| Literature DB >> 35456297 |
Kacper Nijakowski1, Sylvia Wyzga2, Nisha Singh2, Filip Podgórski2, Anna Surdacka1.
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic has severely affected the human population by revealing many health problems, including within the oral cavity. This systematic review was designed to answer the question "Is there a relationship between oral manifestations and SARS-CoV-2 infection?". Following the inclusion and exclusion criteria, twenty-seven studies were included (according to PRISMA statement guidelines). Based on the meta-analysis, nearly two-thirds of the SARS-CoV-2 positive patients reported oral symptoms, in particular taste alterations, xerostomia and ulcerations (54.73% [95% CI: 46.28-63.04%], 37.58% [95% CI: 26.35-49.53%], and 21.43% [95% CI: 13.17-31.06%], respectively). In conclusion, despite the conducted systematic review, the increased prevalence of oral manifestations in SARS-CoV-2 infection cannot be clearly established due to the possible association of other factors, e.g., individual or environmental factors.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; SARS-CoV-2; oral health; oral lesion; oral manifestation
Year: 2022 PMID: 35456297 PMCID: PMC9029624 DOI: 10.3390/jcm11082202
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Clin Med ISSN: 2077-0383 Impact factor: 4.964
Inclusion and exclusion criteria according to the PICOS.
| Parameter | Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Population | SARS-CoV-2 positive patients—aged from 0 to 99 years, both genders | patients with other infectious diseases |
| Intervention | not applicable | |
| Comparison | not applicable | |
| Outcomes | determined the presence of oral manifestations, including oral lesions | determined only the presence of gastrointestinal manifestations, such as dysphagia |
| Study design | case-control, cohort and cross-sectional studies, case series with min. 10 patients | literature reviews, case reports, expert opinion, conference reports |
| published between 2020 and 2022 | not published in English |
Figure 1Quality assessment, including the main potential risk of bias. (Risk level: green—low; yellow—unspecified; red—high. Quality score: green—good; yellow—intermediate; red—poor).
Figure 2PRISMA flow diagram presenting search strategy.
General characteristics of included studies.
| Author, Year, Setting | Study Design | Pandemic Period | Participants (F/M); Age [Years] | Comorbidities | Hospitalization and COVID-19 Treatment | Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria | General Manifestations with Frequency [%] | Smoking Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abubakr et al., 2021, Egypt [ | questionnaire study | 1 May to 1 July 2020 | 573 (408/165); 36.19 ± 9.11 (range: 19–50) | none | non-hospitalized; NR | Egyptian adults, 18–50 years old; laboratory-confirmed COVID-19 infection (PCR test); non-smokers; non-alcoholics; medically free; mild-to-moderate symptoms; good oral hygiene and not suffering from any oral manifestations before the pandemic | failure to complete the whole questionnaire; poor oral hygiene or any of the oral symptoms before the pandemic; chronic illnesses; smokers; alcoholics; serious COVID-19 infection, severe respiratory failure or required hospitalization | muscle pain (76.4), malaise (72.8), headache (70.0), fever (66.0), loss of smell (61.8), cough (55.5), sore throat (52.4), dyspnea (51.8), diarrhea (50.3) | non-smokers |
| Bardellini et al., 2021, Italy [ | retrospective cross-sectional study | March to April 2020 | 27 (8/19); 4.2 ± 1.7 (range: 3 months–14 years) | NR | hospitalized; NR | pediatric patients (aged 0–14 years old), laboratory evidence of COVID-19 infection, signed informed consent | NR | fever > 38 °C (55.5), mild febrile conditions (37.0), cough (37.0), rhinorrhea (25.9), difficulty in breathing (18.5) | NA |
| Biadsee et al., 2020, Israel [ | questionnaire study | 25 March to 15 April 2020 | 128 (70/58); 36.25 (range: 18–73) | hypertension ( | non-hospitalized; NR | diagnosed by RT-PCR and considered to have mild symptoms, according to the latest WHO joint report | questionnaires with missing information | cough (59.4), weakness (47.7), myalgia (46.9), fever (42.2), headache (40.6), impaired sense of smell (38.3), sore throat (26.6), runny nose (26.6), nasal congestion (22.7), gastrointestinal symptoms (18.8) | smokers ( |
| Bulut et al., 2021, Turkey [ | questionnaire study | September 2020 to March 2021 | 200 (125/75); ranges: 20–30: 89 (62/27), 31–40: 65 (43/22), 41–50: 27 (14/13), 51–60: 15 (4/11), 61–70: 4 (2/2) | NR | hospitalized (11.5); antiviral drugs (61.7), anticoagulant (16.9), hydroxychloroquine (12.3), antiaggregant (7.1), dexamethasone (5.2), antibiotics (5.2); not use any medication (27.9) | reported COVID-19 in anamnesis | age < 18 years | presence of symptoms (87.5) | NR |
| Eduardo et al., 2022, Brazil [ | retrospective cohort study | May 2020 to February 2021 | 472 (150/322);majority range: 51–80 | NR | hospitalized (ICU); orotracheal intubation (89.8), tracheostomy (5.1), nasal catheter (3.8) | adults of both genders, adequate information of oral cavity conditions during ICU hospitalization | oral medicine records without adequate information about gender, age, presence and type of mechanical ventilation, and oral conditions or information about | NR | NR |
| El Kady et al., 2021, Egypt [ | pilot questionnaire study | 15 May to 10 June 2020 | 58 (27/31); range: 18–46 | NR | hospitalized; NR | adults with SARS-CoV-2 infection confirmed by RT-PCR, and isolated in hospitals | NR | NR | NR |
| Elamrousy et al., 2021, Egypt [ | cross-sectional study | 2 September 2020, to 10 June 2021 | 124 (32/92); 50.32 ± 12.47 | diabetes ( | hospitalised; zithrocin (100.0), iverzine (100.0), zinc, vitamin C (100.0), anticoagulant (90.3), antibacterial (70.9), prednisolone (61.3), remdesivir (22.6), acetylcysteine (19.3), foradil (12.9), colchicine or hydroxychloroquine (12.9), antihypertensive (12.9), silymarin (3.2) | adults with SARS-CoV-2 infection confirmed by RT-PCR | without a laboratory-confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 infection, olfactory or gustatory impairment prior to COVID-19 infection, malignant neoplasms or neurodegenerative diseases | asthenia (67.7), breath problems (67.7), cough (67.7), fatigue (19.4), abdominal symptoms (12.9) | NR |
| Fantozzi et al., 2020, Italy [ | questionnaire study | 6 March to 30 April 2020 | 111 (53/58); median 57 (range: 48–67) | hypertension ( | hospitalized; NR | adults with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection | NR | fever (90.9), cough (46.8), dyspnea (34.3), diarrhea (4.5), sore throat (3.6), fatigue (3.6), myalgia/arthralgia (2.7), vomiting (2.7) | smokers ( |
| Favia et al., 2021, Italy [ | observational study | October to December 2020 | 123 (53/70); median 72 | NR | hospitalized; NR | adults with SARS-CoV-2 infection confirmed by RT-PCR after nasal and oropharyngeal swabs | certain pre-existing lesions, symptomatic of pre-existing systemic and local conditions previously diagnosed and well-known to the patients, as well as traumatic lesions; the asymptomatic and mild forms | fever, anosmia, cough, sore throat, congestion and runny nose, nausea or vomiting, muscle and body aches, dermatologic manifestation, pneumonia, dyspnea and hypoxia, acute respiratory distress syndrome, multi-organ failure | NR |
| Fidan et al., 2021, Turkey [ | prospective observational study | April to October 2020 | 74 (25/49); 51.4 ± 6.3 (range: 28–68) | NR | hospitalized; NR | infection confirmed by RT-PCR of nasopharyngeal swab | hormone therapy and/or steroid therapy in the one month prior to the study or taking any drugs that might affect oral lesion; oral lesions prior COVID-19 diagnosis | NR | NR |
| Ganesan et al., 2022, India [ | observational cross-sectional study | 18 October to 7 November 2020 | 500 (133/367); 53.46 ± 17.50 | NR | hospitalized; NR | hospitalized, age ≥ 16 years, treated in the institute | pediatric population, any other systemic conditions affecting oral mucosa | influenza-like illness (64.6), severe acute respiratory infection (18.4) | smokers ( |
| Gherlone et al., 202, Italy [ | retrospective and prospective cohort study | 23 July to 7 September 2020 | 122 (30/92); median 62.5 (IQR 53.9–74.1) | hypertension ( | hospitalized survivors; antibiotics (83.6), biologics (31.1), steroids (29.5) | adults admitted to the emergency department; positive SARS-CoV-2 nasopharyngeal swab on RT-PCR in the presence of clinical and/or radiological signs of COVID-19; signed the informed consent | NR | NR | smokers ( |
| Halepas et al., 2021, USA [ | retrospective cross-sectional study | 15 March to 1 June 2020 | 47 (23/24); 9.0 ± 5.0 (range: 1.3–20.0) | NR | hospitalized; NR | 21 years or younger, fever of prolonged duration, laboratory evidence of inflammation, required hospitalization, multiorgan involvement, confirmed positive COVID RT-PCR or serology test results | NR | multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children; fever > 5 days (100.0), systemic rash (68.1), conjunctivitis (57.5), vomiting (51.1), diarrhea (38.3), myocarditis (36.2), cervical lymphadenopathy (19.2), cough (14.9), irritability (14.9), cranial nerve palsy (12.8), pericardial effusion (12.8), extremity edema (12.8), arthritis (8.5), rhinorrhea (6.4) | NR |
| Katz and Yue, 2021, USA [ | registry study | NR | 895 (386/509); 0–9: 5.33%, 10–17: 2.47, 18–34: 39.9, 35–44: 11.1, 45–54: 1.2, 55–64: 11.2, 65–74: 12.3, 74–85: 16.5 | respiratory disease, endocrine disease, obesity, diabetes, circulatory disease | hospitalized; NR | diagnosis of COVID-19 ICD-10-U07.1 and/or ICD-10-K12.0 (recurrent aphthous stomatitis) | none | NR | smokers and non-smokers (NR) |
| Naser et al., 2021, Iraq [ | prospective study | August 2020 to March 2021 | 338 (138/200); mean 42.1 | hypertension ( | hospitalized; NR | diagnosed with COVID-19 + by PCR; age ≥ 10 years, with acute oral or perioral lesions either during admission or which appeared later during treatment; nonsmoker, no alcohol consumption | age ≤ 10 years; lesions appeared or were well established before SARSCoV-2 infection; not tolerating follow-up or refusing to enroll in study | NR | non-smokers |
| Natto et al., 2021, Saudi Arabia [ | pilot cross-sectional study | 28 July 28 to 5 October 2020 | 109 (36/73); 39.3 ± 12.4 | diabetes ( | non-hospitalized; NR | symptomatic and non-hospitalized, diagnosed with COVID-19 through a nasopharyngeal swab using RT-PCR | age < 18 years or suspected patients without any definitive diagnosis | muscle pain (77.1), fever (67.9), cough (50.5), headaches (49.5), no smell (44.0), sore throat (35.8), diarrhea (31.2), shortness of breath (22.0), nausea (20.2), runny nose (15.6), vomiting (9.2) | non-smokers (majority) |
| Nuno-Gonzalez et al., 2021, Spain [ | cross-sectional study | 10 to 25 April 2020 | 666 (386/280); mean 55.7 | NR | hospitalized; NR | positive RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2, or bilateral pneumonia; only adults; mild-to-moderate COVID-19 pneumonia | NR | NR | NR |
| Rafałowicz et al., 2021, Poland [ | observational study | until mid-2021 | 1256 | present (NR) | survivors—hospitalized (about 30.0); NR | infected with SARS-CoV-2 in the period from 2 to 6 months before the visit | NR | fever, malaise, anosmia, pneumonia, diarrhea, vomiting, fatigue, irritability, trouble sleeping and concentrating, sweating, amnesia, shortness of breath, palpitations | NR |
| Riad et al., 2020, Egypt [ | case series | April to August 2020 | 13 (8/5); 51.08 ± 8.79 (range: 34–62) | diabetes ( | non-hospitalized; dexamethasone ( | generalized pain and soreness within the oral cavity related mainly to non-keratinized mucosa without a specific cause; positive RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2 | NR | ageusia (30.8), fever (15.4), anosmia (15.4) | smokers ( |
| Riad et al., 2021, Egypt [ | case series | May to August 2020 | 18 (14/4); 35.11 ± 13.3 (range: 18–72) | NR | non-hospitalized; paracetamol ( | offensive oral malodor that precipitated notable psychosocial distress; positive RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2 | NR | fever (11.1), anosmia (11.1), dry cough (5.6), ageusia (5.6) | smokers ( |
| Riad et al., 2022, Egypt [ | case series | April to June 2020 | 26 (17/9); 36.81 ± 15.65 (range: 16–70) | none | non-hospitalized; paracetamol | pain in the tongue; positive RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2 | NR | fever (15.4), ageusia (11.5), sore throat (7.7), dry cough (3.8) | NR |
| Said Ahmed et al., 2021, Egypt [ | case series | NR | 14 (4/10); mean 54.2 | diabetes | hospitalized (71.4); NR | 14–30 days post COVID-19 recovery, complaining from pain, loss of one or more maxillary teeth, exposed bone, pus discharge, and bad odor | NR | NR | NR |
| Sinjari et al., 2020, Italy [ | observational study | May to June 2020 | 20 (9/11); mean 69.2 | hypertension ( | hospitalized; lopinavir/ritonavir and/or hydroxychloroquine | both gender and of any age, hospitalized for COVID-19, able to give consent to participate in the study | in need of intensive care and/or unable to give consent to participate in the study or unable to intend or to want | NR | smokers ( |
| Soares et al., 2022, Brazil [ | case series | NR | 14 (4/10); mean 58 (range: 23–88) | hypertension ( | non-hospitalized; NR | positive RT-PCR testing for SARS-CoV-2; oral lesions | NR | Dysgeusia, anosmia, fever, headache, dyspnea, dry cough | NR |
| Subramaniam et al., 2021, India [ | short-term observational study | April to June 2020 | 713 (297/416); range: 12–80 | diabetes, hypertension, asthma | hospitalized; multivitamins and vitamin C following prescribed treatment norms for the care of COVID-positive patients | both genders infected with SARS-CoV-2, diagnosed on RT-PCR in the age group of 12–80 years, admitted to the hospital | age < 12 and >80, not willing to give written informed consent, seriously ill requiring intensive care | complaints ranging from mild fever, sore throat, to difficulty in breathing | NR |
| Villarroel-Dorrego et al., 2022, Venezuela [ | observational study | NR | 55 (25/30); 51 ± 23.24 (range: 1–89) | hypertension ( | hospitalized (ICU: 34.5); combination of lopinavir and ritonavir, dexamethasone and remdesivir (ICU) | hospitalized with COVID-19 confirmed by PCR and a rapid antigen FIA diagnostic test | NR | NR | NR |
| Zarpellon et al., 2021, Brazil [ | case series | NR | 26 (15/11); mean 50 (range: 8–76) | hypertension or diabetes | hospitalized (ICU); mechanical ventilation support | SARS-CoV-2 positive deceased who were admitted in ICU | NR | severe acute respiratory syndrome | smokers ( |
Legend: F, females; M, males; NR, not reported; ICU, intensive care unit; RT-PCR, reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction; FIA, fluorescent immunoassay.
Detailed characteristics of included studies considering oral manifestations.
| Author, Year | Investigation | Prevalence of Oral Manifestations [%] | Type of Oral Manifestations with Location and Frequency [%] |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abubakr et al., 2021 [ | self-report survey | 71.7 | loss of taste (55.5), xerostomia (47.6), oral or dental pain (23.0), ulcerations (20.4), pain in jaw bones or joint (12.0), halitosis (10.5); 2 or 3 manifestations simultaneously (28.3) |
| Bardellini et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 55.6 | taste alteration (11.1), oral pseudomembranous candidiasis (7.4), geographic tongue (3.7), coated tongue (7.4) and hyperemic pharynx (37.0) |
| Biadsee et al., 2020 [ | self-report survey | NR | xerostomia (56.3), changes in taste sensation (52.3), masticatory muscle pain (11.7), change in sensation in the tongue (9.4), swelling in the oral cavity (7.8): 4 in the palate, 4 in the tongue and 2 in the gums, plaque-like changes in the tongue (7.0), oral bleeding (4.7) |
| Bulut et al., 2021 [ | self-report survey | NR | taste loss (53.0), halitosis (21.0), oropharyngeal wound and pain (18.0), pain in the chewing muscles (16.0), pain in the temporomandibular joint (17.5), gum bleeding (17.5), xerostomia (38.0, after recovery 12.0), aphthous ulcer (14.5), sensitivity and/or pain in teeth (12.0), herpes labialis (8.5), burning in the tongue (7.5) |
| Eduardo et al., 2022 [ | physical examination | 51.3 | mechanical trauma (18.1), viral infection (11.4), unspecific erosive lesions (10.5), petechial/hematoma (10.5), dryness of oral mucosa (9.9), oral bleeding (7.5), dryness of lips (6.0), dental associated lesions (6.0), candidiasis (5.4), edema (3.6), sialorrhea (3.3), tongue coating (3.0), varicose (2.4); 2 or 3 concomitant alterations (23.2) |
| El Kady et al., 2021 [ | self-report survey | 67.2 | dry mouth (39.7), gustatory dysfunction as loss of salt sensation (34.5), loss of sweet sensation (29.3), and altered food taste (25.9), burning sensation in mouth or tongue (22.4), difficult swallowing (22.4), oral ulcers (17.2), spots of mouth or lips (13.8), pain or swelling in the salivary gland or cheek (13.8), pain or swelling below the mandible (10.3), tongue redness (8.8), gingival bleeding (7.0) |
| Elamrousy et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 90.3 | dry mouth (83.9), ulcers (81.3), taste loss (54.8), candidiasis (37.5), hyperpigmentation (22.6), atrophic tongue (15.6), petechiae (15.6), burning sensation (14.3), tongue coating (9.4), herpes infection (6.3), white lesions (6.3); tongue (75.0), labial mucosa (59.4), buccal mucosa (46.9), lips (40.6) floor of mouth (34.4) and gingiva (12.5) |
| Fantozzi et al., 2020 [ | survey | NR | taste dysfunction (59.5), xerostomia (45.9), swallowing difficulties (18.0) |
| Favia et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 65.9 | ulcerative lesions (52.8), hyperplasia of papillae (39.0), candidiasis (22.7), blisters (15.4), petechial (11.4), angina bullosa (8.9), ulcero-necrotic gingivitis (5.6), geographic tongue (5.6) and fissured tongue (4.0) |
| Fidan et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 78.4 | aphthous-like ulcer (36.5), erythema (25.7), lichen planus (16.2); tongue (31.8), buccal mucosa (27.0), gingiva (14.9), palate (5.4) |
| Ganesan et al., 2022 [ | physical examination | NR | alteration in taste sensation (51.2), xerostomia (28.0), erythematous macules with burning sensation (7.2), atrophic glossitis (4.6), non-specific solitary ulcers (3.0), candida-like lesions (1.0), white patch (1.0), ductal inflammation (0.4) |
| Gherlone et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 83.9 | salivary gland ectasia (43.0), white tongue (29.0), dry mouth (24.0), masticatory muscle weakness (19.0), oral ulcers (11.0), temporomandibular joint abnormalities (7.0) |
| Halepas et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 55.3 | red or swollen lips (48.9), strawberry tongue (10.6) |
| Katz and Yue, 2021 [ | physical examination | NR | recurrent aphthous stomatitis (0.67; OR = 14.0) |
| Naser et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | NR | loss of taste (79.5), white coats of the tongue (31.6), pain related to the oral cavity (27.8), multiple aphthous ulceration (24.8), dryness (24.5), dysphagia (23.0), white coats of cheeks and gingiva (22.4), white coats of the palate (15.6), single aphthous ulceration (9.1) |
| Natto et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 53.2 | loss of taste (43.4), erythema/desquamated gingivitis (7.3), coated tongue (7.3), ulcers/blisters (6.4) |
| Nuno-Gonzalez et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 11.7 | anterior U-shaped lingual papillitis (5.3), aphthous stomatitis (3.2), tongue swelling (3.0), burning sensation in the mouth (2.4), mucositis (1.8), glossitis with patchy depapillation (1.8), candidiasis (0.5), enanthema (0.3) |
| Rafałowicz et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | NR | discoloration, ulceration, and hemorrhagic changes on the oral mucosa (32.0), mycosis located on the tongue (29.7), unilateral (more often left-sided) aphthous-like lesions on the hard palate (25.8), atrophic cheilitis (12.5); approx. 60% salivary secretory disorders in the initial period of infection, which in 6.68% prolonged up to 4 months after systemic symptoms disappeared |
| Riad et al., 2020 [ | physical examination | NA | mucositis (intraoral pain, sporadic erythema with minor irritations); all over the mouth (53.8), on the buccal mucosa (30.8), palate (15.4), and gingiva (7.7) |
| Riad et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | NA | halitosis (the majority with ‘fair’ level of oral hygiene, except for two patients (11.1) with a ‘poor’ level, while one patient (5.5) further complicated by an intraoral ulcer) |
| Riad et al., 2022 [ | physical examination | NA | tongue ulcers (92.3 of them not bleeding, ranged between 1 and 7 ulcers per patient, and their size ranged between 1 and 5 mm corresponding to herpes-like ulcers with scalloped borders); all of them manifested on dorsum or side of the tongue, while 4 (15.4) on the ventral surface |
| Said Ahmed et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | NA | maxillary mucormycosis osteomyelitis |
| Sinjari et al., 2020 [ | self-report survey | NR | xerostomia (30.0), impaired taste (25.0), difficulty in swallowing (20.0, burning sensation (15.0) |
| Soares et al., 2022 [ | physical examination | 100.0 | petechial, ecchymosis, reddish macules, and chronic ulcers with more than 7 d of evolution, vesiculobullous eruptions; only the palate (57.1), tongue (28.6), either the lip or palate (14.3) |
| Subramaniam et al., 2021 [ | physical examination | 1.26 | ulcers on the buccal mucosa, burning sensation, generalized mucositis on the labial mucosa, erythema of tongue margins, tongue papillary atrophy, bilateral angular cheilitis, reddish-white spots on the palate |
| Villarroel-Dorrego et al., 2022 [ | physical examination | 40.0 | alteration or a total loss of taste (60.0), pain or burning in the mouth (36.4), xerostomia (27.3), candidiasis (12.7), hemorrhagic ulcerative lesions (7.3), multiple ulcerations resembling cancer sores (5.5), lingual varicose veins (5.5), migratory glossitis (5.5), enanthems in the labial or cheek mucosa (3.6), severe angular cheilitis (1.8), white plaques (1.8) and lichenoid lesions (1.8), recurrent cold sore (1.8) |
| Zarpellon et al., 2021 [ | physical examination (post mortem) | NA | vesiculo-bullous and ulcerative lesions in the oral mucosa, such as tongue, lips and buccal mucosa |
Legend: NR, not reported; NA, not applicable.
Figure 3Forest plot presenting the summarised prevalence of oral manifestations among SARS-CoV-2 positive individuals.
Figure 4Forest plot presenting the summarized prevalence of xerostomia among SARS-CoV-2 positive individuals.
Figure 5Forest plot presenting the summarized prevalence of ulcerations among SARS-CoV-2 positive individuals.
Figure 6Forest plot presenting the summarized prevalence of taste alterations among SARS-CoV-2 positive individuals.