| Literature DB >> 34390282 |
Aniello Maiese1, Alice Chiara Manetti1, Chiara Bosetti1, Fabio Del Duca2, Raffaele La Russa3, Paola Frati2, Marco Di Paolo1, Emanuela Turillazzi1, Vittorio Fineschi2.
Abstract
SARS-CoV-2 (severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2), the new coronavirus responsible for the pandemic disease in the last year, is able to affect the central nervous system (CNS). Compared with its well-known pulmonary tropism and respiratory complications, little has been studied about SARS-CoV-2 neurotropism and pathogenesis of its neurological manifestations, but also about postmortem histopathological findings in the CNS of patients who died from COVID-19 (coronavirus disease 2019). We present a systematic review, carried out according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review standards, of the neuropathological features of COVID-19. We found 21 scientific papers, the majority of which refer to postmortem examinations; the total amount of cases is 197. Hypoxic changes are the most frequently reported alteration of brain tissue, followed by ischemic and hemorrhagic lesions and reactive astrogliosis and microgliosis. These findings do not seem to be specific to SARS-CoV-2 infection, they are more likely because of systemic inflammation and coagulopathy caused by COVID-19. More studies are needed to confirm this hypothesis and to detect other possible alterations of neural tissue. Brain examination of patients dead from COVID-19 should be included in a protocol of standardized criteria to perform autopsies on these subjects.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; autopsy; central nervous system; histology; neurological manifestation; neuropathology
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34390282 PMCID: PMC8420197 DOI: 10.1111/bpa.13013
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Brain Pathol ISSN: 1015-6305 Impact factor: 7.611
FIGURE 1Search strategy: a methodological appraisal of each study was conducted according to the PRISMA standards, including an evaluation of bias. The data collection process included study selection and data extraction
Published studies on the histopathological features of neurological involvement in COVID‐19
| References | No. of brain examined | Sex | Age | Pre‐existing conditions | Neurological manifestations |
| Macroscopic brain findings | Microscopic brain findings | Additional information |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||||||||
| Al‐Dalahmah et al. ( | 1 | M | 73 years | DM, hypertension | Sudden onset headache, nausea, vomiting, and loss of consciousness | Brain CT scan: cerebellar hematoma, edema, and compression of the medulla, tonsillar herniation, intraventricular hemorrhage, and secondary obstructive hydrocephalus | Edema, upward herniation of the midbrain, tonsillar herniation, SAH, cerebellar hematoma, intraventricular hemorrhage, and marked lateral and third ventricle dilatation | Severe diffuse hypoxic changes with red neurons, acute infarcts in the dorsal medulla and pontine tectum, cerebellar microhemorrhages and neutrophilic infiltration, microglial nodules and neuronophagia in the inferior olives and cerebellar dentate nuclei, mild perivascular, parenchymal, and leptomeningeal lymphocyte infiltrates, perivascular hemorrhages, red neurons in the olfactory bulb | Tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in nasal epithelium, olfactory bulb, cerebellar clot, and cerebellum‐ Olfactory epithelium with chronic active inflammation |
| Bradley et al. ( | 5 (14 autopsies) | 3 F, 2 M | Mean age 68 years (range 42–84) | DM and other metabolic disorders, hypertension, OSAS, obesity, CKD, COPD, CAVD, osteoporosis, chronic pain, arthritis, cancer, demyelinating neuropathy, CVD, recent pneumonia, AD | Altered mental status (1), headache (1), none (3) | Not reported | Scattered punctate SAH (1), no diagnostic alterations in the remaining | Rare brainstem microhemorrhages (1), no diagnostic alterations in the remaining | ‐ |
| Bryce et al. ( | 20 (67 autopsies) | 29 F, 38 M | Mean age 67.50 years (range 34–94) | Hypertension, DM, CAD, CKD, COPD, asthma, HF, AF, obesity, co‐infections, cancer, transplantation | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Diffuse microthrombi and acute ischemic (3 small and patchy, 1 large) or hemorragic (1) infarcts; global anoxic brain injury, microhemorrhages, and vascular congestion (6); focal T‐cells infiltrates (2); neuronal loss and minimal inflammation in the remaining | ‐ |
| Deigendesch et al. ( | 7 | 1 F, 6 M | Mean age 71.6 years (range 54–96) | All except one had comorbidities, such as: hypertension, obesity, atherosclerosis, steatosis hepatitis, APL, DM, dyslipidemia, cancer, CAVD, IHD, hypothyroidism, AF, CMS, PD, CVD | Disorentation, agitation (1), vertigo (1), coma (1). Others had no specific neurological signs or symptoms | Not reported | Moderate global brain edema without ceredebral mass displacement (1) | Microglial activation, sparse perivascular and leptomeningeal T‐cell infiltrates, mild acute hypoxic‐ischemic encephalopathy (2) | Tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in olfactory bulb (4), optic nerve (2). |
| Fabbri et al. ( | 10 | 3 F, 7 M | Median age 60.9 years (range 44–74) | CVD, hypertension, glaucoma, CKD, drug abuse, obesity, DM, Crohn disease, dyslipidemia, COPD, IHD, AF, hypothyrodism | No specific neurological signs or symptoms | Not reported | Edematous and heavy brain (mean weight 1560 g) and meningeal congestion; bilateral uncal herniation (2); cerebral infarction (3), purulent accumulation on the leptomeningeal vault (1), focal SAH (1). | Microthrombi with focal microscopic recent infarcts, red neurons, small blood vessels ectasia, perivascular edema and microhemorrhages, scattered hemosiderin‐laden macrophages, microglia activation (5), leptomeningeal vascular congestion, mild perivascular T‐lymphocytic infiltration in one case | Olfactory nerve and brain tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in one case |
| Hanley et al. ( | 9 (10 autopsies) | 2 F, 7 M | Median age 65 years (range 52–79) | Only reported: hypertension, COPD, obesity | Not reported | Not reported | Hemorrhagic conversion of a middle cerebral artery stroke (1) | Ischemic changes (9), microglial activation (5), mild perivascular T‐ cell infiltration (5) | Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in 4 cases |
| Jaunmuktane et al. ( | 2 | F | Early 50s | DM, asthma | Not reported | Brain CT scan: recent and established multifocal infarcts | Acute and subacute watershed infarcts in the anterior‐MCA and MCA–PCA territories, and a subacute infarct in the right lentiform nucleus | Acute and subacute cerebral ischemic infarcts with granulation tissue and perivascular hemorrhages alongside fibrin microthrombi | ‐ |
| M | Mid‐60s | Hypertension, asthma | MRI brain: leukoaraiosis and right intraparietal sulcus high signal intensity (FLAIR image), microhemorrhages (T2 weighted); small acute infarcts (DWI) | Acute and subacute white matter microhemorrhages; bilateral subacute pallidal infarcts; occasional subacute microinfarcts in the cortex, some with hemorrhagic conversion | Mild leptomeningeal lymphohistiocytic inflammation in the right intraparietal sulcus; hemosiderin‐laden macrophages, swollen axons; several chronic infarcts and microinfarcts (likely embolic) in cerebellar cortex and right thalamus | ||||
| Jensen et al. ( | 2 | M | 66 years | None | Poor neurological state even off sedation | Brain CT scan: diffuse bilateral gyral calcifications | Thinning and darkening calcification areas | Multifocal subacute cortical infarcts with extensive perivascular calcification, cerebral amyloid angiopathy | Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: negative |
| M | 71 years | hypertension, IHD, COPD, DM | Slow to wake from sedation | Brain MRI: old cerebellar SAH | Small cerebellar SAH | Cerebellar cortical subacute infarction (corresponding to the SAH); internal capsule sub‐acute micro‐infarct; moderate T‐cells infiltration, neuronophagia, microglia activation with nodules, mild perivascular T‐cell infiltrates | |||
| Kantonen et al. ( | 4 | 1 F, 3 M | Mean age 68.25 years (range 38–90) | Hypertension, obesity, CVD, DM, COPD, CKD, osteoporosis, AD, CAA, malignancies, gout | Delirium and unconsciousness (4), ageusia (1) | Not reported | Brain swelling, substantia nigra and locus coeruleus depigmentation, putamen lacunae, enlarged perivascular spaces, microhemorrhages | Hypoxic changes and perivascular degeneration (4), inflammatory cells infiltration (1), vasculopathy with perivascular hemorrhage (1), white matter lesions (1), axonal spheroids foci (1) | Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: negative |
| Kirschenbaum et al. ( | 2 | M | 70 years | Renal transplant, CAD, hypertension | No specific neurological signs or symptoms | Not reported | Not reported | Perivascular leukocytic infiltrates, predominantly in the basal ganglia, and intravascular microthrombi | Olfactory epithelium histology and immunohistochemistry: leukocytic infiltrates in the lamina propria (T > B cells) and focal mucosal atrophy, olfactory nerve axonal damage |
| M | 79 years | Severe pulmonary hypertension | Loss of taste and smell | ||||||
| Matschke et al. ( | 43 | 16 F, 27 M | Median age 76 years (range 51–94) | CVD, COPD, or other pulmonary conditions, dementia, PD, epilepsy, prior stroke, IHD, CKD, solid or hematological malignancies, IBD, OSAS, trisomy 21, psychiatric disorders, cirrhosis; no pre‐existing conditions in 3 cases | Not reported | Not reported | Mean weight 1302 g, brain oedema (23), arteriosclerosis (all), ischemic lesions (11), grey matter heterotopia (1, the trisomy 21 case), cerebral metastasis (1), neuronophagy (2) | Astrogliosis (also in the olfactory bulb), diffuse microglia activation with occasional nodules, T lymphocytes infiltration, neuronophagy (2), ischemic lesions (6 fresh, 5 old). Immunohistochemistry: subpial and subependymal regions HLA‐DR positive | ‐ |
| Meinhardt et al. ( | 33 | 11 F, 22 M | Median age 71.60 years (range 67–79) | DM, hypertension, CAVD, hyperlipidemia, CKD, dementia, prior stroke | Impaired consciousness (5), headache (2), behavioral changes (2) | Not reported | Only reported: intraventricular hemorrhage | Acute hypoxic and ischemic lesions (both in the brainstem and brain, 6 cases), microglia nodules (1), microhemorrhages (1), acute/subacute hypoxic‐ischemic encephalopathy (1), SAH (1) | Tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in the olfactory mucosa (20) and cerebellum (3). |
| Paniz‐Mondolfi et al. ( | 1 | M | 74 years | PD | Intermittently alert and agitated | Not reported | Not reported |
Presence of 80 to 110 nm viral particles in frontal lobe brain sections. Pleomorphic spherical viral‐like particles within the endothelial cells, even blebbing in/out of the endothelial wall. Neural cell bodies: distended cytoplasmic vacuoles containing enveloped viral particle exhibiting electron dense centers with distinct stalk‐like peplomeric projections | Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: positive |
| Remmelink et al. ( | 11 | 3 F, 8 M | Median age 63.81 years (range 49–77) | CAD, CVD, diabetes, hypertension, CKD, COPD, cancer, liver transplant | Not reported | Not reported | Recently drained subdural hematoma (1) and cerebral hemorrhage (1) | Cerebral hemorrhages or hemorrhagic suffusion (8), focal ischemic necrosis (3), edema and/or vascular congestion (5), diffuse or focal spongiosis (10) | Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: positive in 9 samples |
| Reichard et al. ( | 1 | M | 71 years | IHD | No specific neurological signs or symptoms | Not performed | Brain swelling, disseminated hemorrhages (1 mm–1 cm) | Hypoxic changes, intraparenchymal hemorrhages with peripheric macrophages, axons damage, and oligodendrocyte apoptosis; generalized reactive gliosis; mielin loss; perivascular macrophage; few organizing/organized infarcts | ‐ |
| Rhodes et al. ( | 10 | 5 F, 5 M | From middle age to elderly | Only reported: hypertension | Not reported | Not reported | Brain swelling (2), herniations (2), intraparenchymal hemorrhages (1), cerebral infarcts (2), cerebral ventriculomegaly (2), non‐occlysive superior sagittal sinus thrombotic material (1) | Acute neutrophilic endotheliitis (10), acute perivasculitis (5), reactive microangiopathy (10), hypoxic changes (5), leptomeningitis (1), infarcts (5), perivascular hemorrhages (2), acute medullar encephalitis (1), microglial nodules (1) | ‐ |
| Schurink et al. ( | 9 (21 autopsies) | 5 F, 16 M | Median age 68 years (range 41–78) | DM, CVD, COPD, solid or hematological malignancies, other | Not specifically reported, in 1 case the cause of death was necrotising encephalitis | Not reported | Not reported | Hypoxic changes, extensive microglia activation and clustering, astrogliosis, and perivascular T‐cells foci most severe in the cranial medulla oblongata and olfactory bulb, sparse parenchymal T‐cells, neutrophilic plugs (3). | Brain immunohistochemistry for SARS‐CoV−2: negative |
| Solomon et al. ( | 18 | 4 F, 14 M | Median age 62 years (range 53–75) | DM, hypertension, CVD, hyperlipidemia, CKD, prior stroke, dementia, treated anaplastic astrocytoma | Myalgia (3), headache (2), taste decrease (1) | Brain CT scan performed in 3 cases: no acute abnormalities | Atherosclerosis (14), residual anaplastic astrocytoma (1) | Acute hypoxic injury in the cerebrum and cerebellum with cerebral cortex, hippocampus, and cerebellar Purkinje cell layer neuronal loss (18), perivascular lymphocytes foci (2), focal leptomeningeal inflammation (1). |
Brain tissue qRT‐PCR: low virus load in 5 cases. Brain immunohistochemistry for SARS‐CoV−2: negative |
| von Weyhern et al. ( | 6 | 2 F, 4 M | Median age 69.3 years (range 58–82) | CAVD, cirrhosis, fatty liver changes, AD | Somnolence (3) | Not reported | Not reported | Encephalitis (5), lymphocytic meningitis (6), petechial bleedings (3), neuronal cell loss (4), axon degeneration (3) | TEM: entry of SARS‐CoV−2 into the CNS via endothelial cells |
|
| |||||||||
| Efe et al. ( | 1 | F | 35 years | Not reported | Headache, dizziness, drug‐refractory seizures |
Brain MRI: left temporal lobe hyperintense signal in T2 and T2 FLAIR imaging. Brain MRS: choline peak elevation with NAA peak decrease (interpreted as a high‐grade glioma) | ‐ | Left anterior temporal lobectomy, frozen‐section biopsy: perivascular lymphocytic infiltrations alongside diffuse hypoxic changes | Tested positive for SARS‐CoV−2 days after the surgery, delayed encephalitis diagnosis |
| Hernández‐Fernández et al. ( | 2 | M | 69 | Hypertension | Not reported |
Brain CT: bilateral parieto‐occipital white matter involvement with extension to semi‐oval centers, left frontal intraparenchymal hematoma, and right frontal SAH MRI: multiple cortico‐subcortical microhemorrhages, posteriorleucoencephalopathy | Intraparenchymal hemorrhage in both patients | Large intraparenchymal hemorrhages, fibrin microthrombi, vessels' wall alteration (disappearance of endothelial cells, neuropil degeneration), extravasation of inflammatory cells with atypical lymphocytes in the perivascular space, fibrinoid necrosis in one small artery | ‐ |
| M | 61 | Dyslipidemia | Focal seizures | Brain CT: temporo‐parietal hematoma, SAH | Large intraparenchymal hemorrhages, vessels' wall alteration (disappearance of endothelial cells, neuropil degeneration) | ||||
| Total 21 articles | Total 197 | ||||||||
All the subjects were tested positive for SARS‐CoV‐2.
Abbreviations: AD, Alzheimer disease; AF, atrial fibrillation; APL, acute promyelocytic leukemia; CAA, cerebral amyloid angiopathy; CAD, coronary artery disease; CAVD, cardiovascular disease; CMS, chronic multiple sclerosis; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; CKD, chronic kidney disease; CT, computer tomography; CVD, cerebrovascular disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; DWI, diffusion‐weighted magnetic resonance imaging; FLAIR, fluid‐attenuated inversion recovery; HF, heart failure; IBD, inflammatory bowel disease; IHD, ischemic heart disease; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; MRS, magnetic resonance spectroscopy; NAA, N‐acetylaspartate; OSAS, obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome; PD, Parkinson's disease; SAH, subarachnoid hemorrhage; TEM, transmission electron microscopy.
FIGURE 2(A) Leptomeningitis with diffuse presence of CD45, also clearly evident at perivasal level (B). Microglia activation evidenced by IBA1 reaction (C). (D) Perivascular lymphocytic foci (CD4+). (E) Encephalitis with CD4 positivity and, (F) focal leptomeningeal inflammation (CD4+)
Summary of the main histological brain findings gathered from the published reports
| Main brain findings | Number of cases | References |
|---|---|---|
| Hypoxic changes (including red neurons) | 58 (29.4%) | ( |
| Microthrombi | 21 (10.6%) | ( |
| Ischemic lesions | 30 (15.2%) | ( |
| Micro‐ and perivascular hemorrhages | 24 (12.2%) | ( |
| Hemorrhagic lesions | 13 (6.6%) | ( |
| Microgliosis and microglia activation (with or without nodules) | 74 (37.6%) | ( |
| Astrogliosis | 52 (26.4%) | ( |
| Parenchymal or perivascular inflammatory infiltrates | 31 (15.7%) | ( |
| Leptomeningeal inflammation | 11 (5.6%) | ( |
| Olfactory bulb involvement (cell injury or virus RNA detection) | 57 (28.9%) | ( |
The percentage is calculated considering the total amount of examined brains (197).