| Literature DB >> 35031507 |
Justin L Blaty1, Lourdes M DelRosso2.
Abstract
Healthy sleep is of utmost importance for growth, development, and overall health. Strong evidence shows that sleep is affected negatively in patients and particularly children with Tourette Disorder (TD). There is also a frequent association of TD with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) which alone has negative effects on sleep and cumulatively worsens the associated sleep findings. The most consistent polysomnographic findings in patients with TD is decreased total sleep time, lower sleep efficiency and an elevated arousal index. Polysomnography studies have confirmed the presence of movements and persistence of tics during both Rapid Eye Movement (REM) and NREM sleep [1]. In general Patients with TD are found to have an increased incidence of sleep onset and sleep maintenance insomnia. Some studies have shown increased incidence of parasomnias (including sleepwalking, sleep talking and night terrors), but this may be confounded by the increased underlying sleep disruptions seen in TD. The hypersomnolence found in patients with TD is also suggested to be secondary to the underlying TD sleep disruption. There is not a significant association with sleep disordered breathing or circadian rhythm disorders and TD. Treatment of underlying TD is important for the improvement of sleep related TD manifestations and is outlined in this review.Entities:
Keywords: Insomnia; Parasomnia; Sleep; Tourette disorder; Tourette syndrome
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35031507 PMCID: PMC9250095 DOI: 10.1016/j.bj.2022.01.002
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Biomed J ISSN: 2319-4170 Impact factor: 7.892
Recommended Amount of Sleep for Pediatric & Adult Populations to promote optimal health AASM Consensus Recommendations [12,13].
Infants 0–4 months | Not well established with wide variation & insufficient evidence for associations with health outcomes |
Infants 4–12 months | 12 to 16 h per 24 h (including naps) |
Children 1–2 years | 11 to 14 h per 24 h (including naps) |
Children 3–5 years | 10 to 13 h per 24 h (including naps) |
Children 6–12 years | 9 to 12 h per 24 h |
Teenagers 13–18 years | 8 to 10 h per 24 h |
Adults 18–60 years | 7 or more hours per night on a regular basis |
Fig. 1Contribution of ADHD, other comorbidities and medication effect to sleep disruption in patients with Tourette Disorder.
Fig. 2Proposed evaluation of sleep disorders in children with tourette syndrome including assessment of sleep complaints, assessment of comorbid sleep disorders and consideration to use actigraphy and polysomnography.
Summary of Treatment (∗ means potential use in sleep).
| Treatment | Subjects | Methods | Findings | Cite |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alpha Agonists | ||||
| Clonidine∗ | N = 27 | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 9 (33%): Excellent Response | [ |
| Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | First Line Therapy | [ | ||
| Antiepileptics | ||||
| Topiramate ∗ | Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | Second Line Off Label | [ | |
| Dopamine Depletors | ||||
| Tetrabenazine | 9 patients | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 4 (44%): Marked/Lasting improvement | [ |
| N = 15 | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 7 (47%): Excellent Response | [ | |
| D2 Blocker | ||||
| Tiapride | Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | First Line Therapy | [ | |
| 603 Patients age 5-18 | Multisite, double-blind, double-dummy, randomized, placebo-controlled trial | 68.3% in the tiapride arm had clinical response and these rates of response were significantly higher than those on placebo | [ | |
| Dopamine Precursor | ||||
| Very-low-dose levodopa therapy (VLDT) | Japanese pediatric neurologists | Questionnaire to providers | 14 providers reported treating with VLDT for tics. VLDT was 30–50% effective for all types of tics | [ |
| Benzodiazepine | ||||
| Clonazepam ∗ | N = 13 | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 5 (38%): Excellent Response | [ |
| Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitor | ||||
| Selegiline (Deprenyl) | 25 boys, 4 girls with mean age 11.2 years old (range 6–18) with ADHD + TD | Open Trial | 26 patients reported improvement of ADHD with 2 patients reporting exacerbation of tics | [ |
| Antipsychotic | ||||
| Aripiprazole ∗ | 44 patients aged 18–58 Mean dose 12.2 mg | Prospective uncontrolled open-label study | Results suggest that aripiprazole may improve associated comorbid conditions in addition to tics in patients with TD | [ |
| Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | First Line Therapy | [ | ||
| 78 Patients | Case Series | Aripiprazole is effective and safe in most patient | [ | |
| Sulpiride | 114 patients reviewed | Retrospective analysis | Worthwhile beneficial effects occurred in 59% of patients | [ |
| Fluphenazine | N = 28 | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 15 (54%): Excellent Response | [ |
| Haloperidol | N = 24 | 11 (32%): Excellent Response | [ | |
| Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | Second Line Therapy | [ | ||
| Pimozide | N = 9 | Retrospective uncontrolled open-label study | 5 (56%): Excellent Response | [ |
| Risperidone ∗ | 12 year old boy | Pre & Post PSG | Blockage of dopaminergic systems with antipsychotic risperidone reverts both TD symptoms and disturbances | [ |
| Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | Second Line Off Label | [ | ||
| SSRI (Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor) | ||||
| Fluoxetine | 21 year old | Observational study | Significant reduction (at least 50%) of abnormal movements and objective improvements | [ |
| Nonpharmacologic Therapy | ||||
| Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics (CBIT) ∗ | 126 children aged 9–17 from Dec 2004–May 2007 randomized to CBIT or supportive therapy and education. | RCT Observer Blind | Behavioral intervention led to a significantly greater decrease on the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale | [ |
| Diet, Exercise and Sleep | 6 Electronic Databases | Scoping Review | Study in Progress | [ |
| Morning Light Therapy ∗ | 34 Adults with tick disorder | Findings showed some benefits following brief light therapy in tic disorder, but significantly greater eveningness and sleep disturbance | [ | |
| Alternate Therapy | ||||
| Cannabis/Cannabidiol (CBD)/Cannabimovone (CBM) | 10,000 Abstracts | Systematic Review | The evidence supporting improvement Tourette syndrome was described as limited, insufficient, or absent. | [ |
| 98 patients | Retrospective analysis | CBM resulted in a subjective improvement of tics (of about 60% in 85% of treated cases), | [ | |
| 42 patients | Interview | MC seems to hold promise in the treatment of TD as it demonstrated high subjective satisfaction by most patients however not without side effects and should be further investigated as a treatment option for this syndrome. | [ | |
| Nicotine | Expert opinion | When chronically taken, nicotine may result in protection against TD | [ | |
| Procedural Intervention | ||||
| Botulinum toxin | Expert Opinion | Botulinum toxin may be helpful in the treatment of focal motor tics and in some simple and complex phonic tics (including coprolalia) | [ | |
| Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) | Expert Opinion | DBS for TD is a valid option for medically intractable patients | [ | |
| Supplement | ||||
| Iron Replacement ∗ | Children <18 year old diagnosed with TD during 2009–2015 with recorded ferritin levels | Retrospective analysis | Iron supplementation showed a trend towards improvement of tic severity upon follow-up. | [ |
| Changma Xifeng Tablets | Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | First Line Therapy | [ | |
| Jiuwei Xifeng Granules | Expert Opinion from National Guideline of Traditional Chinese Medicine | First Line Therapy | [ | |
| 5-Ling Granule | 603 Patients age 5-18 | Multisite, double-blind, double-dummy, randomized, placebo-controlled trial | The clinical efficacy of 5-LGr is comparable to tiapride in reducing tics. Its safety profile is better than tiapride. 5-LGr can be considered a safe and effective therapy for TD. | [ |
Fig. 3Video-polysomnography segment demonstrating a tic during sleep stage REM (blue arrow). Red circles highlight position changes after tics resulting in sleep disruption. On left column from top down 1. Time axis, 2. Single lead electrocardiogram, 3. Scoring of arousals, 4–6 and 9–11 electroencephalogram, 7–8 electro oculogram, 12 technician notes, 13 chin electromyogram, 14 snore sensor, 15–17 leg electromyogram, 18–27 breathing sensors, 28–29 and 31–32 oxyhemoglobin saturation, 30 and 38 capnography, 33 heart rate, 34–36 body position sensor, 37 EKG.