Takeshi Osawa1. 1. Laboratory of Theriogenology, Department of Veterinary Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Miyazaki, Miyazaki 889-2192, Japan.
Abstract
A certain level of endometrial bacterial infection and inflammation is involved in bovine uterine involution during the puerperal period. Factors that hamper normal uterine involution expose the uterine environment to pathological conditions, causing different endometritis levels. The lack of proper diagnostic tools extends the time to conception. Efforts have been made to elucidate the postpartum uterine environment, including bacterial flora, changes in transient endometrial inflammation, and the pathophysiology of endometritis, to improve bovine reproductive performance. E. coli and Trueperella pyogenes in the uterus are likely to cause persistent infection, and Mycoplasma bovigenitalium infection is associated with dystocia and cytological endometritis in postpartum dairy cows. Due to the widespread use of cytobrush as a diagnostic tool for bovine subclinical endometritis (SE) that enables quantification of the degree of inflammation, we found that endometritis at week 5 postpartum was associated with delayed first ovulation. Approximately 30% of open cows have SE during the postpartum period, and cows with low blood glucose during prepartum have a high risk of developing SE. Additionally, cows with purulent vaginal discharge do not always have endometritis but only vaginitis and/or cervicitis. Intrauterine infusion of polyvinylpyrrolidone-iodine (PVP-I) improves fertility and promotes endometrial epithelial cell regeneration after inducing transient uterine inflammation, suggesting that PVP-I could be a good alternative to antibiotics. In conclusion, prepartum management to prevent glucose deficiency, prompt diagnosis to identify causative agents and intrauterine inflammation levels, and appropriate treatment to minimize antimicrobial resistance is beneficial for tackling endometritis and improving reproductive performance in bovine herds.
A certain level of endometrial bacterial infection and inflammation is involved in bovine uterine involution during the puerperal period. Factors that hamper normal uterine involution expose the uterine environment to pathological conditions, causing different endometritis levels. The lack of proper diagnostic tools extends the time to conception. Efforts have been made to elucidate the postpartum uterine environment, including bacterial flora, changes in transient endometrial inflammation, and the pathophysiology of endometritis, to improve bovine reproductive performance. E. coli and Trueperella pyogenes in the uterus are likely to cause persistent infection, and Mycoplasma bovigenitalium infection is associated with dystocia and cytological endometritis in postpartum dairy cows. Due to the widespread use of cytobrush as a diagnostic tool for bovine subclinical endometritis (SE) that enables quantification of the degree of inflammation, we found that endometritis at week 5 postpartum was associated with delayed first ovulation. Approximately 30% of open cows have SE during the postpartum period, and cows with low blood glucose during prepartum have a high risk of developing SE. Additionally, cows with purulent vaginal discharge do not always have endometritis but only vaginitis and/or cervicitis. Intrauterine infusion of polyvinylpyrrolidone-iodine (PVP-I) improves fertility and promotes endometrial epithelial cell regeneration after inducing transient uterine inflammation, suggesting that PVP-I could be a good alternative to antibiotics. In conclusion, prepartum management to prevent glucose deficiency, prompt diagnosis to identify causative agents and intrauterine inflammation levels, and appropriate treatment to minimize antimicrobial resistance is beneficial for tackling endometritis and improving reproductive performance in bovine herds.
The decline in the conception rate of dairy and beef cows is a major reproductive management problem in Japan and other parts of the world [1]. It is
important to identify the predisposing factors, establish proper diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for reproductive disorders in the early postpartum period, and breed healthy animals to
tackle this decline. After calving, the pituitary gland exerts its luteinizing hormone response to gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) as early as 7 days postpartum [2], and ovarian function resumes a few weeks postpartum. Complete uterine involution takes more time than ovarian function, and the uterus is usually not ready for the embryo
to implant until approximately 5 weeks postpartum in cows. When the ovaries start functioning normally, and uterine involution becomes complete, some cows can conceive by artificial
insemination (AI) after estrous detection or a timed AI protocol without estrous detection [3,4,5,6,7,8]. However, some other cows cannot
get pregnant because the uterine environment is not yet ready to accept the embryo for implantation because of persistent intrauterine inflammation beyond the puerperium.Factors involved in persistent intrauterine inflammation include improper metabolism, abnormal calving, and unhygienic barn conditions (Fig. 1). Heavy bacterial colonization after dystocia, poor hygiene, and poor uterine defense mechanisms can lead to puerperal uterine infections [9, 10]. Pathogenic microorganisms cause inflammation in the endometrium, delay uterine involution, and hinder embryo survival [11]. However, the diagnostic and therapeutic protocols that should be implemented to obtain the best subsequent reproductive performance remain unclear. This article reviews some of
the predisposing factors and the diagnostic and therapeutic aspects of persistent endometritis in postpartum cows.
Fig. 1.
A schematic picture of predisposing factors (yellow circles) for persistent endometritis along with prepartum and postpartum periods in the cow.
A schematic picture of predisposing factors (yellow circles) for persistent endometritis along with prepartum and postpartum periods in the cow.
Predisposing Factors for Persistent Endometritis in Cows
Metabolism
Nutrition and its management are important factors that affect the uterine environment of cows. We investigated the impact of metabolic traits and body condition score (BCS) during early
lactation on subclinical endometritis (SE) diagnosed at weeks 5, 6, and 7 postpartum [12]. In animals diagnosed at week 5, blood urea nitrogen (BUN)
and BCS at weeks 6 and 7 were significantly lower in animals with SE (SE group) than in those without SE (Non-SE group). In animals diagnosed at week 6, blood glucose at week 4 postpartum
was significantly lower in the SE group than in the non-SE group. BCS at weeks 3 to 7 was significantly lower in the SE group at week 7 than in the non-SE group. Therefore, low blood
glucose, BUN, and BCS could be risk factors for developing cytologically diagnosed endometritis at weeks 5, 6, and 7 postpartum. Later, we found that low postpartum and prepartum glucose
levels were associated with uterine infection in postpartum dairy cows [13]. In this study, the blood glucose concentrations at week 3 and week 1
prepartum were significantly lower in cows with infection at both weeks 5 and 7 postpartum (persistent bacterial infection) than those in cows without infection at both weeks 5 and 7
postpartum, those with infection at week 5 but without infection at week 7 postpartum, and those without infection at week 5 but with infection at week 7 postpartum (Fig. 2). This result indicates a negative energy balance prepartum in cows exhibiting persistent bacterial infection at weeks 5 and 7 postpartum. This decrease in glucose concentrations
might be partially due to inadequate dry matter intake. However, a more important contributor is the increased glucose clearance from blood because of nutrient partitioning, which directs
glucose toward the insulin-insensitive tissues, primarily the mammary gland [14]. These findings are supported by a previous report [15], which showed that cows with uterine infection suffer disturbances in energy metabolism until 4 weeks postpartum and delay in the physiological
adaptations required to meet their energy needs. This delay might be confirmed by decreased blood glucose concentrations at 4 and 6 weeks postpartum in cows diagnosed with endometritis at 6
weeks postpartum [12]. Glucose availability to fuel neutrophil function may contribute to the impaired capacity observed during the transition period
[16]. A positive association was detected between greater plasma insulin-like growth factor-I concentrations and clinical endometritis (CE) during 3
to 5 weeks postpartum in multiparous dairy cows [17]. These findings highlight the benefits of identifying cows at risk of developing uterine
infections around the calving period in terms of early implementation of preventive strategies. Veterinary practitioners or herd managers should monitor pre-and postpartum variations in
blood metabolite concentrations and BCS in cows since such variations might render cows more susceptible to uterine infection.
Fig. 2.
Blood glucose concentrations (mean ± SD) in cows of different test groups during the prepartum (3 weeks and 1 week before calving; wk –3 and wk –1, respectively) and postpartum period
(3, 5, and 7 weeks after calving; wk 3, wk5 and wk 7, respectively) (Reproduced with permission of the Society for Reproduction and Development from Ghanem et al. J
Reprod Dev 62: 457–463, 2016 [13]). Negative for infection (Neg-Neg: Blue line) at 5 (wk 5) and 7 (wk 7) weeks after calving, positive for
infection at wk 5 but not wk 7 (Inf-Neg: Green line), positive for infection at wk 7 but not wk 5 (Neg-Inf: Brown line), and persistent uterine bacterial infection at wk 5 and wk 7
(Inf-Inf: Red line).
Blood glucose concentrations (mean ± SD) in cows of different test groups during the prepartum (3 weeks and 1 week before calving; wk –3 and wk –1, respectively) and postpartum period
(3, 5, and 7 weeks after calving; wk 3, wk5 and wk 7, respectively) (Reproduced with permission of the Society for Reproduction and Development from Ghanem et al. J
Reprod Dev 62: 457–463, 2016 [13]). Negative for infection (Neg-Neg: Blue line) at 5 (wk 5) and 7 (wk 7) weeks after calving, positive for
infection at wk 5 but not wk 7 (Inf-Neg: Green line), positive for infection at wk 7 but not wk 5 (Neg-Inf: Brown line), and persistent uterine bacterial infection at wk 5 and wk 7
(Inf-Inf: Red line).
Abnormal calving
Stillbirth and dystocia both have a significant impact on the subsequent reproductive performance and productivity of the cattle industry [18].
Additionally, vulvovaginal laceration has been recognized as a risk factor for postpartum uterine disease [19]. Since there is an association between
abnormal calving and subsequent endometritis, understanding the risk factors for abnormal calving will help to implement measures to reduce the incidence of endometritis. We identified the
risk factors for stillbirth and dystocia in Japanese black cattle by retrospectively analyzing 41,116 calving records of 15,378 animals from 905 farms in the suburban areas of Miyazaki City,
located on the southeastern coast of Kyushu, Japan, and found that low temperatures during the late pregnancy period, primiparity, premature birth, and excessive fetal weight were risk
factors for stillbirth and dystocia in this cohort of animals [20]. In addition, we clarified the association between selenium and liposoluble vitamins
with stillbirth [21]. In this study, selenium and vitamin A serum levels in cows with stillborn calves were significantly lower than those in cows that
had normal calving. Adequate selenium and vitamin A levels in the serum are important for successful calving, reducing the subsequent risk of developing endometritis.
Microbial contamination and infection
In cows, CE and SE are characterized by a purulent uterine discharge existing in the vagina and an enlarged cervix beyond 3 weeks postpartum [22], and
a certain number of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) exist in the endometrium in the absence of clinical signs, respectively [23]. Whether the
disease is clinical or subclinical, endometritis is triggered by uterine microbial infection following contamination through the dilated cervix during parturition and colonization of the
endometrium. Causative agents of uterine infection include microorganisms, such as bacteria, viruses, protozoa, and fungi, which cause infertility, embryonic death, and abortion in cattle
[24,25,26,27,28,29]. Among them, bacteria are the most reported agents for bovine endometritis.Over 90% of cows have microorganisms in their uterus for the first 2 weeks following calving, 78% between days 16 and 30, 50% between days 31 and 45, and 9% between days 45 and 60
postpartum [30]. Most of these bacteria are environmental contaminants and are cleared by the uterus without impairing fertility [31]. Bacteriological studies have identified Trueperella pyogenes, Bacteroides spp., Fusobacterium necrophorum,
Escherichia coli, Streptococcus spp., Clostridium spp., Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus spp.
as the bacteria most likely to be associated with bovine endometritis [32, 33]. T. pyogenes,
Prevotella spp., F. necrophorum, and Escherichia coli are the major uterine pathogens [34].T. pyogenes cooperates with aerobic-facultative anaerobic bacteria and/or gram-negative obligate anaerobes such as F. necrophorum and
Prevotella spp. in formulating uterine bacterial flora [35]. Severe endometrial lesions are mainly caused by T.
pyogenes, which is the most prevalent bacterial type in the late postpartum period and acts synergistically with anaerobic pathogens such as F. necrophorum [34, 36, 37]. However, limited data are available on the persistence of
T. pyogenes and anaerobic bacteria in the uterus of cows and their association with cytological endometritis and purulent vaginal discharge (PVD) under field conditions.
Therefore, we examined the persistence of bacterial infections caused by T. pyogenes and anaerobic bacteria isolated during the postpartum period (weeks 5 and 7 postpartum)
using cytobrush techniques in relation to PMN percentage (PMN%) and the condition of vaginal mucus discharge in dairy cows. We observed that 15% of the animals had bacterial infections both
at weeks 5 and 7 postpartum (persistence of infection) and that there was a positive correlation between the severity of cytological endometritis, PVD, and the persistence of infection
[38]. Additionally, cows with persistent bacterial infection at both weeks showed a significantly higher prevalence of cytological endometritis than
those without bacterial infections at weeks 5 and 7 postpartum (Table 1). In this study, T. pyogenes was not isolated alone, except in one cow, but was isolated together with aerobic-facultative anaerobic bacteria such as
F. necrophorum and Prevotella spp. This highlights the importance of these pathogens in inducing endometritis. F. necrophorum produces a
leukotoxin, Prevotella melaninogenicus, which inhibits phagocytosis, and T. pyogenes produces a growth factor for F. necrophorum [22]. Contrastingly, although E. coli plays a key role in the metritis–endometritis syndrome complex [29, 34, 39], the number of E. coli-positive samples was surprisingly low in our study
[38]. These results indicate that the prevalence of E. coli infection decreases in the late postpartum period, while that of
T. pyogenes and anaerobes increases, which supports previous observations that E. coli dominated the uterus in the first few days after calving.
T. pyogenes was later found in animals with severe CE [31, 40], and E. coli
was a pioneer pathogen that predisposed cows to infection with T. pyogenes, which was strongly associated with CE [41]. In metagenomic
analyses of 16S rRNA gene sequences from endometrial samples of postpartum dairy cows, T. pyogenes was the predominant bacteria in animals with CE, and the microbiome in
cows with CE had a loss of bacterial diversity [42]. Vaginal E. coli from cows with metritis or endometritis possessed the virulence
factor gene as well as elevated motility and biofilm formation capacity that could confer the ability to colonize the bovine genitalia, and E. coli strains from phylogroup
B1 were associated with postpartum uterine disease [43]. The shift in the uterine microbiome in cows that develop metritis is characterized by
heterogeneity loss and a decrease in bacterial richness [41].
Table 1.
Prevalence of cytological endometritis in cows with and without bacterial infection at weeks 5 and 7 postpartum
Week 5
Week 7
Cows
PMN †
Endometritis
PMN †
Endometritis
≤ 6%
≥ 6%
(%)
≤ 4%
≥ 4%
(%)
Cows negative for bacterial infection at both weeks
29
3
9.4 a
24
8
25 a
Cows positive for bacterial infection at both weeks
1
9
90 b
1
9
90 b
Total
30
12
25
17
(Reproduced with permission of the Society for Reproduction and Development from Ghanem, et al. J Reprod Dev 61: 54–60, 2015 [38]). Bacterial infection was defined here as infection by T. pyogenes and anaerobes. †Diagnostic criteria for cytological endometritis were ≥ 6% and ≥ 4% PMN at
weeks 5 and 7, respectively. a–b: different letters reflect differences between groups (P < 0.001).
(Reproduced with permission of the Society for Reproduction and Development from Ghanem, et al. J Reprod Dev 61: 54–60, 2015 [38]). Bacterial infection was defined here as infection by T. pyogenes and anaerobes. †Diagnostic criteria for cytological endometritis were ≥ 6% and ≥ 4% PMN at
weeks 5 and 7, respectively. a–b: different letters reflect differences between groups (P < 0.001).Effective prevention and treatment of T. pyogenes, certain E. coli strains, and anaerobic bacterial infections should be implemented to mitigate the
persistence of uterine infections and inflammation, thereby shortening the days open in postpartum dairy cows. Other bacteria, such as Staphylococcus spp.,
Streptococcus spp. or non-E. coli aerobic gram-negative rods have also been isolated as additional flora along with major uterine pathogens [44]. In a recent study, common uterine pathogens were rarely detected, and the composition and diversity of the microbiota consisted of
Staphylococcus, Bacillus, and Streptococcus spp. in the uterus of cows with mild endometritis [45].Mycoplasma species can also be isolated from the bovine reproductive tract. The first isolation of Mycoplasma bovigenitalium from the genital tract of cows
was reported in 1947 [46]. While M. bovigenitalium has been found in cows with low fertility, in whom no other cause of infertility
has been found [47], it has also been found in the vaginal mucus of normal cows, which has led to speculation concerning its role as a pathogen [48, 49]. However, the association between mycoplasma infection and cytological endometritis based on PMN% remains
unclear. We investigated the incidence of mycoplasma infection in the uterus of 209 postpartum Holstein cows using a novel and rapid PCR to detect 7 mycoplasma species and detected only
M. bovigenitalium in 7.4% of the samples [50]. We also found that the incidence of dystocia was significantly higher in
mycoplasma-positive cows than in mycoplasma-negative cows. This might be due to the microbial entrance into the uterus at calving or reduced immune function in the genital tracts of cows
that have recently experienced dystocia. In addition, the incidence of cytological endometritis was significantly higher in mycoplasma-positive than in mycoplasma-negative cows at week 7
postpartum. This might indicate that M. bovigenitalium aggravated the severity of endometritis when it was associated with dystocia. Moreover, M.
bovigenitalium seems to be pathogenic to the endometrium and not opportunistic. These results indicate that M. bovigenitalium infection in the uterus might be
associated with recent dystocia and cytological endometritis in postpartum dairy cows. Additional investigations in a large population of postpartum cows are required to confirm this. Future
studies should focus on the follow-up of infected cows to evaluate the pathogenicity of mycoplasma, the ability of cows to self-cure the infection, and the subsequent reproductive
performance of infected animals.
Diagnoses for Bovine Endometritis
Establishing regular CE and SE diagnoses during the early postpartum period is important because it could minimize negative effects on reproductive performance, and hence, maximize the
benefits gained from improved reproductive performance. The Metricheck device for evaluating vaginal mucus turbidity during weeks 3 and 4 postpartum and fluid detection in the uterus by
ultrasonography and vaginoscopy during week 6 postpartum can be used as good diagnostic tools for CE and as a good predictive tool to predict the subsequent reproductive performance of dairy
cattle [51]. However, the diagnosis of SE requires the detection of intrauterine (endometrial) inflammation in the absence of PVD. Although the risk
factors and pathophysiology of PVD and cytological endometritis are at least partly shared, uterine and cervical tissue trauma and bacterial infection appear to play a greater role in PVD,
whereas regulation of the immune response appears to play a greater role in cytological endometritis [52].Several diagnostic techniques for detecting the occurrence of inflammatory processes in the uterus include ultrasonography [53], bacterial culture from
the uterus [54], uterine biopsy [55], and uterine cytology have been described [56]. Ultrasonography and bacterial culture have low sensitivity, and uterine biopsy followed by histological examination is expensive, time-consuming, and clinically inaccessible
under practical field conditions.In human and veterinary medicine, PMNs collected using a cytobrush are commonly studied as biomarkers to monitor the severity of inflammation and the relationship between a high PMN% and
reproductive disturbances [57, 58]. PMNs exhibit rapid chemotaxis toward pathogenic bacteria along with
macrophages and uterine inflammation can be detected rapidly as PMNs migrate into the endometrium [23]. Thus, endometrial cytology using cytobrush
techniques has been developed as a useful method for diagnosing CE and SE in cows. Additionally, PMN% determination is an objective method that can evaluate the extent of local inflammation
within the uterus since the occurrence of cytological endometritis has been reported to have a detrimental effect on subsequent postpartum fertility [59,
60]. While endometrial cytology using a cytobrush is relatively uncomplicated under field conditions, it still requires staining smear samples on
slides and microscopic examination to make a diagnosis. It is important to be able to rapidly diagnose postpartum endometritis using validated cow-side techniques to improve reproductive
performance at the herd level. Several research groups, including ours, have proposed the determination of leukocyte esterase (LE) activity, an enzyme produced by neutrophils, as a cow-side
test for diagnosing postpartum SE [61,62,63]. Test strips can analyze LE
activity in urine samples, uterine lavage fluid, or uterine cytobrush samples. Our results showed that LE activity correlated significantly with PMN% at 3, 5, and 7 weeks postpartum (Fig. 3). The finding that LE activity increased significantly in cows with SE agreed with that of previous studies [61, 62] and showed that the association was the strongest and many cows had high PMN% at week 3 because neutrophils were present at greater numbers than at weeks 5 and 7 postpartum. Cows
in the early postpartum period tend to have high neutrophil proportions in endometrial cytology [56], which may have helped to improve the sensitivity of
the reagent strip test. Our results suggest that evaluation of LE activity by test strips at week 3 postpartum may be an alternative to endometrial cytology for diagnosing SE.
Fig. 3.
Associations of levels of leukocyte esterase (LE) (n = 43) with PMN% in endometrial samples from dairy cows (Reproduced with permission of the Japanese Society of Veterinary Science
from Nazhat et al. J Vet Med Sci 80: 302–310, 2018 [63]). Graphs A to C show the associations between LE levels and PMN% at W3
(A), W5 (B), and W7 (C).
Associations of levels of leukocyte esterase (LE) (n = 43) with PMN% in endometrial samples from dairy cows (Reproduced with permission of the Japanese Society of Veterinary Science
from Nazhat et al. J Vet Med Sci 80: 302–310, 2018 [63]). Graphs A to C show the associations between LE levels and PMN% at W3
(A), W5 (B), and W7 (C).
Effect of Persistent Endometritis on Ovarian Status
We observed that PMN% was higher in animals with anovulatory follicles (> 23 mm) with low progesterone (P4) than in those with follicles of 10–23 mm, and animals showed corpus
luteum (CL) at 6 weeks postpartum [64]. These results support other reports, concluding that cows with bacterial infections in the genital tract had
slower growth of dominant follicles and were less likely to ovulate [35, 65].PMN% was significantly higher in the non-CL group than in the CL group at week 5 postpartum [66]. The PMN% and vaginal mucus scores during week 5
postpartum in cows ovulating by day 28 were significantly lower than the PMN% and vaginal mucus scores in those ovulating by day 49. These results suggest that a higher PMN% at week 5
postpartum is associated with delayed resumption of ovarian cyclicity in high-producing dairy cows. Delayed onset of ovarian activity in cows with endometritis compared to that in healthy cows
has been reported [67, 68]. However, no relationship was found between bacteriological findings and ovarian
activity [39]. Another group found no consistent relationship between the stage of the estrous cycle and uterine neutrophil function [69].Besides the first ovulation, uterine infection affects the length of the luteal phase after the first postpartum CL formation. Cows with persistent T. pyogenes and anaerobic
bacterial infections had a significantly prolonged luteal phase (PLP) than cows without infection, indicating that persistent T. pyogenes and anaerobic co-infection could
diminish ovarian activity [38]. Postpartum cows with uterine infections are less likely to ovulate because the growth of the dominant follicle is slower,
and there are lower plasma estradiol concentrations [22]. If cows ovulate, endometrial cytokines might alter steroidogenesis by luteal cells, which could
contribute to a lower P4 secretion or an increase in the prostaglandin (PG) E2/PGF2 ratio, which might extend the luteal phase.It is difficult to determine whether the presence of T. pyogenes and anaerobes retards the resumption of ovarian cyclicity or whether delayed postpartum ovarian activity
enhances infection and persistence of T. pyogenes and anaerobes. When ovulation occurs before the uterus expels all the exudates and debris, a heavy bacterial growth such as
that of T. pyogenes occurs, and CL is retained for a prolonged interval [70]. Furthermore, the first CL to develop in cows with uterine
disease secretes less P4 than normal animals [65]. T. pyogenes infusion into the uterus caused luteal regression;
consequently, first-wave dominant follicles, which normally become atretic and ovulated in half of the infused cows [71]. However, CL did not regress in
the remaining cows, and the mechanism determining the fate of CL remains unclear [72]. Serum P4 concentrations in cows with PLP were higher
than those in cows with normal ovarian activity, indicating that the occurrence of PLP in clinically healthy, high-producing dairy cows was not associated with uterine infection [73].
Treatments for Bovine Endometritis
Clinical endometritis
If loads of various stressors and pathogens exceed the immunocompetence of the host, the cow will fail to undergo a physiological uterine repair process, and intrauterine inflammation can
occur. Subsequently, intrauterine inflammation can persist and lead to subfertility or infertility if left untreated [11, 12]. In such cases, robust treatment interventions are required. Many therapeutic methods have been employed, including hormonal administration, such as PGF2α
or estradiol, and intrauterine antibiotic infusions [74]. For problems with residual hormones or antibiotics, antibiotic-resistant bacteria, withdrawal
periods, and safe and proper treatments to deal with these uterine diseases are needed [75, 76].Conversely, povidone-iodine (polyvinylpyrrolidone-iodine or PVP-I) has the advantage that it does not require a withdrawal period and does not pass into the milk [77]. While 2.0% PVP-I is commonly used to treat endometritis and pyometra, intrauterine 0.5% PVP-I treatment has positive effects on the bovine reproductive performance of
repeat-breeders [78]. Therefore, an adequate PVP-I concentration and optimal treatment protocol should be developed. We determined whether 2.0% or 0.5%
PVP-I is better for treating severe CE diagnosed using endometrial cytology in dairy cattle [79]. Cows with severe CE (PMN% > 30%), which had
recuperated from pyometra a week before, were treated with either 2.0% or 0.5% PVP-I. The PMN% in the endometrial epithelium 2 weeks after intrauterine infusion in the 2.0% group was
significantly lower than that in the 0.5% group. Moreover, the first service conception rate was higher, the number of services per conception was lower, and the time to conception was
shorter in the 2.0% group than in the 0.5% group. Thus, a 2.0% intrauterine PVP-I infusion seems to be a better option than 0.5% PVP-I in treating severe CE in dairy cows and in those who
recover immediately from pyometra. Presumably, the free iodine efficacy might have been reduced by the presence of even small amounts of organic materials, as ultrasonography cannot detect
them in the uterus after the removal of accumulated pus. Therefore, the final iodine concentration in the 2.0% group might have been closer to 0.1%, which is the concentration known to
release maximum free iodine and show antiseptic effects in vitro [80,81,82]; thus, 2.0% PVP-I was more effective in treating cows with severe endometritis. However, the threshold PMN% at the time of AI that could affect subsequent reproductive
performance and indicate the appropriate timing for treating endometritis should be clarified in future studies.
Subclinical endometritis
Intrauterine infusion of 2% PVP-I is not only effective in treating cows with severe endometritis but is also likely to be effective in promoting endometrial epithelial cell regeneration
and improving fertility in cows with SE as well as CE. We randomly divided 120 lactating clinically healthy Holstein-Friesian cows at 5 weeks postpartum into 3 groups: intrauterine PVP-I
infusion (PVP), saline (SAL), and no treatment (NTX); endometrial cytology was performed daily from day 0 (at week 5 postpartum) to day 7 in a subset of the cows to describe the duration of
inflammation after PVP-I infusion and to determine the effect of the infusion on subsequent fertility [83] (Fig.
4). All cows received timed AI on day 17. Although PMN% significantly increased in PVP compared to SAL and NTX on day 1, it decreased to a level similar to that of the other groups by
day 2 (Fig. 5), and the conception rate was significantly higher in PVP cows than in SAL and NTX cows. In addition, we conducted another experiment to evaluate the histopathology of the endometrium
in dairy cows. Twenty-five cows were randomly classified into sacrifice at 24 h or 48 h after 2% PVP-I infusion, and 24, 48, 72, or 96 h after SAL infusion, and histopathology was performed
on the uterus of each cow. Stratified columnar epithelium in the uterus disappeared 24 h after PVP-I or saline infusion. Subsequently, the epithelium was regenerated 48 h after PVP-I, but
not after saline infusion, and regenerated 72 h after saline infusion, indicating that neutrophil infiltration in the subcutaneous tissue may have promoted endometrial epithelial cell
regeneration after PVP-I administration. Future studies are needed to elucidate the relationship between epithelial regeneration and neutrophil infiltration in cows with endometritis and
healthy cows after PVP-I infusion into the uterus.
Fig. 4.
Schematic diagram of a timed AI protocol consisting of intrauterine infusion of PVP-I followed by CIDR insertion for 7 days in lactating dairy cows (Reproduced with permission of the
Japanese Society of Veterinary Science from Yoshida et al. J Vet Med Sci 82: 926–934, 2020 [83]). Animals were assigned to
receive intrauterine infusion of povidone-iodine (PVP-I) or physiological saline (SAL) at 5 weeks ± 3 days postpartum (D0), followed by a subsequent CIDR-synch timed artificial
insemination (AI) protocol 7 days later. PVP, Intrauterine infusion of 2% PVP-I; SAL, Intrauterine infusion of SAL; NTX, No treatment; PGF2α (prostaglandin F2α),
500 μg cloprostenol; CIDR, Controlled internal drug release insert containing 1.9 g progesterone; GnRH (gonadotrophin-releasing hormone), 100 μg fertirelin acetate; CB, Cytobrush; US,
Ultrasonography of the ovaries and uterus.
Fig. 5.
Changes in the percentage of polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMN%). (Reproduced with permission of the Japanese Society of Veterinary Science from Yoshida et al. J Vet
Med Sci 82: 926–934, 2020 [83]). PMN% in endometrial samples collected for 8 consecutive days after intrauterine infusion of povidone-iodine
(PVP-I) (PVP: n = 14), physiological saline (SAL: n = 15), or no treatment (NTX: n = 15) in postpartum dairy cows. Letters A, B, and C reflect the differences between days in the PVP,
SAL, and NTX groups, respectively. a–b: Different letters indicate differences between groups on D1 (P < 0.001); * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001.
Schematic diagram of a timed AI protocol consisting of intrauterine infusion of PVP-I followed by CIDR insertion for 7 days in lactating dairy cows (Reproduced with permission of the
Japanese Society of Veterinary Science from Yoshida et al. J Vet Med Sci 82: 926–934, 2020 [83]). Animals were assigned to
receive intrauterine infusion of povidone-iodine (PVP-I) or physiological saline (SAL) at 5 weeks ± 3 days postpartum (D0), followed by a subsequent CIDR-synch timed artificial
insemination (AI) protocol 7 days later. PVP, Intrauterine infusion of 2% PVP-I; SAL, Intrauterine infusion of SAL; NTX, No treatment; PGF2α (prostaglandin F2α),
500 μg cloprostenol; CIDR, Controlled internal drug release insert containing 1.9 g progesterone; GnRH (gonadotrophin-releasing hormone), 100 μg fertirelin acetate; CB, Cytobrush; US,
Ultrasonography of the ovaries and uterus.Changes in the percentage of polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMN%). (Reproduced with permission of the Japanese Society of Veterinary Science from Yoshida et al. J Vet
Med Sci 82: 926–934, 2020 [83]). PMN% in endometrial samples collected for 8 consecutive days after intrauterine infusion of povidone-iodine
(PVP-I) (PVP: n = 14), physiological saline (SAL: n = 15), or no treatment (NTX: n = 15) in postpartum dairy cows. Letters A, B, and C reflect the differences between days in the PVP,
SAL, and NTX groups, respectively. a–b: Different letters indicate differences between groups on D1 (P < 0.001); * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001.Recently, a high prevalence of multi-antimicrobial (including third-generation cephalosporin)-resistant E. coli in the uterine lumen of cows with metritis and/or
endometritis has been reported [84, 85]. Likewise, T. pyogenes isolates derived from postpartum
dairy cows with metritis harbored a high prevalence of several different antibiotics [86]. Cephalosporin is the treatment of choice for bovine uterine
diseases in many parts of the world. Antibiotic resistance of microbes surely affects the clinical outcome of treatment with cephalosporin, and therefore, may warrant an alternative
treatment [85]. Antibiotic resistance has become a serious concern for both animal and human health. Therefore, as an alternative to antibiotics, PVP-I
should shed light on endometritis therapy in cows, although it has been available for a long time.
Conclusions
A portion of the pathophysiology and some of the predisposing factors for bovine endometritis have been clarified through the cytobrush technique and the development of therapeutic protocols
during the early postpartum period. Prepartum management to prevent glucose deficiency, prompt diagnosis to identify causative agents and levels of intrauterine inflammation, and appropriate
treatment to minimize the emergence of antimicrobial resistance should be beneficial for tackling endometritis and improving reproductive performance and productivity in bovine herds.
Conflict of interests
The authors declare no conflicts of interest associated with this manuscript.
Authors: Patrick S Ramsey; M Dee Lyon; Alice R Goepfert; Suzanne Cliver; Jane Schwebke; William W Andrews; Robert L Goldenberg; John C Hauth Journal: Obstet Gynecol Date: 2005-01 Impact factor: 7.661
Authors: Erin J Williams; Deborah P Fischer; Dirk U Pfeiffer; Gary C W England; David E Noakes; Hilary Dobson; I Martin Sheldon Journal: Theriogenology Date: 2005-01-01 Impact factor: 2.740