| Literature DB >> 33919179 |
Laura Wengenroth1, Fanny Berglund2, Hetty Blaak3, Mariana Carmen Chifiriuc4, Carl-Fredrik Flach2, Gratiela Gradisteanu Pircalabioru4, D G Joakim Larsson2, Luminita Marutescu4, Mark W J van Passel3,5, Marcela Popa4, Katja Radon1, Ana Maria de Roda Husman3, Daloha Rodríguez-Molina1,6,7, Tobias Weinmann1, Andreas Wieser8,9, Heike Schmitt3.
Abstract
Antibiotic resistance has become a serious global health threat. Wastewater treatment plants may become unintentional collection points for bacteria resistant to antimicrobials. Little is known about the transmission of antibiotic resistance from wastewater treatment plants to humans, most importantly to wastewater treatment plant workers and residents living in the vicinity. We aim to deliver precise information about the methods used in the AWARE (Antibiotic Resistance in Wastewater: Transmission Risks for Employees and Residents around Wastewater Treatment Plants) study. Within the AWARE study, we gathered data on the prevalence of two antibiotic resistance phenotypes, ESBL-producing E. coli and carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae, as well as on their corresponding antibiotic resistance genes isolated from air, water, and sewage samples taken from inside and outside of different wastewater treatment plants in Germany, the Netherlands, and Romania. Additionally, we analysed stool samples of wastewater treatment plant workers, nearby residents, and members of a comparison group living ≥1000 m away from the closest WWTP. To our knowledge, this is the first study investigating the potential spread of ESBL-producing E. coli, carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae, and antibiotic resistance genes from WWTPs to workers, the environment, and nearby residents. Quantifying the contribution of different wastewater treatment processes to the removal efficiency of ESBL-producing E. coli, carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae, and antibiotic resistance genes will provide us with evidence-based support for possible mitigation strategies.Entities:
Keywords: ESBL-producing E. coli; antibiotic resistance; carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae; employees; residents; wastewater treatment plants
Year: 2021 PMID: 33919179 PMCID: PMC8143112 DOI: 10.3390/antibiotics10050478
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Antibiotics (Basel) ISSN: 2079-6382
Figure 1Legend Graphical Abstract: Overview of AWARE study, with (A) the participating countries, (B) the study domain, wastewater treatment plant samples, and workers of and residents living nearby wastewater treatment plants, (C) the techniques involved (questionnaire, molecular and cultural analyses of ESBL-EC, CPE, and the resistome, and (D) the outcome: epidemiological evaluation of differences in prevalence of ESBL-EC, CPE, and the resistome between workers and residents of wastewater treatment plants and the general population, changes in relative and absolute resistance along different wastewater chains, and models for airborne and waterborne exposure to resistant bacteria and resistance genes.
Recruitment of participants into the AWARE study.
| Germany | The Netherlands | Romania | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Selection of WWTPs | Eligible WWTPs are selected due to the following criteria: There are residents living in <300 m vicinity of WWTP, WWTP is located close enough to laboratories for the analyses of samples | All 21 regional waterboards 3 are included. | WWTPs are chosen to assure a good representativeness of different regions across the country. |
| Invitation of WWTPs | The operators of the WWTPs are contacted by the local study team and asked to participate. | The waterboards are informed of the study through the Dutch Water Authorities and asked to participate. | The operators of the WWTPs are contacted by the local study team and asked to participate. |
| Response in WWTPs | 8 WWTPs are interested in participating. | 12 waterboards are interested in participating 4. | 9 WWTPs are interested in participating. |
| Study presentation and informing of WWTP workers | The study team visits 6 interested WWTPs and presents the project to the workers 1. | The WWTP workers of 10 waterboards are invited to attend a presentation of the study by the local study team 5. The workers of the remaining 2 waterboards are recruited internally through email. By sending the presentation to all workers via email, also workers not attending the meeting are reached. | The WWTP operators inform and invite the employees to participate. Afterwards, several short information sessions are organized at the WWTPs for recruiting participants. |
| Informing of nearby residents | The study team researches the street names of all streets within ≤300 m vicinity of a participating WWTP through Google Maps and asks the local registration office 2 for the full address of all persons aged 16–67 years and having their main residence in those streets. | Due to concerns of the waterboards, residents living in ≤300 m vicinity of a WWTP cannot be included. | Invitations to the study are done using door-to-door approach. Additionally, in public places like streets, parks, and markets, potential participants are orally addressed and information sheets with details about the study are distributed. The participants are at least 18 years old. |
| Informing of comparison group | The addresses are collected in the same way as for the nearby residents, except that addresses >1000 m away from the closest WWTP and close to a train station are chosen to allow fast transportation of samples by the study team. | All addresses within a 500 m radius of GPs, who are willing to cooperate, are identified 6. Then, 300–500 addresses per GP are randomly selected to extract personal data from the Dutch Personal Records Database (BRP). Information on the study is sent to all residents living at the selected addresses over 16 years of age. | Same procedure as for nearby residents |
| Incentives for participants 7 | Participants participate in a raffle with 10 shopping vouchers with a total value of 1500 Euros. | Every participant receives a gift card worth 20 Euro. | Every participant is granted 5 Euro. |
| Timing of sample taking | To control for seasonal variation of ESBL-EC, CPE, and ARGs all samples (water, air, stool) from the surroundings of one WWTP are aimed to be taken within eight weeks. | ||
1 Two WWTPs stepped back from participation because they feared that residents and media might complain about WWTPs in case ESBL-EC, CPE, or ARGs would be found in their WWTP. 2 If addresses cannot be retrieved from the local registration offices, members of the study team go from door to door to recruit participants. In case of no reply, up to two reminders are sent (7 and 21 days after initial invitation). Further methods will be performed to increase the response: newspaper articles describing the AWARE project published by local newspapers, online advertisement on the study’s Facebook page and in groups like notice boards and job advertisements, flyers about the AWARE study in doctors’ offices of local physicians, invitations via e-mail to workers from different work fields (industry and public sector). 3 Waterboards are regional government bodies supervising, e.g., sewage treatment in their respective regions. 4 Nine waterboards did not want to participate out of fear for causing commotion among nearby residents or workers, or lack of interest to invest time and/or manpower to help organize recruitment. 5 WWTP workers generally work at multiple WWTPs, making it impossible to study workers of specific WWTPs. Therefore, all workers of waterboards were invited to participate, but only a selection of WWTPs (1–3 per waterboard) are selected for environmental sampling. 6 General practitioners (GP) within a 2–5 km distance from selected WWTPs are approached for cooperation, to function as a collection and preservation point of stool samples. Addresses of within a 500 m radius of GPs are identified using Geographical Information System (GIS) software (version ArcGis 10.6.1). 7 Participants who hand in a stool sample and a completed questionnaire.
Figure 2Collection points of water, air, and stool samples.