Juliana F W Cohen1, Scott Richardson2, Christina A Roberto3, Eric B Rimm4. 1. (1)Department of Health Sciences, Merrimack College, North Andover, MA; (2)Department of Nutrition, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Harvard University, Boston, MA. Electronic address: cohenj@merrimack.edu. 2. (2)Department of Nutrition, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Harvard University, Boston, MA. 3. (3)Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA. 4. (4)Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: During 2010, the US Department of Agriculture updated the school meals standards, including three progressively decreasing sodium targets. The Target 1 standards went into effect in 2014, but during 2018, the US Department of Agriculture delayed the Target 2 standards until 2024 and eliminated the Target 3 standards citing concerns regarding the availability and acceptability of lower-sodium foods. In addition, there are currently no sugar standards, and it is unknown whether sugar is substituted for salt in lower-sodium school foods. OBJECTIVE: To examine the availability, selection, and consumption of school lunches already in alignment with the Target 2 and 3 sodium levels and the association between sodium and sugar. DESIGN: An observational cafeteria-based study conducted during fall 2018. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: Students (n = 1985) in grades three through eight attending 13 elementary/kindergarten through eighth-grade schools in a large, urban school district in New England. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Availability, selection, and consumption were examined using plate waste methodology. STATISTICAL ANALYSES PERFORMED: Mixed-model analysis of variance accounting for student demographic characteristics with schools/students as a random effect (students nested within schools) were used to examine differences in availability, selection, and consumption. Linear regression was used to examine the association between sodium and sugar in the school foods. RESULTS: The majority of meals selected (87%) and consumed (98%) were already in alignment with the Target 2 standards. There were significant inverse associations between sodium levels and consumption; each 100-mg increase in sodium was associated with a decrease in consumption by 2% for entrées (P = 0.002) and 5% for vegetables (P = 0.01). When examining the association between sodium and sugar, each 10-mg reduction in sodium was associated with 1-g increase in sugar among entrées (P < 0.0001), whereas there was a significant positive association between sodium and sugar with vegetables and condiments. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides some evidence that schools may already have the ability to provide lower-sodium meals that are acceptable to students, and therefore the recent rollbacks to the sodium standards may be unwarranted. Study findings suggest that the US Department of Agriculture should take under consideration policies that would limit added sugar for school meals as sugar may be substituted for salt.
BACKGROUND: During 2010, the US Department of Agriculture updated the school meals standards, including three progressively decreasing sodium targets. The Target 1 standards went into effect in 2014, but during 2018, the US Department of Agriculture delayed the Target 2 standards until 2024 and eliminated the Target 3 standards citing concerns regarding the availability and acceptability of lower-sodium foods. In addition, there are currently no sugar standards, and it is unknown whether sugar is substituted for salt in lower-sodium school foods. OBJECTIVE: To examine the availability, selection, and consumption of school lunches already in alignment with the Target 2 and 3 sodium levels and the association between sodium and sugar. DESIGN: An observational cafeteria-based study conducted during fall 2018. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: Students (n = 1985) in grades three through eight attending 13 elementary/kindergarten through eighth-grade schools in a large, urban school district in New England. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Availability, selection, and consumption were examined using plate waste methodology. STATISTICAL ANALYSES PERFORMED: Mixed-model analysis of variance accounting for student demographic characteristics with schools/students as a random effect (students nested within schools) were used to examine differences in availability, selection, and consumption. Linear regression was used to examine the association between sodium and sugar in the school foods. RESULTS: The majority of meals selected (87%) and consumed (98%) were already in alignment with the Target 2 standards. There were significant inverse associations between sodium levels and consumption; each 100-mg increase in sodium was associated with a decrease in consumption by 2% for entrées (P = 0.002) and 5% for vegetables (P = 0.01). When examining the association between sodium and sugar, each 10-mg reduction in sodium was associated with 1-g increase in sugar among entrées (P < 0.0001), whereas there was a significant positive association between sodium and sugar with vegetables and condiments. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides some evidence that schools may already have the ability to provide lower-sodium meals that are acceptable to students, and therefore the recent rollbacks to the sodium standards may be unwarranted. Study findings suggest that the US Department of Agriculture should take under consideration policies that would limit added sugar for school meals as sugar may be substituted for salt.
Authors: Juliana F W Cohen; Scott A Richardson; Sarah A Cluggish; Ellen Parker; Paul J Catalano; Eric B Rimm Journal: JAMA Pediatr Date: 2015-05 Impact factor: 16.193
Authors: Norrina B Allen; Juned Siddique; John T Wilkins; Christina Shay; Cora E Lewis; David C Goff; David R Jacobs; Kiang Liu; Donald Lloyd-Jones Journal: JAMA Date: 2014-02-05 Impact factor: 157.335