Simone Nicolardi1, Renzo Danuser2, Viktoria Dotz3, Elena Domínguez-Vega1, Ali Al Kaabi2, Michel Beurret3, Chakkumkal Anish3, Manfred Wuhrer1. 1. Center for Proteomics and Metabolomics, Leiden University Medical Center, Albinusdreef 2, 2333 ZA Leiden, The Netherlands. 2. Janssen Vaccines AG (Branch of Cilag GmbH International), Rehhagstrasse 79, CH-3018 Bern, Switzerland. 3. Bacterial Vaccine Discovery & Early Development, Janssen Vaccines and Prevention B.V., Archimedesweg 4-6, 2333 CN Leiden, The Netherlands.
Abstract
Bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines have a major role in preventing microbial infections. Immunogenic bacterial glycans, such as O-antigen polysaccharides, can be recombinantly expressed and combined with specific carrier proteins to produce effective vaccines. O-Antigen polysaccharides are typically polydisperse, and carrier proteins can have multiple glycosylation sites. Consequently, recombinant glycoconjugate vaccines have a high structural heterogeneity, making their characterization challenging. Since development and quality control processes rely on such characterization, novel strategies are needed for faster and informative analysis. Here, we present a novel approach employing minimal sample preparation and ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry analysis for protein terminal sequencing and characterization of the oligosaccharide repeat units of bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines. Three glycoconjugate vaccine candidates, obtained from the bioconjugation of the O-antigen polysaccharides from E. coli serotypes O2, O6A, and O25B with the genetically detoxified exotoxin A from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were analyzed by MALDI-in-source decay (ISD) FT-ICR MS. Protein and glycan ISD fragment ions were selectively detected using 1,5-diaminonaphtalene and a 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid/2-hydroxy-5-methoxybenzoic acid mixture (super-DHB) as a MALDI matrix, respectively. The analysis of protein fragments required the absence of salts in the samples, while the presence of salt was key for the detection of sodiated glycan fragments. MS/MS analysis of O-antigen ISD fragments allowed for the detection of specific repeat unit signatures. The developed strategy requires minute sample amounts, avoids the use of chemical derivatizations, and comes with minimal hands-on time allowing for fast corroboration of key structural features of bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines during early- and late-stage development.
Bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines have a major role in preventing microbial infections. Immunogenic bacterial glycans, such as O-antigen polysaccharides, can be recombinantly expressed and combined with specific carrier proteins to produce effective vaccines. O-Antigen polysaccharides are typically polydisperse, and carrier proteins can have multiple glycosylation sites. Consequently, recombinant glycoconjugate vaccines have a high structural heterogeneity, making their characterization challenging. Since development and quality control processes rely on such characterization, novel strategies are needed for faster and informative analysis. Here, we present a novel approach employing minimal sample preparation and ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry analysis for protein terminal sequencing and characterization of the oligosaccharide repeat units of bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines. Three glycoconjugate vaccine candidates, obtained from the bioconjugation of the O-antigen polysaccharides from E. coli serotypes O2, O6A, and O25B with the genetically detoxified exotoxin A from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were analyzed by MALDI-in-source decay (ISD) FT-ICR MS. Protein and glycan ISD fragment ions were selectively detected using 1,5-diaminonaphtalene and a 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid/2-hydroxy-5-methoxybenzoic acid mixture (super-DHB) as a MALDI matrix, respectively. The analysis of protein fragments required the absence of salts in the samples, while the presence of salt was key for the detection of sodiated glycan fragments. MS/MS analysis of O-antigen ISD fragments allowed for the detection of specific repeat unit signatures. The developed strategy requires minute sample amounts, avoids the use of chemical derivatizations, and comes with minimal hands-on time allowing for fast corroboration of key structural features of bacterial glycoconjugate vaccines during early- and late-stage development.
The
emergence and spreading of antimicrobial-resistant (AMR) pathogenic
bacteria pose a threat to healthcare systems and economies worldwide.[1] In the United States (US) alone, more than 23,000
deaths a year are associated with AMR pathogens with an annual healthcare
cost of more than $4.6 billion.[2,3] Globally, AMR infections
could lead to 10 million deaths a year by 2050. Therefore, novel therapeutic
and prevention strategies are urgently needed to effectively manage
AMR infections.[4,5]Vaccination against pathogenic
bacteria prevents bacterial infections
and limits the use of antibiotic treatments thus reducing the occurrence
of antimicrobial resistance.[6] Several bacterial
vaccines are currently available to tackle bacterial infections, such
as meningococcal and pneumococcal diseases, diphtheria, tetanus, and
pertussis, and more are under development.[6−8] Bacterial vaccines
rely on a range of different technologies and designs.[6,9−11] Glycoconjugate vaccines are made of a carbohydrate
moiety, derived from either a bacterial capsule or an O-antigen polysaccharide
(O-PS), and a carrier protein.[12] The chemical
conjugation of these components requires multiple steps of purification,
detoxification, and chemical activation. In contrast, bioconjugation—the
recombinant, enzymatic production of a glycoconjugate directly in
bacterial cells—is a more straightforward and low-cost method
for the production of relatively pure glycoconjugate vaccines.[13] The coupling of the biosynthesized bacterial
polysaccharides and the carrier protein is carried out in bacterial
host cells, usually, Escherichia coli, using specific
enzymes such as the oligosaccharyltransferase PglB.[14−17] This technology has been recently used to develop glycoconjugate
vaccine candidates against E. coli serotypes O1,
O2, O6A, and O25B by coupling the serotype-specific O-antigens to
exotoxin A from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (EPA).[16,18−20]E. coli is an opportunistic
Gram-negative bacterium
commonly found in the gut of humans and other warm-blooded animals.
Commensal strains have a symbiotic relationship with the host while
pathogenic strains can cause severe extra-intestinal diseases such
as urinary tract infections, neonatal meningitis, and sepsis. Vaccines
against extra-intestinal pathogenic E. coli (ExPEC)
are needed to contrast the rising incidence of E. coli infections and the emergence of AMR strains.[21] The high strain diversity of E. coli is
shown by the ∼186 different O-types that have been identified
from the detection of different O-PSs.[22−25] The O-PS is a component of the
lipopolysaccharide (LPS) that is present on the outer membrane of
Gram-negative bacteria and is highly immunogenic. This characteristic
has been successfully used for the development of bacterial vaccines.[16,20,26]The bioconjugation of O-PSs
to a carrier protein can lead to a
highly heterogeneous glycoprotein. The biosynthesized polysaccharide
is polydisperse, as it is constituted of a varying number of repeat
units (RUs) formed of three to five monosaccharides. The polysaccharide
length can vary considerably ranging up to tens of repeat units. The
number of polysaccharide molecules conjugated to the carrier proteins
also varies, depending on the number of possible conjugation sites.
Consequently, the comprehensive analytical characterization of glycoconjugate
bacterial vaccines, needed to corroborate their structural integrity,
is not trivial and requires a multi-methods approach.[27]Mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful tool for the
analysis of complex
glycoproteins enabling the characterization of their amino acid sequence
and glycosylation.[28] Glycoproteins, i.e.
proteins containing oligosaccharides, have been successfully characterized
at different structural levels (i.e., released glycans, glycopeptides,
and intact protein), whereas the MS analysis of bioconjugated proteins
that contain O-PSs remains very challenging and is thus scarcely reported.[29−32] Nevertheless, useful structural information has been obtained by
MS from purified bacterial LPSs and O-PSs, often corroborating or
complementing the information obtained by NMR spectroscopy.[33,34] These molecules are difficult to ionize and often undergo fragmentation
during the ionization process. Consequently, O-PSs have been rarely
measured in their intact form. Instead, the analysis of their fragment
ions has allowed the determination of the monosaccharide composition
of the oligosaccharide repeat units.[35−37] This approach can be
used for the characterization of O-PSs of bioconjugated bacterial
vaccines.MALDI-in-source decay (ISD) is a fragmentation technique
that can
be applied to both intact proteins and polysaccharides.[38−40] The combination of MALDI-ISD with ultrahigh-resolution FT-ICR MS
enables the detailed analysis of both protein and carbohydrate fragment
ions over an extended m/z range.[39,41,42] Interestingly, MALDI-ISD of intact
glycoproteins has only provided protein sequence information through
the analysis of protein backbone fragment ions. To date, glycan information
has only been obtained through the detection of glycosylated protein
fragments (or their MS/MS analysis) and not from the direct detection
of glycan fragments that were generated from in-source fragmentation
of the glycan moieties from the proteins.[41,43] MALDI analysis is fast and robust and does not require upfront separation
techniques as often needed for ESI MS. MALDI is particularly suitable
for high-throughput analyses and features short measurement times.In this study, we propose a novel analytical strategy based on
ultrahigh-resolution MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS for the corroboration of
both the amino acid sequence and the composition of the oligosaccharide
repeat units of bioconjugated bacterial vaccines. Three different
glycoconjugate vaccines, obtained from the bioconjugation of the O-PSs
from E. coli serotypes O2, O6A, and O25B with EPA
protein, were analyzed. ISD fragment ions from the protein backbone
(i.e., c-, y-, and z-types) and the polysaccharide chains (i.e., B-,
C-, Y-types) were selectively detected using 1,5-diaminonaphthalene
and a 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid/2-hydroxy-5-methoxybenzoic acid mixture
(super-DHB), respectively. The proposed analytical strategy shows
potential for use in early and late development as well as quality
control (QC), for example, for screening of glycoconjugate variants
or for complementary analysis in a multi-methods approach.
Experimental
Section
Samples
The three different glycoconjugate vaccines
were obtained from the bioconjugation of the O-PSs from E.
coli serotypes O2, O6A, and O25B with EPA protein, using
recombinant E. coli production strains.[16,21] The samples, EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcoO25B, were provided by Janssen
Vaccines AG (Branch of Cilag GmbH International), Bern, Switzerland.
The bioproduction of the glycoconjugate vaccines was performed using
Protein Glycan Coupling Technology (PGCT).[14] Briefly, E. coli cells were bioengineered using
plasmids for the expression of the carrier protein EPA, the O-antigen
polysaccharides, and the oligosaccharyltransferase PgIB. In
the cells, the synthesis of the polysaccharide repeat units (RUs)
occurs at the cytoplasmic side on the inner membrane. They are built
upon an undecaprenyl pyrophosphate lipid molecule carrier to form
lipid-linked oligosaccharides (LLOs). The LLOs are then transferred
to the periplasm side where they are recognized by PglB which transfers
the polysaccharide chains onto acceptor sequons (D/E-X-N-X-S/T) on
the carrier protein to produce the N-glycosylated
glycoconjugate vaccine.The glycoconjugates were separated from
host-cell impurities by a series of conventional purification methods.
All glycoconjugate vaccines were then subjected to a structural and
compositional characterization at monosaccharide, intact protein,
and glycopeptide levels.
Buffer Exchange
The bioconjugates
were provided in
Bis-Tris/NaCl buffer. Prior to MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS analysis of the
carrier protein, samples were buffer-exchanged using reversed-phase
solid-phase extraction (SPE). To this end, 2 μL of bioconjugate
solution were added to 10 μL of water in a 500 μL Eppendorf
tube. A C18-ZipTip (Merck Millipore) was washed three times with 15
μL of a water/ACN/formic acid solution (v/v, 50:49.95:0.05)
and then conditioned three times with 15 μL of water. The diluted
bioconjugate was allowed to bind to the SPE tip by pipetting 15 times
up and down. Finally, the loaded SPE tip was flushed three times with
15 μL of water and the sample was eluted in 2 μL of water/ACN/formic
acid (v/v, 50:49.95:0.05) directly onto a MALDI target plate.
MALDI
Sample Spotting
For glycan analysis, 1 or 2 μL
of the glycoconjugate samples in their original buffer were spotted
onto a ground-steel MALDI target plate with 1 μL of either a
10 mg/mL “super-DHB” (a 9:1 (w/w) mixture of 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic
acid and 2-hydroxy-5-methoxybenzoic acid; purchased from Sigma-Aldrich,
Germany) solution in 50:50 (v/v) ACN/water and NaOH 1 mM or a 100
mg/mL super-DHB solution in 50:50 (v/v) ACN/water. The spots were
left to dry at room temperature. For the analysis of the protein backbone,
the glycoconjugate samples were desalted by C18-ZipTip SPE as described
above, by direct elution onto a polished-steel MALDI target plate
and the addition of 1 μL of a saturated solution of 1,5-diaminonaphtalene
(1,5-DAN) in water/ACN/formic acid (v/v, 50:49.95:0.05). The spots
were left to dry at room temperature.
MALDI-ISD FT-ICR Mass Spectrometry
MS measurements
were performed on a 15 T solariX XR FT-ICR mass spectrometer (Bruker
Daltonics, Bremen, Germany) equipped with a CombiSource and a ParaCell.
The MS system was operated using ftmsControl software (Bruker Daltonics).
MALDI measurements were performed using a Smartbeam-II laser system
(Bruker Daltonics) at a frequency of 500 Hz and 200 laser shots per
scan. Two acquisition methods, optimized for the detection of positive
ions in the m/z-range 1000–7000
and negative ions in the m/z-range
300–5000, were used for the measurement of the protein ISD
fragments with 1 M data points. Four acquisition methods were used
for the analysis of the O-PS fragments. These methods were tuned for
increased sensitivity in the m/z-ranges 3500–30000 (with 0.5 M data points), 300–8000
(with 1 M data points), and 1000–7000 (with 1 M data points)
for MS measurements and 94–8000 (with 2 M data points) for
MS/MS analysis. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of carbohydrate
fragment ions was performed on selected precursor ions. The collision
energy was optimized for each precursor ion (40–80 V) for efficient
fragmentation.
Data Analysis
Theoretical fragment
ions of EPA protein
were generated using the online MS-product ProteinProspector tool
(prospector.ucsf.edu/prospector/mshome.htm). Mass spectra were visually
inspected using DataAnalysis 5.0 SR1 (Bruker Daltonics). Only fragment
ions with a mass measurement error lower than 15 ppm were assigned.
Negative fragment ions were assigned up to m/z 1500.Theoretical fragment ions of the O-antigen
oligosaccharide repeat units were generated in GlycoWorkbench 2.1
stable build 146 and matched with observed ions.[44,45] The assignments were then corroborated by a visual inspection of
the mass spectra.
Results and Discussion
N- and C-Terminal Sequencing
of Bioconjugate E. coli Vaccines by MALDI-ISD FT-ICR
MS
Carrier proteins are important
components of glycoconjugate vaccines.[46] Detoxified exotoxin A from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (EPA) has been used as a carrier protein in several immunization
studies.[47−50,21] In the bioconjugation process,
EPA is recombinantly expressed and conjugated with O-PSs. This process
can lead to proteoforms of EPA with different modifications of the
amino acid sequence.[51] Therefore, the structural
integrity of the protein sequence must be verified to ensure the safety
and quality of the bioconjugate product. Typically, protein sequence
information can be obtained from the enzymatic digestion of glycoproteins
and LC-MS/MS analysis of (glyco)peptides. Alternatively, proteins
can be analyzed in their intact form using “top-down”
MS-based strategies.[52] One of these strategies
involves the use of MALDI-ISD MS to generate protein fragment ions
directly during the ionization process.[38,53] Since MALDI
primarily leads to singly charged ions, the comprehensive analysis
of the generated ISD fragments requires a wide m/z-range of detection. Consequently, MALDI-ISD MS typically
allows for the characterization of the terminal regions. Recently,
we showed that ultrahigh-resolution MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS, in both positive
and negative ion modes, allows for the in-depth characterization of
intact (glyco)proteins.[41,42,54,55] Although MALDI is tolerant to
the presence of a small amount of salt in the sample, desalting before
MS analysis can significantly increase the quality of the ISD mass
spectra of proteins.In this study, we explored MALDI-ISD FT-ICR
MS for the characterization of the glycoconjugates EcoO2, EcoO6A,
and EcoO25B to confirm the N- and C-terminal portions of the EPA protein
that was recombinantly expressed (Figures S1–S2). Typically, a long series of c′-, y-, and z′-type
fragment ions were detected up to m/z 7000 and used for the determination of the sequence coverage which
was 12%, 8%, and 14% for EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcO25B, respectively (Figures and S2 and Supporting Tables S2–S5). The presence of Bis-Tris and NaCl in the sample
buffer affected the analysis, and desalting of the samples was therefore
key for the sensitive detection of protonated or deprotonated protein
fragment ions. Ultrahigh-resolution measurements allowed for a reliable
identification of ISD fragment ions even in m/z-region below m/z 1000
which is typically dominated by MALDI matrix cluster ions. As previously
shown for other proteins, analysis in negative ion mode improved the
detection of small ISD fragment ions (Figure S3).[55] Of note, for EcoO6A, the series of
c′-type fragment ions was limited to c′6 and c′7
(Figures and S4–S5). EPA contains four potential glycosylation
sites, and only two of these (i.e., Asn8 and Asn650) are located close
to the protein termini and are covered by our sequencing method. The
absence of nonglycosylated c′-type fragment
ions larger than c′7 observed for EcoO6A may
be explained by the fact that Asn8 of this glycoconjugate vaccine
is almost fully occupied, as is supported by glycopeptide analysis
(data not shown). Glycosylated peptide fragment ions were not detected,
possibly as a consequence of their high m/z-values and the low sensitivity at m/z-values higher than 7000. The first 5 amino acids from
both protein termini were not directly characterized; however, the
detection of the negative fragment ions c′6 (m/z 446.1641; sequence (N-terminus)-GSGGGD) and z′6
(m/z 588.2270; sequence GDQNAT-(C-terminus))
provides strong evidence of the integrity of the N- and C-terminal
portions. A long series of z′-type ions were detected for all
the glycoconjugates indicating a low glycosylation site occupancy
at Asn650. These results, which were obtained from a fast analysis
of the glycoconjugates and a straightforward interpretation of the
mass spectra, provided useful information on the EPA protein N- and
C-termini.
Figure 1
Sequence coverage of the carrier protein EPA obtained from the
analysis of the glycoconjugates EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcoO25B by MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS (see also Figure S2 and Supporting Tables S1–S4). Only the sequence
portions covered by the sequencing method are indicated.
Sequence coverage of the carrier protein EPA obtained from the
analysis of the glycoconjugates EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcoO25B by MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS (see also Figure S2 and Supporting Tables S1–S4). Only the sequence
portions covered by the sequencing method are indicated.
Direct Analysis of the Oligosaccharide Repeat Units of E.
coli Bioconjugate Vaccines by MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS
The structural analysis of O-PSs conjugated to carrier proteins is
pivotal for assessing the integrity of glycoconjugate bacterial vaccines,
which is generally understood to be strongly related to their safety
and efficacy. Bacterial O-PSs are usually constituted of large and
polydisperse sequences of oligosaccharide subunits. Since MS analysis
of intact O-PSs is challenging, fragment ions are commonly registered
to study the monosaccharide composition of their repeat units.[35−37] However, such a strategy is not commonly used for the analysis of
glycoconjugate vaccines. Recently, we showed that ultrahigh-resolution
MALDI FT-ICR MS allows for a detailed analysis of intact monodisperse
synthetic polysaccharides and their ISD fragment ions which were produced
using super-DHB as a MALDI matrix.[39,40] The sensitive
analysis of MALDI-ISD fragment ions of polysaccharides required the
presence of cations (e.g., Na+). Therefore, in this study,
the glycoconjugates EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcoO25B were also analyzed
by MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS with super-DHB and without desalting of the
samples which were in Bis-Tris/NaCl buffer. This allowed for the suppression
of the ISD fragment ions generated from the protein moiety enhancing
instead the signal of sodiated polysaccharide fragment ions.The structure of the oligosaccharide repeat units of E. coli serotypes O2, O6A, and O25B have been previously elucidated and
reported (Figure ).[56−59]
Figure 2
Structures
and SNFC symbols of the O2, O6A, and O25B O-antigen
oligosaccharide repeat units (RUs). These structures were previously
reported.[56−59]d-Fuc3NAc is 3-acetamido-3-deoxy-d-fucose. Calculated
mass of O2 RU (C34H56N2O21): 828.3376 Da. O6A RU (C34H56N2O25): 892.3172 Da. O25B RU (C34H55NO24): 861.3114 Da. The O-antigen polysaccharides are
directly linked to Asn residues on the carrier protein. SNFC symbols:
rhamnose, green triangle; N-acetylglucosamine, blue
square; N-acetylfucosamine, white/red triangle; N-acetylmannosamine, yellow square; glucose, blue circle;
mannose, green circle; acetylation, Ac.
Structures
and SNFC symbols of the O2, O6A, and O25B O-antigen
oligosaccharide repeat units (RUs). These structures were previously
reported.[56−59]d-Fuc3NAc is 3-acetamido-3-deoxy-d-fucose. Calculated
mass of O2 RU (C34H56N2O21): 828.3376 Da. O6A RU (C34H56N2O25): 892.3172 Da. O25B RU (C34H55NO24): 861.3114 Da. The O-antigen polysaccharides are
directly linked to Asn residues on the carrier protein. SNFC symbols:
rhamnose, green triangle; N-acetylglucosamine, blue
square; N-acetylfucosamine, white/red triangle; N-acetylmannosamine, yellow square; glucose, blue circle;
mannose, green circle; acetylation, Ac.Thus, this study aimed to assess the applicability of MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS for a straightforward corroboration of the O-antigen compositions
and structures directly from the analysis of the bioconjugate vaccines.
The MALDI-ISD FT-ICR mass spectra, in the m/z-range 300–3000, of the three glycoconjugates are
reported in Figure . The fragmentation process led to the cleavage of the glycosidic
bonds (from any of the different polysaccharide chains attached to
the EPA protein) and the formation of sodiated B and C fragment ions
with B ions being more intense (Figure S6). B ions covering a single repeat unit (named 1RU) were detected
at m/z 851.3299, 915.3100, and 884.3038,
for EcoO2, EcoO6A, and EcoO25B, respectively. B ions corresponding
to two (2RU) and three repeat units (3RU) were also observed in the
same mass spectrum while larger B ions corresponding to up to 11 repeat
units could be detected using different acquisition methods and depending
on the analyzed glycoconjugate (Figures S7–S8). Of note, the number of repeat units on a polysaccharide chain
could be higher than what was detected by MALDI-ISD FT-ICR MS as larger
fragment ions may suffer from a lower ionization efficiency, and measurements
at high m/z-values are notoriously
less sensitive. In addition to the fragment ions corresponding to
complete repeat units, more fragment ions were detected as a consequence
of the cleavage of one or more different glycosidic bonds (Figures –4 and S9–S10).
The mass spectra were further complicated by a high chemical background
derived from the analysis of not desalted samples. The evaluation
of the mass defect (i.e., the difference between exact and nominal
mass) allowed for the reliable identification and exclusion of these
background peaks.
Figure 3
Enlargements of MALDI-ISD FT-ICR mass spectra of the glycoconjugates
EcoO2 (A), EcoO6A (B), and EcoO25B (C) in the m/z-range 300–3000. Sodiated B ions corresponding to
one, two, and three repeat units (1RU, 2RU, and 3RU) were detected
and annotated. Not annotated peaks were generated from the cleavage
of different glycosidic bonds as exemplified in Figure and Figures S9–S10 for the m/z-range between 1RU
and 2RU. Compositional differences between these fragment ions are
exemplified by the reported m/z differences.
The theoretical monosaccharide residual masses are the following:
hexose = 162.0528 Da; deoxyhexose = 146.0579 Da; N-acetylhexosamine = 203.0794 Da; N-acetyldeoxyhexosamine
= 187.0845 Da; acetylated deoxyhexose = 188.0685 Da. The calculated m/z-values of sodiated B-ions corresponding
to one, two and three RUs are reported in Table S5.
Figure 4
Enlargement of the MALDI-ISD FT-ICR mass spectrum
of the glycoconjugate
EcoO2 (see Figure ) in the m/z range between sodiated
B-ions corresponding to 1RU and 2RU. The cleavage of one or more glycosidic
bonds led to the formation of the fragment ions highlighted in red.
Different isomeric fragment ions may exist for each assigned peak.
Enlargements of MALDI-ISD FT-ICR mass spectra of the glycoconjugates
EcoO2 (A), EcoO6A (B), and EcoO25B (C) in the m/z-range 300–3000. Sodiated B ions corresponding to
one, two, and three repeat units (1RU, 2RU, and 3RU) were detected
and annotated. Not annotated peaks were generated from the cleavage
of different glycosidic bonds as exemplified in Figure and Figures S9–S10 for the m/z-range between 1RU
and 2RU. Compositional differences between these fragment ions are
exemplified by the reported m/z differences.
The theoretical monosaccharide residual masses are the following:
hexose = 162.0528 Da; deoxyhexose = 146.0579 Da; N-acetylhexosamine = 203.0794 Da; N-acetyldeoxyhexosamine
= 187.0845 Da; acetylated deoxyhexose = 188.0685 Da. The calculated m/z-values of sodiated B-ions corresponding
to one, two and three RUs are reported in Table S5.Enlargement of the MALDI-ISD FT-ICR mass spectrum
of the glycoconjugate
EcoO2 (see Figure ) in the m/z range between sodiated
B-ions corresponding to 1RU and 2RU. The cleavage of one or more glycosidic
bonds led to the formation of the fragment ions highlighted in red.
Different isomeric fragment ions may exist for each assigned peak.For EcoO25B, a certain degree of deacetylation
of the repeat units
was expected as the glycopeptide analysis (data not shown) revealed
an average number of acetylation per repeat unit of about 0.5. The
presence of acetylation variants introduced a higher degree of complexity
in the mass spectra (Figure S10). The ratios
between deacetylated (d_RU) and acetylated RU were determined for
fragment ions corresponding to 1RU, 2RU, and 3RU (Figure C): 1d_1RU/1RU was 0.23; 1d_2RU/2RU
was 0.53; 2d_2RU/2RU was 0.08; 1d_3RU/3RU was 0.73; 2d_3RU/3RU was
0.20. This corresponds to an average number of acetylation per repeat
unit of about 0.8. The degree of deacetylation was higher for fragment
ions corresponding to a higher number of RUs (Figure S7C).Of note, the analysis of the polysaccharide
moieties by MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS, solely, may not be sufficient to exclude the presence of
unexpected low-abundance polysaccharide variants; therefore, the use
of other analytical strategies is recommended for a multi-level characterization
of glycoconjugate bacterial vaccines.B ions corresponding to
1RU and 2RU were further characterized
by CID MS/MS for corroboration of the repeat unit composition. The
results of these analyses are reported in Figure . CID of the precursor ions may lead to isomeric
fragment ions which cannot be distinguished in the mass spectra. For
example, the fragment at m/z 1492.5783,
detected in the CID mass spectrum of 2RU of EcoO2 (Figure B), was generated from the
loss of one Fuc3NAc residue. Although this loss can occur at two positions,
the figure was simplified by reporting only one structure. CID analysis
also revealed the presence of isobaric ISD fragment ions generated
from a double fragmentation of the polysaccharide chain. For example,
two isomeric structures were assigned to the fragment ion detected
at m/z 851.3270 in the CID mass
spectrum of 1RU of EcoO2 (Figure A). One corresponded to the B ion of a single oligosaccharide
repeat unit while the other was identified as a fragment ion generated
from Y and B cleavages. Furthermore, the CID analysis of the ISD fragments
generated from EcoO25B showed a diagnostic fragment ion at m/z 414.1368 confirming the position of
the acetylated rhamnose (Figure B). Cross-ring fragment ions were solely detected in
the mass spectrum generated from CID of 1RU of EcoO6A.
Figure 5
MALDI-ISD CID FT-ICR
tandem mass spectra of the sodiated B fragment
ion corresponding to 1RU and 2RU of the glycoconjugates EcoO2 (A and
B), EcoO6A (C and D), and EcoO25B (E and F). For many species, several
isomeric structures are possible of which only a single one is displayed.
*Cross-ring fragment ions.
MALDI-ISD CID FT-ICR
tandem mass spectra of the sodiated B fragment
ion corresponding to 1RU and 2RU of the glycoconjugates EcoO2 (A and
B), EcoO6A (C and D), and EcoO25B (E and F). For many species, several
isomeric structures are possible of which only a single one is displayed.
*Cross-ring fragment ions.
Conclusion
Glycoconjugate bacterial vaccines, obtained from
the bioconjugation
of O-PSs and a carrier protein, commonly have a high structural heterogeneity
that makes their analytical characterization challenging. In this
study, for the first time, we applied ultrahigh-resolution MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS for the characterization of three glycoconjugate bacterial
vaccines constituted of E. coli O2, O6A, and O25B
O-PSs and EPA as a carrier protein with the aim of a fast corroboration
of specific structural features. Both the terminal amino acid sequence
and the monosaccharide composition of the oligosaccharide repeat units
were determined in a straightforward manner using the same MS-based
method and only changing the sodium content in the samples and using
either 1,5-DAN or super-DHB as a MALDI matrix. Of note, the generation
of glycan MALDI-ISD fragment ions directly from intact glycoproteins
was remarkable, as this analysis previously has typically provided
protein and glycan information through the generation of protein backbone
fragment ions (either glycosylated or not), solely.CID MS/MS
analysis of ISD fragment ions corresponding to one or
two repeat units was used to confirm the oligosaccharide repeat structures.
The use of MALDI allowed for fast analysis of the glycoconjugate vaccines
without the need for separation instrumentation (e.g., liquid chromatography
systems).We envision the use of our new analytical strategy
in a multi-methods
approach for the assessment of the structural integrity of recombinant
glycoconjugate bacterial vaccines. The fast determination of key structural
features of carrier proteins and O-PSs by ultrahigh-resolution MALDI-ISD
FT-ICR MS may find applications in the manufacturing process of recombinant
glycoconjugate bacterial vaccines, from development phases (e.g.,
screening of glycoconjugate variants) to quality control (QC). Further
investigations are required to evaluate the adaptation of this technology
to other MALDI MS platforms that are more accessible to the biopharma
industry for the analysis of recombinant glycoconjugate bacterial
vaccines.
Authors: Roger Théberge; Sergei Dikler; Christian Heckendorf; David H K Chui; Catherine E Costello; Mark E McComb Journal: J Am Soc Mass Spectrom Date: 2015-05-22 Impact factor: 3.109
Authors: Yuri E M van der Burgt; David P A Kilgour; Yury O Tsybin; Kristina Srzentić; Luca Fornelli; Alain Beck; Manfred Wuhrer; Simone Nicolardi Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2019-01-08 Impact factor: 6.986
Authors: Pina M Fratamico; Chitrita DebRoy; Yanhong Liu; David S Needleman; Gian Marco Baranzoni; Peter Feng Journal: Front Microbiol Date: 2016-05-03 Impact factor: 5.640