| Literature DB >> 35460578 |
Claire M Erickson1,2, Lindsay R Clark2,3, Emre Umucu4, Nhi H Vo5, Annabelle Santos Volgman6, Nathaniel A Chin2, Fred B Ketchum7, Carolyn H Jones8, Carey E Gleason3,9, Neelum T Aggarwal10,11.
Abstract
As more is understood about the hereditary nature of disease risk, the utility of genetic testing within cardiovascular medicine is increasingly being explored. Although testing may afford more personalized risk stratification, there is a paucity of information regarding patient knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs toward genetic testing among cardiology patients. Participants (n = 530) recruited primarily from a cardiology clinic filled out a 41-item written questionnaire assessing knowledge, beliefs, and attitudes toward genetic testing, motivators and detractors for considering genetic testing, and perceived likelihood for behavior change after hypothetical genetic testing risk stratification. Path analysis was used to test the hypothetical models predicting the likelihood of getting a genetic test and making behavior changes following genetic testing. The patient population was late-middle-aged (59.0 ± 14.5 years), majority women (61.5%), and about half reported having a bachelor's degree. 58.1% of participants self-identified as White, 25.7% as African American or Black, 6.8% as Spanish, Latino, or Hispanic, 3.0% as Asian or Pacific Islander, and 0.5% as Native American. Gender (being a woman) and more years of education were related to greater knowledge about genetic testing. Racial identity and years of education were related to beliefs about genetic testing. Beliefs, but not knowledge, were related to more positive attitudes and a higher likelihood of pursuing genetic testing. Positive attitudes were related to greater perceived personal control (PPC). Furthermore, attitudes and PPC were related to higher likelihood of lifestyle change after genetic testing. These results highlight the need to integrate the experiences of racialized communities into education/counseling efforts. Most educational counseling efforts lack a nuanced discussion of social determinants of health or beliefs. In addition to factual information, educational counseling must also address people's beliefs, concerns, and the intersecting experiences and identities, which shape patients' relationships with the evolving landscape of healthcare and personalized medicine.Entities:
Keywords: attitudes; beliefs; education; genetic testing
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35460578 PMCID: PMC9545732 DOI: 10.1002/jgc4.1573
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Genet Couns ISSN: 1059-7700 Impact factor: 2.717
FIGURE 1Path analysis testing interest in undergoing genetic testing
FIGURE 2Path analysis testing likelihood to change lifestyle after genetic testing
Sample characteristics
| Overall | |
|---|---|
| Sample size ( | 530 |
| Age at survey | 59.0 ± 14.5 |
| Gender (% women, | 61.5% (326) |
| Education (% w/≥Bachelor degree, | 49.1% (260) |
| Self‐identified race (%, | 58.1% (308) White |
| 25.7% (136) African American or Black | |
| 6.8% (36) Spanish/Latino/Hispanic | |
| 3.0% (16) Asian/Pacific Islander | |
| 0.5% (3) Native American | |
| Income level (%, | 17.4% (92) Prefer not to respond |
| 3.2% (17) None | |
| 20.6% (109) <$35k | |
| 35.3% (187) $35k–$100k | |
| 19.6% (104) >$100k | |
| Clinic recruited from (%, | 88.7% (470) Rush Cardiology |
| 9.1% (48) Rush Oak Park Cardiology | |
| 2.1% (11) Rush OB/Gyn | |
| First time seeing this clinic doctor (% yes, | 21.7% (115) |
| Have heard of genetic testing (% yes, | 83.4% (442) |
| Chance of developing disease that is high enough to want genetic testing | 18.7% (99) 10% chance |
| 22.5% (119) 30% chance | |
| 30.4% (161) 50% chance | |
| 13.8% (73) 70% chance | |
| 7.5% (40) 90% chance |
Reasons for wanting or not wanting genetic testing
| Overall | |
|---|---|
| Sample size | 530 |
| Would get genetic testing even if currently healthy and do not have symptoms (% yes, | 65.1% (345) |
|
Reason for getting test (can choose multiple, out of Want to know health information about self: 79.1% (273) Can use the information to improve health: 75.1% (259) Have right to information about self: 44.6% (154) Other:
To help family: 7.8% (27) Have family history of illness: 1.4% (5) Want to help science/others: 1.2% (4) Prepare self for future: 0.6% (2) | |
|
Reason for not getting test (can choose multiple, out of Don't think information is important: 11.4% (19) Don't think can improve health with information: 24.1% (40) Would only get tested if symptomatic: 54.2% (90) Other:
Older age: 6.0% (10) Need more information: 4.2% (7) Don't care to know: 1.8% (3) Test may be unreliable: 3.0% (5) Concern about discrimination (esp. insurance): 3.6% (6) Learning result may distress me: 1.8% (3) Don't have family history/family with which to share results: 2.4% (4) Religious beliefs: 0.6% (1) |
Likelihood of changing diet and exercise after learning genetic results for disease that can be helped through lifestyle modifications
| Strongly agree | Agree | Neither agree nor disagree | Disagree | Strongly disagree | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Results indicate higher chance (%, | 46.8% (248) | 41.7% (221) | 6.8% (36) | 0 | 0 |
| Results do not indicate higher chance (%, | 15.5% (82) | 34.5% (183) | 32.5% (172) | 10.9% (58) | 0.9% (5) |
| Results inconclusive of chance (%, | 20.8% (110) | 38.9% (206) | 29.8% (158) | 4.9% (26) | 0.8% (4) |