Rupinder M Deol1, Lisa M Thompson2, Kevin M Chun3, Catherine Chesla1. 1. Family Health Nursing, University of California, San Francisco, CA. 2. Emory University, Nell Hodgson Woodruff School of Nursing, Atlanta, Georgia. 3. College of Arts and Psychology, San Francisco, CA.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Diabetes management and control remain poor in Asian Indians (AI) and is influenced by personal beliefs and cultural practices. Since AIs have a high prevalence of diabetes and are more likely develop complications earlier than any other ethnic group, understanding their beliefs and practices of diabetes management is essential. The purpose of this study was to examine and understand beliefs and practices about diabetes self-management in first-generation AI Hindus and Sikhs. METHOD: Interpretative phenomenology was used to interview 12 first generation AI participants with type 2 diabetes to elicit beliefs and daily self-management practices of diabetes. Interpretative and thematic analysis were completed. RESULTS: Diabetes self-management was a balancing act influenced by Ayurvedic principles, allopathy and dietary practices; gender roles, insufficient knowledge and culturally inappropriate diabetes education. DISCUSSION: Culturally appropriate strategies that incorporate Ayurvedic principles, dietary practices, gender roles should be developed to improve diabetes management.
INTRODUCTION: Diabetes management and control remain poor in Asian Indians (AI) and is influenced by personal beliefs and cultural practices. Since AIs have a high prevalence of diabetes and are more likely develop complications earlier than any other ethnic group, understanding their beliefs and practices of diabetes management is essential. The purpose of this study was to examine and understand beliefs and practices about diabetes self-management in first-generation AI Hindus and Sikhs. METHOD: Interpretative phenomenology was used to interview 12 first generation AI participants with type 2 diabetes to elicit beliefs and daily self-management practices of diabetes. Interpretative and thematic analysis were completed. RESULTS: Diabetes self-management was a balancing act influenced by Ayurvedic principles, allopathy and dietary practices; gender roles, insufficient knowledge and culturally inappropriate diabetes education. DISCUSSION: Culturally appropriate strategies that incorporate Ayurvedic principles, dietary practices, gender roles should be developed to improve diabetes management.
Asian Indians (AIs) have a significantly higher prevalence of diabetes than any other
minority group in the United States (Kanaya et al., 2010; Venkataraman et al., 2004) and have
additional genetic risk factors (high prevalence of insulin resistance, abdominal
obesity and abnormal lipid profiles), which increase the risk for type 2 diabetes at
a lower body mass index as compared to whites (Enas et al., 2007). Studies have found that
beliefs about diabetes play an important role in illness management (Broadbent et al., 2011;
Mc Sharry et al.,
2011) and can inform interventions (Hagger et al., 2003). Despite clear
evidence that diabetes management (dietary changes, regular exercise, and adherence
to appropriate medications) leads to a 53–63% reduction in complications and a 46%
reduction in mortality (Gaede et
al., 1999; Macisaac
& Jerums, 2011) diabetes management and control remain poor in Asian
Indians.
Review of Literature
In the United States, AIs are one of the largest immigrant groups and will soon
become the largest foreign-born group by 2055 (Budiman, 2020). Currently there are no
studies in the United States that have examined AI beliefs and practices in
self-management of diabetes. Understanding beliefs about diabetes are important to
know how people make sense of and manage their illness (Harvey & Lawson, 2009). Because AIs
experience a high prevalence of diabetes and have a genetic predisposition to
develop diabetes and complications earlier than in other ethnic groups,
understanding AI's beliefs and practices in managing diabetes are essential. AIs are
a large and diverse group in terms of the region of origin in India, religion and
cultural beliefs and practices. To describe a coherent set of practices we focused
only on Hindus and Sikhs who share many cultural beliefs and practices. The purpose
of this study was to examine and understand the beliefs and practices of diabetes
self-management in first-generation AI Hindus and Sikhs.
Methods
This was an interpretive phenomenology study aimed at understanding AIs’ daily
practices of managing their diabetes. Interpretive phenomenology is underpinned by
Heideggerian philosophy (Dreyfus, 1991) and illuminate's aspects of experiences that may be taken
for granted. A key tenet of this approach is that narratives of concrete specific
events provide insight to participants engaged and practical activities (Chesla et
al., 2018). The method aims to uncover everyday beliefs and understandings that
guide action (Chelsa, 1994). Given its focus on background or taken-for-granted
understandings in each situation, this method is particularly appropriate to explore
participants’ cultural concerns, resources, capabilities, actions taken to cope and
the subsequent outcomes (Benner,
1994; Benner et al., 2009; Smith et al., 2010).Participants for this study were recruited from Sikh Temples in Northern California
and through snowball sampling. Inclusion criteria included being of Asian Indian
origin, first generation, diagnosed with type 2 diabetes for at least 6 months, over
the age of 18 and a legal permanent resident of the US. To better understand daily
diabetes management participants who were stable with their diabetes and had no
hospital admissions in the last 6 months were recruited. The study was approved by
the Committee on Human Research, Institutional Review Board. Written consent to
participate was obtained from each participant. An interview guide that had been
tested in an earlier pilot study was used to conduct private open-ended interviews
focused on daily management and practices with each participant; second interviews
were conducted with each participant to clarify understanding and complete all study
questions. All interviews were audio recorded, translated to English by the first
author, transcribed verbatim and checked for accuracy for interpretive phenomenology
analysis by the author.
Data Analysis
The interviews were read several times to understand participants’ beliefs and
practices about diabetes self-management. All interviews were systematically
coded in Atlas ti. For this analysis, text coded as “diabetes practices,
diabetes management” and the associated narratives were retrieved for further
analysis. Interpretive notes were entered into Atlas ti for
each narrative and were summarized to identify qualitative distinctions and
exemplars in daily practices and management of diabetes in AIs.
Results
Sample Characteristics
A sample of 12 adult participants (6 men and 6 women) aged 40–75 years, four
Hindus and eight Sikhs were recruited from local temples. The average US
residency was 19 years (range 1–43 years) and the average time since diagnosis
of diabetes was 10 years (range 1–25 years). All the female participants worked
as part-time nannies. Male participants had varied occupations, including small
business owners or managerial positions. Three male participants were
unemployed.Diabetes management in AIs is a complex process and was influenced by cultural
health and practice beliefs. AIs sought a balance between Ayurveda, diet and
allopathy. Ayurveda, which literally means the science of life, is one of the
oldest systems of medicine in India (Mukherjee & Wahile, 2006).
Ayurveda is understood to promote health and not just treat disease. It uses
herbal remedies to balance and harmony, preserve health and life, prevent and
treat disease. Common herbs used in the diets of Indians have been identified as
having antihyperglycemic properties include bitter melon, curry leaf, fenugreek,
coriander, cumin, ginger, turmeric, garlic, okra, cucumber, snake gourd, radish,
tomato, plantain, chili, mango seed powder and brinjal (Mathew et al., 2000; Sinha et al., 2003).
Participants in this study were trying to strengthen their overall health and
balance, as well as trying to treat their diabetes. They used these common desi
(Indian) herbs, spices and, also identified missi roti (a flat bread comprised
of mixing fenugreek, cilantro with soy flour, pearl millet, chickpea and lentil
flour) as an important element in their diet. Some preferred missi roti over
plain roti (an Indian staple flat bread made from stoneground whole wheat flour)
to control their diabetes. Drinking tea and alcohol was also reported to affect
diabetes control.Gender roles also influenced the management of diabetes. Female participants
found it harder to manage their diabetes. Household chores, family duties and
lack of family support influenced how female participants managed their
diabetes. Male participants made drastic changes to their diets and their
family's diet. Diabetes management was also hindered by insufficient knowledge
and access to culturally appropriate information.
A Balancing Act -Ayurveda, Allopathy and Dietary Practices
Participants sought balance and harmony between Ayurveda, allopathic medicine and
diet. Several participants controlled their diabetes by blending herbs and
modifying their diet and used Western medicine as a last resort. Both male and
female participants considered herbs and dietary practices safe and effective
with no adverse side effects. They reported achieving control of their daily
blood sugar when using Ayurveda and dietary practices first before resorting to
allopathy. One female participant described how she adjusted the amount of
diabetes medication she took after she had eaten her herbal supplement.P101F: I will eat some fenugreek and fennel seed in the morning, my sugar
comes way down, and I am able to control it better, it gets low then, I like
to to-keep it at 100–130. Then I will take my western medication, instead of
two tabs I will take one tab.Participants typically preferred familiar herbs and flour that were used in the
Indian cuisine and were readily available in Indian stores to control their
diabetes. They often referred to common Indian herbs used for cooking as “desi”
medications and described the different combinations they used. Common herbs
such as fenugreek, mustard seed, mustard greens and fennel seed were thought to
improve glycemic control. No unique formula of herbs was used by all
participants. Rather, each described the various herbal preparations that they
took to achieve glycemic control. For example, one woman described how she
alternated herbal mixtures, believing that each had a positive effect on her
blood sugar.P105F: I take one powder at a time, for example for the first few weeks I
will eat fenugreek and fennel seed powder. I usually mix it all up and put
it in a bottle and when that finishes then I start my bitter melon powder. I
feel that I should finish the powder that I made first before I make another
powder. I also use flax seed. I will grind it and put it in my milk
sometimes, or in my cereal. I keep doing these types of things because I
think they help with my diabetes.Participants placed great importance on staying healthy and tried to achieve
control of their diabetes by balancing herbs, flour blends and allopathy.
Although all three modalities were considered essential in achieving and
maintaining control of their diabetes, the participants, when questioned did not
understand how these practices worked. Rather they followed patterns that were
familiar or were recommended by family members or community members. If none of
the modalities affected glycemic control, they blamed their fate.P101F: I take desi medication first and then allopathic medication. If you
stop one or the other for some time, then your diabetes worsens. If neither
of them worked then it was your “kismet” or fate that it was not meant to
work. I don’t know whether homeopathic medications are better or not, it is
your body, you don’t know how it is going to react. I take both.Along with herbal blending, participants experimented with various blends of
flour to make roti. Some participants avoided using whole wheat flour, which
they thought contributed to high blood sugar levels. Instead, they used various
other blends of flour and herbs to make missi roti to reduce their blood
sugar.P101F: With that my sugar came down when I used soy, pearl millet, black
chickpea and green lentil flour – mix all these flours and I would make
enough for one or two missi rotis and eat it as soon as I cooked it. It is
the best to keep your sugar under control. I will sometimes put fenugreek,
cilantro, onions, garlic, salt, chili, and mix my flours – wheat, chickpea
flour.Blended flours which are easily available at Indian stores, made it easier for
one participant to make her missi roti. The flour was marketed as a product for
people with diabetes.P105F: It has soybean, chickpea flour and wheat in it. You get it at the
Indian store, and it says it is for diabetes. It has little wheat flour in
it…Even the Sujatha flour, one is regular, and one is for diabetes.Bitter melon was used to control blood sugar and for its hypoglycemic effects.
This fruit like the herbs and flour, is easily available at Indian stores. One
participant, who lacked health insurance due to his immigration status, ate
bitter melon every day when he had no medications left to control his blood
sugar.“What do you do if you don’t have access to medications? I still had some
medications from India – they finished and then I would eat bitter melons
every day”. (P109 M)He described bitter melon as being as effective as insulin in lowering blood
sugar. Each part of the fruit (peel, seeds and juice) was described as
therapeutic.P109M: Bitter melons are stuffed with insulin, even the peels. We should not
throw that stuff away. How we make them by taking off the peels and the
seeds instead we should eat them. We should eat the peels of the bitter
melon that is what has insulin.Like the herbal mixes and the roti, bitter melon was prepared in several
different ways to control blood sugar. For example, one participant squeezed and
drank a teaspoon of bitter melon juice to help him lower his blood sugar.P109M: So, then I ate my bitter melons and with the bitter melon my sugar came
down.A lot of people are surprised when I tell them that I eat bitter melon, I eat
them raw.You take the peel off, take a fistful and squeeze out the juice, you usually
will get I teaspoon, maybe two – you will get 1 teaspoon. One teaspoon of
that is equivalent to two vials of insulin – it has so much insulin in it.
There are at least two vials of insulin in one teaspoon of bitter melon
juice.A female participant, who put small slices of bitter melon in her water overnight
and drank it in the morning reported positive effects on her blood sugar.P111F: I take my pills the one the physician gave me and sometimes I will
take herbals too, like…. sometimes bitter melon. I cut it in pieces and put
it in the fridge. And then in the nighttime I put it in a bowl of water and
then drink the water in the morning and it controls my blood sugar for the
whole day.Overall, herbs, flour blends and bitter melon were considered safe and had no
adverse effects and were natural remedies that were beneficial for general
health as well as for diabetes.P110F: These types of remedies are also good for the body. They have no
negative effects to the body because they are what we eat.Participants were aware that diabetes management required making changes to their
dietary practices. Making and maintaining these changes were a struggle because
they affected deeply ingrained cultural habits and expressions that were not
only dietary but deeply social. For example, tea drinking is an integral aspect
of Indian culture. Tea is consumed at breakfast and in the evening. In fact, it
is a cultural norm to offer tea to guests and visitors. It is usually prepared
by adding milk and sugar to taste. Participants struggled with cutting back on
the amount of sugar added when it came to drinking tea. One female participant
made gradual changes to her sugary tea consumption.P101F: So, I said to myself if my father-in-law can drink tea without sugar
then so can I. But I can’t drink it, I can’t bring myself to drink it. Then
slowly, slowly I started to drink tea without sugar.Similarly limiting or avoiding rice and roti which are staple foods that are
served with main dishes at Indian meals were difficult for several participants.
Instead of avoiding these foods, one participant replaced her white rice and
roti with brown rice, brown roti and vegetables. She felt that giving up meat
would be easier than giving up her rice and roti.P111F: Main thing was my eating (laughs) –I mostly eat brown roti, brown
rice, and more vegetables -no white. I don’t even want to eat meat. I want
to quit it. I don’t feel like eating it at all. Yes, it is a vegetable we
cook all the time. It is better to eat the vegetable. I eat either roti or
rice with vegetables, I can’t live without roti or rice. It is our main
food.On her physician's advice, one female participant tried to control her blood
sugar by eating fruit that was bitter and by avoiding soda.P101F: I was told by my doctor that I could eat everything. Even an apple, he
told me to eat half of a bitter one and not the whole. Eat bitter stuff he
told me. I drank all types of soda; in fact, I drank all the sodas you can
imagine. But now I only drink 7 up or Sprite rarely; I don’t even bring them
for home. Even if I have guests, I don’t offer them soda, I tell them have
tea or water.For some participants, avoiding certain foods was not difficult. One woman
asserted that she did not bring any Indian sweets home. For snacks, she opted to
eat to dry fruits and low sugar Indian cookies, which are readily available at
the Indian store.P105F: It is not hard to stop eating something, especially if it is raising
my blood sugar readings. I say to myself, “It is better I don’t eat this
stuff”, and, if I do, I need to eat very little. Like a small piece. I don’t
even bring any Indian sweets home. I have started dry fruits now, like
almonds, walnuts and cashew nuts. I will eat 3–4 of each nut with my tea in
the morning or 2 rusks. I get my rusks from the Indian store. They have
sugar in them, but less than the other cookies.
Gender Roles Influencing Diabetes Management
Culturally specific gender roles affected daily diabetes management, especially
for female participants. Traditionally, Asian Indian women are responsible for
household chores, meal preparation, and housekeeping and are often the primary
care givers of children and elderly parents (Kaikaya, 2000). In this study, female
participants reported overwhelming household responsibilities that negatively
impacted their capacity to manage their diabetes and maintain glycemic control.
Women lacked time to manage their own dietary needs because they had to cater to
elderly parents and family dietary preferences. As one female participant
divulged, she had no time to make her own meals because making two separate
meals would only increase her household chores. Thus, she ate the parathas (an
unleavened Indian wheat flat bread that is usually fried on a griddle) and roti
even though they had negative effects on her diabetes.P108F: I usually like breakfast, I eat toast and peanut butter, and this is
usually breakfast, at lunch I eat roti, parathas and because you know my
mom, she does not like missi roti – it is healthy, but she
does not want it so then I never make one for myself. It is too much
work.Female participants struggled between cooking meals for the family and managing
their own dietary needs. A family's strong preference for traditional Indian
food or meals that included meat, posed mealtime challenges and made it
difficult to modify meals. Modifying meals for a diabetes diet meant cooking two
dishes at every meal, which created more work for female participants. Catering
to family meal preferences and activities left no time for female participants
to make dietary changes that would benefit their diabetes.P108F: I must cook for her. Indian food for my mother-in-law, because she
likes Indian food… Nobody understands that I am diabetic, that I have to
make it like my way - but they don’t like it… At supper because I am
vegetarian, I must make something vegetarian for myself and for my husband
and my son chicken, So I make them a meat dish. It is extremely hard. Two to
three dishes every meal, every day.Families’ lack of understanding and knowledge about diabetes led to inadequate
support which further hindered diabetes management for several female
participants. A female participant described her husband's support as
superficial. Although he encouraged her to exercise and take care of her
diabetes, he did little to help her with her chores that affected the time
available to care for her diabetes.P108F: Nobody understands what diabetes is. So, it is extremely hard…My
husband is worried too, and he encourages me, praises me go for walk. He
works full time – so I take care of my mother-in-law and the kids, all by
myself.Female participants also reported diabetes management activities themselves,
frequently monitoring blood sugar, administering insulin, monitoring food intake
all within a busy lifestyle created added stress. As with this participant, some
women found the combined responsibilities for the household and their diabetes
to be overwhelming.P108F: Like every day I get up in the morning, I check – I poke myself, check
how much it is, then I take my insulin, sliding scale. I don’t like it -it
is hard. Then again at lunch time and at supper time… And because I must
take my son to school, games and practices. Sometimes I don’t even eat on
time. It is so hard to control, and I think maybe I can’t learn how to live
with diabetes. It makes it so hard to check my blood sugars and give
insulin.In contrast, for male participants, managing diabetes was easier, because they
readily expected overall family habits would change for them, and because their
wives were responsible for provision the household and preparing their meals.
One male said that because his wife had diabetes, he could control his diet. She
bought the food and prepared his meals.P106M: My family is supportive – my wife has diabetes too. She understands.
She cooks and buys the food I want to eat.Several male participants implemented dietary changes within their family to
achieve glycemic control. One male participant decided that the whole family
should switch to whole wheat bread and whole wheat roti.P112M: And now I am concentrating on brown foods versus white food. Now my
whole family eats brown bread. No more white bread in this house!It is noteworthy that none of the female participants described overhauling the
family's diet to address their diabetes requirements.Although male participants emphasized that they could control their diabetes with
drasticdietary changes, they seemed to lack an understanding of what foods to eat. One
described how much he made substantial dietary changes based on casual
information from physicians who came to his workplace.P112M: I changed the whole pattern of how I used to eat. At my workplace I
have this one physician who comes occasionally. She tells me what to do. She
says your diet is particularly important. Take 10 different types of fruits
and vegetables every day in small portions, so that everything is there. She
convinced me there is a way out of diabetes, but it is not easy.Male participants who attributed overeating to be a cause of their diabetes,
modified their diet drastically. Several male participants gave up “junk food”
(sweets and candy), fried foods, spicy foods and became vegetarians after they
were diagnosed with diabetes. Eating meat was considered to have a negative
effect on blood sugar. One male participant related how he stopped eating meat
and cut back on his roti to manage his diabetes. He ate only salads, pasta and
limited the amount of food he ate. He decided that a low calorie, vegetarian
diet was necessary to achieve glycemic control.P103M: I have changed. I don’t eat like a sweet, spicy or fried food. I only
eat vegetables and pasta. The biggest change is my diet is not eating as
much or what I like. I used to eat meat, beef, chicken, mutton, fish and
eggs. l used to eat a lot of IN-N-Out burgers and go to steak house. Now I
eat salad, and more salad.Even though male participants made drastic changes to their diet, learning
portion sizes and nutritional values took several years. One participant
described it was a long, complicated process which was time-consuming due to the
lack of culturally specific dietary information.P112M: The books told me how many calories each food had. Like one tortilla,
fries, half cup of grapes…. so, you get used to that. So, you have to learn
it for a couple of times – it is not easy and is difficult to do.Male participants also emphasized that exercise combined with diet control was
essential in managing their diabetes. One man explained it this way:P107M: Look I think you should avoid junk food. You should pay attention
to what you eat. You also need to go to the gym.In contrast females where largely silent on the issue of physical activity in
diabetes management.Abstinence from alcohol was a challenging for male participants, even though
alcohol negatively impacted their blood sugars.P109M: That is my negative point. I will have some alcohol, eat my dinner and
go straight to bed. Everything else, I do well to keep my diabetes under
control.
Insufficient Knowledge in Managing Diabetes
Lack of adequate and reliable knowledge influenced daily dietary self-management
of diabetes. Participants confessed that lack of knowledge was a challenge to
daily diabetes management. One female participant stated that, because she did
not know much about diabetes, she was unable to give much advice to any of her
family members. She told them to make simple dietary and lifestyle changes; she
told her children to avoid negative thoughts that created unwanted stressors.
Based on her life experiences, unnecessary stress had caused her diabetes.
Limiting stress would prevent diabetes.P110F: I don’t really give them much advice because there is not much that I
know about diabetes. I tell them to eat sensibly that is limit the amount
you eat, don’t take on stress, and don’t talk bad or think badly about
anyone.Similarly, a male participant felt that he had insufficient knowledge in diabetes
management and yearned for more information although he did not know how to
access it.P103M: Roti, eat more salad and more – I don’t know much else to eat. I don’t
have enough information, maybe only 10–15%. I don’t know much about – like I
don’t go to any classes. If they have some class or seminar, I can attend
then I can know more.Counting or limiting carbohydrates and calories, created further challenges for
several participants. One participant described how he controlled his diet by
watching his carbohydrate intake, yet when asked how many carbohydrates he
consumed he described the number of calories he ate.P102M: I mean I watch the nutrition, how much carbohydrate there is in there,
sugar or fat are in there. Before I never used to watch, I just used to
eat.I: So, you are counting your carbs?P102M: Yeah, yeah. What I think is I try to eat less than 2,000 calories, at
least. For my health like my physician said 1,400 −1,500, like I try to eat
under 2,000 calories.Participants implemented dietary changes based on unreliable sources such as
social networks to manage their diabetes. One participant described hearing from
an unknown source that eating only two meals a day was recommended for adequate
glycemic control. Like several other participants in the study, he limited his
food portions and switched to whole wheat flour.P112M: A recent study in England said two meals a day for diabetes is good. I
don’t know if you have heard about it or not? But I just heard it 2–3 weeks
ago and they said that two meals and that is where I am. I eat only two
meals a day. Like afternoon meals is more like a snack, or probably no meal.
No meals meaning you just take something which is non-caloric. For breakfast
I will have a brown tortilla, roti. Homemade roti – pure brown and not half
brown. Not mixed white and brown, some people do that.
Need of Appropriate Diabetes Education
Diabetes education is critical to the success of managing diabetes (Hu, 2011). In the view
of one participant, language barriers and lack of culturally appropriate dietary
information dissuaded many from attending diabetes education classes.P101F: There is one thing that I think would really help me with my diabetes
and that is getting information on the types of food I eat and how it
affects my sugar. My physician told me to go to the diabetes classes and I
told her I don’t want to. I did not tell her the reason though – I will tell
you the reason. I am not a fan of classes and really, I don’t understand
English that well – so what is the point of going. I will be wasting my time
and I don’t eat the food they eat. I eat mainly Indian food.By contrast, a female participant asserted that diabetes classes taught her
portion control and other preventative behaviors that improved his glycemic
control.P111F: Yes, I took classes. Diabetes classes. I learned portion control that
in those classes and to check my feet all the time. They were helpful.
Discussion
Currently there is little guidance for dietary practices that are tailored to
Asian Indians with type 2 diabetes. A study conducted in the Bay Area reported
that health care providers did not provide culturally appropriate dietary advice
and did not understand AIs dietary preferences (Koenig et al., 2012). In our study
cultural beliefs and dietary practices influenced how AIs managed their
diabetes. Ayurveda in conjunction with allopathic medication allowed
participants to have autonomy in managing their diabetes. Self-treatment was
primarily based on knowledge of ayurvedic principles that were deeply rooted in
the participants’ beliefs and daily cultural practices. Most of the herbs,
vegetables and flour used in ayurvedic approaches were readily available in
Indian stores and were frequently used to treat general health as well as
diabetes. These were believed to be less harmful to the body, with fewer side
effects than allopathic medications. Participants believed that bitter melon,
daily herbal and flour blends had beneficial effects. Bitter melon was used for
its hypoglycemic effects (Liu et al., 2021) and fennel and fenugreek to reduce hyperglycemia
(Pereira et al.,
2019). If allopathy and Ayurveda did not work, they blamed their
fate.Our study suggests that daily dietary diabetes management was influenced by
gender, family roles and insufficient knowledge. Family responsibilities,
caregiving activities and a lack of family support had a negative impact on the
capacity to care for their diabetes in female participants. They also lacked
personal time to manage their diabetes because they had to cater to the needs of
their children, husband and elderly parents. There seemed to be no family
discussion about the disease or alterations in family habits when is affected
women. In contrast AI men reported having better control of their diabetes
because their wives prepared their meals. Although male participants made
drastic changes to their diets such as avoiding roti, meat and alcohol,
implementing these changes within their families was hindered by their children
who lacked motivation.Poor diet is a major risk factor (Dixit et al., 2011) and dietary changes
are known to improve risk in AIs in India (Ramachandran et al., 2006) and the
United States (Kandula et
al., 2007). AI participants lacked knowledge of culturally specific
diabetes dietary information that could be employed in managing their disease
more effectively. Although they made dietary changes, such as limiting portion
sizes, and avoiding carbohydrates, meat and sugar, AIs lacked access to a
culturally appropriate dietary advice. Most of their information was based on
familiar cultural practices and social networks.
Implications for Practice
Ayurveda, use of herbal and flour blends are common AI practices that are thought
to control diabetes, but the number of studies that have examined their effects
have been limited (Lim et
al., 2019; Misra
et al., 2018). To provide culturally appropriate care for AIs with
diabetes, more research should be conducted on common everyday AI dietary
practices. Health care providers should assess the herbal and flour blends that
are believed to be salutary for diabetes control. As additional information is
developed, these practices can be incorporated into the care and treatment of
diabetes in this population. Until such scientific information is developed,
patients can be encouraged to test their pre-and post-prandial blood sugar to
see how they respond to using Ayurveda self-treatments and vegetarianism. For
example, the dietary practices and behavior, such as eating a missi roti, herbs
and bitter melon should be incorporated into preventive programs. Limiting
excessive sweet tea and alcohol should also be discussed with AIs with
diabetes.Strategies to provide greater support for AI women such as local support groups
and dietary information sessions are needed to empower them to achieve control
of their disease. More information on available resources for the care of
elderly parents would be ideal and might decrease the span of responsibilities
that female participants report. Developing culturally specific ways to engage
family members, especially spouses and children, in understanding the disease
process and how to support female patients must be developed.Even though AIs are familiar with diabetes and often passively accept it, they
lack knowledge of the disease and its complications. Acknowledging the lack of
knowledge could facilitate open discussion and communication between health care
providers and AIs, providing an opportunity to educate this population and
address their concerns. Preventive programs that couple information about risk
with data on positive outcomes that can be achieved by changing health behaviors
are likely to be the most efficacious (Ho et al., 2012). Understanding AI
dietary practices and implementing culturally specific strategies would help
build the partnerships that are essential in improving knowledge and increasing
motivation to prevent diabetes and its complications.
Conclusions
Findings from this study provide a preliminary understanding of daily self-management
practices in AIs with T2DM. Because the rate of developing diabetes is so high among
AIs, culturally appropriate dietary strategies should be implemented as early as
possible. Setting goals within the cultural context that consider gender roles,
dietary practices and Ayurveda, should be incorporated into strategies to improve
diabetes management.
Limitations
Because this study described diabetes self-management of first-generation AIs
(i.e., Sikhs and Hindus) who were recruited from local temples, findings cannot
be generalized to other AI groups (i.e., Muslims and Christians), AIs that do
not go to the temple or second-generation AIs. Furthermore, all the participants
had type 2 diabetes; thus, findings cannot be applied to persons with type 1
diabetes. Finally, most of the participants self-reported A1Cs that were within
normal control, but there was no way of verifying that.
Table 1.
Demographic Characteristics of Asian Indian Participants.
Participants
n = 12
Women
6
Age, yrs.
Women
57.5 ± 9.8
Men
56.2 ± 7.5
Length of time residing in the US, yrs.
19.3 ± 9.9
Diabetes diagnosis, yrs.
10.3 ± 6.2
Religion (n)
Hindu
4
Sikh
8
Demographic Characteristics of Asian Indian Participants.