| Literature DB >> 35012167 |
Maciej Sydor1, Agata Bonenberg2, Beata Doczekalska3, Grzegorz Cofta3.
Abstract
Mycelium-based composites (MBCs) have attracted growing attention due to their role in the development of eco-design methods. We concurrently analysed scientific publications, patent documents, and results of our own feasibility studies to identify the current design issues and technologies used. A literature inquiry in scientific and patent databases (WoS, Scopus, The Lens, Google Patents) pointed to 92 scientific publications and 212 patent documents. As a part of our own technological experiments, we have created several prototype products used in architectural interior design. Following the synthesis, these sources of knowledge can be concluded: 1. MBCs are inexpensive in production, ecological, and offer a high artistic value. Their weaknesses are insufficient load capacity, unfavourable water affinity, and unknown reliability. 2. The scientific literature shows that the material parameters of MBCs can be adjusted to certain needs, but there are almost infinite combinations: properties of the input biomaterials, characteristics of the fungi species, and possible parameters during the growth and subsequent processing of the MBCs. 3. The patent documents show the need for development: an effective method to increase the density and the search for technologies to obtain a more homogeneous internal structure of the composite material. 4. Our own experiments with the production of various everyday objects indicate that some disadvantages of MBCs can be considered advantages. Such an unexpected advantage is the interesting surface texture resulting from the natural inhomogeneity of the internal structure of MBCs, which can be controlled to some extent.Entities:
Keywords: architecture; bio design; bio-composites; biomaterials; biopolymers; fungi; interior design; mycelium; mycelium-based composites; patent documents; wood
Year: 2021 PMID: 35012167 PMCID: PMC8747211 DOI: 10.3390/polym14010145
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Polymers (Basel) ISSN: 2073-4360 Impact factor: 4.329
Figure 1Subject areas of scientific articles on mycelium-based composites.
Figure 2“Author keywords” associations in scientific articles on mycelium-based composites.
The most frequently cited articles on mycelium-based composite materials according to Scopus.
| Year | Title | Type | No. of Citations | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Advanced Materials from Fungal Mycelium: Fabrication and Tuning of Physical Properties | original | 128 | [ |
| 2017 | Morphology and mechanics of fungal mycelium | original | 80 | [ |
| 2017 | Mycelium composites: A review of engineering characteristics and growth kinetics | review | 74 | [ |
| 2012 | Fungal mycelium and cotton plant materials in the manufacture of biodegradable moulded packaging material: Evaluation study of select blends of cotton by-products | original | 74 | [ |
| 2019 | Fabrication factors influencing mechanical, moisture- and water-related properties of mycelium-based composites | original | 66 | [ |
Parameters and aims of mycelium-based composites production in scientific research.
| Fungi | Substrate | Product/Application | Main Results (MBC = Mycelium-Based Composites) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cotton-based (carpel, seed hull) starch, and gypsum | Packaging material | MBC meets or exceeds the characteristics of extruded polystyrene foam | [ | |
| Not specified (possibly as [ | Rice straw, hemp seed, kenaf fibre, switch grass, sorghum fibre, cotton bur fibre, flax shive | Insulation panel | Optimal performance at the noise frequency of 1000 Hz. MBC are comparable to polyurethane foam board and are better than plywood | [ |
|
| Cellulose and potato-dextrose broth (PDB) | Fibrous mycelium film | The substrate should be homogeneous. The PDB in the substrate increases the stiffness of MBC | [ |
|
| Glass fines, wheat grains, and rice hulls | Fire safe mycelium biocomposites | MBC are safer than the typical construction materials: producing much lower heat release rates, less smoke and CO2 and longer time to flashover. Composites with glass fines had the best fire performance | [ |
|
| Beech sawdust, rapeseed straw, bran. Non-woven cotton fibre | Board | Straw-based mycelium composites are stiffer and less moisture-resistant than cotton based | [ |
|
| Wheat straw, rice hulls, sugarcane bagasse, blackstrap molasses, wheat grains, malt extract | Pure mycelium | Mycelium grew slow on rice hull, sugarcane bagasse and wheat straw. Liquid blackstrap molasses accelerates growth, outperforming laboratory malt extracts. | [ |
|
| Flax dust, flax long, wheat straw dust, wheat straw, hemp fibres and pine wood shavings | Thermal insulation | The thermal conductivity and water absorption of MBCs are comparable to those of rock wool, glass wool, and extruded polystyrene. The mechanical properties depend more on the fibre arrangement than on the chemical composition of the fibres | [ |
| Not specified (white-rot basidiomycete mycelium) | Mixture of spruce, pine, and fir | Particleboard | Cellulose nanofibers added to the substrate improved the mechanical properties of MBC by 5% | [ |
|
| Sodium silicate | Pure mycelium | 3% sodium silicate improve thermal stability. The | [ |
|
| Clay, sawdust, bleached and unbleached cellulose | Printed cylinders | The mycelium improves the 3D printing (better water resistance, material stiffness and surface hardness) | [ |
List of scientific review publications for mycelium-based composites for art, architecture, and interior design.
| Year | Reference | No. of Cited Documents | No. of Citations in Scopus | Main Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | [ | 32 | 22 | A production cost model is described which includes labour, material and overhead costs for structured sandwich products produced from MBCs. |
| 2017 | [ | 170 | 74 | 1. MBCs are kind of biopolymer foam, but most studies admit that mechanical performance can be improved in the future. 2. Current use is limited to the packaging and chosen construction applications. New applications have been proposed (acoustic dampers, super absorbents, paper, textiles, structural and electronic parts). |
| 2018 | [ | 21 | 34 | 1. MBCs can be used for a variety of purposes with the advantage of a lower cost and the better disposal than polystyrene that is an environmental problem. 2. The biggest challenge is the negative public perception of fungus-derived products. |
| 2019 | [ | 11 | 26 | MBCs are profitable renewable and degradable material and have the potential to replace petroleum-based materials. |
| 2019 | [ | 108 | 37 | Improvement in know-how is expected to improve the mechanical properties and to standardize the productive process, whereas insulation and thermal properties already have shown competitive results. |
| 2020 | [ | 58 | 21 | 1. There is a correlation between raw input material composition and final material properties. 2. MBCs have implications for sustainable architecture and products. 3. The unique aesthetics of MBCs should be further explored and more clearly identified. |
| 2020 | [ | 80 | 44 | 1. Fungal biorefinery upcycles by-products into cheap and sustainable composite materials. 2. Can replace foam, timber and plastic insulation, door cores, panels, flooring, furnishings. 3. Low density and thermal conductivity, high acoustic absorption, and fire safety. 4. MBCs are suitable as thermal and acoustic insulation foams. |
| 2021 | [ | 77 | 6 | 1. MBCs are more suitable for thermal and acoustic insulation than synthetic foam and wood fibres. 2. MBCs are stiff, lightweight and biodegradable, thus are an alternative to petroleum-based packaging materials. |
| 2021 | [ | 101 | 0 | The process of engineering affects the properties of MBCs. Bioreactor designs such as tray, packed bed and millilitre reactors, influence of mycelium growth conditions and strategies for controlling mycelium microenvironment are discussed to allow optimal process development. |
| 2021 | [ | 118 | 0 | 1. MBCs are advantageous as packaging materials with sufficient acoustic, and thermal insulation, slightly worse than expanded polystyrene. 2. The standardized process to produce an optimized material property has yet to be identified, production is less standardized than conventional engineering materials, and it is not clear how to customize the substrates for a particular species of fungi to optimize the composite mechanics. |
| 2021 | [ | 80 | 0 | 1. MBCs support a circular economy. 2. Finding the ways of enhancing their physicochemical properties will expand the application areas. 3. The properties of MBCs are competitive with those of synthetic polymers used in construction, interior architecture, and other industries. |
| 2021 | [ | 94 | 2 | With the wide variety of fungal species and substrates available, MBCs can improve environmental sustainability of many industrial products. |
Figure 3Annual number of patent applications according to publication year.
Figure 4Shares of companies in the total number of patent applications.
Figure 5Links between countries in patent documents.
Granted patents.
| Order No. | Patent No., Application Year–Granted Year, Reference | Details |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | US 9,485,917 B2, 2007–2016, [ | ED (Ecovative Design LLC). Method for producing grown materials and products made thereby |
| 2 | US 8,001,719 B2, 2009–2011, [ | ED. Method for producing rapidly renewable chitinous material using fungal fruiting bodies and product made thereby |
| 3 | US 8,313,939 B2, 2010–2012, [ | FGT, ACH (Ford Global Technologies LLC, Automotive Components Holdings LLC). A method of making a moulded automotive part with a liquid fungal mixture. |
| 4 | US 8,298,810 B2, 2010–2012, [ | |
| 5 | US 8,227,233 B2 [ | |
| 6 | US 8,227,224 B2 [ | FGT, ACH. Method of making moulded part comprising mycelium coupled to mechanical device |
| 7 | US 8,227,225 B2 [ | FGT, ACH. Plasticized mycelium composite and method |
| 8 | US 8,283,153 B2 [ | FGT, ACH. Mycelium structures containing nanocomposite materials and method |
| 9 | US 8,298,809 B2 [ | FGT, ACH. Method of making a hardened elongate structure from mycelium |
| 10 | CN 102,329,512 B [ | Ford Global Technologies LLC. The sheet stock mycelium of cutting and method |
| 11 | US 9,410,116 B2, 2011–2016, [ | Mycoworks Inc. building materials |
| 12 | US 9,879,219 B2, 2012–2018, [ | ED. A method of producing a chitinous polymer derived from fungal growth |
| 13 | CA 2,834,095 C, 2012–2018, [ | ED. Dehydrated mycelium panels. |
| 14 | US 10,154,627 B2, 2013–2018, [ | ED. Growing mycological biomaterials in tools that are consumed or enveloped during the growth process |
| 15 | FR 3,006,693 B1 2013–2016, [ | Menuiseries Elva. A method of producing a composite material based on natural fibres inoculated with mycelium and parts obtained with this method |
| 16 | US 9,253,889 B2 2012–2016 [ | ED. Sheet built-in an electrical circuit |
| 17 | US 9,085,763 B2, 2013–2015, [ | ED. Production dehydrated mycelium elements to form tissue morphology using Pycnoporus cinnabarinus |
| 18 | AU 2013/251269 B2, 2013–2015, [ | ED. Self-supporting composite material |
| 19 | US 10,144,149 B2, 2014–2018, [ | ED. Stiff mycelium bound part and method of producing stiff mycelium bound parts |
| 20 | US 9,394,512 B2, 2015–2016, [ | ED. Method for growing mycological materials |
| 21 | US 9,469,838 B2, 2015–2016, [ | Mycoworks Inc. Set of mycelium-based materials with wood timber |
| 22 | CN 105,292,758 B 2016–2017, [ | Shenzhen Zeqingyuan Technology Dev Service Co Ltd., Univ Sichuan Agricultural. Production method for biomass packing material |
| 23 | AU 2015/271912 B2, 2015–2020, [ | ED. Method of manufacturing a stiff engineered composite |
| 24 | US 9,914,906 B2, 2016–2018, [ | ED. Process for solid-state cultivation of mycelium on a lignocellulose substrate |
| 25 | CN 106,148,199 B, 2016–2019, [ | Jiangxi University of Technology. Agricultural waste-based mycelium material with good a cushion performance and mechanical property |
| 26 | CN 106,633,989 B, 2016–2019, [ | Shenzhen Zeqingyuan Technology Development Service Co Ltd. Using bagasse as fungi-based biomass packaging material of major ingredient and preparation method thereof |
| 27 | US 10,604,734 B2, 2017–2020, [ | University of Alaska Anchorage. Thermal insulation material from mycelium and forestry by-products |
| 28 | KR 102,256,335 B1, 2019–2021, [ | Lee Beom Geun. Eco-friendly packing materials comprising mushroom mycelium and the process for the preparation thereof |
| 29 | US 11,015,059 B2, 2019–2021, [ | Bolt Threads Inc. Composite material, and methods for production thereof |
Most influenced patent documents.
| No. | Patent Document | Extended Patent Family Size | Number of Citations of the Patent Document in Other Patent Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | US 2008/0145577 A1 “Method for producing grown materials and products made thereby” [ | 43 | 44 |
| 2 | US 2012/0270302 A1 “Method for Making Dehydrated Mycelium Elements and Product Made Thereby” [ | 15 | 4 |
| 3 | WO 2019/099474 A1 “Increased Homogeneity of Mycological Biopolymer Grown into Void Space” [ | 12 | 8 |
| 4 | US 2012/0135504 A1 “Method for Producing Fungus Structures” [ | 11 | 20 |
| 5 | US 2018/0282529 A1 “Solution Based Post-Processing Methods for Mycological Biopolymer Material and Mycological Product Made Thereby” [ | 9 | 5 |
| 6 | US 2020/0024577 A1 “Method of Producing a Mycological Product and Product Made Thereby” [ | 7 | 4 |
Figure 6Mycelium-based material during growth (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 7Mycelium-based material after growth: smooth surface with (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 8Mycelium-based composite: smooth texture, with visible fibres (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 9Mycelium-based composite: rough texture, deriving from substrate fragmentation (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 10Mycelium-based composite: smooth and rough textures, combined in one object (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 11Mycelium-based light fixture: (a)—with lamp on, (b)—general appearance (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 12Mycelium-based semi-finished object (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 13Finished object: mycelium-based bowl fixed to the rough-timber torus-shape base (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).
Figure 14Coffee table with mycelium-based tabletop (design and photo: A. Bonenberg).