| Literature DB >> 34200861 |
Łucja Zielińska-Tomczak1, Piotr Przymuszała1, Szymon Tomczak2, Izabela Krzyśko-Pieczka3, Ryszard Marciniak1, Magdalena Cerbin-Koczorowska1.
Abstract
The growing popularity of health education on social media indicates the need for its appropriate evaluation. This paper aims to present the potential of the Kirkpatrick Model (KM) with New World Kirkpatrick Model (NWKM) additions to evaluate the nutritional education provided by dieticians via Instagram. Instagram profiles of ten dieticians providing nutritional education for their followers were analyzed in March and April 2021. The study sample included profiles of both macro- and micro-influencers. The analyzed quantitative data included Instagram Engagement Rate and the number of likes and comments per post. The qualitative analysis of the comments was performed following the theoretical framework provided by the KM and NWKM. Collected data showed followers' satisfaction, commitment, and relevance of the presented content, fulfilling the Level 1 of NWKM. Level 2 of NWKM was represented by 4 out of 5 dimensions (knowledge, attitude, confidence, commitment). No comments were found only for skills. Both Levels 3 (Behavior) and 4 (Results) of the KM were met. However, the use of the NWKM for them seems limited. The KM can be used to evaluate nutritional education on social media. The NWKM additions seem applicable mostly for Levels 1 and 2.Entities:
Keywords: Instagram; Kirkpatrick Model; dieticians; health promotion; nutritional education
Year: 2021 PMID: 34200861 PMCID: PMC8230514 DOI: 10.3390/nu13062005
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1Average engagement rate on Instagram.
The comment evaluation form used during the study with examples.
| NWKM Level. | Dimensions (Where Applicable) | IG Code | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1: Reaction | Customer Satisfaction | IG5 | “Finally, this is super explained! Brilliant post” |
| Engagement | IG1 | “Do we count the amount of protein according to the total body weight or lean weight?” | |
| Relevance | IG4 | “And that’s what I understand. I was just looking for such inspiration. Finally a profile that meets my expectations” | |
| Level 2: Learning | Knowledge | IG5 | “Great, thanks! 🤗 I finally know how many kcal I should eat per day” |
| Skill | - | - | |
| Attitude | IG9 | “The super cocktail 😍 I will definitely make 😋” | |
| Confidence | IG2 | “Maybe I will finally succeed” | |
| Commitment | IG10 | “I’m going to do a test in May!” | |
| Level 3: Behavior | IG8 | “Thanks to you, I started to get up earlier. In the beginning, it was difficult, but now I get up at 5–6 without any problems, and go to bed at 21–22. The difference is amazing” | |
| Level 4: Results | IG10 | “We have been following the recommendations on the right since the beginning of the year. 🙌 The effects exceeded our expectations.” |
IG—Instagram; NWKM- New World Kirkpatrick Model.
Characteristic of Instagramers’ profiles.
| IG 1 Code | Followers Number | Range | IER 2 | Likes 3 | Comments 3 | Engagement 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| 36,165 | micro | 3.15 | 1149 | 37 | higher |
|
| 225,376 | macro | 1.87 | 4292 | 81 | lower |
|
| 2031 | micro | 15.19 | 269 | 59 | higher |
|
| 65,795 | micro | 2.48 | 1673 | 43 | higher |
|
| 65,227 | micro | 3.89 | 2609 | 48 | higher |
|
| 135,217 | macro | 1.63 | 2165 | 78 | lower |
|
| 24,296 | micro | 2.33 | 649 | 32 | higher |
|
| 118,837 | macro | 3.23 | 3996 | 110 | higher |
|
| 231,997 | macro | 1.72 | 4153 | 110 | lower |
|
| 51,367 | macro | 2.11 | 1124 | 28 | lower |
1 IG—Instagram. 2 IER—Instagram Engagement Rate. 3 per post. 4 profile’s engagement relative to the average.