Literature DB >> 34295531

Green spectrofluorimetric assay of dantrolene sodium via reduction method: application to content uniformity testing.

Nora A Abdalah1, Mona E Fathy1, Manar M Tolba1, Amina M El-Brashy1, Fawzia A Ibrahim1.   

Abstract

Green analysis has turned out to be of a great value in all areas, including pharmaceutical analysis. Thus, it is extremely important to consider the environmental influence of each step in developing any analysis technique. The present work illustrates a validated, simple and green spectrofluorimetric method for the analysis of dantrolene sodium (DAN). The developed process is characterized by being of high sensitivity as well as being relatively inexpensive. The suggested technique based on the formation of a highly fluorescent product of DAN via its reduction by the aid of Zn/HCl system. The resulting fluorophore showed a powerful fluorescence at λ em 344 nm after excitation at λ ex 279 nm. Calibration graph revealed a great linear regression (r = 0.9998) within concentration ranging from 0.05 to 2.0 µg ml-1. The suggested method had very low detection and quantification limits of 0.010 and 0.031 µg ml-1, respectively. The applied technique was effectively used in the determination of DAN in its pharmaceutical preparations. The results were compared with those from using the official United States Pharmacopeia (USP) method and they were in a good agreement. Moreover, content uniformity testing of DAN in capsules was performed adopting the investigated technique with satisfying results. The greenness of the suggested technique was confirmed by the three standard assessment tools. Therefore, the developed technique can be used in the routine quality control analysis of DAN with minimum harmful impact on nature or individuals.
© 2021 The Authors.

Entities:  

Keywords:  content uniformity testing; dantrolene sodium; green analysis; pharmaceutical formulations; reduction; spectrofluorimetry

Year:  2021        PMID: 34295531      PMCID: PMC8278042          DOI: 10.1098/rsos.210562

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  R Soc Open Sci        ISSN: 2054-5703            Impact factor:   2.963


Introduction

Dantrolene sodium (DAN) is chemically designated as sodium;3-[(E)-[5-(4-nitrophenyl)furan-2-yl]methylideneamino]-2-oxo-4H-imidazol-5-olate (scheme 1) [1]. It is used to treat muscle tightness and cramping caused by certain nerve disorders such as injuries of the spinal cord, stroke and cerebral palsy. It works by relaxing the muscles, so it helps to reduce muscle pain and stiffness and improves the patient's ability to move around. DAN is also used with other therapies to prevent or treat special cases of high fever (malignant hyperthermia) related to anaesthesia and surgery [2]. It is official in the US [3], British [4] and Japanese [5] Pharmacopeias, where it was determined by HPLC. Several reported methods were published for DAN determination including spectrofluorimetry [6], HPLC [7-11], HPTLC [12], UPLC [13], voltammetry [14-17] and colorimetry [18]. Investigating the literature revealed that a few analytical techniques were presented for the analysis of DAN. Most of the reported methods were chromatographic methods, which usually require high-priced equipment and advanced skills to manipulate them successfully. Also, most of the reported analytical methods were of high hazardous impact on both the analyst and nature [6,8-10,12]. Reviewing the literature showed that there was no spectrofluorimetric method stated for DAN determination except for that published in 1973 [6].
Scheme 1

Reduction of DAN to RDAN.

Reduction of DAN to RDAN. The recommended technique in this research is based on the fact that DAN does not have native fluorescence, which is attributed to the presence of a nitro group attached to the aromatic ring in its structure. It is known that nitro group has a powerful fluorescence quenching effect [19] because of its electron withdrawing ability. However, once the amino group comes out from reducing the nitro group, DAN gains its remarkable intrinsic fluorescence [20]. Based on the obtained high fluorescence of DAN, this study was devoted to developing a highly sensitive spectrofluorimetric procedure to determine DAN in pure form along with single and combined dosage forms. Content uniformity testing was also conducted to ensure consistence of DAN capsules. Our target was also directed to assess the greenness of the suggested technique in order to prove its safety to the environment. Moreover, the suggested technique was extensively validated according to the ICH guidelines [21] providing an assurance of reliability of the method during normal use. Therefore, this method presents the advantages of sensitivity, greenness, lack of sophistication and cost-effectiveness. The method is also specific and selective because of the absence of interference encountered from capsule excipients or from co-formulated drug, paracetamol. Green analytical chemistry (GAC) started appearing in the early 2000s [22,23]. This developing field cares about ensuring that the presented analytical procedures reduce consumption of harmful reagents and increase the protection of the analysts as well as the environment. [24]. Recently, there have been significant precautions in procedural means with the aim of avoiding or reducing the hazardous effect of analytical procedures. The main approaches involve re-using, replacement with greener options and decreasing the usage and detoxification of reagents and solvents. In this research, greener options were chosen in every step of the proposed method and its greenness was confirmed by the three standard assessment tools [25-27]. For spectrofluorimetric measuring, a Cary Eclipse fluorescence spectrophotometer with a xenon flash lamp was used. The applied voltage was 600 V. Smoothing factor of 10 was applied to the obtained spectra. For manipulation of data, Cary Eclipse software from Agilent Technologies was used. A Consort pH-meter (Belgium) was used. A model SS101H230 Sonix ultrasonic bath (New York, USA). DAN was generously given by Chemipharm Pharmaceutical Industries (Giza Governorate, Egypt) with purity of 100.03% as stated by the official United States Pharmacopeia (USP) method [3]. Dantrelax® capsules batch no. 200075A containing 25 mg of DAN are product of Chemipharm Pharmaceutical Industries and were bought from a neighbouring pharmacy in Egypt. Dantrelax compound® capsules batch no. 201123A containing 25 mg DAN and 200 mg paracetamol are product of Chemipharm Pharmaceutical Industries and were bought from a neighbouring pharmacy in Egypt. The water used throughout the processes was bidistilled water. All the solvents used were of HPLC grade while the reagents used were of analytical reagent grade. Surfactants such as 98% cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), 94% sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), tween-80, carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) and 32% hydrochloric acid (HCl), and chemicals used for buffer preparations such as boric acid and sodium hydroxide were all obtained from El-Nasr Pharmaceutical Chemical Co. (ADWIC, Cairo, Egypt). All surfactants were used as 0.2% w/v aqueous solutions. Zn metal dust was bought from BDH Chemicals (Poole, UK). Acetonitrile, ethanol and n-propanol are Sigma-Aldrich products (Germany), while methanol was bought from Tedia (USA). Acetate and borate buffer covering the pH range of (3.0–5.0) and (6.0–10.0), respectively, were prepared at a concentration of 0.2 M. Britton Robinson Buffer (0.04 M) covering pH range of (2.0–7.5) was prepared according to USP guidelines [3].

Experimental procedure

Preparation of stock standard solution

An accurate amount of DAN pure powder was weighed, transferred to a 100 ml volumetric flask, and dissolved using ethanol as green diluting solvent to make stock solution of 500 µg ml−1. The solution showed stability for at least 7 days if stored in the refrigerator.

Procedure for reduction of DAN

The used reduction system consisted of 32% HCl (1.0 ml) and Zn metal dust (0.4 g). DAN stock solution (5.0 ml) was added to a 50 ml conical flask containing 10 ml of bidistilled water. Next, the reduction system was added starting with HCl followed by the addition of Zn metal dust. The flask contents were left to interact for 20 min with intermittent shaking to guarantee the complete reduction, then filtered using a grade 1, Whatman filter paper, into a 100 ml volumetric flask. The 50 ml conical flask was rinsed five times using 3 ml of water and the washings were passed through the used filter paper to the previous 100 ml measuring flask. After that, the same 100 ml volumetric flask was completed to the mark with distilled water to get working standard solution of 25.0 µg ml−1 reduced dantrolene sodium (RDAN).

Calibration graph construction

Different volumes from RDAN working standard solution were transferred into a set of 10 ml volumetric flasks to get final concentrations in the range of 0.05–2.0 µg ml−1. The flasks were completed to their mark with bidistilled water and then mixed. The fluorescence intensities of the obtained solutions were measured at 344 nm using 279 nm as excitation wavelength. The relative fluorescence intensities (RFI) were plotted versus the final RDAN concentrations (μg ml−1) to get the calibration graph. Alternatively, the corresponding regression equation was obtained.

Analysis of DAN in single and combined dosage form

The content of 10 capsules of Dantrelax® 25 mg or Dantrelax Compound® were carefully evacuated, accurately weighed and blended. Then, an amount of the powder equivalent to one capsule of each dosage form was accurately weighed, transferred into two separate 100 ml measuring flasks followed by the addition of 60 ml of ethanol to each flask. The flask contents were then mixed by the aid of sonication for half an hour and completed to the mark with ethanol. Filtration of contents of each flask was done to get rid of the insoluble excipients. The filtrates were proceeded as explained in §§2.4. and 2.5. The capsules' nominal contents were calculated from the previously constructed calibration graph or by the corresponding regression equation.

Content uniformity testing for Dantrelax® 25 mg

Ten capsules of Dantrelax® (25 mg) were individually evacuated and transferred to 10 separate 100 ml measuring flasks followed by the addition of 60 ml of ethanol to each flask. The flask contents were then mixed by sonication for half an hour and completed to the mark with ethanol. The contents of each flask were filtered and the procedure for the reduction of DAN was then applied. Content uniformity testing was performed according to United States Pharmacopeia guidelines [3]. The acceptance value (AV) was then calculated after simultaneous analysis of 10 individual capsules.

Results and discussion

The proposed spectrofluorometric technique depended on conversion of DAN into a highly fluorescent product. This was done by the reduction of the aromatic nitro compound (DAN) using Zn/HCl system into the corresponding amino compound (RDAN) as shown in scheme 1. The RDAN showed powerful fluorescence due to the development of a stable resonance product of DAN by relation to former publications [20,28]. Consequently, RDAN was found to have a strong fluorescence at 279/344 nm. Figure 4 shows the fluorescence spectra of 1 µg ml−1 DAN and RDAN at 279/344 nm. Several experimental parameters influencing the reduction process and fluorescence intensity of RDAN were thoroughly studied and optimized to achieve maximum fluorescence behaviour. Comparing with the only published spectrofluorimetric method [6], which used hazardous solvents such as dimethylformamide, the suggested technique was much greener with no harmful effect on the analyst or the environment. The greenness of the proposed method was well assessed adopting the three ideal assessment tools [25-27]. Moreover, the previously reported method did not include either the determination of DAN in pharmaceutical preparation or the testing of content uniformity of the capsule.
Figure 4

Fluorescence spectra of DAN and RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1), where a and b are excitation spectra and a′ and b′ are emission spectra.

For more verification of the reliability and safety, the analytical performance of the recommended method was compared with some of the previously reported methods [6,8-10,12-15], as shown in table 1. The comparison shows the novelty, greenness, simplicity and high sensitivity of the proposed method.
Table 1

Analytical performance of the suggested technique and some reported methods.

methodrangeLODtechnique hazard and simplicity
spectrofluorimetry [6]0.1–4.0 µg ml−1not availableIt is a combination of extractions, chromatography and the fluorimetry. It is time consuming, as the extraction, evaporation and separation steps are performed in about 70 min or more [10]. Usage of dangerous solvents makes it a non-green method.
HPLC [8]1.0–10 µg ml−1not availableSimilar to the previous method, it involves prolonged extraction and separation steps.
HPLC [9,10]0.7–2.8 µg ml−18 ng ml−1It is very complicated and includes exhausting time-consuming extraction steps. Furthermore, the usage of many organic solvents has a very harmful effect on the analyst and nature.
HPTLC [12]0.1–1.5 µg band−10.033 µg band−1In terms of greenness, the usage of chloroform and ethyl acetate is not preferable owing to their huge toxicity and harmful effect on both the analyst and the environment. Also, this method is slightly time consuming as the saturation time is about 30 ± 5 min.
UPLC [13]0.5–10 µg ml−1not availableThis is a complicated technique through the usage of two columns and a photodiode array. The mobile phase contains acetonitrile which is considered one of the toxic solvents.
voltammetry [14]0.1–2.6 µg ml−1not availableThe used dropping mercury electrode (DME) is poisonous, so care should be taken in its handling.
DC and DPa polarographic methods [15]5 × 105 and 5 × 106 M respectivelynot availableDealing with DME and liquid nitrogen is very dangerous and needs high caution.
The proposed method in this research0.05–2 µg ml−10.010 µg ml−1Simple technique was employed. No toxic or hazardous solvents were used. This method can be applied in the pharmaceutical preparations and content uniformity testing. The degree of greenness was evaluated using three assessing tools.

aDC, direct current; DP, differential pulse.

Analytical performance of the suggested technique and some reported methods. aDC, direct current; DP, differential pulse.

Experimental conditions optimization

Influence of the reduction system

The reduction system regarding Zn metal dust amount, HCl volume and the time of reduction at ambient temperature was studied to obtain the highest fluorescence intensity. The main target was to identify the most appropriate reduction system to obtain the greatest fluorescence intensity without consuming resources. The effect of Zn metal dust quantity from 0.05 to 0.7 g, volume of 32% HCl from 0.5 to 2.5 ml and reduction time from 5 to 60 min at normal temperature and pressure on the RFI were studied. It was noticed that RFI increased by increasing Zn metal dust and HCl up to 0.35 g of Zn metal dust and 0.8 ml of 32% HCl. Thus, 0.4 g of Zn metal dust and 1.0 ml of 32% HCl were the optimal amounts to ensure complete reduction of DAN (figures 1 and 2, respectively). Additionally, the influence of reduction time on the product fluorescent and its stability was studied. It was found that the reduction process started immediately, and the reaction product reached maximum intensity after 17 min (figure 3). The stability of the reduction product was checked and it was found that it did not change for at least 7 days. The fluorescence spectrum of the produced RDAN is illustrated in figure 4.
Figure 1

Influence of zinc metal dust amount on the formation of fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1).

Figure 2

Influence of 32% HCl volume on the formation of the fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1).

Figure 3

Influence of reaction time on the formation and stability of the formed fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1).

Influence of zinc metal dust amount on the formation of fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1). Influence of 32% HCl volume on the formation of the fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1). Influence of reaction time on the formation and stability of the formed fluorophore RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1). Fluorescence spectra of DAN and RDAN (1.0 µg ml−1), where a and b are excitation spectra and a′ and b′ are emission spectra.

Influence of organized media

The effect of various organized media on the fluorescence characteristics of RDAN fluorophore were studied using cationic, anionic, non-ionic surfactants and macromolecules as (CTAB), (SDS), (Tween-80) and (CMC), respectively. One millilitre of each surfactant was added to a 10 ml measuring flask containing 1 ml (10 µg) RDAN solution, and the flask was completed with water. It was found that CTAB caused a slight decrease in the RFI of the RDAN while other tested organized media caused an obvious decrease in RDAN fluorescence as shown in figure 5.
Figure 5

Influence of various organized media on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Influence of various organized media on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Influence of pH

Different kinds of buffers, for example, 0.04 M Britton–Robinson buffers, 0.2 M of both acetate and borate buffer, covering pH range of 2–10 were applied to study the influence of pH on the fluorescence intensity of RDAN. The study revealed that the best RFI was achieved using water only without the need for any of the previously mentioned buffers, as demonstrated in figure 6. Consequently, no buffer was used during the experiment, since completing with only water produced the highest fluorescence intensity.
Figure 6

Influence of various buffers pH on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Influence of various buffers pH on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Influence of diluting solvent

The influence of several diluting solvents was studied to find out their impact on the RDAN fluorescence. The studied solvents were water, acetonitrile, methanol, ethanol and n-propanol. As shown in figure 7, it was discovered that bidistilled water was the most suitable solvent to be used, as it had the lowest blank reading and subsequently the highest RFI with reproducible results. Besides, water is the safest, less harmful, cost-effective and the ultimate green eco-friendly option as a solvent. Conversely, ethanol, acetonitrile and n-propanol caused a huge reduction in the fluorescence intensity of the RDAN.
Figure 7

Influence of various diluting solvents on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Influence of various diluting solvents on RFI of 1.0 µg ml−1 RDAN.

Method validation

To consider the suggested technique a validated procedure, the ICH [21] guidelines was applied to check the validity of the suggested technique, and the results are summarized in table 2.
Table 2

Analytical performance data by the suggested technique.

parameter
DAN
linearity range (µg ml−1)0.05–2.0
intercept (a)28.255
slope (b)488.712
correlation coefficient (r)0.9998
s.d. of residuals (Sy/x)6.153
s.d. of intercept (Sa)1.523
s.d. of slope (Sb)3.215
percentage relative standard deviation, % RSD1.610
limit of detection, LOD (µg ml−1)0.010
limit of quantitation, LOQ (µg ml−1)0.031
Homoscedacticityacalculated F1.17
tabulated F3.17

aSignificance level 95% and degrees of freedom of nine for both numerator and denominator [29].

Analytical performance data by the suggested technique. aSignificance level 95% and degrees of freedom of nine for both numerator and denominator [29].

Linearity, detection and quantification limits

Calibration graph was constructed within the range of 0.05–2.0 µg ml−1 of RDAN, each individual concentration relative fluorescence intensity was recorded three times followed by plotting it versus the corresponding concentration to obtain the calibration graph. Table 2 contains a summary of the data statistical analysis [29]. The data shown proved the linearity of the calibration graph using the homoscedasticity test which showed F-test value of 1.17 while the tabulated F-value of 3.18. That ensures the homoscedasticity of the variance and the validity of the suggested technique in the studied range. Also, the developed method offers a very high sensitivity with very low detection and quantification limits. All these features are at a low price compared with other reported methods.

Accuracy and precision

There is no significant difference between the results obtained from the suggested technique and that from the official USP [3] regarding accuracy and precision (table 3). It is based on a liquid chromatographic analysis using reversed phase HPLC and gradient elution with different ratios of two different solutions; solution a (120 : 80 : 7 mixture of ammonium acetate buffer, acetonitrile and glacial acetic acid) and solution b (70 : 30 mixture of acetonitrile and water). The used column is C18, the flow rate is 1.5 ml min−1 and UV detection is at 365 nm. The comparison was performed using Student's t and variance ratio F-tests [29].
Table 3

The results of DAN determination in pure form by the suggested technique and official USP method. N.B. The tabulated t and F values are 2.2 and 19.38, respectively, at p = 0.05 [29].

parametersuggested techniqueOfficial USP method [3]
mean99.63100.03
± s.d.1.601.08
t0.40
F2.53
The results of DAN determination in pure form by the suggested technique and official USP method. N.B. The tabulated t and F values are 2.2 and 19.38, respectively, at p = 0.05 [29]. Precision was assessed at two levels: repeatability was evaluated through analysis of three different concentrations of RDAN within the calibration curve three times each on the same day (intra-day precision) and intermediate precision by repeating analysis of every one of the three concentrations on three sequential days (inter-day precision). The two levels of precision were proven by the small relative standard deviations and are shown in table 4.
Table 4

Precision data for DAN determination by the suggested technique. N.B. Each result is the average of three separate determinations.

amount taken (µg ml−1)% found% RSD% error
intra-day
0.2100.81 ± 0.770.77 0.44
0.599.89 ± 0.890.89 0.51
1.099.47 ± 0.200.21 0.12
inter-day
0.2100.15 ± 1.291.29 0.74
0.5100.63 ± 1.431.42 0.82
1.099.57 ± 1.091.09 0.63
Precision data for DAN determination by the suggested technique. N.B. Each result is the average of three separate determinations.

Specificity and selectivity

Thanks to the specificity of the suggested technique, the excipients of the capsule preparations did not affect the results. Moreover, paracetamol in the combined capsule showed no interference in the analysis of DAN which indicate the selectivity of the suggested technique.

Robustness

The suggested technique robustness was determined by the steadiness of the fluorescence intensity upon intended calculated slight alterations in the optimum selected conditions. The changed parameters included Zn metal dust, 32% HCl amounts (0.4 ± 0.05 g), (1.0 ± 0.2 ml), respectively and the reduction time (20 ± 2 min). These slight alterations that might happen through the experimental process had no effect on the RFI of RDAN, as demonstrated in table 5.
Table 5

Robustness of the suggested technique using DAN (1.0 µg).

parametermean ± s.d.% RSD
amount of zinc metal dust, 0.35, 0.40 and 0.45 g100.72 ± 1.131.12
volume of 32% HCl, 0.9, 1.0 and 1.1 ml99.81 ± 1.121.12
reduction reaction time, 18,20 and 22 min100.07 ± 1.801.80
Robustness of the suggested technique using DAN (1.0 µg).

Application

Pharmaceutical applications

One of the targets of this study was to analyse DAN capsules either in single capsules (Dantrelax® capsules) or in compound capsules (Dantrelax compound® capsules). Comparing the obtained results with those of the official USP method [3] using t- and F-tests [29] showed no difference between them [3] concerning precision and accuracy, respectively as shown in table 6.
Table 6

Results for the DAN determination in single and co-formulated capsules by the suggested technique and official USP method. N.B. The tabulated t and F values are 2.77 and 19.0, respectively at p = 0.05 [29]. Dantrelax® or Dantrelax compound® capsules containing 25 mg of DAN or 25 mg DAN and 200 mg paracetamol, respectively. The nominal contents of the DAN in Dantrelax® and Dantrelax compound® capsules were found to be 24.98 and 24.97 mg, respectively.

parameterpharmaceutical dosage forms
Official USP method [3]
Dantrelax® capsulesDantrelax compound® capsulesDantrelax® capsulesDantrelax compound® capsules
mean99.9399.89100.30100.03
± s.d.1.141.351.010.72
t0.110.16
F1.273.48
Results for the DAN determination in single and co-formulated capsules by the suggested technique and official USP method. N.B. The tabulated t and F values are 2.77 and 19.0, respectively at p = 0.05 [29]. Dantrelax® or Dantrelax compound® capsules containing 25 mg of DAN or 25 mg DAN and 200 mg paracetamol, respectively. The nominal contents of the DAN in Dantrelax® and Dantrelax compound® capsules were found to be 24.98 and 24.97 mg, respectively.

Content uniformity testing

As a result of the high sensitivity of the suggested technique and its capability of easily measuring the fluorescence intensity of a single capsule extract after reduction with satisfactory accuracy, the suggested technique is perfectly suitable for content uniformity testing of DAN in its capsules. The test steps were carried out referring to the USP method [3]. The AV was determined, and it came out to be less than the maximum allowed AV (L1). The results show an outstanding uniformity for DAN in its capsules as shown in table 7.
Table 7

Results of content uniformity testing of DAN in capsules using the suggested technique.

parameterpercentage of the label claim
Dantrelax® capsules 25 mg of DAN/capsule
mean ()100.28
% RSD1.39
% Error0.44
calculated value (AV)3.34
Max. allowed AV (L1) [3]15
Results of content uniformity testing of DAN in capsules using the suggested technique.

Greenness evaluation

Nowadays the greenness of an analytical method became as important as its sensitivity. The greenness of the analytical method guarantees protection of human and environmental factors from damage and unpleasant effect of chemicals. The authors developed the presented technique making sure that it fulfils as much as possible the greenness requirements. The analytical method is generally considered ultimate green if it totally avoids the use of toxic organic solvents, time-wasting derivatization procedures, energy utilization and waste production. There are currently some established standards for greenness evaluation of analytical methods, such as the National Environmental Methods Index (NEMI) labelling, analytical eco-scale score [25] and recently the Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI) [26]. The above three evaluation methods were applied to the suggested analytical technique to evaluate its greenness, as explained below. The NEMI pictogram for the suggested analytical technique is demonstrated in table 8. The table reveals that the method meets all the criteria to be a ‘green method’. Water and HCl used in the suggested technique are neither considered persistent bioaccumulative toxic (PBT) [30] nor hazardous [31] by the EPA's Toxic Release Inventory [32,33]. The waste volume is not more than 50 g or ml and the method pH is not less than 2 and not more than 12. That is, the four terms of the greenness profile are fulfilled in the proposed analytical method. So far, this assessment tool is qualitative only, as the quantity of reagents or the kind of hazards was not involved [25].
Table 8

Results for greenness assessment of the suggested technique by three standard green analytical chemistry metric tools.

Results for greenness assessment of the suggested technique by three standard green analytical chemistry metric tools. Analytical eco-scale is a semi-quantitative tool and depends on several parameters, such as the amount of reagents, hazards (as defined by the Globally Harmonized System (GHS) for labelling of chemicals), energy consumption, industrial hazard, waste amount and treatment way. As shown in table 8, penalty points are calculated according to these parameters [27]. The penalty points are then added for the whole process and included in the eco-scale calculation, using that equation: The closer the results to 100, the greener the analytical method [27]. In the proposed technique, the score was 93 indicating an excellent green methodology. Tables 8 and 9 illustrate that the proposed technique fulfilled the majority of GAPI [26] criteria except field 15 (coloured red) which describes the waste without treatment. Field 5 is coloured yellow as the method includes simple preparation (filtration), field 10 is coloured yellow as the reagents used have moderate health effects as stated by National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) [26], while field 14 is yellow because the waste produced is 10 ml per sample. Overall, the results indicate the greenness of the proposed technique.
Table 9

Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI) parameters for the suggested method.

categoryadescription
sample preparation
 collection (1)off-line
 preservation (2)none
 transport (3)none
 storage (4)normal condition
 type of method: direct or indirect (5)indirect (simple preparation(filtration))
 scale of extraction (6)c
 solvents/reagents used (7)
 additional treatments (8)
reagent and solvents
 amount (9)<10 ml
 health hazard (10)HCl = 3 and Zn = 0)
 safety hazard (11)HCl = 0 and 1 Zn = 0
instrumentation
 energy (12)≤1.0 kWh per sample
 occupational hazard (13)hermetic sealing of the analytical process
 waste (14)10 ml
 waste treatment (15)no treatment
 quantificationbyes

aThe numbers between parentheses are the numbers in the GAPI pictogram (on the right in table 8).

bThe circle inside the central pentagram represent the quantification property of the method.

cThe pentagram representing items number 6, 7, 8 is not shown in the GAPI pictogram since no sample preparation steps is included in the procedure.

Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI) parameters for the suggested method. aThe numbers between parentheses are the numbers in the GAPI pictogram (on the right in table 8). bThe circle inside the central pentagram represent the quantification property of the method. cThe pentagram representing items number 6, 7, 8 is not shown in the GAPI pictogram since no sample preparation steps is included in the procedure. In summary, the proposed technique is considered green based on the results of the three independent assessment techniques. The proposed technique is environmentally safe for the determination of DAN with minimal impact on human health. The greenness of the suggested technique complements its simplicity, rapidness and sensitivity.

Conclusion

This study presents and validates a novel green, sensitive, time-saving and cost-effective spectrofluorimetric technique for DAN determination by chemical reduction mechanism. The high sensitivity and selectivity of the proposed technique made it easy and appropriate for DAN determination in single and co-formulated pharmaceutical preparation. This method did not require complicated handling like that associated with other techniques, such as chromatography. Additionally, the usage of dangerous organic solvents was not essential, which distinguishes this technique to be of lower toxicity and cost. The content uniformity of DAN in the Dantrelax® capsules was also verified. Therefore, the presented technique could be suited for routine quality control in pharmaceutical manufacturing depending on its high sensitivity and greenness. Click here for additional data file.
  17 in total

1.  Liquid chromatography in pharmaceutical analysis VII: determination of dantrolene sodium in biological fluids.

Authors:  S J Saxena; I L Honigberg; J T Stewart; J J Vallner
Journal:  J Pharm Sci       Date:  1977-05       Impact factor: 3.534

2.  Determination of dantrolene and its reduced and oxidized metabolites in plasma by high-performance liquid chromatography.

Authors:  M Lalande; P Mills; R G Peterson
Journal:  J Chromatogr       Date:  1988-08-19

3.  Quantitative determination of dantrolene sodium and its metabolites by differential pulse polarography.

Authors:  P L Cox; J P Heotis; D Polin; G M Rose
Journal:  J Pharm Sci       Date:  1969-08       Impact factor: 3.534

4.  A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical procedure: Green Analytical Procedure Index.

Authors:  J Płotka-Wasylka
Journal:  Talanta       Date:  2018-01-06       Impact factor: 6.057

5.  Liquid chromatography in pharmaceutical analysis VI: determination of dantrolene sodium in a dosage form.

Authors:  S J Saxena; I L Honigberg; J T Stewart; G R Keene; J J Vallner
Journal:  J Pharm Sci       Date:  1977-02       Impact factor: 3.534

6.  Simultaneous determination of dantrolene and its metabolite, 5-hydroxydantrolene, in human plasma by high-performance liquid chromatography.

Authors:  Y Katogi; N Tamaki; M Adachi; J Terao; M Mitomi
Journal:  J Chromatogr       Date:  1982-03-12

7.  Spectrofluorometric determination of clonazepam in dosage forms: Application to content uniformity testing and human plasma.

Authors:  Fathalla Belal; Fawzia Ibrahim; Zainab Sheribah; Heba Alaa
Journal:  Luminescence       Date:  2017-05-18       Impact factor: 2.464

8.  Spectrofluorometric determination of nimodipine in dosage forms and human urine.

Authors:  F Belal; A A Al-Majed; S Julkhuf; N Y Khalil
Journal:  Pharmazie       Date:  2003-12       Impact factor: 1.267

Review 9.  Spasticity - Pathogenesis, prevention and treatment strategies.

Authors:  Anju Ghai; Nidhi Garg; Sarla Hooda; Tushar Gupta
Journal:  Saudi J Anaesth       Date:  2013-10

10.  Comparison Study of Voltammetric Behavior of Muscle Relaxant Dantrolene Sodium on Silver Solid Amalgam and Bismuth Film Electrodes.

Authors:  Renáta Šelešovská; Pavlína Martinková; Michaela Štěpánková; Tomáš Navrátil; Jaromíra Chýlková
Journal:  J Anal Methods Chem       Date:  2017-09-13       Impact factor: 2.193

View more
  1 in total

1.  Development of Ecofriendly Derivative Spectrophotometric Methods for the Simultaneous Quantitative Analysis of Remogliflozin and Vildagliptin from Formulation.

Authors:  Mahesh Attimarad; Katharigatta N Venugopala; Bandar E Al-Dhubiab; Rafea Elamin Elgack Elgorashe; Sheeba Shafi
Journal:  Molecules       Date:  2021-10-12       Impact factor: 4.411

  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.