Isabelle C Samper1,2, Ana Sánchez-Cano1,3,4, Wisarut Khamcharoen1,5, Ilhoon Jang1,6, Weena Siangproh5, Eva Baldrich3, Brian J Geiss7,8, David S Dandy2,8, Charles S Henry1,2,8. 1. Department of Chemistry, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, United States. 2. Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, United States. 3. Diagnostic Nanotools Group, Institut de Recerca, Vall d'Hebron Barcelona Hospital Campus, Barcelona 08035, Spain. 4. Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona, Barcelona 08193, Spain. 5. Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Srinakharinwirot University, Bangkok 10110, Thailand. 6. Institute of Nano Science and Technology, Hanyang University, Seoul 04763, South Korea. 7. Department of Microbiology, Immunology, and Pathology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, United States. 8. School of Biomedical Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523, United States.
Abstract
Rapid and inexpensive serological tests for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies are needed to conduct population-level seroprevalence surveillance studies and can improve diagnostic reliability when used in combination with viral tests. Here, we report a novel low-cost electrochemical capillary-flow device to quantify IgG antibodies targeting SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid proteins (anti-N antibody) down to 5 ng/mL in low-volume (10 μL) human whole blood samples in under 20 min. No sample preparation is needed as the device integrates a blood-filtration membrane for on-board plasma extraction. The device is made of stacked layers of a hydrophilic polyester and double-sided adhesive films, which create a passive microfluidic circuit that automates the steps of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The sample and reagents are sequentially delivered to a nitrocellulose membrane that is modified with a recombinant SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein. When present in the sample, anti-N antibodies are captured on the nitrocellulose membrane and detected via chronoamperometry performed on a screen-printed carbon electrode. As a result of this quantitative electrochemical readout, no result interpretation is required, making the device ideal for point-of-care (POC) use by non-trained users. Moreover, we show that the device can be coupled to a near-field communication potentiostat operated from a smartphone, confirming its true POC potential. The novelty of this work resides in the integration of sensitive electrochemical detection with capillary-flow immunoassay, providing accuracy at the point of care. This novel electrochemical capillary-flow device has the potential to aid the diagnosis of infectious diseases at the point of care.
Rapid and inexpensive serological tests for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies are needed to conduct population-level seroprevalence surveillance studies and can improve diagnostic reliability when used in combination with viral tests. Here, we report a novel low-cost electrochemical capillary-flow device to quantify IgG antibodies targeting SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid proteins (anti-N antibody) down to 5 ng/mL in low-volume (10 μL) human whole blood samples in under 20 min. No sample preparation is needed as the device integrates a blood-filtration membrane for on-board plasma extraction. The device is made of stacked layers of a hydrophilic polyester and double-sided adhesive films, which create a passive microfluidic circuit that automates the steps of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The sample and reagents are sequentially delivered to a nitrocellulose membrane that is modified with a recombinant SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein. When present in the sample, anti-N antibodies are captured on the nitrocellulose membrane and detected via chronoamperometry performed on a screen-printed carbon electrode. As a result of this quantitative electrochemical readout, no result interpretation is required, making the device ideal for point-of-care (POC) use by non-trained users. Moreover, we show that the device can be coupled to a near-field communication potentiostat operated from a smartphone, confirming its true POC potential. The novelty of this work resides in the integration of sensitive electrochemical detection with capillary-flow immunoassay, providing accuracy at the point of care. This novel electrochemical capillary-flow device has the potential to aid the diagnosis of infectious diseases at the point of care.
Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) caused by the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus
2 (SARS-CoV-2) was classified as a pandemic by the World Health Organization and has caused
over 4 M deaths worldwide as of July 2021.[1] In order to contain the
pandemic, different strategies have been developed within the last year to detect SARS-CoV-2
infections and monitor the virus spread. Both antigen and antibody detection play important
roles in pandemic management as well as assessment of patient prognosis.Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) is considered to be the gold
standard method for detecting the presence of virus, while rapid antigen tests are used for
screening at point-of-care (POC) facilities.[2] Meanwhile, serological
testing has become key for population-level surveillance because it can be used to detect
previous exposure to SARS-CoV-2, even in asymptomatic patients, and enables identification
of individuals that remain susceptible to the virus.[3] Thus,
seroprevalence analysis can guide decision making around social restrictions and lockdown
measures that are in place in most countries.[4] Moreover, serological
assays can be used in combination with RT-qPCR to improve COVID-19 diagnostic
reliability,[5,6] as
well as to establish contact tracing, to identify convalescence plasma donors and to study
antibody titers following vaccination.[7]Current serological assays for COVID-19 include neutralization assays, enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assays (ELISAs), and chemiluminescent immunoassays.[8] Whilst
being highly sensitive, these assays take hours to days to provide results and require
laboratory instrumentation that is not widely available in low-income settings or at the
point of care.[9] In response to the need for rapid tests imposed by the
worldwide pandemic, multiple COVID-19 serology assays,[6,8,10,11]
including POC assays[12] are rapidly emerging. Of the rapid COVID-19
serology tests that are commercially available, most use lateral-flow immunoassay (LFIA)
formats. While LFIAs offer a simple operation and deliver fast results,[13]
their clinical sensitivity remain far lower than standard laboratory methods, limiting their
impact on pandemic control and management.[14] In addition, LFIAs require
an advanced reader to give quantitative results.Electrochemical bioanalytical methods have gained considerable interest in recent
years[15] because they provide easy and rapid signal quantification,
require simple instrumentation, and enable assay miniaturization.[16]
Critically, sensitive electrodes can be integrated in microsystems, enabling the analysis of
small-volume samples.[17] Coupled with immunoassays, they can achieve
extremely low detection limits.[18,19] Electrochemical immunoassays have been successfully applied to the
detection of viral antigens[20,21] and anti-viral antibodies.[22,23] While providing great analytical sensitivity and clinically
relevant dynamic range, electrochemical immunoassays typically require multistep procedures
and laboratory-based equipment.[18,19] Yet, with the growing use of carbon as an electrode material and the
miniaturization of electronic instrumentation, electrochemical assays can now be made
low-cost and portable, allowing for high-performance diagnostic assays to be deployable at
the point of care.[24−28]Electrochemical paper-based devices (ePADs) have attracted widespread attention in
biosensing due to their numerous advantages.[29] A paper is one of the most
common materials used in capillary-flow devices because it is affordable, flexible, easy to
dispose, and allows simple device fabrication.[30] ePADs are used to
transport solutions through microfluidic channels, delivering them to an electrode that
drives an electrochemical reaction. The flow is driven by the capillary force of the paper,
without the need for an external pump. As a result, ePADs provide portability and simplicity
while achieving high analytical performance offered by electrochemical techniques.[31] However, difficulty with controlling flow and the resulting non-uniform flow
rates are the known limitations of ePADs. Capillary-driven microfluidic systems, such as
laminated devices made of polyester films, were developed to overcome these limitations,
enabling uniform, fast, and accurate flow control.[32,33] Compared to paper-based devices, which suffer
from nonspecific adsorption of reagents and analytes on the cellulose fibers, laminated
devices are less adsorbent, hence limiting this problem. Due to their improved flow
capacities and limited nonspecific adsorption, laminated devices offer better analytical
performance than paper-based devices.[33]Here, we present an electrochemical capillary-flow immunoassay that combines the ease of
use of an LFIA with the high sensitivity of electrochemical detection methods. Our novel
assay is applied to the detection of IgG antibodies against a SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid
protein (anti-N antibodies) in human blood samples. An anti-N IgG antibody was chosen as the
analytical target of our novel device because of its clinical relevance in COVID-19
diagnosis and patient prognosis.[34−36] Based on our
previous work,[33,37] the
device developed here is made of stacked layers of polyester and double-sided adhesive
films, which create a capillary-flow microfluidic circuit. The device integrates a
blood-filtration membrane for on-board plasma extraction. Dried reagents along the
microfluidic flow path are rehydrated during device operation and sequentially delivered to
a detection zone. The detection zone consists of a stencil-printed carbon electrode (SPCE)
held onto a nitrocellulose membrane (NCM) that is modified with capturing agents specific to
the target analyte, anti-N antibody. If present in the sample, anti-N antibody is detected
using chronoamperometry in a sandwich assay setup. Development of the electrochemical
capillary-flow device is presented, and a sensor response is characterized. As a
proof-of-concept experiment, the device is coupled to a near-field communication (NFC)
potentiostat operated from a smartphone, demonstrating its full potential for POC use.
Experimental Section
Reagent Preparation
N Protein
A recombinant SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein (N protein) was produced as described
elsewhere.[38,39]
Briefly, a bacteria-codon optimized gBlock was cloned into a pET28a bacterial expression
with a C-terminal 6xHis tag. A recombinant protein was expressed in BL21(DE3) pLysS
E. coli and purified by nickel affinity and size exclusion
chromatography. To minimize aggregation, 50 mM of HEPES buffer (pH 7.4), 500 mM of NaCl
was used throughout the purification process. N protein purity was assessed using sodium
dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. A solution of 0.5 mg/mL
recombinant N protein was prepared in 45 mM of trehalose and 4.5% glycerol and striped
onto a 3 × 16 mm NCM (FF120, GE) using a reagent dispenser (Claremont Bio), so that
120 ng N protein was dispensed on each strip. N protein striped NCMs were stored at 4
°C for up to a month before use, as stability over storage was illustrated
elsewhere.[37]
HRP-Antibody
Anti-mouse-IgG conjugated to horseradish peroxidase (HRP-antibody; ab97040, Abcam) was
used as a detection antibody. A solution of 5 μg/mL HRP-antibody was prepared in
0.01 M FeSO4–EDTA, 4% trehalose, and 0.1% BSA to enable storage of the
dried antibodies for at least 5 months.[40] HRP-antibody reagent pads
were made by pipetting 10 μL of this solution onto 3 × 5 mm glass fiber pads
(Millipore Sigma, GXDX203000) and were then dried at 37 °C for 30 min. They were
stored at 4 °C for up to a week before use.
Anti-N Antibody
Antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 N proteins (GTX632269, GeneTex Inc.) were spiked in 0.1 M
phosphate buffer saline (PBS) pH 7.4 (PBS-based sample) or in blood samples. Whole human
blood from healthy individuals was obtained from Lee Biosolutions.
Other Reagents
The electrochemical substrate used throughout this study was
3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB), purchased from Sigma-Aldrich
(T0440). The washing buffer solution consisted of 0.1 M PBS (pH 7.4) and 0.1% Tween80.
All solutions were prepared using ultrapure water purified using a Milli-Q system
(Millipore Sigma).
Electrode Fabrication
Electrodes were fabricated using a stencil-printing method described previously.[41] Graphite powder (3569, Asbury Carbons) was hand-mixed with carbon ink
(E3178, Ercon Inc.) in the ratio 0.6–1 (%w/w) to create a graphite paste.
Single-use stencils were made of 100 μm thick polyester films (PP2500, 3 M), which
were cut using a CO2 laser cutter (Zing 1000, Epilog) following a pattern designed with
CorelDRAW. A stencil was taped onto a whole polyester film (PP2500, 3 M) and a squeegee
was used to print the graphite paste onto the film. Upon removal of the stencil, the SPCEs
were cured at 60 °C for 30 min. SPCEs were then plasma treated at 500 mTorr, 125 W
for 2 min to improve electrochemical performance.[41] Finally, Ag|AgCl
ink (901773, Sigma-Aldrich) was hand-painted on the reference electrode (RE) and cured at
60 °C for 30 min. Plasma-treated electrodes, as fabricated here, have been shown to
be stable for at least 10 days[41] and were used for up to a week
following plasma treatment.
Capillary-Flow Device Fabrication
The capillary-flow device was fabricated similarly to a device previously
reported,[37] with major differences including the design and number of
layers, the materials used and the integrated SPCE. Here, the device was constructed by
stacking four layers of a 100 μm thick hydrophilic polyester film (PP2500, 3 M)
intercalated with three layers of a 50 μm thick double-sided adhesive (467 MP, 3 M).
On each of these seven layers, elements of the microfluidic circuit (channels, inlets,
outlets and vent holes) were designed using CorelDRAW and cut with a CO2 laser
cutter, to create the 3D microfluidic network shown in Figure A. An HRP-antibody reagent pad was placed in the device channel
before adding the top layer of polyester film. Then, a blood-filtration membrane (Vivid GX
Membrane, Pall Corporation) was placed over the sample inlet, to retain blood cells and
deliver plasma to the microfluidic channel. Subsequently, a NCM striped with an N protein
was inserted at the outlet of the microfluidic channel, and a waste pad (Grade 1 CHR,
Whatman PLC) was placed over the end of the NCM to create a passive pump for the fluidic
system. Finally, a SPCE was placed on top of the NCM, upside-down, so that the working
electrode (WE) was in contact with the N protein strip. The SPCE was held in position on
the NCM by the layer four adhesive (L4, Figure Ai).
Figure 1
Schematic overview of the electrochemical capillary-flow immunoassay. (A) Exploded
view (i) and 3-dimensional view (ii) of the capillary-flow device incorporating a
stencil printed carbon electrode (SPCE) facing a NCM. Exploded view (i) shows the four
layers of polyester film (gray, L1, L3, L5, L7) and the three layers of double-sided
adhesive (turquoise, L2, L4, L6) assembled to create the 3-dimensional microfluidic
network represented in (ii). Pink arrows indicate flow direction during delivery
regime. In channels where flow direction is different between filling and delivery
regimes, blue arrows indicate flow direction during filling regime. Where channels are
superimposed, arrows indicate flow direction in both top and bottom channels. (B)
Electrochemical immunoassay and detection mechanism. If present in the sample, anti-N
antibodies are captured by N proteins striped on the NCM. Secondary HRP-labeled
antibodies subsequently bind to anti-N antibodies and catalyze the oxidation of the
substrate TMB, creating an electroactive compound (oxTMB) that is detected via
chronoamperometry.
Schematic overview of the electrochemical capillary-flow immunoassay. (A) Exploded
view (i) and 3-dimensional view (ii) of the capillary-flow device incorporating a
stencil printed carbon electrode (SPCE) facing a NCM. Exploded view (i) shows the four
layers of polyester film (gray, L1, L3, L5, L7) and the three layers of double-sided
adhesive (turquoise, L2, L4, L6) assembled to create the 3-dimensional microfluidic
network represented in (ii). Pink arrows indicate flow direction during delivery
regime. In channels where flow direction is different between filling and delivery
regimes, blue arrows indicate flow direction during filling regime. Where channels are
superimposed, arrows indicate flow direction in both top and bottom channels. (B)
Electrochemical immunoassay and detection mechanism. If present in the sample, anti-N
antibodies are captured by N proteins striped on the NCM. Secondary HRP-labeled
antibodies subsequently bind to anti-N antibodies and catalyze the oxidation of the
substrate TMB, creating an electroactive compound (oxTMB) that is detected via
chronoamperometry.
Device Operation and Electrochemical Recording
The assay was initiated by adding a 10 μL blood sample onto the blood-filtration
membrane. Then, 85 μL of washing buffer were added to the buffer inlet, as shown in
Video S1. Once the buffer had started to flow through the NCM, a 0.0 V
potential was applied to the WE (vs the Ag|AgCl RE) using a portable potentiostat
(PalmSens4) and chronoamperometry recording started. Following the sequential and
automated delivery of sample, washing buffer, HRP-antibody and washing buffer to the NCM,
1 μL of TMB was added to the substrate inlet on the NCM, as indicated in Figure Aii. In the presence of HRP in the detection
zone, TMB gets oxidized into an electrochemically active product (oxTMB), which is then
reduced at the electrode surface, generating an increase in the cathodic current. The
electrochemical immunoassay detection mechanism is illustrated in Figure
B.
Results and Discussion
Electrochemical Capillary-Flow Device Design
The electrochemical capillary-flow device was developed with the aim of detecting
anti-SARS-CoV-2 N protein specific antibodies with high sensitivity at the point of care.
The design of the capillary-flow device was based on previous POC devices developed by our
group[32,33,37] and incorporated a SPCE to allow for high-sensitivity detection.
Assembled layers of laser-cut polyester and double-sided adhesive films created the
microfluidic circuit shown in Figure A. This
microfluidic circuit provided sequential delivery of the reagents used in the
electrochemical immunoassay to a detection zone. The detection zone consisted of a NCM
that was modified with a capturing agent, recombinant SARS-CoV-2 N protein, and a SPCE in
contact with it. The SPCE had been plasma-treated for improved electrochemical
performance, as previously characterized.[41] The flow was maintained by
an absorbent waste pad placed downstream from the detection zone.The capillary flow-driven assay was initiated by adding a 10 μL sample of whole
blood on the blood-filtration membrane. This allowed blood cells to be retained in the
membrane, while plasma passed through it and entered the channel. The buffer was then
added to the device, simultaneously filling all the device channels by capillary action,
as illustrated by the arrows in Figure Aii) and
shown in Video S1. This was possible, thanks to a bare glass fiber pad (L3, Figure Ai) and a vent hole (L7, Figure Ai) that were added to the buffer channel to prevent
air from being trapped. The buffer flow under the blood-filtration membrane carried blood
plasma to the NCM. If present in the sample, anti-N antibodies bound to the N proteins
immobilized on the NCM (Figure B). While buffer
kept flowing in the channels and through the NCM, washing away unbound sample components,
HRP-antibodies were released from the reagent pad placed on L4 (Figure
A) and subsequently delivered to the NCM. At this point, HRP
antibodies bound to anti-N antibodies if present on the NCM. To prevent non-specific
absorption of HRP-antibody the blood-filtration membrane, which could act as a passive
pump due to evaporation, the center channel was split into two superimposed channels and a
hydration channel was incorporated into the device (shown in dark gray in Figure Aii). This enabled the plasma to flow through the top
channel while the washing buffer and the HRP-antibody flow through the bottom one (so
called HRP-antibody delivery channel, shown in yellow in Figure Aii). Both channels converged at the end of the device, after the
blood-filtration membrane but before the NCM. Evaporation of solution through the
filtration membrane was also minimized by covering it with a lid made of a polyester film
(Figure Ai). Following HRP-antibody delivery,
the excess of HRP-antibody that had bound to the NCM was washed off automatically by the
washing buffer running through the device. Lastly, 1 μL of the TMB substrate was
added to the substrate inlet on the NCM, as indicated in Figure Aii. From there, it flowed to the detection zone where it was
oxidized by HRP when present. The resulting electroactive compound (oxTMB) was finally
detected via chronoamperometry using the SPCE held on the NCM. The complete sandwich
immunoassay and electrochemical detection mechanism are illustrated in Figure B.
Sequential Delivery of Reagents
The ability of the capillary-flow device to sequentially deliver reagents to the
detection zone was demonstrated with a whole blood sample and color dyes to mimic
reagents, as shown in Figure .
Figure 2
Sequential delivery of blood sample (A), washing buffer (B), HRP-antibodies (C)
washing buffer (D), and TMB (E) to the detection area. HRP-antibody and TMB solutions
are represented by yellow and blue dyes, respectively.
Sequential delivery of blood sample (A), washing buffer (B), HRP-antibodies (C)
washing buffer (D), and TMB (E) to the detection area. HRP-antibody and TMB solutions
are represented by yellow and blue dyes, respectively.Once the sample and the buffer were introduced in the device, the flow started and pulled
the plasma through the NCM in 1 min (Figure A).
Efficient blood cell filtration through the filtration membrane was confirmed by visually
assessing the color of the solution flowing through the NCM and the absorbent waste pad.
While dark red residue remained on the membrane, the fluid emerging through the membrane
was clear (Figure A). This observation is
consistent with results published by our group and others.[37,42,43] Following
plasma delivery to the NCM and a subsequent buffer wash (Figure B), the yellow dye that had dried on the reagent pad to mimic the
HRP-antibody was released through the HRP-antibody delivery channel and flowed to the
detection zone (Figure C, 12 min).
Simultaneously, buffer flowed through the hydration channel to keep the blood-filtration
membrane hydrated, driving the flow to the NCM. After approximately 1 min, the
HRP-antibody-mimicking yellow solution stopped flowing through the NCM and washing buffer
from the buffer channel was delivered instead, to wash out excess HRP-antibody (Figure D). Lastly, 1 μL of substrate-mimicking
blue solution was added to the device at time 16 min and flowed past the detection zone in
4 min (Figure E, 20 min). Overall, these results
confirm that the reagents are sequentially delivered to the detection zone in less than 20
min. Estimated incubation periods in the devices are 3 min for blood, 6 min for rehydrated
HRP-antibody, and 4 min for TMB on the detection zone, with automatic buffer washes
between them.
Static Electrochemical Detection of Anti-N Antibodies
Initial anti-N antibody assays were performed on PBS-based samples using a capillary-flow
device identical to the one shown in Figure A,
but without a blood-filtration membrane and a hydration channel (Figure S1). The first anti-N antibody measurements were carried out under
static conditions. In this set up, the NCM was removed from the capillary-flow device upon
completion of the fluidic assay and before addition of 1 μL of the TMB substrate.
Chronoamperometry measurements started 2 min after the addition of TMB to the NCM. Three
SPCEs were successively connected to several NCMs exposed to different anti-N antibody
concentrations. Figure A displays the
chronoamperograms recorded from a single SPCE exposed to five anti-N antibody
concentrations ranging from 0 to 1 μg/mL and the calibration curve generated by this
dataset is shown in Figure B, together with
calibration curves of the other two SPCEs (insert).
Figure 3
Static electrochemical detection of anti-N antibodies in PBS samples. (A)
Chronoamperograms obtained from one SPCE consecutively connected to the NCM taken from
five capillary-flow devices, each exposed to a 5 μL PBS-based sample of distinct
anti-N antibody concentration. (B) Corresponding calibration curve showing
blank-subtracted current at t = 100 s (red). (Insert), amplification
of B showing the measurements recorded with three independent SPCEs (red, blue, and
purple) and overall signal fit (black dashed line). Markers and error bars represent
average and standard deviation (sd) over a 10 s interval centered in 100 s. Data
fitted with a 4-parameter logistic (4PL) regression. Limits of detection (LODs) are
calculated as the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3 sd of the blank signal.
Static electrochemical detection of anti-N antibodies in PBS samples. (A)
Chronoamperograms obtained from one SPCE consecutively connected to the NCM taken from
five capillary-flow devices, each exposed to a 5 μL PBS-based sample of distinct
anti-N antibody concentration. (B) Corresponding calibration curve showing
blank-subtracted current at t = 100 s (red). (Insert), amplification
of B showing the measurements recorded with three independent SPCEs (red, blue, and
purple) and overall signal fit (black dashed line). Markers and error bars represent
average and standard deviation (sd) over a 10 s interval centered in 100 s. Data
fitted with a 4-parameter logistic (4PL) regression. Limits of detection (LODs) are
calculated as the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3 sd of the blank signal.The current-to-concentration response of each SPCE followed a 4PL model, which is typical
for immunoassays.[44] Inherent variability of electrodes that are stencil
printed by hand resulted in different LOD across the 3 SPCEs. Nevertheless, all three LODs
were below 2 ng/mL, demonstrating the ability of this assay to consistently detect anti-N
antibody concentrations in 5 μL PBS samples down to the low ng/mL range, which
outperforms commercially available[45,46] as well as recently-developed POC anti-N antibody
assays.[47−49] These results prove that
the capillary-flow device successfully delivers sample and detection antibody to the NCM
and performs effective washing steps. It also demonstrates successful electrochemical
detection of TMB as the immunoassay substrate, using a SPCE placed directly on the
NCM.
In-Flow Electrochemical Detection of Anti-N Antibodies
Following preliminary results in the static measurement setup, flow-based anti-N antibody
tests were performed on PBS-based samples by running chronoamperometry under flow
conditions. Chronoamperometry measurements were started upon delivery of buffer to the
detection zone and ended upon flow completion. Three SPCEs were successively connected to
four capillary-flow devices that were supplied with PBS-based samples of four different
anti-N antibody concentrations ranging from 0 to 100 ng/mL.Under flow conditions, delivery of TMB to the detection zone produced a transient
increase in the cathodic current (Figure A) that
correlated to the concentration of anti-N antibody in the sample (Figure
B). As in the static measurement setup, the
current-to-concentration response of each SPCE followed a 4PL model and variability
between electrodes stencil printed by hand was observed. LODs obtained were slightly
higher than those achieved in the static setup, which can be due to dispersive blurring of
TMB in the microfluidic flow. However, in-flow detection of anti-N antibodies in the low
ng/mL range was still possible.
Figure 4
In-flow electrochemical detection of anti-N antibodies in PBS samples. (A) Excerpt of
chronoamperograms recorded from one SPCE consecutively connected to four different
capillary flow-devices, each supplied with a 5 μL PBS-based sample of distinct
anti-N antibody concentration. Data were time-aligned with TMB delivery to the
detection zone (t = 0). (B) Calibration curves obtained for three
independent SPCEs (red from data shown in A, blue and purple) and overall fit for all
three SPCEs (black dashed line). Markers and error bars represent average and sd over
a 30 s interval centered in the current local minimum. For each SPCE, the blank signal
is subtracted from the data. Data fitted with a 4PL regression. LODs are calculated as
the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3 sd of the blank signal.
In-flow electrochemical detection of anti-N antibodies in PBS samples. (A) Excerpt of
chronoamperograms recorded from one SPCE consecutively connected to four different
capillary flow-devices, each supplied with a 5 μL PBS-based sample of distinct
anti-N antibody concentration. Data were time-aligned with TMB delivery to the
detection zone (t = 0). (B) Calibration curves obtained for three
independent SPCEs (red from data shown in A, blue and purple) and overall fit for all
three SPCEs (black dashed line). Markers and error bars represent average and sd over
a 30 s interval centered in the current local minimum. For each SPCE, the blank signal
is subtracted from the data. Data fitted with a 4PL regression. LODs are calculated as
the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3 sd of the blank signal.
Detection of Anti-N Antibodies in Whole Human Blood
Finally, whole human blood was spiked with different anti-N antibody concentrations
ranging from 0 to 100 ng/mL. These samples were run on the complete fluidic device
integrating the blood-filtration membrane, as shown in Figure , and chronoamperometry measurements were carried out under flow
conditions, as described previously. Three SPCEs were successively connected to four
capillary-flow devices running these whole blood samples spiked with anti-N antibodies.
In-flow chronoamperograms from one SPCE (Figure A) show the increase in the cathodic current recorded upon delivery of TMB to the
detection zone. The correlation between the magnitude of this current and the
concentration of anti-N antibody in the whole blood samples is shown in Figure B for all three SPCEs.
Figure 5
In-flow detection of anti-N antibodies in human whole blood samples. (A)
Representative chronoamperograms recorded from one SPCE consecutively connected to
four different capillary flow-devices supplied with 10 μL human whole blood
samples spiked with different anti-N antibody concentrations. Data were time-aligned
with TMB delivery to the detection zone (t = 0). (B) Calibration
curves recorded with three independent SPCEs (red from data shown in A, blue and
purple) and overall fit for all three SPCEs (black dashed line). Markers and error
bars represent average and sd over a 30 s interval centered in the current local
minimum. For each SPCE, the blank signal is subtracted from the data. Data fitted with
a 4PL regression. LODs are calculated as the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3
sd of the blank signal.
In-flow detection of anti-N antibodies in human whole blood samples. (A)
Representative chronoamperograms recorded from one SPCE consecutively connected to
four different capillary flow-devices supplied with 10 μL human whole blood
samples spiked with different anti-N antibody concentrations. Data were time-aligned
with TMB delivery to the detection zone (t = 0). (B) Calibration
curves recorded with three independent SPCEs (red from data shown in A, blue and
purple) and overall fit for all three SPCEs (black dashed line). Markers and error
bars represent average and sd over a 30 s interval centered in the current local
minimum. For each SPCE, the blank signal is subtracted from the data. Data fitted with
a 4PL regression. LODs are calculated as the anti-N concentration corresponding to 3
sd of the blank signal.As for PBS-based samples, the current-to-concentration response of each SPCE followed a
4PL model and variability between electrodes was observed. This is shown by the difference
in the magnitude of current response observed between the three SPCEs and highlights the
variability of our current electrochemical device. The magnitude of the currents recorded
here was 20 times higher than for PBS-based samples. This signal increase was attributed
to three main causes: (i) blood sample volume was 10 μL instead of 5 μL for
the PBS-based samples, to cover the entire surface of the blood-filtration membrane and to
maximize analyte extraction; (ii) delivery of blood sample to the NCM was slowed down by
the blood-filtration membrane, allowing for longer sample incubation time on the detection
zone, hence enhancing analyte capture; and (iii) the higher viscosity of plasma compared
to PBS could further decrease the sample flowrate through the NCM. The increased signal
magnitude for whole blood samples lead to improved analytical performance, with higher
sensitivity and lower LODs down to the 5 ng/mL range (Figure ), which matches that of commercially available
tests.[45,46]Table S2 provides a side-by-side comparison of the performance of our
electrochemical capillary-flow device in relation to other tests for SARS-CoV-2 anti N
antibodies reported in the literature or commercially available. Note that our device is
the only one providing a quantitative detection in whole blood samples at the point of
care.
Proof-of-Concept Detection on a Smartphone
As a proof-of-concept experiment, the electrochemical capillary-flow device was coupled
to an NFC potentiostat operated by a smartphone and this truly portable system was used to
detect anti-N antibodies in whole blood samples. Commonly available in smartphones, NFC is
a low-cost technology that enables wireless communication using a simple setup, making it
ideal for use in POC applications. The NFC potentiostat (SIC4341, ISO14443A, Silicon Craft
Technology PLC) was operated by an Android smartphone (Motorola One, XT1941) running a
mobile application made available by Silicon Craft (SIC4341 Allstar Android app). The
electrochemical capillary-flow device was connected to the NFC potentiostat via a socket
mounted on the NFC potentiostat printed circuit board, in which the SPCE was inserted, as
shown in Figure A.
Figure 6
(A) Picture of the whole smartphone-based detection system, showing the
electrochemical capillary-flow device connected to the NFC potentiostat, which is
wirelessly operated from a smartphone. (B) In-flow chronoamperograms wirelessly
recorded using the NFC potentiostat operated by a smartphone. Data are from two
different capillary flow-devices supplied with 5 μL PBS-based samples of 0 and 1
μg/mL anti-N antibody concentrations.
(A) Picture of the whole smartphone-based detection system, showing the
electrochemical capillary-flow device connected to the NFC potentiostat, which is
wirelessly operated from a smartphone. (B) In-flow chronoamperograms wirelessly
recorded using the NFC potentiostat operated by a smartphone. Data are from two
different capillary flow-devices supplied with 5 μL PBS-based samples of 0 and 1
μg/mL anti-N antibody concentrations.The connection between the NFC potentiostat and the smartphone was established by simply
placing the smartphone over the NFC potentiostat, and this wireless connection
automatically powered it. First, basic electrochemistry was performed to demonstrate the
well-functioning of the NFC potentiostat. A cyclic voltammogram recorded from a SPCE in
ferri/ferrocyanide is shown in Figure S2, and the complete measurement set up and recording is shown in
Video S2. Then, to demonstrate the capability of this system to detect
anti-N antibody, two electrochemical capillary-flow devices supplied with PBS-based
samples of 0 (blank sample) and 1 μg/mL anti-N antibody were run and
chronoamperometry was performed using the NFC potentiostat. The current responses from
these two measurements are displayed in Figure B. A clear increase in the cathodic current recorded from the 1 μg/mL
anti-N antibody sample was observed while the current from the blank sample remained
constant throughout the 5 min measurement. While the concentration of anti-N antibody
tested here was higher than the targeted clinical range, this proof-of-concept experiment
demonstrates the capacity of the NFC potentiostat to be used for this assay. Further
optimization of the NFC potentiostat current range is needed to allow the detection of
current responses generated by samples of low anti-N antibody concentrations. This fully
portable wireless smartphone-based system would greatly facilitate detection at the point
of care.
Conclusions
We have presented the development of a new electrochemical capillary flow device and
demonstrated its ability to detect IgG antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 N proteins with
performance matching commercially available tests.[45,46] The device is easy to use, can be fabricated at
low cost (<$0.5, see Table S1), and is single-use/disposable, making it ideal for POC applications.
Thanks to an integrated blood-filtration membrane, a droplet of whole blood is added
directly to the device and cells are continuously filtered, while plasma is delivered to a
microfluidic circuit, which then performs the multistep assay. This eliminates the need for
sample preparation, provides sequential delivery of multiple reagents to the detection zone,
reduces the number of pipetting steps, and minimizes user intervention, enhancing the
potential of such devices for use in a POC setting. Like in a sandwich LFIA assay, the
target analyte anti-N antibody is captured on a NCM modified with N protein and detected
using labelled secondary antibodies. However, the device developed here uses electrochemical
detection via a SPCE that is placed on the NCM and connected to a portable potentiostat.
While maintaining the ease of use and the rapidity of a LFIA, this novel system provides a
highly sensitive detection, with detection limits lower than 10 ng/mL anti-N antibody in
human whole blood samples as small as 10 μL. Critically, the electrochemical detection
provides a quantitative output, eliminating any possible user interpretation error, which is
a major advantage of the system to be used at the point of care. In a proof-of-concept
experiment, the device was successfully used with a low-cost NFC potentiostat operated from
a smartphone. This potentiostat could be integrated with the device in the future, so that
the whole system is disposable. This would eliminate the need for any dedicated
instrumentation as the test could be run from a smartphone only, making it useable at the
point of need. Future work shall focus on tuning the NFC potentiostat to match its recording
range to output signals from samples of clinically low analyte concentration. Whilst there
is preliminary evidence showing stability over storage of every active component of the
device (the electrode,[41] the N protein modified NCM[37]
and the detection antibody reagent pad[40]), a stability study of the
complete device was not conducted yet and would be necessary for the device to access the
POC market. Lastly, further developments are needed to increase the reproducibility of our
measurements. We believe that variability between electrodes, which are currently
stencil-printed by hand, could be eliminated by screen-printing electrodes in batches, as it
is performed in manufacturing settings. Additionally, manufacturing capillary-flow devices
in batches would allow for uniform assembly of the device layers and provide a consistent
pressure between the electrodes and the NCM. This is difficult to accomplish by hand
assembly but is necessary to enhance the reproducibility of our quantitative detection to
translate it to real-world POC use. Applied to the detection of other pathogens, this novel
electrochemical capillary-flow technology has the potential to aid the diagnosis of multiple
infectious diseases at the point of care.
Authors: Isabelle C Samper; Catherine J McMahon; Melissa S Schenkel; Kaylee M Clark; Wisarut Khamcharoen; Loran B R Anderson; James S Terry; Emily N Gallichotte; Gregory D Ebel; Brian J Geiss; David S Dandy; Charles S Henry Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2022-03-09 Impact factor: 6.986
Authors: Nathan K Khosla; Jake M Lesinski; Monika Colombo; Léonard Bezinge; Andrew J deMello; Daniel A Richards Journal: Lab Chip Date: 2022-09-13 Impact factor: 7.517
Authors: Gustavo Martins; Jeferson L Gogola; Lucas H Budni; Maurício A Papi; Maritza A T Bom; Maria L T Budel; Emanuel M de Souza; Marcelo Müller-Santos; Breno C B Beirão; Craig E Banks; Luiz H Marcolino-Junior; Márcio F Bergamini Journal: Anal Chim Acta Date: 2022-10-04 Impact factor: 6.911