Vince S Siu1, Minhua Lu1, Kuan Yu Hsieh1,2,3, Kierstyn Raines1, Youssef A Asaad1, Krishna Patel1, Ali Afzali-Ardakani1, Bo Wen1, Russell Budd1. 1. IBM T.J. Watson Research Center, Yorktown Heights, New York 10598, United States. 2. Institute of Biomedical Engineering, College of Electrical and Computer Engineering, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu 30010, Taiwan. 3. Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, College of Electrical and Computer Engineering, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu 30010, Taiwan.
Abstract
This paper reports on a low-cost, quantitative, point-of-care solution for the early detection of nitrite, a common biomarker for urinary tract infections (UTIs). In a healthy individual, nitrite is not found in the urine. However, a subject with a suspected UTI will produce nitrite in their urine since the bacteria present will convert nitrate into nitrite. Traditionally, nitrite is monitored by urinary dipsticks that are either read by eye or using a reflectance spectrophotometer. Both methods provide a semiquantitative positive or negative result at best. In this paper, we described a novel, affordable, portable transmission-based colorimeter for the quantitative measurement of nitrite. A unique permutation of the Griess reaction was optimized for the clinical detection of nitrite in urine and is reported. By using nitrite spiked in a salt buffer, artificial, and human urine samples, the performance of the colorimeter was evaluated against dipsticks read using two commercial dipstick analyzers, Urisys 1100 (Roche Diagnostics) and Clinitek Status+ (Siemens Medical Solutions). The colorimeter was able to detect the clinically relevant range of nitrite from 0.78 to 200 μM in a salt buffer. The detection limit in artificial urine was determined as 1.6 μM, which is ∼16× more sensitive than commercial dipstick reflectance analyzers, enabling the possibility for earlier detection of urinary infections. The colorimeter is assembled using off-the-shelf components (<$80) and controlled by a smartphone application via low-energy bluetooth. It has a built-in color correction algorithm and is designed to enable for a turbidity correction in samples containing bacteria or other cellular debris as well. The mobile application can display the nitrite concentration for a single sample or display the results over a period of time. Tracking urinalysis results longitudinally can help identify trends such as increases in nitrite concentrations over an individual's baseline and identify possible infections earlier. While the detection of nitrite was showcased here, this portable analyzer can be expanded to other colorimetric-based chemistries to detect a panel of biomarkers, which can improve the overall sensitivity and specificity of the desired assay.
This paper reports on a low-cost, quantitative, point-of-care solution for the early detection of nitrite, a common biomarker for urinary tract infections (UTIs). In a healthy individual, nitrite is not found in the urine. However, a subject with a suspected UTI will produce nitrite in their urine since the bacteria present will convert nitrate into nitrite. Traditionally, nitrite is monitored by urinary dipsticks that are either read by eye or using a reflectance spectrophotometer. Both methods provide a semiquantitative positive or negative result at best. In this paper, we described a novel, affordable, portable transmission-based colorimeter for the quantitative measurement of nitrite. A unique permutation of the Griess reaction was optimized for the clinical detection of nitrite in urine and is reported. By using nitrite spiked in a salt buffer, artificial, and human urine samples, the performance of the colorimeter was evaluated against dipsticks read using two commercial dipstick analyzers, Urisys 1100 (Roche Diagnostics) and Clinitek Status+ (Siemens Medical Solutions). The colorimeter was able to detect the clinically relevant range of nitrite from 0.78 to 200 μM in a salt buffer. The detection limit in artificial urine was determined as 1.6 μM, which is ∼16× more sensitive than commercial dipstick reflectance analyzers, enabling the possibility for earlier detection of urinary infections. The colorimeter is assembled using off-the-shelf components (<$80) and controlled by a smartphone application via low-energy bluetooth. It has a built-in color correction algorithm and is designed to enable for a turbidity correction in samples containing bacteria or other cellular debris as well. The mobile application can display the nitrite concentration for a single sample or display the results over a period of time. Tracking urinalysis results longitudinally can help identify trends such as increases in nitrite concentrations over an individual's baseline and identify possible infections earlier. While the detection of nitrite was showcased here, this portable analyzer can be expanded to other colorimetric-based chemistries to detect a panel of biomarkers, which can improve the overall sensitivity and specificity of the desired assay.
Typically, dipsticks
are used to measure the concentration of different
analytes in urine. Dipsticks are disposable, inexpensive to manufacture,
easy-to-use, and read visually by eye. However, these readings are
subjective and error-prone, and the accuracy is highly dependent on
(1) proper sample preparation, (2) correct interpretation of the reference
color scale, and (3) precise timing of the readout. Proper sample
preparation involves using a dip-and-wipe method of submerging the
dipstick into the sample and then carefully wiping the edge of the
dipstick along the rim of a cup to remove excess liquid. This ensures
that each test pad is exposed to the correct volume of liquid. A test
pad that is exposed to too little or too much liquid can introduce
errors in the color readout. The different shades of color of the
test pad will vary depending on the illumination conditions, causing
potential errors when the dipstick is read visually by eye. Individuals
who are color-blind would inherently be unable to read and interpret
these dipsticks. Moreover, a typical urine test strip has five or
more test pads that may need to be read at different times. For example,
the glucose test pad needs to be read at 30 s, nitrite and protein
need to be read at 60 s, and leukocytes can be read at 120 s after
dipping into the liquid. Having several reagent pads with the same
readout time and requiring the user to interpret the results simultaneously
against a reference scale marked on the bottle may be difficult for
an untrained user. Given these challenges of dipstick urinalysis,
it is difficult to obtain good accuracy with dipsticks when used in
an at-home environment.In order to improve the accuracy of
dipsticks for at-home testing,
several companies, such as Healthy.io[1] and
Scanwell Health,[2] have included the use
of a smartphone to take an image of the dipstick where the color is
interpreted using built-in algorithms to eliminate user subjectivity.
Other researchers have created a device that controls for uniform
lighting and uses video captured by a smartphone to interpret the
color and results.[3] Other groups have opted
to use paper-based microfluidics to control the sample flow and filter
out particles to improve detection sensitivity.[4] However, for all these methods, the dipstick readout is
still semiquantitative at best.In the clinic, benchtop-sized
reflectance photometers such as the
Urisys 1100 from Roche Diagnostics (Indianapolis, IN) and the Clinitek
Status+ from Siemens Medical Solutions (Malvern, PA) are used to electro-optically
read the colored pads on a dipstick. A user would place the test strip
into a sliding tray, and the measurement is done by capturing the
reflected light from three LEDs positioned at a fixed angle above
the reading zone.[5] Although present day
reagent strips and reflectance photometers have reached a high degree
of perfection, there still exists a number of intrinsic drawbacks.
For example, using reflected light, the background of the test strip
can interfere with the lower limits of sensitivity for many reagents.
While it is possible to modify the chemical composition of the reagents
to overcome this drawback, chemical modification is often expensive
and difficult. Moreover, reflectance photometers report only a binary
positive or negative readout in the case of nitrite, and a quantized
semiquantitative readout for other analytes like protein and creatinine.
This prevents other important metrics such as the protein-to-creatinine
ratio to be determined and tracked in conditions like chronic kidney
disease.Thus, a low-cost, portable, and cloud-enabled system
that can provide
a quantitative readout of analytes in urine would have great value
for at-home monitoring and tele-health applications. There has been
work reported on using capillary electrophoresis to monitor nitrite
in urine, but the >20 min sample processing time and washing steps
are complicated for an at-home user.[6−8] Several studies have
demonstrated microfluidic technologies that could help simplify sample
preparation and achieve precise control of sample volume. However,
these devices are often nonreusable and would add cost and complexity
to the system.[9−11] Other groups have developed low-cost, wireless spectrophotometers
to perform more quantitative measurements.[12,13] However, the use of a mini-spectrophotometer in the design can make
the device cost-prohibitive for use in an at-home setting.In
this paper, we describe an affordable, quantitative, portable,
transmission-based colorimeter that can measure nitrite in a salt
buffer and artificial and human urine samples. Nitrite is an important
biomarker for the early detection of urinary tract infections. The
bacteria such as Escherichia coli present
in an infection will convert the nitrate into nitrite, which is detectable
in urine. In one study, a positive nitrite detection in urine suggests
99% likelihood to indicate a UTI in children of any age.[14] We explored various permutations of the Griess
reaction, a well-known scheme for nitrite detection, and optimized
a set of reagents for transmission-based measurements. We compared
the performance of the colorimeter with dipsticks read on two reflectance-based
dipstick analyzers: the Chemstrip 10+SG test strip read using the
Urisys 1100 and the Multistix 10SG test strip read using the Clinitek
Status+ (Figure a).
We found that our transmission-based instrument can detect nitrite
as low as 1.6 μM, about 16× more sensitive than the reflectance-based
analyzers. A table comparing the performance of our colorimeter and
other high performance devices is provided in Table S1. A more sensitive nitrite detection can enable earlier
UTI detection and treatment. We also demonstrated the use of a mobile
application to report the nitrite concentration for a single event
as well as to display readings captured over time. Any increase in
nitrite observed over time is also another indicator for the onset
of an infection. This device is a first step to bringing an affordable,
portable, quantitative urinalysis for at-home patient monitoring.
Figure 1
(a) Example
of two Roche Chemstrip 10+SG and Siemens Multistix
10SG urine dipsticks dipped in a 5 mM hydrion buffer solution of 0
and 200 μM nitrite at pH 5.4. The dipsticks were read by the
Roche Urisys 1100 and Siemens Clinitek Status+ analyzers, respectively.
(b) Image of the quantitative, transmission-based colorimeter, Android
phone, and cuvettes containing reagents for nitrite detection. (c)
Schematic showing the top and bottom views of the colorimeter and
its internal components. (d) Cross-section view of A-A shows the placement
of the two photodetectors (PD) of the transmitted and scattered light
paths.
(a) Example
of two Roche Chemstrip 10+SG and Siemens Multistix
10SG urine dipsticks dipped in a 5 mM hydrion buffer solution of 0
and 200 μM nitrite at pH 5.4. The dipsticks were read by the
Roche Urisys 1100 and Siemens Clinitek Status+ analyzers, respectively.
(b) Image of the quantitative, transmission-based colorimeter, Android
phone, and cuvettes containing reagents for nitrite detection. (c)
Schematic showing the top and bottom views of the colorimeter and
its internal components. (d) Cross-section view of A-A shows the placement
of the two photodetectors (PD) of the transmitted and scattered light
paths.
Results and Discussion
Colorimeter Device Design
The colorimeter is a hand-held
device housed in a 70 × 70 × 21.5 mm3 3D-printed
casing (Figure b).
Samples are measured using 10 mm path length poly(methyl methacrylate)
(PMMA) cuvettes, which have an optimum transmission in the visible
spectral range from 340 to 800 nm. The colorimeter was designed to
operate in ambient conditions. Top and bottom views of the colorimeter
and the placement of its internal components are shown in Figure c, and an electronic
schematic of all the components and connections is provided in Figure S1. In the sample slot, there is a pair
of multiwavelength light-emitted diodes (LED) and a photodetector
placed on opposite sides for transmission measurement. The LED is
located 8.6 mm from the inside bottom of the cuvette, and a minimum
sample volume of 0.8 mL is needed to generate a reproducible transmission
reading from a given sample (Figure S2).
A second photodetector is placed at 90° to the LED to capture
the scattered light that is used for turbidity measurements. A surface-mount
red–green–blue–white (RGBW) neopixel LED from
Adafruit is used as the light source and was selected for its small
form factor and digital control. The LED emitting colors had the following
peak wavelengths: red (620–625 nm), green (522–525 nm),
and blue (465–467 nm). The white wavelength is a quasi-white
light generated from the mixture of the RGB wavelengths.[15] The LED is mounted outside of the cuvette holder
with a small aperture to expose the LED pixels. The photodetector
is installed behind a baffle that is located 10 mm from the aperture
to eliminate interference from stray light. Figure d provides a cross-sectional view of the
transmitted and scattered light paths. An Arduino controller board
with low energy bluetooth capability, such as the Adafruit Feather
M0 Bluefruit Low Energy board, was used to control the operation of
the LEDs and the photodetectors. It was also used to communicate with
an Android smartphone via an application developed
for data collection, analysis, and storage. The Android application
can display the concentration of nitrite for a single event or a set
of readings over time.
Selection of Nitrite Detection Reagents
Four chemical
reactions based on the Griess reaction were identified and evaluated
for thte detection of nitrite in a 5 mM hydrion buffer (Scheme ). The Griess reaction consists
of an aniline derivative and a coupling reagent in an acidic solution.
The most common arrangement uses sulfanilamide with N-(1-naphthyl)ethylenediamine dihydrochloride (NED) (Reaction 1) and
has been established as the European standard for measuring nitrite
concentration in drinking water (BS EN ISO13395).[16,17] When a sample containing nitrite is added, the nitrite ions react
with sulfanilamide in a Griess diazotization reaction to form a diazonium
salt. This salt then reacts with NED to form a reddish-pink azo dye
that can be quantified using a spectrophotometer to determine the
nitrite concentration. Some common aniline derivatives including p-arsanilic acid, nitroaniline, and p-aminoacetophenone
and other coupling reagents such as 3-hydroxyl-1,2,3,4 tetrahydrobenzo-(h)-quinoline (THBQ) can be used to change the sensitivity
and solubility of the azo dye formation in solution. Reactions 2 and
3 are the chemistries used on the Roche Chemstrip and Siemens Multistix
urine dipsticks, respectively.[18−20] Reaction 4 is a permutation of
Reactions 1 and 3. While the Griess reaction is well-known for detection
of nitrite in solution, we are not aware of studies that characterize
and optimize the reaction for use in transmission measurements of
urinary nitrite in a clinically relevant range.
Scheme 1
Schematic of Four
Chemical Reactions Based on the Griess Reaction
to Detect Nitrite in Solution
Reaction 1 has been
established
as the European standard for determining nitrite concentrations in
drinking water. Reactions 2 and 3 are the nitrite detection chemistries
used on the Chemstrip dipstick by Roche and Multistix dipstick by
Siemens, respectively. Reaction 4 is a permutation of Reactions 1
and 3.
Schematic of Four
Chemical Reactions Based on the Griess Reaction
to Detect Nitrite in Solution
Reaction 1 has been
established
as the European standard for determining nitrite concentrations in
drinking water. Reactions 2 and 3 are the nitrite detection chemistries
used on the Chemstrip dipstick by Roche and Multistix dipstick by
Siemens, respectively. Reaction 4 is a permutation of Reactions 1
and 3.Reactions 1–4 were characterized
for reproducibility, pH
independence, limit of detection, and stability in a 5 mM hydrion
salt buffer containing varying known amounts of nitrite. All four
reactions were reproducible across 10 readings, and the same response
was achieved in solutions of pH 4.3 and pH 7.9. Reactions 1 and 4
had a detection limit of 0.78 μM, which is 8× more sensitive
than Reactions 2 and 3. Using THBQ, we noticed a brownish-yellow background
coloration even at the lowest concentrations of nitrite (Figure S3a,b). Although the colorimeter has a
built-in color correction algorithm, we opted to further evaluate
Reactions 1 and 4 which use NED, since the samples remained colorless
even at the lower nitrite concentrations. One explanation is that
NED is more polar than THBQ as a coupling reagent, hence it will form
a more soluble dye in the acidic aqueous medium. It was observed that
the solution mixture of Reaction 1 turned pink over time, perhaps
due to some impurities in the sulfanilamide powder. Since the solution
mixture of Reaction 4 containing p-arsanilic acid
and NED remained colorless over time, it was chosen and used as the
primary nitrite detection scheme for subsequent experiments (Figure S3c).The detection reagents from
Reaction 4 was validated against a
nitrite detection kit from Sigma (Cat No: 23479) using a SpectraMax
i3x benchtop spectrophotometer. Samples were prepared containing nitrite
ranging from 0.78 to 100 μM in a 5 mM hydrion salt buffer at
pH 7.0. The Sigma kit has a suitable nitrite detection range between
6.25 and 100 μM. The detection reagents in Reaction 4 were well-correlated
with the kit when read using the spectrophotometer (Figure a). Interestingly, the Griess
reagents from the kit had a narrower dynamic range of nitrite detection
compared with the reagents in Reaction 4 as seen by the standard curves
in Figure S4a. In the linear range of the
Sigma kit, the spectrophotometer reading of the kit is similar to
the measurements from the colorimeter using reagents in Reaction 4
(Figure S4b).
Figure 2
(a) Comparison of the
measured nitrite concentration using detection
reagents from the Sigma nitrite detection kit (red circles) and the
reagents described in Reaction 4 of this work (black squares). The
yellow box depicts the suitable nitrite detection range of the Sigma
kit. (b) Comparison of the measured versus the prepared nitrite concentrations
using reagents described in Reaction 4 on a SpectraMax i3x spectrophotometer
(red circles) and a colorimeter (black squares).
(a) Comparison of the
measured nitrite concentration using detection
reagents from the Sigma nitrite detection kit (red circles) and the
reagents described in Reaction 4 of this work (black squares). The
yellow box depicts the suitable nitrite detection range of the Sigma
kit. (b) Comparison of the measured versus the prepared nitrite concentrations
using reagents described in Reaction 4 on a SpectraMax i3x spectrophotometer
(red circles) and a colorimeter (black squares).Next, measurements on the colorimeter and the spectrophotometer
were compared using samples with known nitrite concentrations in a
5 mM hydrion salt buffer at pH 7.0. Both the colorimeter and spectrophotometer
detected nitrite between 3.125 to 100 μM and were well-correlated
(Figure b). This suggests
the colorimeter could be used for quantitative measurements, and coupled
with its lightweight and portable form-factor, the colorimeter could
be translated for at-home use.
Nitrite Detection in 5
mM Hydrion Salt Buffer
Serial
dilution was used to prepare nitrite samples between 0 and 200 μM
in a 5 mM hydrion salt buffer at pH 4.3, 5.4, 6.3, 7.3, and 7.9. The
samples were spiked into the PMMA cuvettes containing the nitrite
detection reagents. Each reaction occurs very rapidly with a minimal
decrease in signal after 60 s. In this study, measurements were taken
using the colorimeter after 10 min to ensure each reaction achieved
steady-state as shown by the reaction kinetics data in Figure S5. Figure a shows the performance of the colorimeter measuring
these samples with a nitrite detection limit of 0.8 μM in the
salt buffer. Since the azo-dye product formed from the Griess reaction
causes the solution to turn pink, the maximum absorption peaks occur
at the green wavelengths. Thus, the transmitted light intensity from
the green channel was used to determine the nitrite concentration,
since it was most sensitive to any variations in concentration (Figure S6).
Figure 4
(a) Transmitted intensity was measured using the colorimeter as
a function of nitrite concentration for nitrite samples prepared in
5 mM hydrion buffer solution with pH ranging from 4.3 to 7.9. (b)
Nitrite concentrations determined from colorimeter measurements taken
in artificial urine (AU) (pH 5–8) spiked with varying concentrations
of nitrite. The yellow box indicates the detectable sensing range
for the dipsticks read using the Siemens and Roche reflectance photometers.
Cuvettes containing nitrite detection reagents mixed with nitrite
samples are shown.
The nitrite samples were also
read using the Chemstrip and Multistix dipsticks and their respective
reflectance photometers, a Urisys 1100 and a Clinitek Status+. The
nitrite reagent area on a urine dipstick will turn from white to pink
in the presence of nitrite. This can happen if an individual has a
urinary tract infection (UTI), where Escherichia coli or other bacteria reduce the nitrate in urine to nitrite.[14,21,22] Since nitrite is not present
in healthy urine, any degree of pink coloration would be interpreted
as a positive result.Both the Roche and Siemens dipsticks were
used to measure nitrite
in the same samples prepared for the colorimeter. While a few samples
containing 12.5 μM nitrite were reported as positive by the
analyzer at different pH values, it was found that a sample must contain
a minimum of 25 μM of nitrite to generate a positive response
in a reproducible manner (Figure ). In comparison, the colorimeter was able to detect
nitrite as low as 0.8 μM in a salt buffer, equating to a ∼32×
improvement in sensitivity.
Figure 3
Array of nitrite pads stitched from cropped
images of independent
Chemstrip 10+SG and Multistix 10SG dipsticks dipped in buffers with
varying concentrations of nitrite and pH. The dipsticks were read
by a Roche Urisys 1100 and a Siemens Clinitek Status+ analyzer. Minus
and plus signs on each pad indicate a negative or positive readout
from the two analyzers.
Array of nitrite pads stitched from cropped
images of independent
Chemstrip 10+SG and Multistix 10SG dipsticks dipped in buffers with
varying concentrations of nitrite and pH. The dipsticks were read
by a Roche Urisys 1100 and a Siemens Clinitek Status+ analyzer. Minus
and plus signs on each pad indicate a negative or positive readout
from the two analyzers.
Nitrite Detection in Artificial
Urine
Similarly, nitrite
samples were prepared in artificial urine (AU) purchased from Pickering
Laboratories. Ready-to use artificial urine solution was chosen since
it closely resembled human urine. The formulation contained a nontoxic
perservative to avoid bacteria growth and has a pH of 6.5. A new calibration
curve was generated with samples containing known concentrations of
nitrite in artificial urine at pH 7.0 (Figure S7).Equation is the logistic equation used to fit the
data, where x is the measured transmitted intensity
value from the colorimeter
and y is the calculated nitrite concentration present
in the sample. For a series of samples spiked with varying amounts
of nitrite, the nitrite amount was calculated using the calibration
curve. This measured value was reported as a function of the actual
nitrite concentration spiked in the sample. The 45° diagonal
line is a reference line that shows perfect equality between the measured
nitrite concentration versus the prepared nitrite concentration (Figure b). Since all the values from the colorimeter lie closely on the
45° diagonal line, the readings from the colorimeter can be used
to determine the nitrite concentration in unknown samples with good
accuracy.(a) Transmitted intensity was measured using the colorimeter as
a function of nitrite concentration for nitrite samples prepared in
5 mM hydrion buffer solution with pH ranging from 4.3 to 7.9. (b)
Nitrite concentrations determined from colorimeter measurements taken
in artificial urine (AU) (pH 5–8) spiked with varying concentrations
of nitrite. The yellow box indicates the detectable sensing range
for the dipsticks read using the Siemens and Roche reflectance photometers.
Cuvettes containing nitrite detection reagents mixed with nitrite
samples are shown.While the dipstick analyzers
provide a binary negative or positive
determination of nitrite in a given sample starting at 25 μM,
the colorimeter can quantitatively determine exact values of nitrite
in samples from 0.8 μM in a salt buffer and 1.6 μM in
artificial urine up to 200 μM in clinically relevant pH values
from 5–8.
Color Correction Algorithm
Urine
can vary from a light,
pale straw color for a healthy individual to a dark, cloudy appearance
in someone who is dehydrated or sick. Urine can also appear pinkish,
red, or even blue depending on the food or medication taken. The color
of the urine will impact the transmission measurement and in turn
affect the accuracy of nitrite detection. Thus, it was necessary to
develop an algorithm to remove the color effects from the nitrite
measurements.The nitrite measurement and color correction were
performed using the colorimeter. Before the insertion of any sample
cuvettes, the on and off intensity for red (R), green (G), blue (B),
and white (W) lights are measured by flashing the R, G, B, and W LED
pixels on and off and taking the reading of a photo diode. Those readings
are denoted as I(cal,i),on for the on
intensity of RGBW and I(cal,i),off for
the off intensity, where i denotes for R,G,B, and W. Next, a sample
cuvette with no preloaded reagents is inserted into the colorimeter,
and the transmission intensity of RGBW light is measured through the
sample. Those readings are denoted as I(cal,(i)color for light on intensity and I(cal,(i)color,off for light off intensity. Finally, the sample is added to a cuvette
containing nitrite detection reagents, and the transmitted intensities
for RGBW light are measured again. Those measurements are denoted
as I(t,(i)nitrite and I(cal,(i)nitrite,off for on and off transmission intensities.
The color of the urine can be expressed as a 16-bit R,G,B value and
displayed on the mobile application using eq :A color correction calculation is applied
to determine the corrected
amount of nitrite present using eq :where i denotes
the red (R),
green (G), blue (B), and white (W) colors of the LED illumination
(I), and t stands for transmitted light.To
demonstrate the color effects on the detection of nitrite, we
added a water-soluble yellowish-brown dye into 10 mM phosphate buffer
(pH 6.0) and prepared solutions at 1/2, 1/4, 1/8, and 1/16 dilution.
Nitrite was spiked into the diluted dye solutions starting at 200
μM and was serially diluted to zero. A sample without any nitrite
added was included as a control. Figure a is a plot of the measured nitrite concentration
versus the known nitrite concentration in these prepared dye solutions
before and after the color correction. It is expected that the 1/2
diluted solution will appear the darkest with the least light transmitted
due to its color, while the 1/16 diluted solution will appear the
lightest and have the greatest light transmitted. Color correction
reduced the error in nitrite detection by as much as 15 μM,
which is significant for earlier UTI detection. Without color correction,
a sample with a nitrite concentration of 1.6 μM will be mistaken
as 12.5 μM in the 1/2 diluted solution.
Figure 5
Nitrite concentrations
calculated from colorimeter measurements
of varying concentrations of nitrite spiked into (a) sequential dilutions
of artificial urine (AU) containing a yellow dye additive, with and
without color correction, and (b) human urine (HU) samples with the
color correction algorithm applied.
Nitrite concentrations
calculated from colorimeter measurements
of varying concentrations of nitrite spiked into (a) sequential dilutions
of artificial urine (AU) containing a yellow dye additive, with and
without color correction, and (b) human urine (HU) samples with the
color correction algorithm applied.The performance of the colorimeter and the two dipstick analyzers
to detect nitrite spiked in four freshly collected human urine (HU)
is shown in Figure b. In a normal healthy urine sample, there should be zero nitrite
present. Applying the color correction algorithm to four human urine
samples spiked with varying concentrations of nitrite showed improved
correlation between the measured and known nitrite concentrations
in the sample. Three of the four human samples have nitrite values
that were slightly under-measured, suggesting potential interference
from the sample matrix. It was subsequently found that the presence
of urobilinogen can reduce the measured transmitted intensity (data
not shown), which will be investigated further.Besides color,
the turbidity of the sample can also affect the
accuracy of the colorimeter reading. A urine sample can appear turbid
if there are bacteria cells or other debris present. These particles
can scatter the incoming light and reduce the amount of light reaching
the in-line photodetector. To correct for the turbidity in a given
sample, the scattered light is measured using a second photodetector
placed at 90° to the in-line photodetector. If a sample is more
turbid, the higher amount of scattered light will be captured by this
second photodetector. Stabilized formazin turbidity standard sets
from Hach were used to generate a calibration curve between the turbidity
measurement from the colorimeter and the optical density of the same
samples measured using a NanoDrop spectrophotometer (ThermoFisher
Scientific). The plot of the optical density versus scattering intensity
was used to convert the measurement to a physical turbidity value
(Figure S8), and this is displayed on the
mobile phone application. For certain applications where the urine
sample may appear cloudy, perhaps due to an infection, the colorimeter
will be able to determine the level of cloudiness. Additional studies
with urine samples spiked with bacteria or cellular debris are needed
to develop and validate a turbidity correction algorithm that can
further improve the accuracy and sensitivity of the colorimeter for
nitrite detection.
Detection Reagent Stability
In order
for the assay
to be practically used, the nitrite detection reagents should be stable
at room temperature or a refrigerated environment for a prolonged
period of time. Initial stability studies were conducted by preparing
and storing nitrite detection reagents at room temperature, 4 °C,
and −20 °C and then testing these reagents with samples
containing various concentrations of nitrite in a 5 mM hydrion salt
buffer between 0 and 200 μM over a 25 day period. The nitrite
readings remained stable for at least 25 days, regardless of storage
temperature (Figure S9), suggesting that
the nitrite assay can be suitable for at-home or remote use. Further
work will investigate the ability to lyophilize the nitrite detection
reagents and determine the stability of the dried formulation.
Data Recording
and Monitoring
Nitrite values are displayed
on the Android mobile application after each measurement. The data
are stored locally on the mobile phone, and the results can be displayed
as a function of time. This tracking of nitrite values is important
to identify any trends such as increases in nitrite concentrations
over an individual’s baseline, since this can be used as another
indication for an infection. The application is programmed to highlight
when nitrite levels are normal and display a warning message if the
nitrite levels are high (Figure S10). In
the next iteration of the colorimeter, the goal is migrate the data
analytics and the storage of the data values onto a HIPAA compliant
cloud-based server, which would allow for the measurement data to
be easily accessible by clinicians or other members of a patient’s
healthcare team.
Conclusions
We have demonstrated
the first-step toward building an affordable,
portable colorimeter for the quantitative measurement of urinary nitrite
for at-home monitoring. The colorimeter is built from off-the-shelf
components (<$80) with a 3D-printable case. The device pairs via bluetooth to an Android phone that can store and report
single measurements as well as a time-series of stored results. The
Griess reaction used to detect nitrite on traditional dipsticks was
modified and optimized for use in a transmission-based environment.
The colorimeter can detect nitrite as low as 0.8 μM in a salt
buffer and 1.6 μM in artificial urine in a quantitative manner.
Compared with commercial dipstick reflectance photometers, the ∼16×
improvement in sensitivity for nitrite in artificial urine may be
useful in detecting and treating urinary tract infections earlier.
The nitrite detection reagents were stable for at least 25 days at
room temperature, 4 °C, and −20 °C. Next steps include
connecting the mobile application to a cloud-based server to perform
its data analytics and storage as well as multiplexing the colorimeter
to include additional biomarkers such as leukocytes, which are present
in the case of an infection. A multiplex panel of biomarkers will
improve the sensitivity and specificity of the overall assay and the
confidence it has to predict a given disease.
Materials and Methods
Chemicals
and Materials
Sulfanilamide, N-(1-naphthyl)ethylenediamine
dihydrochloride (NED), p-arsanilic acid, hydrochloric
acid (37%), and sodium nitrite were
of analytical reagent grade and purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St.
Louis, MO). The Sigma nitrite detection kit (Catalog No. 23479) was
also purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Hydrion buffer chemvelopes at various
pH values from 4.0 to 8.0 were purchased from MicroEssential Laboratories
(Brooklyn, NY). Artificial urine (Cat. No. 1700-0600) was purchased
from Pickering Laboratories (Mountain View, CA). Formazin beads were
from the Hach Company (Loveland, CO).
Preparation of Reagents
for Nitrite Detection
Using
the Griess reaction, which consists of combining an aniline derivative
and a coupling reagent in an acidic solution, four arrangements were
tested for nitrite detection using the colorimeter (Scheme ).[23] Reaction 1 was prepared by adding 0.25 g of sulfanilamide to 24.75
of mL distilled water followed by 0.25 mL of hydrochloric acid. The
mixture was well-mixed before 0.025 g of N-(1-naphthyl)-ethylenediamine
dihydrochloride (NED) was added. Reaction 2 was prepared by adding
0.05 g of sulfanilamide to 25 mL of methanol followed by 0.8 g of
citric acid and 0.0425 g of 3-hydroxyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydrobenzo-(h)-quinoline (THBQ). Reaction 3 was prepared by adding 0.0625
g of p-arsanilic acid to 25 mL of methanol followed
by 0.8 g of citric acid and 0.0425 g of THBQ. Lastly, Reaction 4 was
prepared by adding 0.0325 g of p-arsanilic acid to
24.75 mL of distilled water followed by 0.25 mL of hydrochloric acid
(37%). The mixture was well-mixed before 0.0025 g of NED was added.
Varying amounts of sodium nitrite were spiked into the hydrion salt
buffer, artificial, and human urine samples for testing.
Colorimeter
Measurement
To prepare a sample for measurement,
the colorimeter is first paired with an Android phone via bluetooth. By using the software application, an initial calibration
measurement is performed with no cuvette in the sample slot to correct
for any possible variations in the LED intensities. Next, a cuvette
with no detection reagents but only the sample added is inserted and
the color and turbidity of the sample are measured and recorded. Then,
1 mL of sample is added to the cuvettes containing 1 mL of detection
reagent and measured. For time-based measurements, the reaction is
measured using a colorimeter every 10 s for 10 min. For end-point
measurements, a series of 10 measurements are recorded and averaged
at 10 min after the reaction has reached a steady state. The software
application calculates the nitrite concentration based on the photodetector
reading and built-in calibration curve and color interference correction
algorithm. The turbidity measurements can in the future be used to
correct for any interference from the bacterial or cellular components
in the urine sample. The results are digitally displayed on the phone
screen and saved as a .csv file locally on the device for downstream
analytics.
Dipstick Measurement
Two commercial
dipsticks, Roche
Chemstrip 10+SG and Siemens 10SG, were chosen for nitrite detection.
The dipsticks were read by Roche Urisys 1100 and Siemens Clinitek
Status+ reflectance photometers, respectively. First, a clean dipstick
was dipped into a sample solution and wiped along the edge of the
container to remove excess liquid. Then, the dipstick was placed onto
the sample tray of the reflectance photometer and the on-screen instructions
were followed. Typically, results will be generated by the instrument
within 2 min of placing the dipstick on the sample tray.
Authors: Gennifer T Smith; Nicholas Dwork; Saara A Khan; Matthew Millet; Kiran Magar; Mehdi Javanmard; Audrey K Ellerbee Bowden Journal: Lab Chip Date: 2016-05-24 Impact factor: 6.799