| Authors | Country | Title | Objectives | Type of study | Target group and sample size | Study results |
|
Nisticò V, et al. (27)
| Italy |
The psychological impact of COVID-19 among asample of Italian individuals with High FunctioningASD
|
Assessing the prevalence of stress, anxiety,depression, and symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among a sample of 45 adults with a high-functioning ASD during the first two months of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy and according to a sample of 45 healthy controls.
|
A cross-sectional studyusing an online survey
|
Adults with ASD,45 person with high-functioning ASD under the age of 18 and 45 healthy controls
| Patients with high-functioning ASD suffer more from depression, anxiety, stress, and symptoms related to PTSD than the healthy group during the first two months of the COVID-19 pandemic. |
|
Rodríguez C, et al. (28)
| Cuba |
Psychological impact on children with ASD duringCOVID-19 confinement
|
To describe the psychologicaldisturbances ofASD childrenduring confinement byCOVID-19 and tostimulate the family toself-managepsychologicalresources to controlmisbehaviors
| A review study |
Providing a characterization of the manifestations in children with thisdisorder from detention by COVID-19 and providing psychological resources andgeneral guidelines to parents for immediate attention to the alterations presented bythese children to better cope with the period of confinement.
|
In crises like this pandemic, there are changes in ASD children’s mental health.Aggression, sleep disorders, irritability, screaming, and the occurrence of stereotyped behaviors are the most common changes.The Quarantine can be very challenging for autistic children who react inappropriately to their daily changes.
|
|
Asbury K, et al. (29)
| England |
How is COVID-19 Affecting the Mental Health of Children with SpecialEducational Needs and Disabilities and Their Families?
| Investigating the effect of coronavirus outbreak on the mental health of children with various disorders and special educational needs, and their families | A qualitative study | Participants were 241 parents or guardians of school-age children with various disorders and special educational needs in the UK, of whom 197 were autistic children. | Many families reported that COVID-19 affected their mental health, often leading to increased fear and anxiety. A few families also reported increased anxiety, low mood, and stress. The data suggest that parents experienced more stress and anxiety than children. But the frequency of fear was similar among parents and children |
|
Bent S, et al. (30)
| China |
The Experience of Parents of Children with ASDSpectrum Disorder During the COVID-19 Pandemic:A Qualitative Analysis
|
To identify some generalchallenges andhighlight strategies thatfamilies are currentlyusing to address theunique experiences ofsupporting a child withASD amidst aworldwide pandemic
| A qualitative study, including semi-structured telephone interviews with parents |
Fifteen parents of children and adolescents in a non-governmental school for children with level two and three of ASD(11 to 21 years old)
|
Parents discussed their experiences with social skills, e-learning, transfer,the structure, difficulty, and stress associated with COVID- 19, and the positive changes during the COVID-19 pandemic.
|
|
Colizzi M, et al. (31)
| Italy |
Psychosocial and Behavioral Impact of COVID-19 inASD: An Online Parent Survey
| Evaluation of the effect of COVID-19 pandemic on ASD patients and determining whether pre-pandemic social, demographic, or clinical characteristics predict adverse outcomes |
A cross-sectional, descriptive, qualitative study,an online parent survey
| Data from 527 participants, including parents and guardians of people with ASD, were available in the survey. |
The majority of the parents of ASD patients found the period of change and emergency restrictions as challenging. They need more commitment than ever.Many parents reported problems managing their children’s daily activities, especially regarding leisure and structured activities.Behavioral problems worsened in more than a third of the ASD patients.
|
|
Lee V,Et al.. (32)
| Canada |
Impact of COVID-19 on theMental Health and Wellbeing ofCaregivers and Families ofAutistic peopleA Rapid Synthesis Review
|
Identifying and eliminating knowledge gapsand providing evidence for the family’s desires, abilities, and perceptions of their current experiences with COVID-19.Providing a summary of evidence related to the mental health needs of caregivers and families of children andadolescents with ASD disorder in a short search period and a description of how these needs relate to family mental health and caregiver and resilience
| A Review study. Three types of search strategies were used in this study | Twenty-two articles were included in this review. |
Eleven articles published in research journals showed increasing social disorders such asJob loss, increased marital conflicts, and financial instability.Some reports showed increased behavioral challenges that lead to difficulty in parent-child interactions and tension in family relationships.Some studies showed that parents experienced increased anxiety and stress and needed more support.One in three empirical studies discussed the psychological distress, health challenges, and mental health in caregivers and families during the COVID-19 pandemic.
|
|
Charles E, et al. (33)
| America(USA) |
COVID-19 andAdults WithIntellectualDisability,ASD,Epilepsy,or BrainInjuries:Findings From an Online Survey
| Investigating the impact of the coronavirus pandemic in adults with a wide range of disabilities such as ASD | An online survey. The survey was available online from April 17, 2020, to May 1, 2020 | A total of 2469 adults afflicted with disabilities |
About 93% of respondents reported observing the pandemic’s recommendations, and 7% reported disregarding them.Respondents who felt anxious or depressed over COVID-19 were asked about their access to emotional and support services.About 80% reported having access to these services, and 20% reported inaccessibility to them.Around 72% of respondents received direct health care and services, and 76% continued to provide these services during the pandemic.But only 50% could keep a safe distance from each other.
|
|
Cassidy SA, et al. (17)
| Multi national (Canada, UK, USA) |
An expert discussion onASD in the COVID-19Pandemic
|
This roundtable,therefore, aims tobring together autisticadults, their families,practitioners, and academics across thefields of disabilityrights, public health,medicine, psychology,and mental healthacross differentcountries and contexts
| Commentary | 8 Participants |
Provide some issues that need to beaddressed during this epidemic,especially for adults with ASD. Things that can bedone during this period, suggestionsas well as opportunities that thispandemic has created for people.
|
|
Narzisi A. (19)
| Italy |
Handle the ASD spectrumcondition during Coronavirus(COVID-19) Stay at Homeperiod: Ten tips for helpingparents and caregivers ofyoung children
|
The main aim ofthis editorial is to givesome advice,summarized in 10 tips,to help families tohandle children withASD during this period.
| editorial | Italian colleagues |
COVID-19 is questioning the routine of our young children with ASD, and they are called to respect rules and habits that are not always understandable for them (i.e., disinfect your hands, do not touch your eyes or nose, and cover your mouth. They are also not able to see people they would like to meet and must stay at home).These changed routines could cause profound suffering for them. For this reason, we all (parents, therapists, and researchers) must be united andquickly establish new and functional routines to allow our young children to be safe and peaceful. As ASD experts we have to find different ways to get close to our patients and their families.
|
|
Ersoy K, et al. (34)
| Turkey |
The Comparison of Impact of Health Anxiety on Dispositional Hope and Psychological Well-Being of Mothers Who Have Children Diagnosed with ASD and Mother Who Have Normal Children, in COVID-19 Pandemic
|
It aimed to comparethe effect of healthanxiety on the dispositional hope and the psychological wellbeing levels between mothers with autistic children and mothers with normal children in the COVID-19 pandemic
|
An empiricalarticle–Quantitative
|
Participants of theresearchconstitute a totalof 126 mothers (60mothers withautistic childrenand 66 motherswith normalchildren) living inİstanbul
|
Results of the study revealed that the impact of health anxiety on the psychological wellbeing levels among mothers with autistic children are more substantial than it was among motherswith normal children. It wasfound that mothers with autisticchildren, compared to mothers withtypical children tended to have a higher level ofhealth anxiety about chronic diseases and were inclined tohave a lower level of dispositional hope and psychological wellbeing.
|
|
Degli Espinosa F, et al. (35)
| Italy |
A Model of Support for Families of Children With ASD Livingin the COVID-19 Lockdown: Lessons From Italy
| Include some parents’ comments at the end to share the parent perspective in real-time as this pandemic unfolds across the world |
Commentary– ABA Parentprotocol
| Parents of children with ASD |
Parental report of challengingbehavior; of theirability to maintain the agreed structure; direct measurements of children’s adherence to parental instructions; direct measurements of challenging behavior during the coaching session; and parents’ procedural fidelity
|
|
Stankovic M et al. (36)
| Serbia |
The serbian experience of challenges of parenting childrenwith asds during the COVID-19 pandemic andthe state of emergency with police lockdown
|
This study aims to provide acomprehensiveexploration ofchallenges experiencedby parentsof autistic childrenspectrum disorder(ASD) in Serbia duringthe COVID-19pandemic and policelockdown
|
An empiricalArticle –Quantitative
| A total of 85 parents completed a survey in this study (74% mothers, 22% fathers, 4% other relatives). |
The survey revealed a lack of support, feelings of helplessness, variouschallenges and needsamongst parents, which althoughwere present before, have become moreprominent during an emergency state. Atthebeginning of police lockdown, mostparents of the children withASD handled their children on theirown, which suggests that the government needs better plans and strategies for future similar situations.
|
|
Szabo TG et al. (37)
| USA |
From Helpless to Hero: Promoting Values-Based Behaviorand Positive Family Interaction in the Midst of COVID-19
| Focused on the ways to promote prosocial conduct at home by pointing out that these actions are reflections of superpowers possessed by children |
A commentary– Parentalguideline
|
Target group: Parents andSample size: not mentioned.
|
The current crisis has created an unprecedented demand for parent support. Still, it has also forced us to curtail in-person services and, instead, interact via phone and the Internet media. With simple exercises based on known principles, strategies, and kernels, behavior analysts connecting with parents online may promote positive parenting to the extent that had never happened before. We have focused on the ways topromote prosocial conduct athome by pointing out that these actions are reflections of superpowerspossessed by children. But it is equally valid that parents, navigating an unprecedented situation with no lead time, are the unsung heroes of thisera.
|
|
Brondino N et al. (38)
| Italy |
Effective Strategies for Managing COVID-19Emergency Restrictions for Adults with SevereASD in a Daycare Center in Italy
|
To evaluate the impact of restrictions on challenging behaviors in a sample ofindividuals with ASD and cognitive impairment attending a daycare center beforecomplete lockdown
| retrospective study |
A total of 18 youngadults, of which 13 are males that all presented severe ASD
|
At present, the COCID-19 emergency is still representing a massivepsychological overload for all individuals. Additionally, returning to the same level of activity as before the COVID-19 pandemic may not be easy. Our retrospective study did notshow a significant change in our individuals’ problematic behaviors with ASD after initiation of COVID-19 restrictions. We could cautiously hypothesize that the preventive countermeasures we adopted effectively reduced distress in individuals with ASD.
|
|
Jeste S et al. (39)
| USA |
Changes in access to educational and healthcare servicesfor individuals with intellectual and developmentaldisabilities during COVID‐19 restrictions
|
The objectives of this online survey were to understand the changes in access to services caused byCOVID-19 restrictionsfor individuals with geneticsyndromes associatedwith IDDs and to survey caregivers about helpful resources in both education and health care
| An online survey (with the online questionnaire) | A total of 818 respondents (669 within the USA and 149 outside the USA) |
COVID-19 restrictions have significantly affected the access to services forindividuals with syndromic IDDs. Telehealth may provideopportunities for the delivery of care and education in a sustainable way, not only as restrictions endure but also after being lifted.
|
|
Manning J et al. (40)
| USA |
Perceptions of Families of Individuals with ASDduring the COVID-19 Crisis
|
The primary aim wasto explore the extentand causes of stressorsexperiencedby families of individuals; and the secondary purpose was todetermine whetherthere was anassociation betweenworking status ofparent, level of severity of the individualwith ASD,and previous levels ofsupport on the currentexpressed distressdue to COVID-19.
| an online survey |
A total of 471 respondentswere included (offamilies inMichigan)
|
Our study revealed that during theCOVID-19 crisis, individuals with ASDand their families report high levels of stress and disruption to life. The most outstanding areas of stress were around isolation, illness, and finance, and we noted many free-text responses revealing a desire of families to communicate the burden with whichthey are living. Not surprisingly, the more severe symptoms the individual with ASD is reported to have, the greater the caregiver’s reported degree of stress. Additionally,caregivers report a higher degree ofstress when the individual with ASD isyounger, while they report individualswith ASD who are older areexperiencing greater stress.
|
|
Tromans S et al. (41)
| UK |
Priority concerns for people with intellectualand developmental disabilities during theCOVID-19 pandemic
|
To provide systematic andevidence-basedinformation of thepriority concerns forpeople withintellectual disabilitiesand orASD regarding the COVID-19 pandemic
| A cross-sectional study |
Thirty-twoorganizationswere contacted, of which 26 (81%) responded.
|
The recommendations highlight theexpectations of people withintellectual disabilities and or ASDin the current pandemic. It could support policymakers and professionals’ delivery and evidenceperson-centered care. They were askedto report the 5 highest-ranking concerns pertaining to the COVID-19pandemic in each of the followingthree domains:(a) mental health and challengingbehavior,(b) physical health and epilepsy, and(c) social circumstances and support.
|