| Literature DB >> 35216378 |
Irena Wieleba1, Kamila Wojas-Krawczyk1, Paweł Krawczyk1, Janusz Milanowski1.
Abstract
Despite the enormous progress and development of modern therapies, lung cancer remains one of the most common causes of death among men and women. The key element in the development of new anti-cancer drugs is proper planning of the preclinical research phase. The most adequate basic research exemplary for cancer study are 3D tumor microenvironment in vitro models, which allow us to avoid the use of animal models and ensure replicable culture condition. However, the question tormenting the scientist is how to choose the best tool for tumor microenvironment research, especially for extremely heterogenous lung cancer cases. In the presented review we are focused to explain the key factors of lung cancer biology, its microenvironment, and clinical gaps related to different therapies. The review summarized the most important strategies for in vitro culture models mimicking the tumor-tumor microenvironmental interaction, as well as all advantages and disadvantages were depicted. This knowledge could facilitate the right decision to designate proper pre-clinical in vitro study, based on available analytical tools and technical capabilities, to obtain more reliable and personalized results for faster introduction them into the future clinical trials.Entities:
Keywords: lung cancer; organoids; spheroid; tumor microenvironment; tumor-on-chip
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35216378 PMCID: PMC8876687 DOI: 10.3390/ijms23042261
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Mol Sci ISSN: 1422-0067 Impact factor: 5.923
Figure 1Histological types of lung cancer: NSCLC: SQCLC–28%, LUAD–38%, AIS–2%, LCC–10%; SCLC–15%, LCNEC–5%, and Lung Carcinoid–2% of all cases (this graph was created in GraphPad Prism 9).
Figure 2Characteristics of main elements of the tumor microenvironment, involved in tumor progression, angiogenesis, and metastatic promotion.
Figure 3Graphic description of the key elements to mimic tumor microenvironment in vitro.
Figure 4The origin of cancer cell obtained for 3D lung cancer in vitro model formation.
Short description of selected cited works is provided.
| Cellular Components of the Model | The Aim of the Model Design | Reference | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Three-dimensional co-culture: lung adenocarcinoma cell lines, normal human epithelial cell line, human fibroblast and autologous CSC in a ratio 1:1:1:0.2 |
Tumor chemo- and radio-resistance analysis | Chan et al. [ |
| NCI-H460 and A549 cell lines established on pre-prepared decellularized tumor-associated matrix |
Role of the fibronectin in tumor extracellular matrix | Cho et al. [ | |
| Microencapsulation method for obtaining three-dimensional co-culture: NCI-H157, lung derived CAFs, THP-1/peripheral blood derived monocytes |
Prediction of chemo- and immunotherapy response | Rebelo et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional co-culture aggregate: NHLF, HUVECs and A549/PC9 in ratio 4:3:3 |
ABC transporter analysis Tumor chemo-resistance analysis | Jaromi et al. [ | |
| Long-term co-culture of A549 spheroids and fibroblasts |
Interaction between tumor and tumor-stromal cells (fibroblasts) | Takahashi et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional co-culture: MDA-MB-231, MSCs, HLFs and HUVECs established on collagen-based Matrigel and fibrin gels, with the presence of bioengineered blood vessel |
Tumor angiogenesis and blood vessel invasion study | Kwak et al. [ | |
|
| Spheroidal co-culture: A549, human lung fibroblasts cell line, HUVECs, established on hydrogel with vascular-mimicking channels |
Drug-dose testing | Park et al. [ |
| Three-dimensional microspheres: A549, fibroblasts, bone marrow derived MSC established on hyaluronic microparticles |
Drug testing Adequate method to use for different co-cultures | Ferreira et al. [ | |
| Silk fibroin and chitosan-based scaffold |
Tumor spheres formation Neovascularization study | Li et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional co-culture: A549 and human lung fibroblast established on N-isopropylacrylamide-based hydrogel |
Doxorubicin-drug response analysis Tumor hypoxia study | Dhamec et al. [ | |
| A549 (cisplatin-resistant) spheroids established on collagen type I based hydrogel, cultured in advanced microfabricated multichambered device |
Study of lung cancer impacts on muscle cachexia Tumor chemoresistance study Tissue anisotropy examination | Mondrinos et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional cell culture: A549 or H1299 with co-culture of NK-92 cells established on peptide-functionalized poly(ethylene glycol)-based hydrogel |
Correlation between integrins density in hydrogel and NK cells mobility | Temples et al. [ | |
| MSC activated by secretomes from different metastatic niches, established in hydrogel by encapsulation technic |
Simultaneous analysis of transcriptome and secretome Examination of correlation between primer and metastatic tumor | Blache et al. [ | |
| Tumor-on-chip model |
Monitoring tumor-cell death under chemotherapy or induced by TILs | Veith et al. [ | |
| Metastatic tumor-on-dish model |
Analysis of DNA phenotype changes during metastasis | Ramamoorthy et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional culture: A549 and HCC827 cultured on See porcine material |
Gefitinib sensitivity study Prediction of targeted therapy response | Strattman et al. [ | |
| Three-dimensional cell co-culture: A549/H358 and IMR90 or A549/H358, IMR90 and THP-1 cell lines were mixed with collagen-rich extracellular matrices and basement membrane, next cultured in bioreactor |
Study on exosomes role in interaction between tumor and tumor microenvironment Exosomes role in tumor immunology | Goliwas et al. [ | |
| A549 cells cultured on decellularized rat-derived lung in bioreactor |
Mimicking tumor growth in vitro | Mishra et al. [ | |
| Multicellular aggregates pre-cultured in syngeneic mice were established on laminin rich matrix |
Investigation of miRNAs role in EMT process | Padhye et al. [ |
Advantages, disadvantages, and potential applications of presented 3D tumor–tumor microenvironment in vitro models.
| Type of 3D Model | Advanteges | Disadvanteges | Applicability in Lung Cancer Diagnostic and Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multicellular spheroids |
Cancer cells obtained from commercial cell lines within the known molecular profile. Commercial or autologous cells could be used in coculture. Tumor exhibit heterogeneous features. Tumor has hypoxia polarization. Procedure is less complicated than for organoids. No limitation to access to patient derived tumor samples. Cost effective and less time consuming (3 days). |
Genetic profile may be different from that in commercial cell lines, obtained on 80s. A constant molecular profile for each commercial cell line allows for reproducible results but does not reflect the clinical reality. |
Prescreening activity of potential drug. Gene regulation and molecular changes analysis with gene editing technique (e.g., CRISPR/Cas9). Study on different molecular pathways. The use of commercial cell lines gives the possibility for better statistical analysis and results’ translation, because of maintaining repeatability of cell lines’ genetic and molecular profile. |
| Organoids |
Established from patient derived tissue samples is a personalized in vitro model. Allows obtaining similar to the clinical "population" under laboratory conditions. Has more heterogenic structure than spheroids derived from commercial cell lines. It could contain other than tumor cells (e.g., CSC). |
Cell source is highly depending from the quality of diagnostic technique (bronchoscopy) in patients with non-operable lung cancer. The limitation and a high risk of low-quality sample. Tissue samples obtained during surgery resection, performed in lung cancer patients with I-IIIA disease stage, represent different than advanced disease stage’ molecular profile. Time consuming (≥6 days). Access to patients derived samples is needed. |
Precise molecular diagnostic for each patient. Potential application in personalized medicine prediction |
| Hydrogel-based technics: |
Hydrogels can be used as a scaffold for different spheroidal culture and organoids. Both synthetic and natural hydrogels have different stiffness and capacity level, which transmits into the metabolomic of the whole model. |
Synthesis and optimization of hydrogel scaffolds require advanced equipment use and is time consuming. |
Analysis of the correlation between different types of tumor-stromal elements, tumor cells, tumor-related immune cells in changeable proportions. |
| Bioprinting (Tumor-on-chip, tumor-on-dish) |
Autologous samples are used for generation of bionic tissue/organ samples. Contains liquid phase. Could contain blood vessel mimicking channel. There is a possibility to take two types of analysis: on-chip (limitation of material loos), and off-chip (e.g., analysis of fluid content). |
Require high quality material, including patient derived samples. It’s an expensive technique, which require advanced equipment. Interdisciplinary work. |
Advanced drug screening. Study on disease development and progression. The possibility of conducting the examination at the level of the whole organ. |
| Bioreactors |
A natural decellularized scaffold is used (e.g., mouse decellularized lungs). Metabolites’ changes can be monitored in real-time observation. Long-term culturing could be provided. |
Specialized equipment is required A complex procedure. Required to obtain potential scaffold from animal model. |
Drug metabolism in cancer cell and tumor microenvironments screening. Cancer metabolism study. |