| Literature DB >> 33930237 |
Wendy Cadge1, Mariah Lewis1, Julia Bandini2,3, Sara Shostak1, Vivian Donahue4, Sophie Trachtenberg1, Katelyn Grone5, Robert Kacmarek6, Laura Lux7, Cristina Matthews8, Mary Elizabeth McAuley7, Frederic Romain6,9, Colleen Snydeman10, Tara Tehan5, Ellen Robinson9,10.
Abstract
AIMS: To understand how nurses experience providing care for patients hospitalized with COVID-19 in intensive care units.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; critical care; intensive care units; nurse administrators; nursing staff
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33930237 PMCID: PMC8236976 DOI: 10.1111/jonm.13353
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Nurs Manag ISSN: 0966-0429 Impact factor: 4.680
Demographic characteristics of 14 participants
| Characteristic | No. (%) |
|---|---|
| Age, mean ( | 34.3 (9.6) |
| Female sex | 14 (100) |
| Race/ethnicity | |
| White | 13 (92.9) |
| Black | 1 (7.1) |
| Highest educational level | |
| Bachelor's degree | 12 (85.7) |
| Master's degree | 2 (14.3) |
| Mean ( | 10.9 (7.9) |
Data were self‐reported on behalf of the participant. Two participants did not provide this information.
Additional quotations
| Theme | Subtheme | Quotations |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Challenges of working with new co‐workers and teams | a. Relationships on new care teams had to be negotiated | ‘From the start… I think everyone's emotions and like stress levels were so high, like that entire like month and a half that I was there that like… there were a lot of strong personalities to interact with at times. And I felt for me, because they didn't know me, I had to sort of prove myself and my like nursing skill set and like my, my strengths and what I can do’. |
| ‘[Sometimes] it was like ‘How do we even know…what team we're on?’ It… felt so disorganized… there were circumstances where you felt like [unfamiliar staff] didn't trust you as well… It was just a hard position to be in. To feel like you're the only one seeing the patient, but you aren't contributing to their care at all because no one's listening to you’. | ||
| b. Nurses struggled with lack of defined roles | ‘There wasn't really clear‐cut expectations aside from like basically like a double‐sided sheet of 8x12 paper that explained to like the general care nurses like very, very basic safety things and like didn't encompass like what our role would really be with them’. | |
| ‘…but next time around… [general care nurses need to know] what our roles are going to be, or at least give us some basic tests that were ours to own because that would let the ICU nurse hand it over. Because the ICU nurses… some of them didn't know what to do with us’. | ||
| c. Challenges arose from being paired with different nurse partners each day, while also working with other unfamiliar staff | ‘…we were placed with different nurses from shift to shift, and if an ICU nurse I was with one day had a bad experience with a floating nurse the day before, it was sort of like, ‘I'll do everything I have to do,’ and like, ‘I'll let you know when I need help.’ …I just felt like sometimes I was just a body there, like I wasn't actually doing nursing things that I've been trained to do’. | |
| ‘There were multiple people signed in and out of the patient at multiple times over the course of the day. And like I don't know whether I'm just like working with an intern or working with like an attending as my responding… And nobody introduced themselves [or] trusted each other's experience…it was a really, really bad model in that way’. | ||
| d. Creation of function‐specific teams was universally helpful | ‘I liked the COBRA Team… they would come in, place new central lines and A lines… and it wasn't like the medical resident attempting to place the A line while the nurse is… in the room exposed longer… like these people actually knew what they were doing, and it was a quick thing’. | |
| ‘…we used the Proning Team and that was, that was a huge help especially when nobody knew how to do it in the beginning. We were watching videos on how to do it’. | ||
| ‘So, the Spanish Language Team started doing updates… The provider would call the family with the medical team's update and like have the medical terminology but also like the colloquial terminology to like share information in, you know, a compassionate way. So, I, I just think that like that was honestly like the best thing that we could've done for these families, especially because… there was one day that like every single COVID patient on our unit was Spanish‐speaking only’. | ||
| 2. Challenges of maintaining existing working relationships | a. Gained significant support from existing relationships made on original home units | ‘[I was with] 3 of my closest friends… so just having them to be able to turn to and… bounce ideas off of or… even vent to… having some familiarity with one's colleagues also made it easier for nurses to support each other in providing patient care’. |
| ‘And I remember…I kind of had the sense of like, “You know what, it's gonna be different than [home unit], but like it's gonna be great. All of my friends are gonna be there, like we're gonna work as a team, and we're gonna make it work”’. | ||
| ‘I think honestly the best thing that happened to me during COVID was I didn't realize like how great my like actual [home unit] coworkers were…everyone just came together so well and they were always there for me…we were always there for each other… I feel like everyone [was] such a family’. | ||
| b. Deployment disrupted the maintenance of staff relationships | ‘I think that there should have been more check ins with the nursing staff that got floated, for sure, because you took them from their comfort home, you took them from doctors they know, you took them from a layout of a floor that they know and you dumped them in a unit that you had no clue about’. | |
| ‘There were a bunch of nurses over there that were definitely not okay. And that's where I wish that there had been like a better checking system where my manager from [home unit] could have acknowledged the fact that one of her staff on [surge ICU] was not doing well. We need to fix that situation’. | ||
| d. Preferred inter‐peer support as opposed to institutional resources | ‘Honestly there probably were [resources], I know MGH is great at that. But I didn't… seek it. I had my peers and I had you know the CNS… [who] was a great resource to me. If I ever felt nervous, I would feel comfortable going to her… I had my peers and my colleagues and my friends to kind of help you know guide me through it’. | |
| ‘I didn't reach out to any of those resources. I have used them in the past prior to this which were helpful… but I internalized a lot of it and when I found that it was too much for me to carry myself I just needed to get away from work. And I felt like once it was too much I had to‐ I think the thought of doing‐ going through EAP just like tied me more to it’. | ||
| 3. Role of nursing leadership in providing information and maintaining morale | a. Supported clinical practice through consistent informational emails and memos | ‘… one email that I always read every week was [from] our CNS. [It was] almost like a Q and A sheet and it would go through and say different questions that maybe we would be asking…. And so it was quick, to the point, with a question, with an answer, and that was… super helpful’. |
| ‘[The CNS] every day would come up with this… 10 page… template… like a guide almost, like helping the [general care] and ICU nurses… because every day things were evolving. Every day they were coming out with new medicines, or new practices, or you know like maybe proning isn't the best way to do it…. Every day things were changing, and she very quickly, like I mean she was up I think at 1:00 in the morning like even like editing this, this guide that she'd give us’. | ||
| b. Leadership was crucial for nurses' daily functioning and morale | ‘…the huddles at the beginning throughout it with our staff and our nurse director were very good…we could talk to each other, express [concerns], [and] it was in real time as we were going through it. You can bring stuff up, support was given’. | |
| ‘[The Nurse Manager] acknowledged how hard [this experience was] was and I think that helped. Everyone just like needed to hear it’. | ||
| c. Deployed nurses serving under new leadership required additional support | ‘…when we realized we were staying on our floor the news came out that the other floors had to switch. So we immediately started trying to make them feel welcome, like that was a concerted effort on the part of the nurses on [surge ICU]’. | |
| ‘I said this before about like just welcoming everybody to the unit… it just helped knowing that your management was like “We know that you can't be perfect nurses right now, we know your documentation isn't going to be perfect, like we're going to do the best we can with what we have, and that's what we can do for right now”’. | ||
| 4. Importance of institutional level acknowledgement of their work | a. Improper and insufficient acknowledgement from hospital administrators | ‘[Senior leadership] came to our unit once and went to one side of the unit [and the nurses] were pretty harsh [saying], “Where have you been? We've been here now for a month. We haven't seen you once”’. |
| ‘I can certainly say that finding out that our merit raises and retirement contributions… [were] frozen was definitely not very supportive…it feels like… after everything we went through… we're kind of getting the short end of the stick’. | ||
| b. Lack of understanding from family, friends, and media | ‘So…we had a great relationship and camaraderie before, but I think COVID solidified that and I’m very grateful [for my coworkers] because I could be like, “Oh my god. Do you know what I had to do today?” And they could really understand it, where if I came home and tried to tell my family, they're like, “Oh, don't tell me that”’. | |
| ‘…no one else around you understood it. They weren't there. And even now, like when people ask me… what was it like, [I say] it sucked. You didn't want to do it, but you did it’. | ||
| c. Nurses felt unseen and unheard | ‘…there was just zero, zero acknowledgement for what we did. And still there has been none…We got nothing. They gave us a t‐shirt… So, it's felt very bitter and sour… I know deep down that I was of service to the patients that needed me… but it is challenging to work for an organization…and to not be able to be given the recognition we as a staff deserve’. | |
| ‘I think my biggest thing… I would say is that you know not feeling recognized and not feeling like a valuable, other than my own personal recognition…I think that also has you know something to do with… the coping piece, you know, like if, if there was a lot of acknowledgement and recognition, like maybe we would be like ‘Okay, well we went through this really tough thing but you know, it was for the greater good…’ but like none of that has even transpired’. |