A recent article in Scars, Burns & Healing incorporated video footage
for the first time.[1] The paper looked into the possibility that usage of power tools, particularly
dermatomes, which are commonly used in reconstructive surgery, may be an aerosol-generating
procedure (AGP) and the use of video footage supported and complemented the conclusion that
procedures using powered dermatomes were likely to be AGPs. In the context of the COVID-19
pandemic, there are likely to be many parallels in all areas where power tools are utilised in
the operating room, and the increasing importance of targeted and tiered levels of personal
protective equipment (PPE) based on risk.The utilisation of videos in clinical medicine, medical education and research has increased
over the years, finding applications across multiple disciplines and areas. Video-based
observation has been used in primary care research,[2] evaluation of practices in prenatal and cancer genetic counselling,[3] in vivo visualisation of oxygen free-radical production,[4] medical education facilitation and performance feedback,[5-7] and many other areas
of clinical practice, examples of which are observational gait analysis,[8] HIV prevention intervention[9]and debriefing after trans-catheter aortic valve replacement.[10] The driver behind utilisation for educational purposes of visual messages, over or in
addition to the verbal message, is the observation that the brain processes and stores images
better than words. In fact, when neural correlates of memory for pictures and words were
studied to delineate brain activity patterns using positron emission tomography, encoding of
pictures resulted in greater cortical activity, leading to superior picture memory.[11] Hence online educational resources are increasingly becoming more and more diverse,
integrating videos.[12] A well-established Journal of Video Experiments
(JOVE; https://www.jove.com/journal), for
example, provides a peer-reviewed repository of science videos, for scientific research and
education. In other cases, capturing a video contributes directly to building scientific
evidence of specific phenomena which would be difficult to visualise or otherwise document,
such as oxygen free-radical production,[4] gait analyses[8] or continuous quality improvement in clinical practice.[10]It should be noted that while the usage of photographic and video support in medical
education and research enhances learning processes, more effectively documents visual
phenomena and supports the progress of medical research, such use does raise fundamental
ethical considerations around concerns and potential challenges of an ethical
nature,[13,14] particularly with the
increasing development of open access publishing and diffusion of material over the World Wide
Web, which add to the well-known complexities related to the fragmentation of the research
ethics approval processes.[15]A recently published report from a large cohort study of inpatients with COVID-19 has
confirmed the high mortality risk associated with the disease in the general population, with
increasing age, male gender, obesity and other chronic co-morbidities all being independent
risk factors for a negative outcome.[16] When considering healthcare workers (HCWs), it is known that AGPs could expose them to
respiratory infections, although this exposure risk has not been fully quantified. In a
meta-analysis of five case-control and five retrospective cohort studies evaluating the
transmission of SARS to HCWs, multiple procedures were reported to be associated with
increased risk of transmission, particularly in areas of anaesthesiology, respiratory and
intensive care medicine, with tracheal intubation being the intervention generally most
associated with risk.[17] Nevertheless, the concerns around the spread of COVID-19 have affected many other areas
and domains of medical practice, including ophthalmology,[18] otorhinolaryngology,[19] cardiac surgery[20] and cardiopulmonary resuscitation.[21] Many different factors are likely to be related to HCW infection, including the use and
availability of adequate PPE, infection control measures, and training and performance of
procedures with high risk of contact with infected bodily fluids and/or aerosol generation.[22]In conclusion, video content, whether for educational or specific scientific purposes,
complements, enriches and, in some cases, entirely replaces the standard usual method of
written publication, supporting students, educators and researchers.
Authors: E James Essien; Osaro Mgbere; Emmanuel Monjok; Ernest Ekong; Marcia M Holstad; Seth C Kalichman Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2010-11-03 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: V Ojetti; C Di Campli; M Mutignani; A Migneco; A Tridente; N G Silveri; G Gasbarrini; A Gasbarrini Journal: Dig Liver Dis Date: 2003-05 Impact factor: 4.088
Authors: Jaap J Brunnekreef; Caro J T van Uden; Steven van Moorsel; Jan G M Kooloos Journal: BMC Musculoskelet Disord Date: 2005-03-17 Impact factor: 2.362
Authors: Ascanio Tridente; Paul A H Holloway; Paula Hutton; Anthony C Gordon; Gary H Mills; Geraldine M Clarke; Jean-Daniel Chiche; Frank Stuber; Christopher Garrard; Charles Hinds; Julian Bion Journal: BMC Med Ethics Date: 2019-05-07 Impact factor: 2.652
Authors: Michael D Christian; Mona Loutfy; L Clifford McDonald; Kennth F Martinez; Mariana Ofner; Tom Wong; Tamara Wallington; Wayne L Gold; Barbara Mederski; Karen Green; Donald E Low Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2004-02 Impact factor: 6.883
Authors: Andrew Thamboo; Jane Lea; Doron D Sommer; Leigh Sowerby; Arman Abdalkhani; Christopher Diamond; Jennifer Ham; Austin Heffernan; M Cai Long; Jobanjit Phulka; Yu Qi Wu; Phillip Yeung; Marc Lammers Journal: J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 2020-05-06