Tadayuki Iida1, Yasuhiro Ito2, Miho Kanazashi1, Susumu Murayama3, Takashi Miyake4, Yuki Yoshimaru5, Asami Tatsumi6, Satoko Ezoe7. 1. Department of Physical Therapy, Faculty of Health and Welfare, Prefectural University of Hiroshima, Mihara, Japan. 2. School of Health Sciences, Fujita Health University, Toyoake, Aichi, Japan. 3. Department of Physical Therapy, Hospital of Shiromachi, Mihara, Hiroshima, Japan. 4. Department of Clinical Gene Therapy, Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka University, Suita, Japan. 5. Hiroshima City Rehabilitation Hospital, Asaminami, Japan. 6. Department of Nursing, University of Human Environments, Obu, Aichi, Japan. 7. Health Service Center Izumo, Shimane University, Izumo, Japan.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: To establish a method to prevent and manage fatigue caused by psychological and physical stress in young females, early detection factors, such as understanding of fatigue and causes of psychological and physical stress, as well as a review of early management of psychiatric disease, are important. With increasing knowledge regarding the diverse causes of stress, it is important to select biomarkers with consideration of the types of stress burden and mechanisms underlying the development of physical symptoms. The methods used to search for stress characteristics is an issue that needs to be addressed. However, consensus regarding objective assessment methods for impaired mental health is lacking. METHODS: We examined the effects of an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE), considered to be a uniform source of psychological and physical stress, on biomarkers of oxidative stress and fatigue in 16 third-year female medical university students (21.3 ± 2.1 years old) in Japan with a normal menstrual cycle. A self-administered questionnaire consisting of Zung's Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS) and State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) was used to assess subjective stress. Furthermore, stress-related biomarkers (urinary 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine [u-8-OHdG], urinary 5-hydroxytryptamine [u-5-HT], and salivary human herpesvirus-6 [s-HHV-6]) were examined at 1 month, 1 week, and 1 day before, and 1 week after the OSCE. RESULTS: The results indicated that the OSCE did not have effects on u-8-OHdG, a biomarker of oxidative stress. However, u-5-HT and s-HHV-6 were found to be elevated in examinations performed prior to the OSCE. CONCLUSIONS: The present findings suggest that u-5-HT and s-HHV-6 levels can be used for objective assessment of mental and physical fatigue in young females, including that produced not only by knowledge regarding an upcoming OSCE, but also by skill and attitude aspects related to that examination.
BACKGROUND: To establish a method to prevent and manage fatigue caused by psychological and physical stress in young females, early detection factors, such as understanding of fatigue and causes of psychological and physical stress, as well as a review of early management of psychiatric disease, are important. With increasing knowledge regarding the diverse causes of stress, it is important to select biomarkers with consideration of the types of stress burden and mechanisms underlying the development of physical symptoms. The methods used to search for stress characteristics is an issue that needs to be addressed. However, consensus regarding objective assessment methods for impaired mental health is lacking. METHODS: We examined the effects of an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE), considered to be a uniform source of psychological and physical stress, on biomarkers of oxidative stress and fatigue in 16 third-year female medical university students (21.3 ± 2.1 years old) in Japan with a normal menstrual cycle. A self-administered questionnaire consisting of Zung's Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS) and State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) was used to assess subjective stress. Furthermore, stress-related biomarkers (urinary 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine [u-8-OHdG], urinary 5-hydroxytryptamine [u-5-HT], and salivary human herpesvirus-6 [s-HHV-6]) were examined at 1 month, 1 week, and 1 day before, and 1 week after the OSCE. RESULTS: The results indicated that the OSCE did not have effects on u-8-OHdG, a biomarker of oxidative stress. However, u-5-HT and s-HHV-6 were found to be elevated in examinations performed prior to the OSCE. CONCLUSIONS: The present findings suggest that u-5-HT and s-HHV-6 levels can be used for objective assessment of mental and physical fatigue in young females, including that produced not only by knowledge regarding an upcoming OSCE, but also by skill and attitude aspects related to that examination.
The state of impaired physical function due to continuing or accumulated stress is
referred to as “fatigue,” and in recent years that has been the focus in searches
for biomarkers in the body that can be used as objective indices to assess mental health.
Fatigue is a phenomenon that features decreased mental and physical
performance caused by a general physical or mental burden in the affected
individual, accompanied by a desire for rest and feelings of discomfort.
Among the mechanisms involved, changes in oxidative stress biomarkers such as 8-isoprostane
and urinary 8-hydroxy-2ʹ-deoxyguanosine (u-8-OHdG),[4-8] which are common to both
physical and mental burdens, have been confirmed as underlying the manifestation of
fatigue from findings showing that oxidative stress from reactive oxygen species
(ROS) induces destruction of nerve cells, mainly those in autonomic
nerves.[9-11]In addition, examinations of mental fatigue from the perspective of autonomic nerve
activity have shown that hyperactive sympathetic nerve activity caused by
parasympathetic nerve activity suppression is common in cases of acute and subacute fatigue.
According to the monoamine hypothesis of depression, accumulated fatigue is
due to a decrease in the ratio of serotonin to dopamine, resulting in a decrease in
performance when serotonin is increased.
One possible cause is thought to be alteration of intestinal flora by a
stress response via the gut-brain axis, thus promoting 5-HT biosynthesis from
enterochromaffin cells.[14,15] Aoki et al
examined the usefulness of human herpesvirus 6 (HHV-6), a known biomarker, in
subjects with physiological or pathological fatigue, and found that an elevated
level had a strong relationship with physiological fatigue. HHV-6 infection is
latent, though when immunity is reduced, a virus reactivation is manifested, thus
quantification of activated HHV-6 can be useful as an objective indicator of and
used to measure fatigue.
However, though a direct association between HHV-6 and u-5HT has not been
shown, it is possible that CD4+ T cells indirectly activated by HHV-6B
induce upregulation of 5-HT from intestinal EC cells.
This has been suggested and is considered to be a factor related to increased
5-TH in association with changes in intestinal flora. With fatigue caused by stress,
the type and magnitude of decreased performance differs because of variations in
causes for that burden. Therefore, it has been suggested that biomarkers used for
fatigue quantification should be selected based on the type of burden and mechanism
underlying manifestation of fatigue.
Fatigue is one of the big 3 alarms, along with pain and fever. With its
accumulation, the immune system becomes weakened and susceptibility to infectious
disease, such as respiratory infection and herpes labialis, is increased. In fact, a
physiological response by the stress response system and immune system because of
fatigue can be predicted, though there may be a time lag between awareness of
accumulated fatigue and an associated response. Therefore, subjective evaluations of
fatigue and biomarkers used for fatigue quantification, as well as their
relationships over time are needed.Ferreira et al
investigated psychological (anxiety) and physical (cortisol levels) factors
in a cross-sectional study in subjects who underwent an objective structured
clinical examination (OSCE), to examine the effects on specific skills and behaviors
in a simulated work environment, and reported that no significant relationship was
found. On the other hand, OSCE-related nervousness, stress, and anxiety are
consistently reported.[19-22] Hence, the OSCE is assumed to
be a psychological and physical stressor, and not only the
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis including cortisol but also ROS or autonomic
nerve activity may be involved. The male-to-female ratio for psychiatric diseases
caused by psychological stress is reported to be 1:2.
In Japan, the incidence of psychiatric diseases in younger age groups has
gradually increased during the past 20 years and recently been emphasized.
Mental health of young females is important for preventing psychiatric
disease, though the manner in which stress is felt and its causes vary.To effectively explore objective indices to help young females with mental health, an
understanding of the time lags between a subjective evaluation for accumulating
fatigue and biomarkers used for fatigue quantification is required. In the present
study, we examined the effects of an objective structured clinical examination
(OSCE),[25,26] a test that objectively evaluates skills and attitudes prior to
clinical practicums, and generally understood as a uniform psychological and
physical stressor, on biomarkers indicating oxidative stress, serotonin, and fatigue
in young females.
Methods
Participants
The study participants were third-year female students at a medical university in
Japan. A full explanation of the study contents and methods were provided in
advance, and all enrolled participants provided informed written consent (Figure 1). Volunteers
were recruited under the condition that their menstrual cycle was between 26 and
38 days, based on the cumulative pattern of menstrual cycles presented by Taylor
et al .
Finally, 16 students who participated in a meeting explaining the study
were chosen for inclusion (mean age ± standard deviation [SD]: 21.3 ± 2.1 years,
height: 160.3 ± 4.3 cm, weight: 53.1 ± 5.3 kg). None were smokers, based on
their self-report. The survey was conducted from December 2015 to January 2016
and time was divided into 4 periods: 1 month, 1 week, and 1 day before, and
1 week after the OSCE. The period of 1 month before was set as the baseline, as
that was considered to be a time prior to stress related to the OSCE, while
1 day before was considered to be the time of maximum fatigue. Samples collected
on the day of the OSCE might have affected the results of the test, so those
were obtained 1 day before based on this ethical reason. The collection times
1 week before and after the OSCE were set as the same day of the week that the
OSCE was conducted. The school timetable of a Japanese university typically
varies according to the day of the week, thus the internal consistency between
physical and psychological stress as part of the daily rhythm, such as wake-up
and class times, was considered. In addition, the 1 week after period was set in
consideration of previous reports showing that a higher level of u-8-OHdG occurs
on the day after the national exam
as well as in individuals with depression symptoms,
and then remains elevated. Also, the 1 week before period was established
so as to compare with the value on the day before the OSCE was conducted, the
point at which stress was considered to be maximum. Heavy physical exercise and
alcohol consumption the day before the sample collection were restricted. This
study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved
by the ethical review board of the Faculty of Health and Welfare, Prefectural
University of Hiroshima (approval No. 14MH045).
Figure 1.
Subject enrollment flow diagram.
Subject enrollment flow diagram.
The objective structured clinical examination (OSCE)
For the OSCE, the students were divided into groups of 5 and each group visited 3
different testing stations. While at a station, each student took the practical
test for a total of 10 minutes. Specifically, the examinee was first given
1 minute to read the case description and then 9 minutes to demonstrate the role
of a therapist. A physical therapist working at an outside facility and not
acquainted with the students took the role of the patient. Two faculty members
who were licensed physiotherapists observed each student’s performance and
evaluated it according to a pre-prepared checklist. The other 4 students in the
same group also observed the examinee student by surrounding them nearby. During
the 10-minute practical test, the examinee was not allowed to interact with
anyone other than the patient-role physical therapist. The examination was
recorded by a video camera for use as feedback after the OSCE.The OSCE was used as a final exam given after taking a series of courses.
Students were required to attend 15 lectures of 90 minutes each and then pass
the OSCE to receive credit for the course. Passing the OSCE requires
communication skills, and professional evaluation and treatment skills, which
the students had studied for approximately 15 weeks. They were given a large
number of possible questions in advance, and based on these questions, practiced
intensively during and outside of the lecture times to prepare for the OSCE.
Therefore, on the day of the examination, each student was expected to be in a
state of chronic physical fatigue due to preparation for the examination as well
as mental tension from anticipation. Variables of autonomic modulation based on
analysis of heart rate variability in the temporal, frequency, and non-linear
domains, subjective perception of distress train, and academic performance were
determined before and after the 2 different evaluations that composed the OSCE.
Additionally, decreasing sympathetic activity was measured.
Survey measures
A self-administered questionnaire survey consisting of Zung’s Self-rating
Depression Scale (SDS) and the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) was
conducted as a measure of subjective stress, and stress-related biomarkers
(urine and saliva samples) were collected at 1 month, 1 week, and 1 day before,
and 1 week after the OSCE. In consideration of the effects of premenstrual
syndrome, the 3 days before the next menstruation (self-reported) were avoided.
The u-8-OHdG level may be elevated during the proliferation period,
and a significantly low SDS score in the secretory phase and high level
of u-8-OHdG in young females with depression symptoms in comparison to those in
subjects without depression symptoms have been reported.
From the above, the 3 days before the next menstruation (self-reported)
were avoided. The SDS contains 20 items and its design is based on the
diagnostic criteria for depression. The participants rated each item with regard
to how they have felt during the past several days using a 4-point Likert scale.
The raw sum score of the SDS ranges from 20 to 80, though the results are
usually presented as SDS index, which is obtained by expressing the raw score
converted to a 100-point scale.
The self-evaluation STAI questionnaire,
developed by Spielberger in 1983, includes separate scales for measuring
State anxiety and Trait anxiety.
The self-evaluation STAI questionnaire, an internationally validated
questionnaire related to levels of test anxiety,
has been shown to have good internal consistency and test-retest reliability.
The anxiety items used for the present study were scaled from 1 to 4,
with higher scores indicating the presence of greater levels of anxiety. On the
other hand, anxiety-absent items were scaled in reverse from 4 to 1. The total
score for the STAI ranged from a minimum of 20 to a maximum of 80. The levels of
u-8-OHdG, urinary 5-HT (u-5HT), and salivary HHV-6 (s-HHV-6) were measured as
stress-related biomarkers. All urine and saliva samples were collected between
12:00 and 13:00, before the participant had lunch. Prior to collecting the
samples, it was confirmed orally that the participant had not engaged in any
strenuous physical activity the day before. Urine specimens used for measuring
u-8-OHdG levels were centrifuged at 1500 rpm for 5 minutes after collection,
with the supernatant then frozen and stored at −20°C. u-8-OHdG levels were
measured using a Highly Sensitive ELISA kit for 8-OHdG (Japan Institute for the
Control of Aging, NIKKEN SEIL. Co., Ltd. Shizuoka, Japan). For urine 5-HT
measurements, urine samples were examined with an All Species Serotonin ELISA
kit (LifeSpan BioSciences, Inc., Seattle, WA, USA). For each sample, the
calculated value was obtained by dividing by the amount of creatinine (u-8-OHdG:
ng/mgCr, u-5-HT: ng/mgCr). All concentration measurements were triple-checked
for maintaining accuracy (R
= 0.91-0.96, CV = 0.022-0.025). Saliva samples were used to measure
s-HHV-6 and collected with a Salivette® (SARSTEDT AG & Co. KG,
Nümbrecht, Germany). They were then centrifuged for 15 minutes at 1500 rpm, and
frozen and stored at −20°C. s-HHV-6 reaction was assessed by extracting all DNA
from the saliva sample, then quantifying the amount of s-HHV-6 DNA using a
real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay. The number of
HHV-6 copies in 1 mL of saliva (copies/mL) was obtained using an in
vitro real-time amplification test (HHV-6 Real-TM Quant; Sacace
Biotechnologies Srl, Como, Italy).
Statistical analysis
The sample size was determined according to the change of u-8-OHdG level by the
national license examination using unified power. Based on the results of a
prior study conducted by Iida et al
on the relationship between before and after the national license
examination and after considering M1 = 7.5 (mean u-8-OHdG level of before the
national license Examination), SD 1 = 1.95, M2 = 11.4 (mean u-8-OHdG level of
after the national license Examination), SD2 = 1.30, correlation
coefficient = .36, two-sided α = .05, and power = 95%, the minimum number of
participants was determined to be 6, which was increased to 16 to take account
for potential attrition.[38,39] The effects of
psychological stress on subjective stress and stress-related biomarkers were
investigated using one-way repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) and
Friedman’s test. One-way repeated-measures ANOVA was conducted by considering
the 4 periods before and after the OSCE (intra-individual level at 1 month,
1 week, 1 day before, and 1 week after) as a single factor, and subjective
stress (SDS and STAI scores), and u-8-OHdG and u-5-HT levels as dependent
variables. Next, multiple comparisons were done using the Bonferroni method.
Friedman’s test was also performed with the 4 periods before and after the OSCE
as a single factor, and s-HHV-6 level as the dependent variable. For multiple
comparison analysis, Bonferroni correction for the mean rank obtained from
Friedman’s test and the number of pairs was performed. The normality of SDS and
STAI scores, and u-8-OHdG and u-5-HT levels was confirmed with a histogram
together with a Shapiro-Wilk test for normality (P > .20).
The normality of s-HHV-6 was shown to be less than P = .05 with
a histogram and the Shapiro-Wilk test, thus no normality was seen. SDS and STAI
scores, and u-8-OHdG and u-5-HT levels of the participants are presented as the
mean ± SD. For s-HHV-6, median and quartile values are shown. SPSS 25.0 J (IBM
Japan, Tokyo) was used for the analyses, with the level of significance set at
P < .05.
Results
Subjective stress
SDS scores
A significant relationship was noted between SDS scores and the 4 periods
before and after the OSCE (P = .002, one-way repeated
measures ANOVA) (Figure
2). The value seen at 1 week before was significantly higher than
that at 1 month before the OSCE (P = .019), while a
significantly lower value was seen at 1 week after as compared with 1 week
before the OSCE (P = .018).
Figure 2.
Relationship between SDS scores and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P = .002.
Values are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error bars).
Bonferroni correction was conducted for each period.
Abbreviations: SDS, self-rating depression scale.
Relationship between SDS scores and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P = .002.
Values are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error bars).
Bonferroni correction was conducted for each period.Abbreviations: SDS, self-rating depression scale.
STAI scores
A significant relationship was noted between STAI scores and the 4 periods
before and after the OSCE (P < .001, one-way repeated
measures ANOVA) (Figure
3). The score was significantly higher at 1 week
(P = .004) and 1 day (P < .001)
before as compared to 1 month before the OSCE. In contrast, it was
significantly lower at 1 week after than 1 day before the OSCE
(P = .004). Furthermore, the trait anxiety score was
significantly higher at 1 week (P = .031) and 1 day
(P = .017) before as compared to 1 month before the
OSCE.
Figure 3.
Relationship between STAI scores and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P < .001
(state and trait anxiety). Solid line indicates STAI scores (state
anxiety). Dotted line indicates STAI scores (trait anxiety). Values
are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error bars).
Bonferroni correction was conducted for each period.
Relationship between STAI scores and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P < .001
(state and trait anxiety). Solid line indicates STAI scores (state
anxiety). Dotted line indicates STAI scores (trait anxiety). Values
are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error bars).
Bonferroni correction was conducted for each period.Abbreviations: STAI, state–trait anxiety inventory.
Oxidative stress and fatigue biomarkers
U-8-OHdG levels
No significant relationship was noted between u-8-OHdG levels and the 4
periods before and after the OSCE (P = .300, one-way
repeated measures ANOVA) (Figure 4).
Figure 4.
Relationship between u-8-OHdG levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P = .300.
Values are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error
bars).
Relationship between u-8-OHdG levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). One-way
repeated-measures analysis of variance: P = .300.
Values are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (error
bars).Abbreviations: u-8-OHdG, urinary 8-hydroxy-2ʹ-deoxyguanosine.
U-5-HT levels
A borderline significant relationship was noted between u-5-HT levels and the
4 periods before and after the OSCE (P = 0.097, one-way
repeated measures ANOVA) (Figure 5). The level of u-5-HT showed a gradual increase prior
to the OSCE, with a tendency for the greatest increase at 1 week after the
examination. In addition, the value was significantly higher at 1 week after
as compared to 1 week before the OSCE (P = .076, adjusted
Bonferroni correction).
Figure 5.
Relationship between u-5-HT levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). Upper: u-5-HT
levels in 4 periods before and after OSCE. Lower: Two-way analysis
of variance by Friedman ranking for 4 periods before and after the
OSCE. One-way repeated-measures analysis of variance:
P = .097. Values are expressed as the
mean ± standard deviation (error bars).
Relationship between u-5-HT levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). Upper: u-5-HT
levels in 4 periods before and after OSCE. Lower: Two-way analysis
of variance by Friedman ranking for 4 periods before and after the
OSCE. One-way repeated-measures analysis of variance:
P = .097. Values are expressed as the
mean ± standard deviation (error bars).Abbreviations: u-5-HT, urinary 5-hydroxytryptamine.
S-HHV-6 levels
A significant relationship was noted between s-HHV-6 levels and the 4 periods
before and after the OSCE (P = .022, Friedman’s test)
(Figure 6). The
highest value for s-HHV-6 level was seen at 1 day before the OSCE and that
was significantly higher as compared to the value at 1 month before the OSCE
(P = 0.037, adjusted Bonferroni correction).
Figure 6.
Relationship between s-HHV-6 levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). Upper: s-HHV6
levels in 4 periods before and after OSCE. Lower: Two-way analysis
of variance by Friedman ranking for 4 periods before and after OSCE.
Friedman test: P = .022. Horizontal background
indicates median −75%, dotted background indicates median −25%.
Median and max values are shown. Numbers indicate the median
(min–max).
Abbreviations: s-HHV6, salivary human herpesvirus-6.
Relationship between s-HHV-6 levels and 4 periods before and after
objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). Upper: s-HHV6
levels in 4 periods before and after OSCE. Lower: Two-way analysis
of variance by Friedman ranking for 4 periods before and after OSCE.
Friedman test: P = .022. Horizontal background
indicates median −75%, dotted background indicates median −25%.
Median and max values are shown. Numbers indicate the median
(min–max).Abbreviations: s-HHV6, salivary human herpesvirus-6.
Discussion
In the present study, the effects of the OSCE, a uniform source of psychological and
physical stress, on biomarkers of oxidative stress and fatigue were examined. The
results showed that the level of the oxidative stress biomarker u-8-OHdG was not
affected, whereas u-5-HT level (a biomarker of serotonin) and s-HHV-6 (a biomarker
of fatigue) levels were elevated before the OSCE. As for u-5-HT, that was gradually
increased as the examination approached, with a borderline significant increase
observed at 1 week after as compared to 1 week before the OSCE. The level of s-HHV-6
in saliva was below the lower limit of detection at 1 month before the OSCE in
nearly all participants, then was significantly increased in more than half at
1 week and 1 day before the OSCE. Based on these results, we considered that the
practical skills training conducted on consecutive days leading up to the OSCE
facilitated accumulation of physical and psychological stress.HHV-6 is characterized by its readiness to reactivate during a latent infection and
responds even to the relatively weak reactivation stimulus of accumulated fatigue,
at which time viruses are reported to be released into saliva.[31,40] In
association with accumulation of psychological stress or fatigue, it is known that
respiratory infections or herpes labialis outbreaks develop, while immune strength
is reported to decrease.
Mechanisms underlying decreased immune strength caused by stress are reported
to include activation of immune cells, such as macrophages, granulocytes, and
natural killer cells, and increases in cytokines including interleukin (IL),
interferon, and tumor necrosis factor (TNF).[41,42] Overproduction of cytokines
has been shown to induce reactivation of HHV-6,
with immune involvement also suggested to have a relationship with increased
detection of s-HHV-6 due to the OSCE.Urinary 5-HT is mainly produced in enterochromaffin cells of the intestinal mucosa
and excreted in blood, and is not highly correlated with serotonin in central
nervous system cerebrospinal fluid.
Previous reports have shown that urinary 5-HT is rarely increased by
psychological stress.[44,45] The present findings as well did not indicate an increase in
urinary 5-HT levels 1 day before the OSCE, the period shown to have the greatest
increase in psychological stress. However, 1 week after the OSCE, the level of
urinary 5-HT showed an increase similar to that seen at the peak SDS and STAI
scores. Possible reasons are stress-induced changes in intestinal flora[15,46] and
associated regulation by intestinal flora of enterochromaffin cells.[47,48] In addition,
it has been reported that 5-HT has a function of suppressing inflammatory cytokines
(TNF-alfa, IL-6, etc).[17,49]The present results showed that the level of s-HHV-6 at 1 day before the OSCE, as
well as that and the level of u-5-HT at 1 week after the OSCE were elevated. The
s-HHV-6 level was increased in association with high psychological stress (SDS and
STAI) scores, while the level of u-5-HT level remained elevated even after the SDS
and STAI scores showed decrease. It has been reported that fatigue due to
overworking causes elevation of s-HHV-6B level,
which is supported by the present data. Also, it is known that elevated
s-HHV-6 is related to psychological stress, especially that which can cause
depression. Such stress stimulates secretion of HHV-6B from the parotid gland and
generates the SITH-CAML complex, which then induces increased CRH, Fkbp5, and REDD1,
and a reduction in hippocampal neurogenesis, leading to activation of the HPA axis
and inducing a stress response such as depression.
HHV-6B has an affinity for CD4+ T cells,
and invades the host via the specific human receptor CD134 and the
gH/gL/gQ1/gQ2 complex.[52-54] In a previous
mouse study, activation of CD4+ T-cells was found to upregulate enterochromaffin
(EC) cell-derived 5-HT, though that process in humans has yet to be reported.
u-5-HT is mainly generated by and released from EC-cells, with virus
infection or intestinal flora considered to be involved in its regulation.[47,48] That then
increases the sense of temporal depression via the increase in the s-HHV-6 axis
caused by fatigue from testing, such as the OSCE. At the same time, it is considered
that s-HHV-6 activates T-cells and the interaction with EC cells of the intestinal
mucosa generates 5-HT. Based on these factors, there may be time lags between
psychological stress scores (SDS, STAI), and s-HHV-6 and u-5-HT level changes.The present findings showed that the OSCE is a psychological stressor, based on SDS
and STAI, both of which are psychological stress tests, though it did not cause
increases in u-8-OHdG levels. Psychological stress is reported to induce ROS
increases,[9-11] while it has
also been shown that u-8-OHdG levels rise together with increased oxidative stress
in the body.
We found a significant correlation between self-rated depression scale (SDS)
and u-8-OHdG,
suggested that young females with depressive symptoms are in a state of
increased oxidative stress. Shimanoe et al
reported a weak positive association between perceived stress and urinary
excretion of u-8-OHdG, and detected high levels of u-8-OHdG in participants with
high levels of perceived (psychological) stress. However, since the present female
students showed normal limits in SDS and STAI results, psychological stress caused
by the OSCE had no effect to increase urinary 8-OHdG levels. Similar to national
examinations and other types of written tests,
the OSCE is both a psychological and physical stressor due to the performance
examination of attitudes and skills. However, it might be difficult to detect the
effects of physical psychological stress caused by the OSCE.This study has several limitations. First, the subject cohort was comprised of female
students from a single university, thus it would therefore be inappropriate to
generalize the findings, though their height and weight were similar to those found
in a national survey conducted in Japan.
In addition, the lifestyles of the students were likely quite similar, unlike
the general population, though that may also be related to a higher internal
validity of the results. Also, smoking history relied on self-reporting and nicotine
levels in urine may need to be measured in a future study. Furthermore, in
consideration of the influence of premenstrual syndrome, no survey was conducted
within 3 days before menstruation. However, since premenstrual syndrome can begin up
to 10 days before menstruation, its influence cannot be excluded. Although full
consideration was given to the confidentiality of the survey content, psychological
stress, smoking, and premenstrual syndrome are known to be related.[23,57] Finally,
psychological stressors were assessed only with the SDS and STAI, and the
participants were not examined by a psychiatrist, thus it cannot be ruled out that
some may have been affected by depression. And self-efficacy might have attenuated
the SDS and STAI.
In a future study, it may be necessary to make judgments about psychological
stress together with results from a psychiatric examination. Nevertheless, the
findings suggest that s-HHV-6 can be used for objective assessment of psychological
and physical stress in young females, including that produced not only by knowledge
regarding, but also skill and attitude aspects of the OSCE. Additionally, the
relationships of severity of depression and anxiety with levels of biological
markers, as well as the correlation of their change rates can vary among individuals
and each investigated item. Therefore, the present results cannot be used to show a
relationship of depression and anxiety severity with levels of biological markers.
In the future, we intend to examine the relationship over time, including the time
lag for increased rates of biomarker levels found in the present study, and scales
indicating the severity of depression and anxiety.
Conclusion
This study of 16 healthy young females revealed responses by s-HHV-6 related to the
OSCE, but no significant oxidative stress responses. Psychological factors
(depression, anxiety) are known to be sensitive to stress. Although the OSCE did not
show effects on u-8-OHdG levels, a biomarker of oxidative stress, the levels of
s-HHV-6, a biomarker of fatigue, were elevated. In addition, an increase in the
levels of u-5-HT was detected at 1 week after the examination. Our results suggest
that s-HHV-6 can be used for objective assessment of fatigue caused by psychological
and physical stress in young females, including that produced not only by knowledge
of, but also skill and attitude aspects of the OSCE. In addition, they provide
evidence that fatigue biomarkers can be utilized for considering the status of
students under psychological and physical stress conditions.
Authors: H Takatsuka; Y Takemoto; T Okamoto; Y Fujimori; S Tamura; H Wada; M Okada; A Kanamaru; E Kakishita Journal: Int J Hematol Date: 2000-04 Impact factor: 2.490