| Literature DB >> 35093147 |
Marisa E Schwab1,2,3, Julia E H Brown4,5, Billie Lianoglou1,2, Chengshi Jin6, Patricia C Conroy3, Renata C Gallagher1,2,7, Paul Harmatz1,2,7, Tippi C MacKenzie8,9,10.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Lysosomal storage diseases (LSDs) are inherited metabolic disorders that may lead to severe multi-organ disease. Current ERTs are limited by anti-drug antibodies, the blood-brain barrier, and early disease onset and progression before ERT is started. We have opened a phase I clinical trial of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) for fetuses with LSDs (NCT04532047). We evaluated the attitudes of parents and patients with LSDs towards fetal clinical trials and therapies.Entities:
Keywords: Clinical trial; ELSI (ethical, legal and social implications); Enzyme replacement therapy; Fetal therapy; Gene therapy; Lysosomal storage disease; Mucopolysaccharidosis; Patient attitudes
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35093147 PMCID: PMC8800365 DOI: 10.1186/s13023-022-02178-z
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Orphanet J Rare Dis ISSN: 1750-1172 Impact factor: 4.123
Distribution of respondents (n = 181) by patient advocacy groups
| Patient group | N (%) |
|---|---|
| National Mucopolysaccharidosis Society (USA) | 100 (55.2%) |
| United Kingdom Mucopolysaccharidosis Society | 36 (19.9%) |
| Duke Pompe Clinical and Research Group (USA) | 24 (13.3%) |
| International Gaucher Alliance | 12 (6.6%) |
| Instituto Vidas Raras (Brazil) | 9 (5%) |
Characteristics of all survey respondents, including patients and parents of patients (n = 181)
| Characteristic | n (%) or median (range) |
|---|---|
| Parent of affected patient | 161 (89%) |
| Age (years) | 39 (17–74) |
| Sex, female | 159 (87.8%) |
| Gaucher type 1 | 7 (3.9%) |
| Gaucher type 3 | 4 (2.2%) |
| Infantile-onset Pompe disease | 25 (13.8%) |
| MPS 1 | 47 (26%) |
| MPS 2 | 23 (12.7%) |
| MPS 3 | 34 (18.8%) |
| MPS 4 | 21 (11.6%) |
| MPS 6 | 13 (7.2%) |
| MPS 7 | 2 (1.1%) |
| Other/Unknown MPS type | 5 (2.8%) |
| Middle school/no formal schooling | 5 (2.8%) |
| High school or diploma | 28 (15.5%) |
| Some college | 35 (19.3%) |
| Bachelor’s degree | 35 (19.3%) |
| Graduate studies | 29 (16%) |
| Unknown | 49 (27.1%) |
MPS Mucopolysaccharidosis
Characteristics of patients (including patient respondents and children of parent respondents) (n = 181)
| Characteristic | n (%) or median (range) |
|---|---|
| 159 (87.8%) | |
| 0–6 months | 35 (19.3%) |
| 7–36 months | 72 (39.8%) |
| 37–60 months | 25 (13.8%) |
| > 60 months | 26 (14.4%) |
| Unknown age | 23 (12.7%) |
| Current age (years) | 10 (0–58) |
| White | 141 (77.9%) |
| Multiracial | 18 (9.9%) |
| Asian | 11 (6.1%) |
| Other/unknown | 6 (3.4%) |
| Black | 2 (1.1%) |
| Hispanic or Latino | 2 (1.1%) |
| American Indian or Alaska Native | 1 (0.6%) |
| Received postnatal ERT | 118 (65.2%) |
| Received stem cell transplant | 49 (27.1%) |
| Received gene therapy | 7 (3.9%) |
| Clinicaltrials.gov is their main source of information | 44 (24.3%) |
| Employer-based | 72 (39.8%) |
| Public (including national healthcare systems) | 87 (48.1%) |
| Privately purchased by a parent | 12 (6.6%) |
| No coverage | 4 (2.2%) |
| Other/Unknown | 6 (3.3%) |
ERT enzyme replacement therapy
Fig. 1Attitudes toward continuation of a future pregnancy affected with an LSD. Respondents were asked the question “If you or your partner were to become pregnant and the fetus were diagnosed with MPS, how likely would you be to end the pregnancy?” A All respondents (n = 180). B Comparison of respondents from the United States (n = 115) and the United Kingdom (n = 38) (p = 0.012, Fisher’s exact test), C Variables with statistical significance on univariate and multivariable regression. OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval
Fig. 2Attitudes toward enrolling in a phase 1 clinical trial for fetal enzyme replacement therapy. Respondents were asked the question “If you or your partner were to become pregnant and the fetus were diagnosed with MPS, how likely would you be to enroll in a phase I clinical trial (to determine safety) for fetal enzyme replacement therapy?” A all respondents (n = 188), B Comparison of respondents from the United States (n = 115) and the United Kingdom (n = 34) (p = 0.58, Fisher’s exact test), C Variables with statistical significance on univariate and multivariable regression. Or odds ratio, CI confidence interval, ERT enzyme replacement therapy
Fig. 3Attitudes toward choosing an approved fetal enzyme replacement therapy. Respondents were asked the question “If you or your partner were to become pregnant and the fetus were diagnosed with MPS, choose fetal enzyme replacement therapy?” A All respondents (n = 191), B Comparison of respondents from the United States (n = 115) and the United Kingdom (n = 35) (p = 0.8, Fisher’s exact test), C Variables with statistical significance on univariate and multivariable regression. MPS6 Mucopolysaccharidosis type 6, OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval, ERT enzyme replacement therapy
Fig. 4Attitudes toward participation in a clinical trial for fetal gene therapy. Respondents were asked the question “If you or your partner were to become pregnant and the fetus were diagnosed with MPS, enroll in a phase I clinical trial (to determine safety) for fetal gene therapy?” A All respondents (n = 138), B Comparison of respondents from the United States (n = 100) and the United Kingdom (n = 29) (p = 0.87, Fisher’s exact test), C Variables with statistical significance on univariate and multivariable regression. OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval, ERT enzyme replacement therapy
| I am a patient with MPS | I am a parent of a patient with MPS |
|---|---|
| 1) I have been diagnosed with MPS | 1) My child or fetus was diagnosed with MPS |
| a. Type I (Hurler, Hurler-Scheie, or Scheie Syndrome) | a. Type I (Hurler, Hurler-Scheie, or Scheie Syndrome) |
| b. Type II (Hunter Syndrome) | b. Type II (Hunter Syndrome) |
| c. Type III (Sanfilippo Syndrome) | c. Type III (Sanfilippo Syndrome) |
| d. Type IV (Morquio Syndrome) | d. Type IV (Morquio Syndrome) |
| e. Type VI (Maroteaux-Lamy Syndrome) | e. Type VI (Maroteaux-Lamy Syndrome) |
| f. Type VII (Sly Syndrome) | f. Type VII (Sly Syndrome) |
| g. Type IX (Hyaluronidase deficiency) | g. Type IX (Hyaluronidase deficiency) |
| h. Other: (free text) | h. Other: (free text) |
| Extremely unlikely | Somewhat unlikely | Neither likely nor unlikely | Somewhat likely | Extremely likely | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| End the pregnancy? | |||||
| Choose fetal enzyme replacement therapy? | |||||
| Enroll in a phase I clinical trial (to determine safety) for fetal | |||||
| Enroll in a phase I clinical trial (to determine safety) for fetal |