
above, and the experiments were performed. In rats who received clavulanic
acid prior to the injection of scopolamine, 10 mg/kg of clavulanic
acid was injected intraperitoneally, and half an hour later, 2 mg/kg
of scopolamine was injected intraperitoneally, and the experiments
were performed.
Behavioral Study
After the rats were
grouped according to which of the different drugs were given, the
Morris water maze test was performed for the behavioral study. For
this aim, a water-filled tank was divided into four quadrants (Q1–Q4),
and a platform was positioned in the Q2 quadrant. Each rat was placed
in a random quadrant that was traced by the software. From days 7–9,
the rats were trained. If the rat could find the maze in the target
quadrant, it was allowed to stay on the platform for 3 s to assess
the position of the platform and then was exited from the maze. Otherwise,
if the rat was not able to find the platform during this time, it
was manually guided to the platform to stay on the platform for 30
s to remember the position of the platform. On day 10, the platform
was removed to determine if the rats could recall where they were
and how long they would spend in the Q2 quadrant trying to find the
platform. Finally, the spatial memory improvement of the rats was
evaluated.
TUNEL Assay
The
TUNEL assay procedure
was based on studies evaluating the effect of drugs on hippocampal
cell death.[27,28] Briefly, after conducting behavioral
studies, the brains of all rats were extracted and maintained in 10%
formalin to perform the TUNEL assay. Genomic DNA breaks during the
apoptotic process, forming two molecular strands of mononucleosome
and oligonucleosome as well as terminal strands that are labeled enzymatically
at the 3′–OH end. The TUNEL test was performed using
the Apo-Direct kit (BD Biosciences). First, the incisions obtained
from the microtome were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered
saline (PBS). The fixed cells were incubated with the blocking solution
(3% H2O2 in methanol) for 10 min at room temperature
and then washed with PBS. The cells were then incubated in ice permeable
solution (0.1% Triton X-100 in 0.1% sodium citrate) for 2 min. After
that, the samples were resuspended in 50 μL of terminal deoxynucleotidyl
transferase (TdT) and nucleotide (TUNEL reaction mixture) and incubated
in a dark area for 1 h. Then, 50 μL of horseradish peroxidase
(HRP)-labeled Converter POD (POD = peroxidase) solution was added,
and the cells were kept at 37 °C in a bain-marie bath for 30
min. Henceforth, after washing, 100 μL of a 3,3′-diaminobenzidine
(DAB) solution was added and incubated in a dark place for 10 min.
Finally, the stained cells were analyzed under a light microscope.
RNA Extraction, cDNA Synthesis, and Real-Time
PCR
The procedure was conducted based on conventional methods
of RNA extraction and the real-time PCR method.[28] In brief, target gene primers including BDNF, Sirtuin 6, and Seladin 1 were
purchased from Cinnagene Inc. The sequences are summarized in Table . After the rats’
brains were extracted, they were homogenized, and the total RNA was
extracted using the RiboEx RNA extraction Kit (Takara) according to
the manufacturer’s protocol. Then, a conventional PCR was performed
to reverse transcribe the RNAs to cDNAs using a cDNA synthesis kit
(Exiqon). Finally, the real-time PCR reaction was conducted by using
the SYBR Premix Ex in a light cycler 96 (Roche) instrument. The extracted
brain samples of rats that had received normal saline were considered
as our control. The mRNA level of β-actin was considered as
an internal control.
Table 1
Primer Sequences
name
sequences
Rpl13
F: 5′-AAGAAGGGAGACAGTTCTGCTG-3′
R: 5′-CTCCTCTTCCGTGATGGCTC-3′
BDNF
F: 5′-ATCCACTGAGCAAAGCCGAA-3′
R: 5′-CCTGGTGGAACATTGTGGCT-3′
Seladin 1
F:5′CGAGTCATCGTCCCACAAGT-3′
R: 5′-GAGTTTTCAGACGGTGTGCAG-3′
Sirtuin 6
F:5′-CTTTATTGTTCCCGTGCGGC-3′
R: 5′-GGGTCGAATATCTCGGGCAG-3′
Statistics
SPSS software ver. 16
was used to analyze the obtained data. A homogeneity of variance test
was performed to evaluate the homogeneity of the data. Then, a one-way
Anova test was used to analyze the results, and a post-hoc test was
used to compare the groups. In all experiments, P < 0.05 was considered significant.
Discussion
Alzheimer’s disease is a type of brain dysfunction that
gradually degrades the patient’s mental abilities. The most
obvious type of dementia is memory impairment, which is seen in patients
with AD. Memory impairment is initially limited to recent events and
learning, but old memories are also damaged gradually. AD is a multifaceted
disease that results from a combination of factors such as age, genetics,
and environmental factors. These factors either cause Alzheimer’s
disease onset or its progression.[29] Approximately
15 million people worldwide currently suffer from AD, and by 2040
the number is anticipated to reach 80 million.[30,31]The mechanisms by which scopolamine induces Alzheimer’s
disease include elevated acetylcholinesterase and decreased acetylcholine
in the synaptic space, increased cytotoxicity signals, Tau levels,
free radicals, oxidative stress, and amyloid-beta, all of which indicates
that scopolamine acts as a potent contributor to Alzheimer’s
disease by increasing toxicity and cell death.[26,32] In this study, an i.p injection of scopolamine was performed to
disturb memory and reduce learning ability, and based on previous
studies and in line with our study, it leads to a significant reduction
in memory in rats. According to the results of our study, the injection
of scopolamine not only impaired spatial memory in rats but also impaired
learning ability during the training, which was in line with previous
findings that showed the injection of scopolamine disrupts immediate
and working memory as in AD.[26,33,34]Memantine is one of the candidate drugs in the treatment of
AD.
Memantine prevents neuronal cell death and Alzheimer disease’s
progression by preventing elevated glutamate levels. Since we aimed
to evaluate the effect of drugs on hippocampal cell apoptosis, memantine
was a suitable drug for this study.[15] Studies
have shown that memantine can improve cognitive (mental) dysfunction.
It has also been revealed that memantine increases the ability to
manage daily tasks and reduces the necessity for patients with AD
to have care.[35−37] In the study performed by Block et al., they injected
20 mg/kg memantine into rats and then induced brain ischemia on them.
The results obtained from the study showed that the swimming time
and distance in the water maze in rats receiving memantine were increased
compared to rats in which only ischemia had been induced.[38] Also, the results of another study revealed
that the nerve damage of the hippocampus in rats with AD was significantly
reduced by memantine.[39] It has also been
shown that treatment with a neuroprotective agent such as memantine
could reduce the function and morphological effects of brain ischemia.[40] Ali et al. investigated the effect of memantine
on scopolamine-induced memory disruption. For this purpose, a group
of mice received scopolamine, after which the memantine was injected.
In line with our study, it was revealed that memantine attenuates
scopolamine-induced memory dysfunction.[41]Clavulanic acid is a safe neuroprotective drug with strong
blood-brain-barrier
permeability and considerable antioxidant and antitoxic effects, which
announce it as a potential therapeutic drug for neurodegenerative
disorders and diseases. However, because of its hepatotoxicity the
consumed doses should be potentially low. Besides, the effects of
clavulanic acid on neurotoxin-induced animal models of Parkinson’s
disease have revealed that this drug protects hippocampal nerve cells’
death against neurotoxic drugs.[42−44] It has also been proven that
clavulanic acid improved behavioral motor function in mice treated
with 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP), a neurotoxic
drug.[45] The main possible mechanism for
its efficiency in AD can be suggested as its NMDAR antagonism, which
can be compared with that of memantine. Although few studies have
been performed on the effect of clavulanic acid on Alzheimer’s
disease, Huh et al. showed that clavulanic acid improved behavioral
defects in all models of human neurological disease.[43] It was also determined that clavulanic acid protects nerve
cells’ death. The results of studies revealed that clavulanic
acid as a compound that modulates central nervous system (CNS) activity
could be a neuroprotective agent in improving the performance of neurotoxin-induced
animal models.[44] However, the underlying
neuroprotective mechanisms of clavulanic acid are not yet clarified,
and further research is needed to elucidate the potential of clavulanic
acid as a treatment for Alzheimer’s. In line with conducted
studies, the results of our study for the first time revealed clavulanic
acid improves the cognitive functions of rats with AD. Moreover, we
showed that this drug protects the hippocampus cell death against
scopolamine.Seladin-1 has recently been known
to be downregulated
in Alzheimer’s disease. This gene has been shown to protect
cells against apoptotic cell death. Livonen et al. showed that seladin-1 was downregulated in patients with AD, in which
this reduction was correlated with hyperphosphorylation of Tau protein.[46,47] It has been revealed that seladin 1 has downregulated
in brain regions selectively degenerated in AD, so its restoration
could be beneficial in patients and models of AD.[46] The results obtained from our study demonstrate that either
memantine and clavulanic acid increase the expression of seladin
1, which was downregulated in scopolamine-induced rats. It
was also clarified that both drugs improved memory performance and
reduced hippocampal cell death; however, these results were more prominent
for clavulanic acid.The role of sirtuin in AD has come to light.
Sirtuin regulates
the neuroinflammation and neuronal degradation that are seen in AD.
Its correlation with DNA repair, telomere maintenance, and genome
integrity has also been seen, which are associated with longer longevity.
Recent studies have proposed sirtuin 6 as a potential therapeutic
target in AD. Downregulated sirtuin levels have recently been reported
to have correlated with increased Aβ production and deposition
in patients with AD.[6,48] It has recently been reported
that sirtuin 6 has reduced expression in AD models, where its upregulation
improves memory function.[28] In line with
studies, we showed that sirtuin 6 has been downregulated in scopolamine-induced
rats while memantine increases its expression and improves memory
function; however, the clavulanic acid had a more significant effect
in comparison with memantine.BDNF strengthens memory formation
by long-term induction of the
hippocampus.[7] Weinstein et al. revealed
that elevated levels of BDNF protect the elderly against AD.[49] Besides, its upregulation has been shown to
participate with a reduced risk of AD or dementia.[50] BDNF takes part in the synaptic growth of the CNS, leading
to enhanced memory functions and hippocampal learning. Its reduction
has been proven to be involved in the progression of AD, in which
the restoration of BDNF led to an improved neurological impairment
in patients with AD.[51] In line with our
study, the results of a recently published article showed that BDNF
was downregulated in mice who received scopolamine, while induction
of memantine could significantly increase its expression alongside
an improved memory performance.[28] Although
we showed that memantine has a similar role, the superior role of
clavulanic acid has come into view for the first time in our study.
Conclusion
The results of the present study showed
for the first time that
clavulanic acid, as an effective drug in scopolamine-induced rats
before and after scopolamine injection, can improve spatial memory
in these rats and also reduce cell apoptosis. It also reduces hippocampal
cell death, which can ultimately prevent the acceleration of Alzheimer’s
disease. Also, the results of our study showed that the expression
of neuroprotective genes, which is reduced in Alzheimer’s disease,
increases after treatment with clavulanic acid, which can be used
as an option in the upcoming preclinical and clinical research for
treatment of Alzheimer’s disease. In conclusion, although the
results of memantine administration were significant, the results
of clavulanic acid injection were more considerable, which due to
its higher blood-brain barrier permeability and the widespread suppressor
role in neuroinflammation may be a promising therapeutic approach
for further research in the areas related to Alzheimer’s disease.
Authors: Barry Reisberg; Rachelle Doody; Albrecht Stöffler; Frederick Schmitt; Steven Ferris; Hans Jörg Möbius Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2003-04-03 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Héctor E López-Valdés; Andrew N Clarkson; Yan Ao; Andrew C Charles; S Thomas Carmichael; Michael V Sofroniew; K C Brennan Journal: Stroke Date: 2014-06-17 Impact factor: 7.914
Authors: Galit Weinstein; Alexa S Beiser; Seung Hoan Choi; Sarah R Preis; Tai C Chen; Demetrios Vorgas; Rhoda Au; Aleksandra Pikula; Philip A Wolf; Anita L DeStefano; Ramachandran S Vasan; Sudha Seshadri Journal: JAMA Neurol Date: 2014-01 Impact factor: 18.302
Authors: Sara Ahmadi-Abhari; Maria Guzman-Castillo; Piotr Bandosz; Martin J Shipley; Graciela Muniz-Terrera; Archana Singh-Manoux; Mika Kivimäki; Andrew Steptoe; Simon Capewell; Martin O'Flaherty; Eric J Brunner Journal: BMJ Date: 2017-07-05