Robert McCunn1, Florian Beaudouin2, Katy Stewart3,4, Tim Meyer2, John MacLean3,4. 1. Heart of Midlothian Football Club, Tynecastle Park , Edinburgh, EH11 2NL, UK. bob.mccunn@me.com. 2. Institute of Sports and Preventive Medicine, Saarland University, Saarbrücken, Germany. 3. Institute of Cardiovascular and Medical Sciences, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK. 4. Hampden Sports Clinic, Glasgow, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There is growing concern surrounding the role of repetitive sub-concussive head impacts, such as football heading, on brain health. OBJECTIVES: Three questions were addressed while only considering studies that observed heading exposure directly: (1) how frequently does heading occur within football training and matches, (2) what are the biomechanical characteristics of heading, and (3) is cognitive function affected by heading? METHODS: This review followed the steps described in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. Electronic databases including MEDLINE and SPORTDiscus were searched from the earliest entry to July 2020. Studies that reported independently quantified heading exposure, biomechanical characteristics of heading or the relationship between heading and cognitive function were included. Data were extracted and used to populate summary tables with reference to each research question. RESULTS: Heading incidence ranged between one to nine headers per player per match. The number of headers observed in small-sided games during training varied depending on the exact format used but generally speaking ranged between zero to one per player per game. The three most commonly reported biomechanical variables were head acceleration, head rotational velocity and overall movement kinematics during the heading action. Average head acceleration ranged from approximately four to 50 g. Nine out of 12 included studies did not observe a negative impact on cognitive test performance following exposure to heading and while three did, these negative effects were limited to specific outcome measures: reaction time and memory function. CONCLUSION: The current weight of evidence summarised herein does not support the notion that heading is deleterious to cognitive performance in the short term; however, this conclusion is tentative due to methodological shortcomings in the existing evidence base.
BACKGROUND: There is growing concern surrounding the role of repetitive sub-concussive head impacts, such as football heading, on brain health. OBJECTIVES: Three questions were addressed while only considering studies that observed heading exposure directly: (1) how frequently does heading occur within football training and matches, (2) what are the biomechanical characteristics of heading, and (3) is cognitive function affected by heading? METHODS: This review followed the steps described in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. Electronic databases including MEDLINE and SPORTDiscus were searched from the earliest entry to July 2020. Studies that reported independently quantified heading exposure, biomechanical characteristics of heading or the relationship between heading and cognitive function were included. Data were extracted and used to populate summary tables with reference to each research question. RESULTS: Heading incidence ranged between one to nine headers per player per match. The number of headers observed in small-sided games during training varied depending on the exact format used but generally speaking ranged between zero to one per player per game. The three most commonly reported biomechanical variables were head acceleration, head rotational velocity and overall movement kinematics during the heading action. Average head acceleration ranged from approximately four to 50 g. Nine out of 12 included studies did not observe a negative impact on cognitive test performance following exposure to heading and while three did, these negative effects were limited to specific outcome measures: reaction time and memory function. CONCLUSION: The current weight of evidence summarised herein does not support the notion that heading is deleterious to cognitive performance in the short term; however, this conclusion is tentative due to methodological shortcomings in the existing evidence base.
Authors: Cara F Levitch; Molly E Zimmerman; Naomi Lubin; Namhee Kim; Richard B Lipton; Walter F Stewart; Mimi Kim; Michael L Lipton Journal: J Int Neuropsychol Soc Date: 2017-08-22 Impact factor: 2.892
Authors: Jaclyn B Caccese; Thomas A Buckley; Ryan T Tierney; Kristy B Arbogast; William C Rose; Joseph J Glutting; Thomas W Kaminski Journal: Sports Biomech Date: 2017-10-16 Impact factor: 2.832
Authors: Kerry Peek; Jordan Andersen; Marnee J McKay; Theo Versteegh; Ian A Gilchrist; Tim Meyer; Andrew Gardner Journal: Sports Med Date: 2021-09-29 Impact factor: 11.928