| Literature DB >> 34997763 |
Katherine M Prioli1, Ilze Abersone1, Patricia M Kopko2, Jay H Herman3, Brian Custer4,5, Laura T Pizzi1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Bloodborne pathogens pose a major safety risk in transfusion medicine. To mitigate the risk of bacterial contamination in platelet units, FDA issues updated guidance materials on various bacterial risk control strategies (BRCS). This analysis presents results of a budget impact model updated to include 5- and 7-day pathogen reduced (PR) and large volumed delayed sampling (LVDS) BRCS. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Model base-case parameter inputs were based on scientific literature, a survey distributed to 27 US hospitals, and transfusion experts' opinion. The outputs include hospital budget and shelf-life impacts for 5- and 7-day LVDS, and 5- and 7-day PR units under three different scenarios: (1) 100% LVDS, (2) 100% PR, and (3) mix of 50% LVDS - and 50% PR.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 34997763 PMCID: PMC9303536 DOI: 10.1111/trf.16778
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Transfusion ISSN: 0041-1132 Impact factor: 3.337
Platelet BRCS included in the model per finalized FDA 2019 guidance
| Platelet type | Time to expiry |
|---|---|
| Single‐step strategies | |
| Large volume delayed sampling (36‐h) | 5 days |
| Large volume delayed sampling (48‐h) | 7 days |
| Pathogen‐reduction | 5 days |
| Two‐step strategies | |
| Primary culture +8 ml secondary culture | 5 days |
| Primary culture +16 ml secondary culture | 7 days |
| Primary culture + rapid secondary test | 7 days |
| Large volume delayed sampling +16 ml secondary test | 7 days |
| Large volume delayed sampling + rapid secondary test | 7 days |
All non‐PR units may additionally receive CMV serology testing and/or irradiation, plus additional NAT testing for emerging infectious diseases (e.g., Zika).
Time to expiry does not reflect maximum usable shelf life of these units.
FDA submission for 7‐day PR units is anticipated in 2021.
FIGURE 1Model development and refinement timeline. BC, bacterial culture; FDA, Food and Drug Administration; GPBA, Grifols Procleix Babesia Assay; ID‐NAT, infectious disease/nucleic acid testing; LVDS, large volume delayed sampling; PR, pathogen reduction; UV, ultraviolet
FIGURE 2Comparison of LVDS and PR management of a 100% purchased platelet inventory. CMV, cytomegalovirus; LVDS‐5, 5‐day LVDS units; LVDS‐7, 7‐day LVDS units; PR‐5, 5‐day PR units; PR‐7, 7‐day PR units;
Model inputs for LVDS and PR platelets
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Acquisition | |
| Weekly units purchased from the blood center | 58 |
| Per‐unit purchase price for PR‐5 & PR‐7 | $643.00 |
| Per‐unit purchase price for LVDS‐5 & LVDS‐7, not irradiated | $596.00 |
| Per‐unit purchase price for LVDS‐5 & LVDS‐7, irradiated | $685.40 |
| Percentage of LVDS‐5 & LVDS‐7 units which are purchased as irradiated | 60.7% |
| Per‐unit cost of additional NAT testing for emerging diseases | $7.50 |
| Average LVDS‐7 unit age at the time of receipt (days) | 4.0 |
| Average LVDS‐5 unit age at the time of receipt (days) | 3.0 |
| Average PR‐5 & PR‐7 unit age at the time of receipt (days) | 2.37 |
| Transfusion and wastage | |
| Mean number of platelet units transfused weekly | 55 |
| Mean 5‐day non‐PR platelet units wasted per week | 6 |
| Mean 7‐day non‐PR platelet units wasted per week | 4.8 |
| Adverse events | |
| Sepsis probability for LVDS units28 | 0.0000972 |
| Sepsis probability for PR units29 | 0 |
| Sepsis cost per non‐fatal case | $80,000.00 |
| Reimbursement | |
| Percentage of platelets transfused in an outpatient setting | 26.3% |
| CMS reimbursement for non‐PR units, not irradiated | $486.80 |
| CMS reimbursement for non‐PR units, irradiated | $617.33 |
| CMS reimbursement for PR units36 | $583.87 |
| Percentage of platelets reimbursed through private pay for those transfused in outpatient setting | 50% |
| Price multiplier for private pay units transfused in the outpatient setting | 2× |
| Percentage of charge which is paid by private payers | 75% |
Abbreviations: CMS, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services; LVDS, large volume delayed sampling; LVDS‐5, 5‐day LVDS units; LVDS‐7, 7‐day LVDS units; NAT, nucleic acid testing; PR, pathogen reduction; PR‐5, 5‐day PR units; PR‐7, 7‐day PR units.
Informed by an assumption.
Aggregate costs from Jefferson internal analysis in 2020.
Informed by a calculation.
The average charge per payment for sepsis in 2017 per the Definitive Healthcare Medicare Database.
Comparison of annual costs, outpatient reimbursements, net budget impact, and shelf‐life impact for the different platelet inventory measures
| 100% scenarios | 50/50 mixed scenarios | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LVDS‐5 | PR‐5 | LVDS‐7 | PR‐7 | LVDS‐5/PR‐5 | LVDS‐7/PR‐5 | LVDS‐5/PR‐7 | LVDS‐7/PR‐7 | |
| Annual costs | ||||||||
| Acquisition: LVDS units | $1,982,864 | n/a | $1,982,864 | n/a | $991,432 | $991,432 | $991,432 | $991,432 |
| Acquisition: PR units | n/a | $1,939,288 | n/a | $1,939,288 | $969,644 | $969,644 | $969,644 | $969,644 |
| Wastage | $206,480 | $188,699 | $163,636 | $117,548 | $197,590 | $176,168 | $162,014 | $140,592 |
| Dispensing for transfusion and transfusion | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 | $113,149 |
| Sepsis | $22,073 | $0 | $22,073 | $0 | $11,036 | $11,036 | $11,036 | $11,036 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Annual outpatient reimbursements | ||||||||
| LVDS units: | ||||||||
| Units not further treated | $204,387 | n/a | $204,387 | n/a | $102,193 | $102,193 | $102,193 | $102,193 |
| Irradiated units | $370,631 | n/a | $370,631 | n/a | $185,316 | $185,316 | $185,316 | $185,316 |
| PR units | n/a | $577,959 | n/a | $577,959 | $288,980 | $288,980 | $288,980 | $288,980 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Net budget impact | ||||||||
| Total annual costs | $2,324,566 | $2,241,136 | $2,281,722 | $2,169,985 | $2,282,851 | $2,261,429 | $2,247,275 | $2,225,853 |
| Total annual reimbursements | $575,018 | $577,959 | $575,018 | $577,959 | $576,488 | $576,488 | $576,488 | $576,488 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Shelf‐life impact | ||||||||
| Mean unit age when placed into inventory (days, [hours]) | 3.00 [72.00] | 2.37 [56.80] | 4.00 [96.00] | 2.37 [56.80] | 2.68 [64.40] | 3.18 [76.40] | 2.68 [64.40] | 3.18 [76.40] |
| Maximum usable shelf life (days, [hours]) | 2.00 [48.00] | 2.63 [63.20] | 3.00 [72.00] | 4.63 [111.20] | 2.32 [55.60] | 2.82 [67.60] | 3.32 [79.60] | 3.82 [91.60] |
Abbreviations: LVDS, large volume delayed sampling; LVDS‐5, 5‐day LVDS units; LVDS‐7, 7‐day LVDS units; PR, pathogen reduction; PR‐5, 5‐day PR units; PR‐7, 7‐day PR units.