Changes in weight and height among Chinese preschool children during COVID-19 school closures.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: COVID-19-related school closures may increase the prevalence of childhood obesity, which has aroused public concerns. We aimed to analyze the weight and height changes in Chinese preschool children during the COVID-19-related school closures period.
METHODS: A total of 124,603 children from multi-city kindergartens in China were included in this study. We evaluated the prevalence of overweight and obese in preschool children experienced school closures, and compared the changes in BMI, weight, and height of preschool children among COVID-19 school closures period, the same period last year and the same period the year before last.
RESULTS: After the school closures, childhood obesity prevalence increased, whereas overweight prevalence decreased. During school closures, the average increase in height was about 1 cm less as compared with the same period last year and the year before last, but no noteworthy difference in the weight change was observed among the three periods.
CONCLUSIONS: During COVID-19 school closures, children's height increase seemed to be more affected than weight change. Innovative, robust, and highly adaptable strategies should be taken to increase physical activity, reduce sedentary time and promote healthy diets, to minimize the adverse impact of school closures.

Introduction

The global spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has causing substantial morbidity and mortality, and triggering a range of public health responses [1]. Following the outbreak of COVID-19 in China in January 2020, the Chinese government issued a stay-at-home order to promote social distancing [2]. Closely related to the stay-at-home orders, school closures are some of the highest-profile social distancing measures widely adopted across all of China’s provinces. In addition to China, many countries around the world have also instituted a nationwide school closure [3]. These closures prevent contact among children and reduce cases [3]. In China, with the effective control of the epidemic, most schools were gradually reopened from August to September 2020. However, in most areas outside China, school closures are likely to continue through the 2020–2021 academic year. Whether and on what scale schools reopen will depend on how the epidemic evolves.

As a result of school closures, children’s daily life is also affected, including insufficient physical activity, excessive sedentary behavior, and unbalanced diets [4]. It has been hypothesized that COVID-19-related school closures may expose children to an increased risk of obesity in a similar way to summer recess [5-8]. Obesity was one of the most serious global problems defined as pandemic before COVID-19 pandemic [9]. And there is a consensus that obesity is associated with various acute or chronic diseases, and also increases risk of COVID-19 infection and complications [10, 11]. Experts in child growth have been very concerned about the potential weight and height change among preschool children during school closures. However, there is limited evidence to evaluate the impact of COVID-19-related school closures on childhood obesity. Therefore, the objective of this study was to show the changes in BMI, weight, and height among Chinese preschool children during COVID-19 school closures, which could provide valuable information on designing and implementing countermeasures to minimize the detrimental impact of COVID-19 and prevent children from obesity onset.

Methods

This was an observational retrospective study. The study participants were preschool children from kindergartens in ten Chinese cities (cities including Nanjing, Nantong, Wuxi, Chengdu, Jinan, Jiaxing, Ningbo, Qingdao, Chongqing, and Zhoushan). Children’s health information of these kindergartens is managed by a Children’s Health Care Network System. In this study, the examined kindergartens were selected in a cluster random sampling. All research data were based on routine physical examinations in kindergarten and extracted through the network system. Through the physical examinations, demographic information was collected, including home domicile, gender, and age. Moreover, we also collected height and weight before (December 2019 to early January 2020) and after (August 2020 to September 2020) school closures. In China, before the outbreak of the epidemic in early January 2020, kindergartens began their winter vacation and closed their schools successively. We collected baseline data of children from December 2019 to early January 2020 as the data of “before school closures”. With the remission of the epidemic, kindergartens began to resume school from August to September 2020. Therefore, we collected the second data from August to September 2020 as the data of “after school closures”. Weight was measured with the participant wearing light clothes and no shoes to the nearest 0.1 kg by a mechanical column scale, and height was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm with a Stadiometer. Each measurement was taken and recorded twice to ensure reliability. From these data, we calculated body mass index (BMI), and the changes in BMI, weight, and height from before until after school closures. Missing data included data for children who did not attend the physical examination before or after school closures, or abnormal value (during the COVID-19 school closures, weight change exceed ±15 kg or height change exceed 15 cm).

We applied Fisher’s exact test to evaluate the difference in the prevalence of overweight and obese children before and after school closures. Overweight and obesity were diagnosed according to the child growth standards of the WHO [12]. To further vertically explore the impact of COVID-19 school closures on obesity among preschool children, we then compared the changes in BMI, weight, and height of preschool children among the COVID-19 school closures period, the same period last year and the same period the year before last. The participant sources, time points and methods of data collection, and exclusion criteria for the same period last year and the year before were the same as those during the COVID-19 school closures. The changes in BMI, weight, and height are graphically plotted as mean in the figures. Statistical data were analyzed by IBM SPSS version 25. The study did not require approval by the ethics committee because of the anonymous nature of the personal information and impossibility of tracking sensitive personal data.

Results

In the past year under COVID-19 pandemics, 19,066 preschool children who attended routine kindergarten physical examination before and after school closures were included in the analysis (Table 1). The children evaluated were 3 years to 5 years and 4 months during the months before school closures (December 2019 to early January 2020). Using the recorded height and weight together with children’s sex and age, we observed the overweight rate had decreased (before vs. after school closures: 17.43% vs. 14.07%, P < 0.001), whereas the obesity rate had increased (before vs. after school closures: 10.47% vs. 12.28%, P < 0.001) during the COVID-19-related school closures.

Table 1

Basic characteristics of participating children evaluated in the three periods.

Period	Baseline time point	Last measured time point	N	Boys, n (%)	Age range	Height, cma	Weight, kga	BMI, kg/m2 a
During the COVID-19 related school closures	2019.12–2020.1	2020.8–9	19,066	10,097 (53.0%)	3 y to 5 y + 4 m	107.0 (6.5)	18.5 (3.3)	16.1 (1.7)
During the same period last year	2018.12–2019.1	2019.8–9	28,228	15,014 (53.2%)	3 y to 5 y + 4 m	106.9 (6.1)	18.6 (3.3)	16.2 (1.7)
During the same period the year before last	2017.12–2018.1	2018.8–9	77,309	40,730 (52.7%)	3 y to 5 y + 4 m	106.8 (6.1)	18.3 (3.1)	16.0 (1.6)

aAll values are presented as mean (SD), measured at baseline time point.

Using a retrospective cohort design, we compared changes in anthropometrics of preschool children among COVID-19 school closures period, the same period last year and the same period the year before last. Table 1 shows the basic characteristics of participating children evaluated in these three periods. Given that participants from the three periods came from same cities, had similar population structure, and the baseline anthropometrics were very close, the previous data were of certain reference value for assessing the impact of COVID-19 on obesity.

We first compared changes in BMI over the three studied periods, as shown in Fig. 1. It is well known that BMI decreases with age between 6 months and 6 years old [12]. During school closures, BMI decreased the least when compared with the same period last year and the year before last. In addition, there was a small increase in BMI rather than a decrease among the relatively older children. To investigate the reasons behind the changes in BMI, we analyzed the changes in weight (Fig. 2). However, no noteworthy difference in the weight change was observed among the three periods. When we further analyzed the changes in children’s height (Fig. 3), we were surprised to find that the average increase in height during school closures was about 1 cm less, compared with the same period last year and the year before last. This may be partly responsible for the increased obesity rate and the least BMI decrease during school closures. However, according to the child height standard of the WHO [12], for the preschool children evaluated during school closures, 71.4% of the children had a height value above P50 and 14.6% have a height value above P95 after school closures, indicating that the preschool children group is still in a good growth state.

Fig. 1

The BMI change of the preschool children over the three periods.

Compared to the pre-COVID-19 periods, preschool children’s BMI decreased the least during the school closures.

Fig. 2

The height change of the preschool children over the three periods.

A The height change in boys; B The height change in girls.

Fig. 3

The weight change of the preschool children over the three periods.

A The weight change in boys; B The weight change in girls.

Discussion

The currently escalating COVID-19 pandemic represents one of the most profound societal and public health challenges. Although school closures were necessary to slow the spread of COVID-19, they may have a profound impact on children’s daily life. As suggested by growing evidences, unfavorable changes in eating, sleep, and activity behaviors occurred during the school closures [13-15]. Most obviously children typically engage in lower levels of physical activity and more sedentary time as compared to school days [13]. And many children have experienced unbalanced diets during the pandemic response [4]. In sum, the COVID-19 school closures have reinforced the obesogenic environment. As expected, our results showed that childhood obesity prevalence increased after the COVID-19-related school closures, and compared to the pre-COVID-19 periods, preschool children’s BMI decreased the least during the school closures.

There is considerable concern about whether the rising obesity rate is related to unhealthy weight gain. Although recent studies have concluded that the reduced physical activity resulting from the enforced quarantine would contribute to weight gain [13, 16, 17], we observed no noteworthy difference in the children’s weight change among the three studied periods. More surprisingly, there was even a drop in the children overweight rate after the school closures period. During the school closures, in response to social distancing policies, children may eat less frequently in restaurants, usually rich in fats, sugars, and salt. Experts in sports medicine have called for that diet matters more than exercise in weight loss, and poor diet generates more disease than physical inactivity, alcohol, and smoking combined [18]. Based on our results, we thus consider that, during the school closures, the effect of weight loss due to reduced calorie intake was more powerful than weight gain due to reduced physical activity. Furthermore, it was suggested that over a long period of time children who are overweight may lower body weight relative to changes in height [19], which also supported our results. In addition, the decreased overweight rate may partly contribute to the increased obesity rate, as a proportion of children who were overweight became obese.

For height changes, compared with the pre-COVID-19 periods, the average increase in height during school closures was about 1 cm less, suggesting the reduced physical activity due to school closures may have contributed to the limited growth in height. The latest statistics show that over the past 35 years (from 1985–2019), China has become the country with the largest gains in height for children and teenagers aged 5–19 [20]. And after school closures, we evaluated the preschool children’s height, and found they were still in a good growth state with most children had a height value above P50. Even so, if COVID-19 school closures lasting a year or more, there may be enormous consequences for children’s overall physical health. In order to minimize the adverse impact of COVID-19, innovative, robust, and highly adaptable strategies must be taken to promote physical activity at home or in residential settings. And schools could make concerted efforts to incorporate physical activities into distance learning curriculum. Moreover, a pro-healthy diet based on rich protein-low fat food, healthy fats, and plant food is also a key strategy.

To the best of our knowledge, this was the first study analyzing weight and height changes in preschool children during the COVID-19-related school closures period. The strengths of the study included the timeliness of the baseline survey across the school closures period and wide geographic representation. Yet, some limitations existed. First, our sample was not geographically equally distributed, with almost half of the participants resided in Jiangsu province (relatively developed areas) and none in Hubei province (outbreak site of COVID-19). Therefore, the observed impact of the pandemic on childhood obesity may have been diminished. Second, this study concerns children in kindergarten years so that the findings may not be generalizable to all children and adolescents. Lastly, the lack of information on diet and physical activity may limit the comparability of outcomes between the COVID-19 period and pre-COVID-19 periods studied. Further studies in larger, more racially/ethnically diverse populations are needed to confirm the preliminary results.

Overall, height increase in children seemed to be more affected than weight change during the school closures. Of public health concern is these short-term changes in response to COVID-19 may become permanent, leading to an increased risk of obesity in children as they get older. Programmatic and policy strategies during the pandemic should therefore focus on increasing physical activity, reducing sedentary time, and promoting healthy diets, which deserves full support and dissemination by all of us. In a comprehensive evaluation of the effective control of the epidemic and the slight impact on children’s height, school closure is more beneficial than harmful in the short term.