| Literature DB >> 33238034 |
Kelsey M Graber1, Elizabeth M Byrne1, Emily J Goodacre1, Natalie Kirby1, Krishna Kulkarni1, Christine O'Farrelly1, Paul G Ramchandani1.
Abstract
Amidst the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, there is uncertainty regarding potential lasting impacts on children's health and educational outcomes. Play, a fundamental part of childhood, may be integral to children's health during crises. We undertook a rapid review of the impact of quarantine, isolation and other restrictive environments on play and whether play mitigates adverse effects of such restrictions. Fifteen peer-reviewed studies were identified, spanning hospitals, juvenile and immigration detention and refugee camps. We found evidence of changes in children's access to play in crises and quarantine. These studies indicated how play might support children enduring isolation but lacked robust investigations of play as an intervention in mitigating impacts of restriction. Studies pertaining to children in isolation due to infectious disease outbreaks were notably absent. It is important that the potential effects of changes to such a crucial aspect of childhood are better understood to support children in this and future crises.Entities:
Keywords: children; disease outbreak; isolation; mental health; play; restriction
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33238034 PMCID: PMC7753247 DOI: 10.1111/cch.12832
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Child Care Health Dev ISSN: 0305-1862 Impact factor: 2.943
FIGURE 1PRISMA flowchart [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Study characteristics
| Study | Country | Design | Measures | Participant age | Sample size | Restriction setting | Type of play | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | Brodsky ( | Israel | Qualitative | NA | 4–10 years | 4 | Hospital | Music |
| (2) | Hollenbeck et al. ( | USA | Quantitative | Observation | 18 months to 4 years | 4 | Hospital | Undefined |
| (3) | Kronick, Rousseau, and Cleveland ( | Canada | Qualitative | Ethnographic observation, interviews | 6–18 years | 20 families | Immigration detention | Undefined |
| (4) | Kronick, Rousseau, and Cleveland ( | Canada | Qualitative | Interviews and observations | 3–13 years | 10 | Immigration detention | Sand play |
| (5) | Kuntz et al. ( | USA | Qualitative | Case studies | 0–7 years | 2 | Hospital | Toy play |
| (6) | Lambert, Coad, Hicks, and Glacken ( | Ireland | Qualitative | Semi‐structured interviews and art activities | 5–8 years | 55 | Hospital | Art, discussion |
| (7) | Linn, Beardslee, and Patenaude ( | USA | Qualitative | Puppet play | 4–6 years | 1 | Hospital | Puppet play |
| (8) | Mares, Newman, Dudley, and Gale ( | Australia | Qualitative | NA | 5 months to 21 years | 2 families | Immigration detention | Undefined |
| (9) | Pytash ( | USA | Qualitative | Case study, observations and interviews | 17 years | 1 | Juvenile detention | Reading, writing |
| (10) | Robb ( | USA | Quantitative | Observation, Affective Face Scale | 4–11 years | 10 | Hospital | Music, varied |
| (11) | Shea and Siu ( | USA | Mixed methods | Study‐specific survey, observation, analysis of worksheet/craft | 14–18 years | 295 | Juvenile detention | Varied |
| (12) | Susman et al. ( | USA | Quantitative | Observation | 18 months to 21 years | 23 | Hospital | Varied |
| (13) | Venable ( | USA | Qualitative | Exit survey | 16 years (mean age) | Not specified | Juvenile detention | Art |
| (14) | Veronese, Cavazzoni, and Antenucci ( | Occupied Palestinian Territories | Qualitative | Thematic analysis of children's art/writing | 6–15 years | 122 | Refugee camps | Art, writing |
| (15) | Winn ( | USA | Qualitative | Thematic analysis of adolescent girls' writing | 14–17 years | Not specified | Juvenile detention | Writing |
Note. All studies met inclusion criteria for involving children ≤18 years, though in two studies (2 and 12), the maximum age of participants was 21 years.
Indicates article found via handsearching.
| (A) Population of interest: | (child* OR adolescen* OR teenage* OR [paediatric OR pediatric] OR youth OR ‘young people’ OR infan* OR toddler OR preschool OR ‘school age’) |
| AND | |
| (B) Quarantine and restricted environments: | (quarantine OR ‘social distancing’ OR ‘social restriction’ OR ‘patient isolation’ OR confine* OR [lockdown OR ‘lock‐down’ OR curfew] OR ‘deprivation‐isolation’ OR ‘protect* environment’ OR detention OR incarceration) |
| AND | |
| (C) Play and related activities: | (play* OR [art OR arts OR ‘arts‐based’] OR sport* OR exercise OR ‘outdoor activities’ OR ‘outdoor spaces’ OR exploration OR discovery OR toys OR games OR ‘social media’ OR [‘free play’ OR ‘free‐play’] OR ‘adult‐directed activities’ OR drawing OR crafts OR reading OR ‘book sharing’ OR [danc* OR sing* OR fun] OR drama* OR imagin*) |