| Literature DB >> 34528014 |
Pamela Laird1,2, Roz Walker3, Fenella J Gill4, Jack Whitby1, Anne B Chang5,6,7, André Schultz1,8,9.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Among Aboriginal children, the burden of acute respiratory tract infections (ALRIs) with consequent bronchiectasis post-hospitalisation is high. Clinical practice guidelines recommend medical follow-up one-month following discharge, which provides an opportunity to screen and manage persistent symptoms and may prevent bronchiectasis. Medical follow-up is not routinely undertaken in most centres. We aimed to identify barriers and facilitators and map steps required for medical follow-up of Aboriginal children hospitalised with ALRIs.Entities:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34528014 PMCID: PMC8355903 DOI: 10.1016/j.lanwpc.2021.100239
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Lancet Reg Health West Pac ISSN: 2666-6065
Interview question guide to conduct parent interviewers
| 1. Did the doctor or other staff talk to you about your child's condition and the need to follow-up in a month? | 1. Knowledge |
| 2. What did the doctor/nurses tell you when you were in the hospital? | |
| 3. Did the doctor or other staff explain to you about lung health? | |
| 4. What did you know about lung health in children? | |
| 5. Did the doctor explain medial information in a way you understood? What would help improve understanding? | 2. Skills (of hospital staff) |
| 6. What is it like coming to the hospital when your child is sick? (Do you feel safe or scared?) | 3. Hospital environment and processes |
| 7. Did you feel okay about talking with the doctors/nurses? How can we help improve things for families? | |
| 8. What can the hospital staff or system do to help you see a doctor in 1-month? | |
| 9. What things might make it hard to follow-up with your doctor or AMS when you leave the hospital? | |
| 10. Did you feel your Aboriginality or your child's Aboriginality affected anything while you were at the hospital? | 4. Beliefs and attitudes |
| 11. Did you feel comfortable to ask your doctor questions? | |
| 12. Did you feel listened to or understood by doctor/nurse? |
Interview question guide to conduct with hospital staff
| 1. What do you need to know/do to provide health information to families and arrange follow-up for Aboriginal children admitted with ALRI? | Knowledge |
| 2. What would prevent you providing health information to Aboriginal parents and arranging follow up? | |
| 3. Do you feel confident in providing health information to Aboriginal families and arranging follow-up for Aboriginal children admitted with ALRI? What skills do you need? | Skills |
| 4. What do you think are the barriers to providing health information and arranging follow-up for Aboriginal children hospitalised with ALRI? (i.e., lack of awareness, skills, knowledge, lack of training) | |
| 5. Are there factors within the hospital setting that could be a barrier or facilitator for Aboriginal families to take on board medical information and attend follow-up? | Hospital environment and processes |
| 6. What processes or policies would assist or prevent with arranging follow-up? | |
| 7. Who is best placed to provide health information to families and arrange follow-up? | Beliefs and attitudes |
Figure 1Steps of thematic analysis
Figure 2Knowledge mapping process
Summary of consultations with external stakeholders
| 1. Knowledge | 1•1 Primary care clinicians identified need to know how to manage children and recognise chronic wet cough | Local clinicians need training in best practice guidelines. Easy access to guidelines to existing updated guidelines. Promote use of existing electronic training module. Create and promote use of /listening to podcasts. |
| 1•2 Hospital staff need to ask parents about Aboriginal status | Aboriginal status is not being asked and patients are not being identified. | |
| 1•3 Hospital staff to ask parents for local clinic details | Question of “Local doctor” being left blank, so summaries not being sent. Change way question is asked to “Where is your local clinic?” as local doctors change regularly and are not assigned to patients. | |
| 3. Skills | 3•1 Liaison between hospitals and primary care is needed following discharge of children with ALRI | Have a primary care liaison person in clinics to liaise with hospital about follow up for children. |
| 3•2 Expert input locally | Ensure Specialist contact for local clinician provided to allow for any direction, clarification, or advice. | |
| 3. Environmental context and resources | 2•1 Discharge summaries | Discharge summary not arriving in a timely way. Discharge summary needs clear instructions for local clinicians with clear summary of management and link to training and guidelines. Improve system for timely discharge summary completions. |
| 2•3 Schedule appointment | Make appointment for local follow-up while child still inpatient. |
Figure 3Codes, subthemes and themes for parents to attend and hospital staff to arrange medical follow-up 1-month post discharge for ALRI in children
Figure 4Steps required to facilitate medical follow-up 1-month post hospitalization for ALRI.
Demographics of parents interviewed
| 1 | 0.6 | Bronchiolitis | Mum | (non-Aboriginal) | Mid-west |
| 2 | 9.8 | Acute exacerbation of Bronchiectasis | Mum | Aboriginal | Kimberley |
| 3 | 1.1 | Bronchiolitis | Mum | Aboriginal | Pilbara and Metropolitan Perth |
| 4 | 1.4 | Viral Induced Wheeze | Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 5 | 1.1 | Bronchiolitis | Mum | Aboriginal | Kimberley |
| 6, 7 | 2.4 | Pneumonia | Mum & Dad | Aboriginal | Mid-west |
| 8 | 0.9 | Bronchiolitis | Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 9 | 1.8 | Bronchiolitis | Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 10 | 2.8 | Viral Induced Wheeze | Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 11,12 | 0.4 | Bronchiolitis | Mum & Dad | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 13 | 9.0 | Aspiration Pneumonia | Mum | Aboriginal | South-west |
| 14 | 10.6 | Chronic Lung Disease | Mum | Aboriginal | Goldfields and South-west |
| 15 | 1.2 | Bronchiolitis/ Pneumonia | Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 16 | 0.11 | Acute bronchiolitis | Foster Mum | Aboriginal | Metropolitan Perth |
| 17 | 7.4 | Acute exacerbation of Bronchiectasis | Grandmother and leader in remote community | Aboriginal | Kimberley |
| 18 | 3.2 | Recurrent bronchiolitis | Mum | Aboriginal | Kimberley |
Barriers for parents to follow-up with their child hospitalised with ALRI post-discharge
| Theme | Sub-theme | Code | Exemplars |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Knowledge | 1•1Staff knowledge of culturally responsive care | Many doctors in room | Mum 4: |
| Doctors talking to each other in front of patient and family | Mum 3: | ||
| Disempowerment | Mum 2: | ||
| Parent belief of being “shamed” by staff or feel shame | Mum 2: | ||
| Clinicians rushing | Mum 2: “ | ||
| 1•2Parent health literacy | No health knowledge | Mum 4: | |
| No health information or explanations given to parents by clinicians | Mum 2: “ | ||
| Clinicians normalising cough symptoms | Mum 6: | ||
| 2. Skills (hospital staff) | 2•1 Staff communication with parents | Clinicians not listening or believing parents | |
| Clinicians dismissive of parent concerns | Aboriginal co-researcher case notes: | ||
| Use of complex medical terminology by Clinicians | Grandmother: | ||
| 3. Hospital processes and environment | 3•1 Admissions process | Regional parents do not have a designated primary care doctor | Mum 2: |
| 3̏•2 Discharge processes | Discharge summary and instructions not sent to local clinic/not sent on time | Mum 2: | |
| No appointment scheduled | Mum 2: | ||
| Parent forgets to make appointment | Mum 2: | ||
| 4. Beliefs and attitudes | 4•1 Prejudice and racism | Parents experience prejudice or racism | Mum 10 |
| Parents perceive staff as prejudiced | Mum 15: “ | ||
| Different hospital experience depending on skin colour | Mum 10: “ | ||
| 4•2 Parent perception of hospital | History of forcible removal of children | Mum 1: | |
| Hospital is a scary place | Mum 4: | ||
| Hospital is a stressful environment | Mum 2: | ||
| 4•3 Parent perception of self | Parent belief of being “shamed” by staff or feel shame | Mum 2: |
Abbreviations:
GP: General Practice doctor
Facilitators for parents to follow-up with their child hospitalised with ALRI post-discharge
| Theme | Subtheme | Code | Exemplars |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Knowledge | 1•1 Parent health literacy | Use of culturally relevant tools | Mum 2: |
| Use of simple language | Mum 4: | ||
| Doctors to give health information to parents | Mum 3: | ||
| 2. Skills (hospital staff) | 2•1Cultural skills | Clinician to build trust with parent | Mum 2: |
| Limit number of clinicians in patient room | Clinicians to have skills in engaging with families. Grandmother: | ||
| 2•2 Staff communication with parents | Clinicians to slow down when engaging with parents | Mum 3: | |
| Clinicians to invite questions from parents | Mum 2: | ||
| Clinician to listen to parents | Mum 2: | ||
| Framing of questions to parents | Mum 2: | ||
| 3. Hospital process and environment | 3•1 Cultural safety of environment | Aboriginal art and flags on the wards | Mum 4: |
| Provide Aboriginal liaison staff | Mum 9: | ||
| 3•2 Admissions process | Timing of ascertaining patient information from parents | Mum 2: | |
| 3•3 Discharge process | Discharge information sent to local primary clinic and hospital on time | Mum 4: | |
| 3•4 Follow-up process | Book follow-up appointment at time of discharge | Mum 2 | |
| SMS reminder for appointment in 1-month | Mum 3: | ||
| Clinic will ensure follow-up | Grandmother: “ | ||
| 4. Beliefs and attitudes (staff and parents) | 4.1 Parent perception of staff | Provide training for staff on impact of racism in health | Mum 15: “… |
| Doctors have credibility and are respected | |||
| 4.2 Parent perception of hospitals | Provision of Aboriginal staff in hospitals | Mum 15: “ |
Abbreviations:
GP: General Practice doctor
AHP: Aboriginal Health Practitioner
SMS: Short Message Service
Barriers for staff to facilitate primary care follow-up for Aboriginal children hospitalised with ALRI
| Theme | Sub-theme | Code | Exemplars |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Knowledge | 1•1Medical knowledge of clinicians | Clinicians not aware of risk to Aboriginal children and need for follow-up at 1 month | Focus group consensus of widespread unawareness by clinicians |
| 1•2Parent health literacy | No health information given to parents | Widespread unawareness of need to give parents health information in culturally secure way. Doctor 6: | |
| 1•3Staff knowledge of culturally responsive care | Unaware of interpreter service or need to ask if interpreter required | Nurse 3: | |
| Clerks not asking Aboriginal status | Clerk 6: | ||
| Clerks not asking for local clinic details | Doctor Aboriginal health: | ||
| Lack of staff training in culturally responsive care | Clerk 5: | ||
| 2. Skills | 2•1Cultural security skills | Lack of skills in culturally responsive care | Clerk 3: |
| 3. Hospital process and environment | 3•1Cultural safety of environment | History of forcible removal of Aboriginal children | Focus group Aboriginal health: Acknowledgement of history of forcible removal of children from hospitals creates negative stigma of hospitals for Aboriginal families. |
| 3•2Admissions process | Timing of ascertaining patient information from parents | A head clerk: | |
| 3•3Discharge process | No Aboriginal status drop-down box in electronic discharge system | Doctor 1: | |
| No ALRI drop-down box with auto populated discharge instructions for primary care doctors | Doctor 1: “… | ||
| Discharge summary instructions not sent to local clinic/not sent on time | Respiratory consultant: | ||
| Complexities of requirements for discharge summary | Discharge doctor: | ||
| 10 am discharge policy of hospital | Discharge doctor: | ||
| 3•4Follow-up process | Lack of policy for ALRI 1-month follow-up | Department of General Paediatrics focus group consensus: There is no policy or procedure for routine follow-up for Aboriginal children with ALRI. | |
| 4Beliefs and attitudes (staff and parents) | 4•1Staff views of other staff roles | Expectation other staff should give health information to parents | Doctor 5: |
| Excessive demands on busy staff | Nurse 6: “T | ||
| Staff may have bias/prejudice against Aboriginal people | Consensus of Aboriginal health staff focus group:1. Important to acknowledge institutional racism within hospital. 2. Important to acknowledge individual bias and prejudice within hospital | ||
| 4•2Staff belief about parents | Belief parents will feel blamed by staff | Clerk 8: | |
| Belief parents will feel discriminated against by staff | Clerk 5: | ||
| Belief about language proficiency of parents | Nurse 1: |
Abbreviations:
ATSI: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
GP: General Practice doctor
ALRI: Acute Lower Respiratory Tract Infections
ALO: Aboriginal Liaison Officer
AHP: Aboriginal Health Practitioner
Facilitators for hospital staff to facilitate medical follow-up for Aboriginal children hospitalised with ALRI
| Theme | Subtheme | Domain | Exemplars or consensus of focus group |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.Knowledge | 1•1Medical knowledge of clinicians | Training for clinicians on Aboriginal lung health | Focus group consensus: 1. Provide training to clinicians – at hospital and in primary care in person, online modules, and podcasts. 2. Easy access to best practice guidelines |
| 1•2 Cultural knowledge of staff | Training for staff on culturally responsive care | Provide training for clerks:1. How to ask Aboriginal status. 2. How to ask about local doctor. Doctor in Aboriginal health: | |
| 1•3Parent health literacy | Clinicians to teach parents about lung health and need for follow-up | Focus group consensus:1. Doctors teach parents on wards. 2. Nurses provide follow-up support education. 3. Clinicians ensure families given pamphlet with instructions | |
| 2. Skills | 2•1Communication with parents | Provide staff with rationale to provide to parents | Aboriginal health practitioner: “ |
| Telephone contact from unblocked number | Nurse in Aboriginal health | ||
| 2•2Cultural skills | Provide staff with training in culturally responsive care and engagement | Clerk 4: | |
| Provide role modelling | Doctor 2: | ||
| 3.Hospital processes and environment | 3•1Cultural safety of environment | Aboriginal flags | Clerk 2: |
| Increase Aboriginal workforce and capacity of non-Aboriginal workforce | Doctor in Aboriginal health: | ||
| 3•2Provide culturally secure health literacy tools | Develop flip charts and pamphlets | Nurse in Aboriginal health: | |
| Ensure tools are readily available | Focus group feedback:1. Tools to easily accessible in clinical workrooms of each ward. 2. Tools need to be accessible electronically on hospital intranet | ||
| 3•3Admissions process | Timing of ascertaining patient information from parents | A lead Clerk: | |
| 3•4Discharge process | Electronic discharge system | Focus group consensus:1. Add Aboriginal status to electronic discharge system. 2. Ensure local clinic is populated. 3. Template to be embedded into electronic system with clear instructions for local primary care clinician to know how to follow-up | |
| 3•5Follow-up process | Primary care follow-up in 1-month | Focus group consensus: Follow-up should happen in primary care not at hospital | |
| SMS reminder | Focus group consensus:Send automated SMS reminder to patients to book an appointment with primary care doctor | ||
| Clear hospital policy | Develop hospital policy for provision of culturally secure health information and follow-up for Aboriginal children hospitalised with ALRI, with clear directives on roles and responsibilities and processes. | ||
| 4. Professional role and identity | 4•1 Staff prejudice of parents | Provide staff with training in culturally responsive care | Provide staff with training in culturally responsive care |
Abbreviations:
ALO: Aboriginal Liaison Officer
SMS: Short Message Service