Literature DB >> 34291004

Application of community-based nutrition education needs assessment in reviewing the course plan of medical and nursing students.

Sahar Golabi1, Mitra Amini2, Atefeh Zahedi3, Maryam Adelipour4, Zahra Shamekhi5, Leila Fakharzadeh1, Samaneh Mansouri1, Mahshid Naghashpour1.   

Abstract

Background: Training needs assessment is the process of recognizing educational needs. This study aimed to apply a community-based nutrition education needs assessment to revise the nutrition course plan in the curriculum of the doctorate of medicine and that of the baccalaureate of nursing.
Methods: The study was designed in 2 phases: (1) nutritional needs assessment; (2) community-based revision of nutrition course plan. In the first phase, 13 nutrition professionals working in the region set out 5 priorities of nutrition-related health problems in the community by a training need assessment based on a survey and scoring system. Then, an expert panel determined the priorities of behavioral and nonbehavioral causes of the nutrition-related health problems by the nominal group technique (NGT). The results of the first phase were used to review the topics of nutrition course plans up to 20%.
Results: The priorities identified in Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan were obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus in adults as well as anemia in pregnant women, respectively. Also, wrong eating habits and insufficient nutrition knowledge were among the most important behavioral causes of nutrition-related health problems in the target community. These results were applied to a community-based review of nutrition course plans for medical and nursing students.
Conclusion: The use of nutritional needs assessment approaches by a survey and nominal group technique with a group of professionals provided an opportunity for a community-based review of the nutrition course plan for medical and nursing students as a first phase in the development of a community-based nutrition course plane.
© 2021 Iran University of Medical Sciences.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Community; Course Plan; Educational Content; Nutrition-Related Health Problems

Year:  2021        PMID: 34291004      PMCID: PMC8285544          DOI: 10.47176/mjiri.35.80

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Med J Islam Repub Iran        ISSN: 1016-1430


↑ What is “already known” in this topic:

Training needs assessment is an essential basis for designing a curriculum development and review. Indeed, community needs and learner needs overlap. In addition, the most medical schools do not deliver applicable nutrition education, and their graduates do not have the necessary nutritional skills in medicine. Also, medical students felt that the nutrition counselling of their patients is unsatisfactory.

→ What this article adds:

The aim of this study was to demonstrate the ability to use community-based nutritional needs assessment techniques to determine nutrition-related health problems in the community to provide a prospect for a community-based review of the nutrition course plan for medical and nursing students as a first phase in the development of a course plane.

Introduction

Need is the "gap" between current and desired conditions or "wants." The disparity between the current and wanted conditions must be measured to identify the need appropriately (1). A needs assessment is a part of planning processes, often used for improvement in education/training (2). Training needs assessment (TNA) is the introduction of the educational goal selection and an essential foundation for designing and setting a curriculum program and its elements. TNA is the process of identifying educational needs leading the training to help achieve the organizational goals. Moreover, TNA makes the necessary changes in the behavior of learners and creates critical abilities in the individuals and the society (3, 4). Most organizations develop and implement education without studying and analyzing needs. These organizations are at risk of being overtrained, less trained, or wholly abandoned (3). TNA results allow the administrator to set up educational goals based on the answers to 2 fundamental questions: Who needs education? What training is needed? (5). One of the educational goals is to meet the society's needs. Although TNA is done to determine educational goals based on learner and community resources, in many cases, the learner's need is considered to be the community's need. On the other hand, learner needs and community needs overlap. A needs assessment based on a survey is a way of asking the group or community members what their most important needs are (6). Studies show that the results of the TNA can be used to design students' educational curriculum, leading to the promotion of adequate health care by them in the social context of the workplace setting (7). Our research is within the constructivists’ research pattern. In constructivism, knowledge is socially created and realities are made by the interaction of interpersonal, cultural, and social factors. Therefore, there are multiple accounts of realities, and meaning is understood through mutual interactions between the researcher and participants and the context of the research. Accordingly, the delivery of nutrition care by a physician/nurse is a behavior established in the social context of the workplace settings. Contextual factors, which may influence nutrition education, are lack of priority for nutrition, lack of faculty to provide nutrition education, poor integration of nutrition as a theme throughout the curriculum, and already overcrowded curriculum (8). Reports have emphasized the need to reform medical education to bring it into an agreement with social needs and expectations (9). Historically, less attention has been paid to nutrition sciences in the curriculums of many medical schools. In 1985, the National Academy of Sciences of the United States published an essential report on nutrition education in medical faculties (10). The results showed that most medical schools in the United States did not provide proper nutrition education and did not produce graduates with the necessary nutritional skills in medicine. Studies focusing on undergraduate and graduate medical students in the United States found that they feel the nutrition counselling of their patients is unsatisfactory. The findings also show that physicians, especially early in their careers, do not have much confidence in the necessary knowledge or skills to counsel and motivate their patients to follow a healthy diet and lifestyle (11-13). In this study, the priorities of nutrition-related health problems in Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan in Southwest of Iran have been determined to review the nutrition course plan at the meso level based on the community needs.

Methods

Ethics

This project was approved by the ethics committee of the vice-chancellor in Research Affairs, Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences, Abadan, Iran (Code: IR.ABADANUMS.REC.1398.052). Students participated in the study voluntarily and their names were not revealed in the written forms. Written informed consent for participation in the study was obtained before formal acceptance to participate.

Study Design

This was a 2-phase qualitative study conducted in Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences in 2017-2019. Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences covers the communication of 3 cities and their suburbs, including Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan, in the Khuzestan province, in the Southwest of Iran in terms of medical education and health care. Moreover, this faculty is located in the fourth educational spatial region from the 10 educational spatial areas of the Ministry of Health and Medical Education, the executive branch responsible for medical education and health within the Iranian government. Ten areas of spatial planning show the geographical breakdown of medical universities in Iran, which is approved in the form of a resolution by the Council of the Cultural Revolution as a macropolicy maker of science and technology in Iran (14).

Adequate Sample Size

The sample size was characterized based on the principles mentioned in the Vasileiou's study (15). In this study we included the whole community of nutrition experts working in the public and private sectors of the cities where the research was conducted. Invited individuals who desired to participate in the study attended the sessions. This phase was completed in 2 phases:

Phase 1: Nutritional Needs Assessment

In the first phase, 13 nutrition professionals (70% females), with a mean age of 33±1 years and the duration of work experience of 6.5±2.3 years working in the governmental and the private nutrition care services of Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan, were included in the study. They had practiced in the field of nutrition and had an in-depth knowledge about the nutrition-related health problems of the community. Nutrition professionals provided the services to the community, including evaluating the nutrition needs of individuals and groups and determining priorities, goals, and objectives to meet nutrition needs as well as the resources and restrictions in the practice setting (16). They were invited to participate in the study by sending an official invitation letter from the university's deputy educational director. They completed worksheets developed by high-level policymakers of Iran's Ministry of Health and Medical Education for an Iranian community-based assessment. Each nutrition professional was asked to record the first 10 nutrition-related health problems observed in the city of her/his workplace. A nutrition-related health problem was a nutrition problem that directly threatens people's health. The resources and examples used to identify the problem were also listed in front of each of the problems. Then, all nutrition professionals scored the listed nutrition-related health problems from 1 to 5. This ranking was based on the extent of the problem, the possibility of intervention, the effectiveness of education in solving the problem, the urgency of the problem, and the social and organizational acceptability of problem-solving. The scores were selected according to the following qualitative criteria: very low = 1, low = 2, average = 3, high = 4, and very high = 5. The scores gave to each problem was summed up to obtain a total score for each problem. Finally, 5 problems with the most obtained score were declared as priorities for the nutrition-related health problems (17). In the second phase, an expert panel was assembled that consisted of 9 professionals in different fields, including health, nutrition, medicine, nursing, and epidemiology, and convened through an official invitation letter. The participants were academics and clinicians who had been involved in clinical and health services related to aspects of health (n = 3), nutrition (n = 1), medical care of community (n = 3), nursing (n = 1), and epidemiology (n = 1) (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1
In this panel, the nominal group technique (NGT) (18) was used to identify a preliminary list of causes of each nutrition-related health problem in the region and categorize them into “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” types. NGT in this project lasted approximately 4 hours and was facilitated by the researcher. Following a description of the process, group purposes with a statement of the importance of participant's contribution, clarification of the members' roles, and an explanation about how the group's output would be used, the NGT session was conducted in 5 steps (19). In the NGT process, a researcher (SM) recorded the voice and described it and other researchers (SG and MN) checked her description and data analysis. The expert panel at vice chancellor in Health, Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences; the use of the nominal group technique to recognize the causes of each nutrition-related health problem. A written permission was obtained to use the photograph.

Step 1: Silent Generation of Causes Priorities

Participants were asked to take 15 minutes to consider the following question: “What are the priorities of the behavioral and nonbehavioral causes of nutrition-related health problem X in our region?” and they were asked to write down their responses privately.

Step 2: ‘Round Robin’ Recording of Causes Priorities

Each contributor was requested to express 1 cause priority at a time, and his/her idea was written on the flip chart without evaluation. Then, the round was repeated and the most critical comment was expressed each time. Thus, we could reach to the adequate numbers of ideas that responded to our research question entirely (saturation).

Step 3: Clarification of Causes Priorities

Each idea was discussed. Participants were encouraged to share their views and express their opinions about the pros and cons of each item. There was a further explanation about each item, so everyone in the group had a full understanding of the concept.

Step 4: Collapse of Causes Priorities

The facilitator organized all the listed causes priorities into “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” groups, simplified them and identified and removed duplicates. These were written on a new flip chart and discussed with the group to ensure that all participants understood and approved of the assembled causes priorities.

Step 5: Ranking of Causes Priorities

Each participant was asked to rank the items on a card and allocated a point between 1 and 5 to each cause, with their first preference receiving 5 points and their fifth predilection earning 1 point based on 2 criteria, including the importance of the reason and the possibility of changing the purpose. The average score was calculated for each item. At this step, all items that had received a rank were listed so that all participants could observe them. The items were then ranked according to the average point. Then, 9 professionals reviewed the rankings, and agreement reached on the final list of 5 priorities of “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” causes. Afterward, the data correlated to nutrition-related health problems in the population of mentioned cities registered in the SIB network (an abbreviation for the Persian equivalent of “Integrated Health System” which is a comprehensive national health information system of the healthcare service delivery centers) were obtained with an official permission from the vice chancellor for health at Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences to access the SIB network and compare it to the study results. Then, a list of nutrition-related health problems in the studied cities was prepared and matched with the findings of the present study.

Method of Qualitative Analysis

The analysis of data from the “nutrition needs assessment” phase of the study and reporting of the results were done using inductive content analysis based on the method described in Beigzadeh study (20), enabling the analysis of data collected by the worksheets and the NGT sessions. Also, we used inductive content analysis to quantitative analysis of data results from the scoring and ranking method used to conclude the completed worksheets and NGT meetings and identify the priorities of nutrition-related health problems and their “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” causes derived from the data (21). Using this technique, all members of the research team listed their ideas for nutrition-related health problem and their cause, and categorized them in a “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” format in a list. The list was then negotiated between members of the research team. This was done in an iterative process until reaching completeness and agreement on the final list. Finally, all members of the research team reviewed the categorized lists for compatibility and confirmation.

Phase 2: Community Based Review ofNutrition Course Plan

In this phase, the "General Principles of Nutrition" course plan in the medical doctorate curriculum, and "Nutrition and Nutrition Therapy" course plan in the bachelor of the nursing curriculum were reviewed. After revision, the course plan was presented to the medical (n = 124) and nursing (n = 128) students (51% male), with a mean age of 20.9 ± 3.5 years in 2 consecutive semesters (first and second semester of 2018-2019 the academic year) through lectures, question and answer sessions, group discussions, team-based learning (TBL), and virtual teaching in 17 sessions.

Results

Nominal Group Technique (NGT)

The final ranking of each nutrition-related health problems priority in Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan from the training need assessment was recognized based on the mean scores obtained by the survey. The top 5 priorities identified in Abadan were obesity in adults; hypertension, overweight, obesity, and anemia in pregnant women; type 2 diabetes mellitus and vitamin D deficiency in adults; nonalcoholic fatty liver diseases; and overweight and obesity in children, respectively. Also, the top 5 priorities recognized in Khorramshahr were type 2 diabetes mellitus, increased consumption of high-carbohydrate and fast foods, vitamin D deficiency, overweight and obesity with an emphasis on abdominal obesity; and hypertension, respectively. Moreover, the top 5 priorities documented in Shadegan were anemia in pregnant women and type 2 diabetes mellitus in adults; incorrect dietary pattern and inappropriate food habits; severe wasting in children aged 5 to 12 years; overweight and obesity in pregnant women and hypertension; and osteoporosis. It is necessary to explain that the nutrition-related health problems with the same score obtained the same priority in the TNA phase.

The Matching of the TNA Finding With the Databases of Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education

To match the data correlated to nutrition-related health problems priority obtained from TNA phase of the study with the databases of the Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education, we extracted the 5 nutrition-related health problem’s priorities recorded in SIB network, with the highest percentage of prevalence among the total population who were under primary health care separately for Abadan (Table 1), Khorramshahr (Table 2), and Shadegan (Table 3) and matched them with the findings of the present study. The results showed close similarities between the data extracted from the present study and the information obtained from the SIB network in terms of 5 recorded nutrition-related health problem’s priorities. Thus, in Abadan, obesity in adults was the first priority of nutrition-related health problems of present study and the second priority of the nutrition-related health problem’s priorities recorded in SIB network.
Table 1

Nutrition-related Health Problems Priorities in Abadan According to the Study Results and Databases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education

Priority RankStudy ResultsDatabases
1Obesity in adultsVitamin D deficiency in adults (68%)*
2Hypertension, overweight, obesity, and anemia in pregnant women;Obesity in adults (67%)*
3Type 2 diabetes mellitus and vitamin D deficiency in adultsOverweight and obesity in pregnant women (40%)*
4Non-alcoholic fatty liver diseasesHypertension (26%)*
5Overweight and obesity in childrenType 2 diabetes mellitus (14%)*

* Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care.

Table 2

Nutrition-related Health Problems Priorities in Khorramshahr According to the Study Results and Databases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education

Priority RankStudy ResultsDatabases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education
1Type 2 diabetes mellitusVitamin D deficiency (68%)*
2Increased consumption of high-carbohydrate and fast foodsOverweight and obesity in adults (66%)*
3Vitamin D deficiencyIncreased consumption of high-carbohydrate and fast foods (28%) *
4Overweight and obesity with an emphasis on abdominal obesityHypertension (26%) *
5HypertensionType 2 diabetes mellitus in adults (14%) *

* Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care

Table 3

Nutrition-Related Health Problems Priorities in Shadegan According to the Study Results and Databases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education

Priority RankStudy ResultsDatabases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education
1Anemia in pregnant women and type 2 diabetes mellitus in adultsVitamin D deficiency in adults (68%)*
2Incorrect dietary pattern and inappropriate food habitsHypertension (26%)*
3Severe wasting in children aged 5 to 12 yearsAnemia in pregnant women (22%)*
4Overweight and obesity in pregnant women and hypertensionType 2 diabetes mellitus in adults (14%)*
5OsteoporosisSevere wasting in children aged 5 to 12 years (13%)*

* Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care.

* Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care. * Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care * Percentage of prevalence among the total population of the city under primary health care. Also, in Khorramshahr, an increased consumption of high-carbohydrate and fast foods was the second nutrition-related health problem’s priorities of the present study but it was the third one in the database recorded in the SIB network. However, in Shadegan, type 2 diabetes mellitus was found as the first priority of nutrition-related health problems in the present study but it was the fourth priority in the database recorded in the SIB network. Moreover, 5 priorities of the recorded nutrition-related health problems in the whole population covered by the Deputy of Health of Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences were obesity in adults (69%), vitamin D deficiency in adults (68%), overweight and obesity in pregnant women (57%), hypertension (26%), and anemia in pregnant women (23%). Table 1. Nutrition-related Health Problems Priorities in Abadan According to the Study Results and Databases of the Iranian Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education

Identification of Causes for Nutrition-Related Health Problems by NGT

In the present study, NGT was selected as a highly structured technique and a democratic process to form a set of collective priorities of “behavioral” and “nonbehavioral” causes for each nutrition-related health problem according to a scoring system by 2 criteria. NGT allows for the sharing of ideas from groups of professionals who had insight into health and nutrition care, which were then discussed and ranked by the group, producing consensus decisions (19). In terms of definition, behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education, and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education. Tables 4 to 8 show the prioritizations of behavioral and nonbehavioral causes of each priority of nutrition-related health problems in the whole region (Abadan, Khorramshahr, and Shadegan). Participants were asked to identify 5 behavioral and nonbehavioral causes of nutrition-related health problems by NGT. However, regarding the nonbehavioral causes of overweight and obesity in children, participants were unable to extract more than 2 nonbehavioral causes. Also, in the case of nonalcoholic fatty liver diseases (NAFLD), the participants extracted 4 behavioral and 3 nonbehavioral causes. Also, in the NGT process, the causes with the same score in step 5 obtained the same rank in the ranking of priorities.
Table 4

The Prioritization of Behavioral and Nonbehavioral Causes of Prioritized Nutritional-Related Health Problem: Obesity in Adults*

Type of CauseRankCause
Behavioral 1Snacking
2Wrong eating habits, low physical activity, irregular sleeping and waking hours
3Insufficient nutrition knowledge
4Wrong cooking method, advertising
5Nervous overeating
Nonbehavioral 1Using technology
2Easy and convenient access to restaurants
3Secondary obesity caused by diseases
4Bad weather
5Residence in the apartment

*Two criteria, including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

Table 8

The Prioritization of Behavioral and Nonbehavioral Causes of Prioritized Nutritional-Related Health Problems: Overweight and Obesity in Children*

Type of CauseRankCause
Behavioral 1 - High carbohydrate diet due to high availability- Sedentary lifestyle due to the change in children's play pattern from active games to sedentary games
2 -Consumption of high-calorie - high-fat foods (like junk food, etc.)- Incorrect eating behaviors at school lunch and school buffet
3 - Incorrect eating behaviors among family and not spending time and money on the child's physical activity- Advances in technology and its use by children
4 - Cultural tendencies towards obesity- Computer games and the resulting reduced physical activity- Tendency to consume dry milk instead of breast milk- Microphagy
5 Consume high-fat local milk Eliminate breakfast
Nonbehavioral 1 - Genetic obesity (both parents)- Inappropriate advertising- Wrong policies
2Obesity caused by diseases such as hypothyroidism

*Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

*Two criteria, including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education. *Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education. *Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education. *Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education. *Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

Review of Nutrition Course Plan

In the second phase, the results of the first phase of the study were applied for the review of medical and nursing nutrition course plans. In the doctorate of medicine's nutrition course plane: (1) the section "understanding the common nutrition-related health problems in the community and their behavioral and nonbehavioral causes," was added (2). The “diseases caused by malnutrition" section was changed to "the spectrum of malnutrition from underweight to overweight and obesity in children and adults, obesity-related complications such as diabetes and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, nutritional anemia (with an emphasis on the gestational anemia), prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of vitamin D deficiency." In the baccalaureate of nursing's nutrition course plan: (1) sections "understanding the common nutrition-related health problems in the community and their behavioral and nonbehavioral causes" and (2) the section "nutrition therapy for obesity in children and adults, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and kidney disease" were added. Nutrition and nursing departments of Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences approved the revised nutrition course plans for implementation.

Discussion

The general aim of this study was a community-based educational need assessment designed to review the nutrition course plan in the doctorate of medicine and baccalaureate of nursing. The results demonstrated the nutrition-related health problems observed in 3 cities covered by Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences as the society's needs. Also, we compared the results obtained from this study with the databases of the Deputy Minister of Health and Medical Education and found close similarities between the results of the present study and the information extracted from SIB network in terms of 5 recorded nutrition-related health problems priorities. Moreover, NGT determined the behavior and nonbehavioral causes of nutrition-related health problems priorities. The extracted society's needs were used for the community-based review of nutrition course plans. Obesity in adults, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and gestational anemia were the first nutrition-related health problems priorities in the investigated community. Also, wrong cooking method, snacking, and eating habits, as well as inadequate nutrition knowledge were found to be the most critical behavioral causes of obesity in the target community. As we know, obesity and diabetes are concerning medical conditions from which people suffer and die from every day (22). Primary care physicians (PCP) must be organized to treat a variety of nutrition-related health problems, such as diabetes and obesity, with nutrition recommendation (23). The aim of upgrading medical education is to train health care professionals to provide better health care and reach better health and quality of life for the community (18). Like every other science, applying the best evidence from health-related problems in main concern areas leads to improving the quality and strength of medical education (24). Meanwhile, nutrition science has developed rapidly over the past 50 years. In an era that requires the practice of evidence-based medicine, there is convincing evidence that lifestyle practices, including nutrition behaviors, influence health, and disease, reflect a need for evidence-based and outcome-focused education (25). Accordingly, the results of our study provided sufficient evidence to review the nutrition course plan of medical and nursing students which is used in their nutrition education. This evidence emphasized the importance of focusing on noncommunicable diseases for a community-based review of a nutrition course plan. Our results are in line with inductive ongoing programs around the world to enhance and improve nutrition education and knowledge of health care professionals which have focused on noncommunicable and chronic disease prevention from a nutrition perspective. Nutrition education review groups in the United Kingdom and the United State have been developed to increase awareness among medical/health care professionals concerning the importance of clinical and public health nutrition in the prevention of noncommunicable diseases (25). Moreover, we found insufficient nutrition knowledge and improper eating habits as the most critical behavioral causes of noncommunicable diseases in the community. Since the provision of nutrition care by clinicians is important in promoting healthy dietary habits, it is important to consider strategies for improving eating habits of the community in the reviewing of nutrition curse planes, including promoting the nutritional awareness of medical and nursing students and teaching community-based nutrition education methods. However, according to qualitative studies, medical students and physicians have reported inadequate nutrition education and preparation during their training at universities due to a lack of priority for nutrition education and poor collaboration with nutrition professionals (8). Exploring the priorities of nutrition-related health problems with the help of nutrition professionals to review the course plan can also help to improve the collaboration of physicians and nutrition professionals, which in itself is effective in promoting nutrition education to students. On the other hand, many reports have highlighted the need to review medical education to align it with community's needs (9). However, disadvantageously, allocated hours in which the medical training may emphasize behavioral, social, and epidemiological sciences have been reduced (26). In the present study, we tried to reveal how can the educators extract the priorities of nutrition-related health problems as the society's needs with the help of professionals and use the extracted needs for community-based review of nutrition course plane of medical and nursing students. The inclusion of new subjects, including obesity in adults, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and gestational anemia as the community's needs in the nutrition course plans of medical and nursing students may improve the awareness of the medical community about social needs. They can also be accomplished by understanding the fundamental determinants of disease, such as behavior and nonbehavioral elements affecting patients' health and quality of life. Our study is one of the few studies to determine the educational needs with a community-oriented approach with an aim to revise the nutrition education for medical sciences students (7, 27-29). Other studies have focused on the improvement of community nutrition education rather than student nutrition education. The literature review showed that from 1996 to 2013 a total of 3 articles have been published. These papers were in the fields of geriatric nutrition training curriculum for nutrition/dietetics programs (7), essentials of nutrition education in medical schools (27), and the need to revise the nutrition curriculum for nutrition students (28). A significant reform in undergraduate medical education curriculum provides a new motivation and a novel opportunity to develop medical nutrition education and training nationwide (29). This is the first study to qualitatively explore the community's needs designed to the community-based review of the nutrition course plan for medical and nursing students. However, the limitation of the present study was that the data were collected from Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences, and thus might not be representative of all Iranian communities. However, as we know, in a qualitative study, the results cannot be generalized to other situations and people (30).

Conclusion

This paper demonstrated the possibility of using the nutritional need assessment by NGT to propose a community-based review of nutrition course plans for medical and nursing students in Southwest of Iran. This was the first phase in the development of a community-based nutrition course plan to focus on nutrition-related health problems in the community, which is most needed in education. The next step is to translate the nutrition-related health problems priorities into a community based revised course plan by setting up the implementation for medical and nursing students and evaluating the new course plans, including the analysis of student feedback and exam performance in future studies.

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank all staff members of Abadan Faculty of Medical Sciences working in the office of Deputy of Health and Education as well as medical and nursing students who participated in the study.

Conflict of Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Table 5

The Prioritization of Behavioral and Nonbehavioral Causes of Prioritized Nutritional-Related Health Problem: Hypertension, Overweight, Obesity, and Anemia in Pregnant Women*

Type of CauseRankCause
Behavioral 1 -Incorrect education-Sedentary lifestyle
2 -Misconceptions-Poor nutritional patterns
3Short intervals between pregnancies
4 -Irregular consumption of dietary supplements-Low consumption of iron-rich foods such as legumes
5Inadequate disease care
Nonbehavioral 1Genetic diseases
2Pre-pregnancy obesity
3 -Short interval between pregnancies-family dimension
4Pre-pregnancy anemia
5Multiplication

*Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

Table 6

The Prioritization of Behavioral and Nonbehavioral Causes of Prioritized Nutritional-Related Health Problems: Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus, and Vitamin D Deficiency in Adults*

RankType 2 Diabetes MellitusVitamin D Deficiency
Type of Cause CauseCause
Behavioral 1 -Sedentary lifestyle (not exercising for at least 30 minutes a day)-High calorie intake in compared to energy requirement -Insufficient exposure to sunlight-Insufficient taking of vitamin D supplement
2 -Tending to consume fast foods-Limited consumption of fruits and vegetables-High sugar intake -Inadequate education about how and how much exposure to sunlight- Unpleasant taste of vitamin D supplements- Limited consumption of dairy products
3-Low perceived sensitivity to diabetesLimited use of micronutrient sources
4 -Inability to control environmental and psychological stress-Limited intake of fatty fish-Limited consumption of legumes -Clothing-Using sunscreen
5Limited consumption of whole grain breadsTendency to traditional medicine and its misinformation about vitamin D intake
Nonbehavioral 1Obesity and insulin resistanceInadequate access to foods fortified with vitamin D
2 -Positive family history and genetics-Use of technology Lactose and gluten intolerance and lack of access to their special milks
3Gestational diabetese mellitus (GDM)High prevalence of kidney disease
4Apartment lifestyle
5 -Bad weather and the resulting sedentary lifestyle,- Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)- Lack of covered parks

*Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

Table 7

The Prioritization of Behavioral and Nonbehavioral Causes of Prioritized Nutritional-Related Health Problems: Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Diseases (NAFLD)*

Type of CauseRankCause
Behavioral 1 -High calories diet-High body mass index (BMI)
2 -Consume sausages-Limited consumption of fruits and vegetables
3 -Tendency to fall asleep immediately after eating- Low selenium intake
4Taking high portion size
Nonbehavioral 1Type 2 diabetes mellitus
2-Toxins and occupational pollutants
3-Pregnancy

*Two criteria including the importance of the cause and possibility of changing the cause were used to prioritize the causes of problems; behavioral causes were defined as causes that could be corrected by nutrition education; and nonbehavioral causes were defined as causes that could not be corrected by nutrition education.

  17 in total

1.  Specialty residency training in medical nutrition education: history and proposal for improvement.

Authors:  Mark H Delegge; Sharon Alger-Mayer; Charles W Van Way; Leah Gramlich
Journal:  JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr       Date:  2010 Nov-Dec       Impact factor: 4.016

2.  Research priorities in medical education in the Eastern Mediterranean Region.

Authors:  M Amini; J Kojuri; F Lotfi; Z Karimian; A S H Abadi
Journal:  East Mediterr Health J       Date:  2012-07       Impact factor: 1.628

3.  Essentials of nutrition education in medical schools: a national consensus. American Medical Student Association's Nutrition Curriculum Project.

Authors: 
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  1996-09       Impact factor: 6.893

4.  Morbidity in family medicine: the potential for individual nutritional counseling, an analysis from the Nijmegen Continuous Morbidity Registration.

Authors:  C van Weel
Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr       Date:  1997-06       Impact factor: 7.045

Review 5.  Interrelationships of food, nutrition, diet and health: the National Association of State Universities and Land Grant Colleges White Paper.

Authors:  W R Bidlack
Journal:  J Am Coll Nutr       Date:  1996-10       Impact factor: 3.169

6.  Nutrition in medicine: nutrition education for medical students and residents.

Authors:  Kelly M Adams; Martin Kohlmeier; Margo Powell; Steven H Zeisel
Journal:  Nutr Clin Pract       Date:  2010-10       Impact factor: 3.080

7.  The need to advance nutrition education in the training of health care professionals and recommended research to evaluate implementation and effectiveness.

Authors:  Penny M Kris-Etherton; Sharon R Akabas; Connie W Bales; Bruce Bistrian; Lynne Braun; Marilyn S Edwards; Celia Laur; Carine M Lenders; Matthew D Levy; Carole A Palmer; Charlotte A Pratt; Sumantra Ray; Cheryl L Rock; Edward Saltzman; Douglas L Seidner; Linda Van Horn
Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr       Date:  2014-04-09       Impact factor: 7.045

8.  A community assessment model appropriate for the Iranian community.

Authors:  Kourosh Holakouie Naieni; Alireza Ahmadvand; Elham Ahmadnezhad; Ali Alami
Journal:  Iran J Public Health       Date:  2014-03       Impact factor: 1.429

9.  Characterising and justifying sample size sufficiency in interview-based studies: systematic analysis of qualitative health research over a 15-year period.

Authors:  Konstantina Vasileiou; Julie Barnett; Susan Thorpe; Terry Young
Journal:  BMC Med Res Methodol       Date:  2018-11-21       Impact factor: 4.615

10.  Internationalization of medical education in Iran: A way towards implementation of the plans of development and innovation in medical education.

Authors:  Ehsan Shamsi Gooshki; Ata Pourabbasi; Hamid Akbari; Nima Rezaei; Ali Arab Kheradmand; Zahra Kheiry; Niloufar Peykari; Fatereh Momeni Javid; Firouzeh Hajipour; Bagher Larijani
Journal:  J Adv Med Educ Prof       Date:  2018-01
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.