| Literature DB >> 34065960 |
Kevin Zhai1, Manaal Siddiqui1, Basma Abdellatif1, Alena Liskova2, Peter Kubatka3, Dietrich Büsselberg1.
Abstract
Glioblastoma (GBM) is an aggressive, often fatal astrocyte-derived tumor of the central nervous system. Conventional medical and surgical interventions have greatly improved survival rates; however, tumor heterogeneity, invasiveness, and chemotherapeutic resistance continue to pose clinical challenges. As such, dietary natural substances-an integral component of the lifestyle medicine approach to chronic diseases-are examined as potential chemotherapeutic agents. These heterogenous substances exert anti-GBM effects by upregulating apoptosis and autophagy, inducing cell cycle arrest, interfering with tumor metabolism, and inhibiting proliferation, neuroinflammation, chemoresistance, angiogenesis, and metastasis. Although these beneficial effects are promising, natural substances' efficacy in GBM is constrained by their bioavailability and blood-brain barrier permeability; various chemical formulations are proposed to improve their pharmacological properties. Many of the reviewed substances are available as over-the-counter dietary supplements, underscoring their viability as lifestyle interventions. However, clinical trials remain necessary to substantiate the in vitro and in vivo properties of natural substances.Entities:
Keywords: brain cancer; carotenoids; coumarins; flavonoids; glioblastoma; lifestyle medicine; lignans; natural compounds; polyphenols; steroids; tannins; terpenes
Year: 2021 PMID: 34065960 PMCID: PMC8150927 DOI: 10.3390/cancers13102317
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cancers (Basel) ISSN: 2072-6694 Impact factor: 6.639
Figure 1Intracellular signaling mechanisms involved in GBM development and progression. Elements of proliferative signaling pathways—especially Akt and mTOR—promote angiogenesis, motility and migratory potential, neuroinflammation, cell cycle progression, chemoresistance, and tumor metabolism, and concurrently inhibit GBM cell death through apoptosis and autophagy.
Figure 2Some classes of natural substances with therapeutic potential in GBM.
Figure 3Major pathways modulated by natural substances in GBM. Effective chemotherapeutic substances increase cell death through apoptosis and autophagy, and inhibit intracellular mechanisms related to proliferation, cell cycle progression, tumor metabolism (Warburg effect), angiogenesis, invasion and metastasis, neuroinflammation, and chemoresistance.
Classes and sources of natural substances with anti-GBM efficacy demonstrated in recent preclinical studies. Many of the listed compounds occur in multiple natural sources.
| Substance | Class/Type | Primary Source(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Alkaloids | ||
| Berberine | Quaternary Ammonium Salt | Barberry ( |
| Carboxylic Acid Derivatives | ||
| Cinnamic Acid | Monocarboxylic Acid | Cinnamon ( |
| Ferulic Acid | Hydroxycinnamic Acid | Giant fennel ( |
| Carotenoids | ||
| Adonixanthin | Carotenone | Derivative of astaxanthin |
| Astaxanthin | Xanthophyll | Chlorophyte ( |
| Crocetin | Apocarotenoid | Saffron ( |
| Coumarins | ||
| Galbanic Acid | Sesquiterpene Coumarin | Celery/carrot/parsley family ( |
| Osthole | Coumarin | Monnier’s snowparsley ( |
| Curcuminoids | ||
| Curcumin | Curcumin | Turmeric ( |
| Flavonoids | ||
| Chrysin | Dihydroxyflavone | Blue passion flower ( |
| Diosmin | Flavone Glycoside | Germander ( |
| EGCG | Catechin | Green tea ( |
| Galangin | Trihydroxyflavone | Galangal ( |
| Matteucinol | Dihydroxyflavonone | Naudin ( |
| Naringin | Flavanone Glycoside | Grapefruit ( |
| Quercetin | Flavonol | Oak ( |
| Resveratrol | Stilbenoid | Grape ( |
| Rutin | Flavonol Glycoside | Rue ( |
| Silymarin (Silibinin) | Flavonolignan | Milk thistle ( |
| Tectorigenin | Methylated Isoflavone | Leopard lily ( |
| Xanthohumol | Prenylated Chalconoid | Hops ( |
| Lignans | ||
| Arctigenin | Lignan/Polyphenol | Greater burdock ( |
| Magnolol | Biphenyl | Houpu magnolia ( |
| Steroids | ||
| Diosgenin | Phytosteroid Sapogenin | Fenugreek ( |
| Gamabufotalin | Steroidal Lactone | Toad ( |
| N45 | Steroidal Saponin | Nan chong lou ( |
| Withaferin A | Steroidal Lactone | Ashwa-gandha ( |
| Tannins | ||
| Tannic Acid | Hydrolysable Tannin | Oak ( |
| Terpenes | ||
| AM01-06 | Sesquiterpene Lactone | Sunflower ( |
| Betulinic Acid | Triterpenoid | White birch ( |
| Cedrol | Sesquiterpene Alcohol | Cypress ( |
| Coronarin D | Diterpene | White ginger lily ( |
| Eucalyptal A | Monoterpenoid | Southern blue gum ( |
| Gossypol | Terpenoid Aldehyde | Cotton ( |
| Paeoniflorin | Terpene Glycoside | Chinese peony ( |
| Triterpenoid Saponin | Chong Lou ( | |
| Pisosterol | Triterpene | Dead man’s foot ( |
| Rupesin E | Iridoid (Monoterpenoid) | Indian valerian ( |
| Tubeimoside-1 | Triterpenoid Saponin | Tu bei mu ( |
| Crude/Purified Plant Extracts | ||
| BcH, BcS | Extract-Food Supplement | Water hyssop ( |
| CE70, CE95 | Ethanol Extract | Shaggy ink cap ( |
| CP | Chloroform Partition | Johnnyberry ( |
| CW | Aqueous Extract | Shaggy ink cap ( |
| KE70, KE95 | Ethanol Extract | Golden chanterelle ( |
| KW | Aqueous Extract | Golden chanterelle ( |
| PE70, PE95 | Ethanol Extract | Puffball ( |
| PPE | Ethanol Extract | Polish propolis (bee glue) |
| PW | Aqueous Extract | Puffball ( |
| RE70, RE95 | Ethanol Extract | Saffron milk cap ( |
| RW | Aqueous Extract | Saffron milk cap ( |
| Other | ||
| Carnosine | Dipeptide | Liebig’s meat extract |
| CrataBL | Protein: Lectin + Serine Protease Inhibitor | Beach block ( |
| GL-PP | Polysaccharide Peptide | Lingzhi ( |
Generalized downstream effects of natural compounds on GBM. Many of the reviewed substances exert measurable cytotoxic effects in vitro. Moreover, several substances reduce tumor size and improve survival in-animal models of GBM.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Increases survival | Eucalyptal A | U87MG orthotopic implants, nude mice | [ |
| Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG subcutaneous xenografts, nude mice | [ | |
| Crocetin | Luc-U251MG orthotopic implants, CD1 mice | [ | |
| Decreases tumor area/perimeter | Astaxanthin | GL261 orthotopic implants, C57BL/6J mice | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 orthotopic implants, C57BL/6J mice | [ | |
| McC1 | U251 heterotopic xenograft, fertilized chicken eggs | [ | |
| Decreases tumor volume | Astaxanthin | GL261 orthotopic implants, C57BL/6J mice | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 orthotopic implants, C57BL/6J mice | [ | |
| Naringin | U87 subcutaneous xenograft, athymic mice | [ | |
| Xanthohumol | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 orthotopic implants, Wistar rats | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87 subcutaneous xenografts, nude mice | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87 subcutaneous xenografts, NOD/SCID mice | [ | |
| Decreases tumor weight | Xanthohumol | U87, LN229 | [ |
| TBMS1 | U87 subcutaneous xenografts, nude mice | [ | |
| Increases cell death/dec. viability | EGCG | U251, MO59J | [ |
| Cinnamic Acid | LN-229 | [ | |
| Ferulic Acid | LN-229 | [ | |
| Astaxanthin | GL261, U251MG | [ | |
| Adonixanthin | GL261, U251MG | [ | |
| Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ | |
| AM02 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM04 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM05 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM06 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| Naringin | U87 | [ | |
| Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ | |
| Rupesin E | GSC-3#, GSC-12#, GSC-18# | [ | |
| Diosmin | U87, GBM02, GBM95 | [ | |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| CP | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Betulinic Acid | U251, LN229 | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Carnosine | U87, T98G | [ | |
| CrataBL | U87 | [ | |
| Tectorigenin | GBM-8401, GBM-8901 | [ | |
| Resveratrol | U87 | [ | |
| Quercetin | U87 | [ | |
| Curcumin | U87 | [ | |
| Paeoniflorin | U251, T98G | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ | |
| CW | LN-18 | [ | |
| CE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| CE95 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KW | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KE95 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| RW | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| RE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| RE95 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| PW | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| PE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| PE95 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| Silymarin | U118 | [ | |
| BcS | U87, T98G, LN-18 | [ | |
| BcH | U87, T98G, LN-19 | [ | |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| GL-PP | U251 | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Decreases colony formation | Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ |
| Rupesin E | GSC-3#, GSC-18# | [ | |
| CP | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| McC1 | U251, GAMG | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| Decreases cloning | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| AM01 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM02 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM03 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM04 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM05 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| AM06 | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Decreases sphere formation | Gossypol | TS13-20, TS13-18 | [ |
| Decreases intracellular ATP | SLCP | U87, U251 | [ |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Gossypol | Diff13-20 | [ | |
| Carnosine | U87, T98G | [ | |
| Upregulates p53 (mRNA) | Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ |
| Upregulates p53 (protein) | BBR | U87, U251 | [ |
| SLCP | U251 | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ |
Figure 4Intracellular mechanisms promoting proliferation in GBM. Growth factors, chemokine ligands, and other upstream signals upregulate the Ras/Raf/MEK/ERK and PI3K/Akt pathways. Downstream effectors, including HIF-1, EGFR, NF-κB, and mTOR, promote DNA synthesis, transcription, and tumor cell proliferation. Proliferative effectors notably engage in crosstalk with other signals in GBM, including those for angiogenesis (HIF-1), cell cycle progression (Akt), metabolism (Akt), motility (PI3K), apoptosis (Akt/mTOR), and autophagy (Akt/mTOR/Beclin-1).
Natural substances decrease proliferation in GBM by downregulating upstream growth factors and chemokine ligands, components of the Ras/Raf/MEK/ERK and PI3K/Akt pathways, and downstream effectors.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decreases proliferation/growth | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ | |
| Rupesin E | GSC-3#, GSC-18# | [ | |
| Crocetin | U87, U138, U251, U373 | [ | |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| Gossypol | Diff13-20, Diff13-18 | [ | |
| Betulinic Acid | U251, LN229 | [ | |
| CrataBL | U87 | [ | |
| Galbanic Acid | U87 | [ | |
| N45 | U87 | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Decreases DNA synthesis | CE95 | U87 | [ |
| CE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KW | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KE95 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| KE70 | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| PW | U87 | [ | |
| PE70 | U87 | [ | |
| RW | U87, LN-18 | [ | |
| PPE | U87, T98G, LN-18 | [ | |
| BcH | U87, T98G, LN-18 | [ | |
| Downregulates SRSF1 (mRNA) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates SRSF1 (protein) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates MYO1B-fl (protein) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates p-PDK1 (protein) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates TGF (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Downregulates TGF-β (mRNA) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates IGF (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ | |
| Downregulates CCL2 (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Upregulates CCL5 (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ | |
| Downregulates HDGF (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ | |
| Downregulates GDNF (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Downregulates PI3K (protein) | SLCP | U87 | [ |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates (p-)PI3K (protein) | Osthole | MOGGCCM, T98 | [ |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates AMPK (protein) | Metformin | U87 | [ |
| Downregulates Akt (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG | [ |
| Downregulates Akt (protein) | Cedrol | RG2 | [ |
| Metformin | U87, U251 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87 | [ | |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| Downregulates p-Akt (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates p-Akt (protein) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ | |
| Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| Xanthohumol | U87 | [ | |
| CP | GAMG | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates mTOR (protein) | Metformin | U87 | [ |
| SLCP | U87 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Downregulates p-mTOR (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates p-mTOR (protein) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| SLCP | U87 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | T98G | [ | |
| Downregulates Raf (protein) | Osthole | MOGGCCM, T98 | [ |
| Downregulates c-Myc | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87 | [ | |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| Downregulates ROS | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| Upregulates CAT activity | Tannic Acid | C6 | [ |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| Upregulates SOD activity | Tannic Acid | C6 | [ |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| Downregulates JNK (protein) | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ |
| Downregulates p-JNK (protein) | Cedrol | RG2 | [ |
| Downregulates p-MEK (protein) | TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates p-ERK (protein) | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| TBMS1 | LN229 | [ | |
| Downregulates p38 (protein) | Diosgenin | T98G | [ |
| Upregulates p-p38 MAPK (protein) | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Downregulates HIF-1α activity | Metformin | U251 | [ |
| Downregulates NF-κB | Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates MET (protein) | TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ |
Figure 5Proapoptotic mechanisms, which involve mitochondrial dysfunction, ER stress, and caspase activation, are suppressed in GBM. Dysregulation of mitochondrial homeostasis (often through oxidative imbalance) leads to the release of cytochrome c, a caspase activator. ER stress upregulates activating transcription factors; in turn, ATFs activate CHOP, p21, and proapoptotic proteins that enhance caspase activation. Active caspase 9 (along with Beclin-1) cleaves caspase 3, which enforces apoptosis and DNA fragmentation. In proliferating GBM cells, however, the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-2 directly inhibits caspase 9, while mTOR inhibits Beclin-1.
Natural substances increase apoptotic cell death in GBM by downregulating apoptotic inhibitors and upregulating active caspases, which cleave PARP-1 and induce DNA fragmentation.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Causes apoptosis | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Osthole | MOGGCCM, T98 | [ | |
| Xanthohumol | U87 | [ | |
| Rupesin E | GSC-3#, GSC-18# | [ | |
| Diosmin | GBM02, GBM95 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Gossypol | TS13-20, Diff13-20 | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Tectorigenin | GBM-8401, GBM-8901 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Causes DNA fragmentation | SLCP | U87, U251 | [ |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates (c-)caspase 9 (protein) | Cedrol | RG2 | [ |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| CP | GAMG | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates caspase 3 (mRNA) | Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ |
| Upregulates (c-)caspase 3 (protein) | EGCG | MO59J, U251 | [ |
| Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ | |
| Osthole | T98 | [ | |
| Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ | |
| Rupesin E | GSC-3#, GSC-18# | [ | |
| Crocetin | U87, U138, U251, U373 | [ | |
| Diosmin | GBM02, GBM95 | [ | |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| CP | GAMG | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Betulinic Acid | U251, LN229 | [ | |
| Resveratrol | U87 | [ | |
| Quercetin | U87 | [ | |
| GL-PP | U251 | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Upregulates (c-)PARP (protein) | Cedrol | RG2 | [ |
| Xanthohumol | U87 | [ | |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| CP | U251 | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| Gossypol | TS13-20, Diff13-20 | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Downregulates PARP-1 (protein) | Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates ICAD (protein) | Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ |
| Upregulates Bax (protein) | SLCP | U87, U251 | [ |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ | |
| Downregulates Bcl-2 (mRNA) | Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ |
| Downregulates Bcl-2 (protein) | Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Upregulates Bad (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates Bim (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Depolarizes MMP | Coronarin D | U251 | [ |
| CP | U251 | [ | |
| McC1 | U251 | [ | |
| Gossypol | TS13-20 | [ | |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates ROS | Coronarin D | U251 | [ |
| SLCP | U87, U251 | [ | |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates cytochrome c (protein) | SLCP | U87, U251 | [ |
| BBR | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates GRP78 (mRNA) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates GRP78 (protein) | EGCG | MO59J | [ |
| Upregulates ATF4 (mRNA) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates ATF4 (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| EGCG | U251 | [ | |
| Upregulates ATF6 (mRNA) | Withaferin A | U251 | [ |
| Upregulates XBP1 (mRNA) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates XBP1 (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates CHOP (mRNA) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates CHOP (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| Upregulates Bax (protein) | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG | [ |
Figure 6Pathways promoting cell death through autophagy are inhibited in GBM cells. mTOR inactivates the pro-autophagy Beclin-1 and upregulates the anti-autophagy P62.
Arctigenin and osthole promote autophagy by upregulating Beclin-1 and LC3B-II and downregulating P62.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Causes autophagy | Osthole | MOGGCCM | [ |
| Upregulates Beclin-1 (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Upregulates Beclin-1 (protein) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Osthole | MOGGCCM | [ | |
| Upregulates LC3B-II (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Upregulates LC3B-II (protein) | Arctigenin | U87MG | [ |
| Downregulates P62 (mRNA) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates P62 (protein) | Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ |
Figure 7Inhibition of regulatory proteins allows for continuous cyclin/CDK activity and cell cycle progression in GBM cells. In healthy cells, FOXO and p53 can activate p27 and p21, respectively, and consequently induce cell cycle arrest to maintain homeostasis. DNA damage as a result of ROS accumulation is a key trigger for p21 activation. However, overactive Akt inhibits FOXO and p53, and therefore facilitates uncontrolled tumor cell growth and division.
Natural substances induce cell cycle arrest in GBM by upregulating p53, p21, and p27, and inhibiting several cyclins and their associated CDKs.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Causes G0/G1 phase cell cycle arrest | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ |
| Coronarin D | U251 | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| Tectorigenin | GBM-8401 | [ | |
| BBR | U87 | [ | |
| GL-PP | U251 | [ | |
| Causes G2/M phase cell cycle arrest | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Pisosterol | U87, U343, AHOL1, 1231N1 | [ | |
| Downregulates Cyclin D1 (protein) | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG | [ | |
| Downregulates CDK1 (protein) | Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ |
| TBMS1 | U87 | [ | |
| Downregulates CDK2 (protein) | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ |
| Downregulates CDK4 (protein) | Tectorigenin | GBM-8401 | [ |
| Downregulates Cyclin A (protein) | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Downregulates Cyclin B1 (protein) | Cedrol | DBTRG-05MG, RG2 | [ |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Upregulates (p-)H2AX (protein) | Coronarin D | U251 | [ |
| CP | U251 | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| Downregulates (p-)RB (protein) | Tectorigenin | GBM-8401 | [ |
| Upregulates p21 (protein) | Coronarin D | U251 | [ |
| U251 | [ | ||
| Withaferin A | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Tectorigenin | GBM-8401 | [ | |
| Upregulates p27 (protein) | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| U251 | [ | ||
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| AM05 | T98G | [ |
Rutin, quercetin, and CrataBL exert pleiotropic and sometimes cell line-dependent effects on neuroinflammation.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Activates microglia | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Upregulates IL-1 (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Upregulates IL-1β (mRNA) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates IL-4 (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Upregulates IL-6 (mRNA) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6, TG1 | [ | |
| Downregulates IL-6 (mRNA) | Rutin | U251, TG1, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | U251, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ | |
| Downregulates IL-6 (protein) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| CrataBL | U87 | [ | |
| Downregulates IL-8 (protein) | CrataBL | U87 | [ |
| Downregulates IL-10 (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, U251, TG1, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | C6, U251, TG1, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ | |
| Downregulates IL-10 (protein) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Upregulates IL-18 (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Upregulates TNF (mRNA) | Rutin | U251, TG1 | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 | [ | |
| Downregulates TNF (mRNA) | Rutin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ |
| Quercetin | U251 orthotopic implants, WR | [ | |
| Upregulates TNF (protein) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Upregulates TNF-α (mRNA) | Rutin | C6 | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Upregulates CX3CL1 (mRNA) | Rutin | C6, WR-U251 orthotopic implants | [ |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates (p-)STAT3 (protein) | Curcumin | U87 | [ |
Figure 8GBM cells gain migration and invasion abilities through EMT and modulation of the cytoskeletal actin framework. Regularization of actin filaments by STAT3/Fascin enhances cell motility; this process is reversible by Cofilin, which in tumor cells is inhibited by RhoA/ROCK/Limk and PI3K/PKA signaling. Upregulation of Snail, Slug, and MMPs further increases motility through EMT induction.
Natural substances decrease GBM cell migration and invasion by downregulating EMT modulators (Snail, Slug, and MMPs), Cofilin inhibitors (RhoA/ROCK/Limk and PKA), and actin polymerizers (STAT3/Fascin).
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reduces cell migration | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Astaxanthin | GL261, U251MG | [ | |
| Adonixanthin | GL261, U251MG | [ | |
| Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| Crocetin | U87, U251 | [ | |
| CP | GAMG | [ | |
| McC1 | U251, GAMG | [ | |
| Tannic Acid | C6 | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Curcumin | U87 | [ | |
| Paeoniflorin | U251, T98G | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ | |
| Rutin | C6 | [ | |
| Magnolol | LN229, U87MG | [ | |
| Gamabufotalin | U87 | [ | |
| Quercetin | C6 | [ | |
| Reduces cell invasion | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Arctigenin | U87MG, T98G | [ | |
| McC1 | GAMG, U251 | [ | |
| CrataBL | U87 | [ | |
| Curcumin | U87 | [ | |
| Paeoniflorin | U251, T98G | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ | |
| Downregulates MMP-2 (protein) | Astaxanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ | |
| Arctigenin | U87MG | [ | |
| TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | T98G | [ | |
| Downregulates MMP-7 (protein) | TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates MMP-9 (protein) | Arctigenin | U87MG | [ |
| Diosgenin | C6 | [ | |
| Downregulates p-PKA 1/2/3 (prot.) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates p-Cofilin (protein) | Eucalyptal A | U87MG, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates fibronectin (protein) | Adonixanthin | GL261 | [ |
| Downregulates laminin (protein) | CrataBL | U87 | [ |
| Downregulates Snail (protein) | TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ |
| Galangin | U87, U251 | [ | |
| Downregulates Snail (mRNA) | Galangin | U87, U251 | [ |
| Downregulates Slug (protein) | TBMS1 | U87, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates Fascin (protein) | Curcumin | U87 | [ |
| Reduces actin filament number | Paeoniflorin | T98G, U251 | [ |
| Downregulates GTP-RhoA (protein) | Paeoniflorin | T98G, U251 | [ |
| Downregulates ROCK (protein) | Paeoniflorin | T98G, U251 | [ |
| Downregulates (p-)Limk1 (protein) | Paeoniflorin | T98G, U251 | [ |
Natural substances reduce angiogenesis and neovascularization primarily by downregulating VEGF.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decreases angiogenesis area | McC1 | U251 heterotopic xenograft, fertilized chicken eggs | [ |
| Decreases blood vessel junctions | McC1 | U251 heterotopic xenograft, fertilized chicken eggs | [ |
| Decreases tube formation | Diosgenin | C6, T98G | [ |
| Upregulates ADAMTS1 (protein) | AM04 | U87MG, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates CD31 (mRNA) | Naringin | U87 subcutaneous xenograft, athymic mice | [ |
| Downregulates CD105 (mRNA) | Naringin | U87 subcutaneous xenograft, athymic mice | [ |
| Downregulates tumor hemoglobin | Naringin | U87 subcutaneous xenograft, athymic mice | [ |
| Downregulates VEGF (protein) | Metformin | U251 | [ |
| U251 | [ | ||
| CrataBL | U87 | [ | |
| Diosgenin | C6 | [ |
Figure 9GBM cells utilize altered metabolic processes (Warburg effect) characterized by increased glucose uptake and lactate generation. Akt, via GSK3β, mediates the transition between the healthy and Warburg phenotypes.
Xanthohumol, carnosine, and crocetin interfere with key enzymes in GBM cell metabolism.
| Effect | Substance | Cell Line(s) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Downregulates HK2 (protein) | Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ |
| Decreases glucose consumption | Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ |
| Decreases lactate production | Xanthohumol | U87, T98G, LN229 | [ |
| Downregulates (p-)GSK3β (protein) | Xanthohumol | U87 | [ |
| Upregulates PDK4 (mRNA) | Carnosine | U87, T98G | [ |
| Downregulates FASN (protein) | Crocetin | U87, U138, U251, U373 | [ |
Synergistic effects of natural substances on GBM. Concurrent administration of PPE and BcH enhances GBM cytotoxicity and reduces DNA synthesis, while curcumin and BBR together reduce proliferation and increase apoptotic cell death.
| Effect | Cell Line | Subs. 1 | Subs. 1 Conc. | Subs. 2 | Subs. 2 Conc. | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Increases cell death/dec viability | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| T98G | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 5, 10, 25, 50, 100 µg/mL | [ | |
| LN-18 | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 50, 100 µg/mL | [ | |
| U87 | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 50, 100 µg/mL | [ | |
| Decreases proliferation | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Causes apoptosis | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Causes DNA fragmentation | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Decreases DNA synthesis | T98G | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 25, 50 µg/mL | [ |
| LN-18 | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 25, 50 µg/mL | [ | |
| U87 | PPE | 30 µg/mL | BcH | 25, 50 µg/mL | [ | |
| Decreases intracellular ATP | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Upregulates ROS | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Upregulates Bax (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Upregulates cytochrome c (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Upregulates (c-)caspase 3 | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Downregulates c-Myc (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Upregulates p53 (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Downregulates Akt (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| Downregulates (p-)Akt (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Downregulates PI3K (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| Downregulates (p-)PI3K (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Downregulates mTOR (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ | |
| Downregulates (p-)mTOR (protein) | U87 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |
| U251 | SLCP | 20 µM | BBR | 100 µM | [ |