| Literature DB >> 35010326 |
Craig R Williams1, Sophie M Burnell1, Michelle Rogers1, Emily J Flies2, Katherine L Baldock3.
Abstract
The world is becoming increasingly urbanised, impacting human interactions with natural environments (NEs). NEs take a number of forms, ranging from pristine, modified, to built NEs, which are common in many urban areas. NEs may include nature-based solutions, such as introducing nature elements and biological processes into cities that are used to solve problems created by urbanisation. Whilst urbanisation has negative impacts on human health, impacting mental and physical wellbeing through a number of mechanisms, exposure to NEs may improve human health and wellbeing. Here, we review the mechanisms by which health can be improved by exposure to NEs, as explained by Stress Reduction Theory, Attention Restoration Theory, and the 'Old Friends'/biodiversity hypothesis. Such exposures may have physiological and immunological benefits, mediated through endocrine pathways and altered microbiota. Citizen Science, which often causes exposure to NEs and social activity, is being increasingly used to not only collect scientific data but also to engage individuals and communities. Despite being a named component of scientific and environmental strategies of governments, to our knowledge, the intrinsic health benefits of Citizen Science in NEs do not form part of public health policy. We contend that Citizen Science programs that facilitate exposure to NEs in urban areas may represent an important public health policy advance.Entities:
Keywords: Citizen Science; natural environments; policy; public health; urbanisation
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 35010326 PMCID: PMC8751081 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19010068
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Theories linking natural environments and human health, with details of key supportive experimental trials.
| Theory | Participants | Study Design | Evidence | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kaplan’s attention restoration theory [ART] | N = 12 | A walk through three distinct districts, representing urban living [zone 1], a natural environment [zone 2], and a busy commercial zone [zone 3]. A neural cap recorded Electroencephalgram (EEG) data. | The zone 2 to zone 3 transition had decreased levels of arousal, frustration and engagement. Indicating that the natural environment reduced directed attention. | [ |
| N = 110 | Viewing 4 sets of 3 images, representative of the core concepts of ART; being away, extent, fascination, and compatibility. | Statistically significant EEG elevations, and decreased BVP, occurred whilst observing natural elements. Supporting claims that humans generate a response to elements within NEs. | [ | |
| N = 38 | 30 min walks along 3 different trails; quiet residential streets [urban], inner-city parklands [greenspace], and along a canal [bluespace]. Measurements were taken at baseline [T1], after walking [T2], and 30 min later [T3]. Measurements included participant rated scales, backward digit spans, cortisol levels from saliva sampling, and heart rate monitoring. | The green and blue NEs gave greater cognitive function improvements and restorative experiences. Improvements in cognitive function took time to exhibit, being measurable at T3 but not T2. | [ | |
| N = 12 | Participants took photos of elements, within a natural place of their choosing, which they believe to positively contribute to their mental health. In depth interviews were used to collect data. | All participants expressed a correlation between removing themselves from built environments and improvements in mental health. | [ | |
| Ulrich’s stress reduction | N = 158 | Self-reported stress was measured via Visual Analogue Scale. Stress was triggered with a Trier Social Stress Test. A personal viewing headset displayed one of ten 6-min 3D videos of street scenes with varying tree density. | Videos with higher tree density correlated with an increase in stress reduction. Tree cover at 62% density increased stress recovery by 60%, compared to a 2% density. | [ |
| N = 48 | 15 min sitting in an urban and a forest landscape. Ongoing physiological measurements were taken as well as psychological self-reposts. | Forest areas significantly lowered diastolic blood pressure and heart rate and increased parasympathetic activity. | [ | |
| ‘Old Friends’/biodiversity hypothesis | N = 60 | Blood samples were collected from children along with history of allergies and asthma. Dust samples were collected from childrens’ bedrooms. Mice were exposed to the dust; immune and airway responses were monitored. | Amish children had 4–6 times lower prevalence of asthma and allergies and different innate immune cell composition. Amish dust had 6.8 times higher levels of endotoxin. Mice exposed to Amish dust had inhibited airway hyperreactivity; this protective effect was blocked in mice deficient in certain innate immune signals [MyD88 and Trif]. | [ |
| N = 24 | Gene sequencing, from stool samples taken at 3 months old, indicated microbiota composition. Mothers reported on the presence of siblings and household pets. | Microbiota quantity and diversity was increased for infants living with pets but not siblings. Siblings and pets altered the composition of the microbiota. | [ | |
| GABRIELA | Settled dust in children’s bedrooms collected for culturing, gram staining and microscopy. Lung function testing with spirometry. | Samples from farming households had a higher biodiversity of fungi and bacteria, which correlated to a reduced prevalence of asthma. | [ | |
| PARSIFAL | Mattress dust collected for single-strand conformation polymorphism testing. | |||
| Human blood samples and live mice | Dust was collected from an urban house and a farm barn and the microbial diversity was quantified. Monocyte-derived human dendritic cells [moDCs] were exposed to dust then coculture with purified naïve T cells. Mice were exposed to dust via intranasal administration. | Urban house dust contained a lower diversity of bacteria than farm barn dust. Exposure to urban house dust drove moDCs towards an ‘allergic’ [Th1-dominated response] while exposure to the highly diverse barn dust drove these cells towards a Th2-type response. Mice exposed to urban house, but not farm barn dust developed allergic inflammation in lungs. | [ | |
| Genetically similar piglets [ | Grown in isolation. Environmental exposures; sterile indoor environment, with or without antibiotics, and outdoors. | Microbiota compositions were dramatically impacted by alterations of early life environmental exposures [ | [ |
Figure 1The complex relationships between Citizen Science, environmental exposure and human health. Evidenced and putative links are represented with arrows coloured in green (benefits), and red (harms). Abbreviations: ART: attention restoration theory IL-10: interleukin 10; SRT: stress reduction theory; TGF-β: transforming growth factor-beta.